Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 80151 (KAR)
SRI P BABU v. SMT PUSHPA BAI
WP/33963/2025 · 2025-12-04
Pradeep Singh Yerur
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 80151 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 80151 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" # $%
&$'! !#
($)
! " # $ %
! &'
$ &
" # $ $#$%%
( $
'' ( $ ( )
! ' '
'''
*
$ $
+ #$$'% *
$
(
,
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$ ,
+ $
-./0 /1 2.234.5/1642.78/349 :-./2-0 ;<826-: =</>-3131<2-/ .20/1 -?0-:-./2-0 ;<826-: =</;.@-.3<//-6><20-23
' 416 >-3131<2 16 =1:-0 A9 34- >-3131<2-/0-=-20.23 .??/1-@-0 A9 34- </0-/ 0.3-0 ! ' ' >.66-0 <2 < 12 <''' A9 * 00131<2.: $139 $1@1: .20-661<26+80?--2?.:8/8
& ./31-6 ./- /-=-//-0 3< .6 >-/ 34-1/ 63.386 A-=</- 34-3/1.:$<8/3
/1-==.;36<=34-;.6-./-.6820-/, 4- >:.1231== =1:-0 . 6813 .?.1263 34- 0-=-20.23 3< 0-;:./- 34.3 34- 6.:- 0--0 0.3-0 & &' .6 28:: .20 @<10.202<3A12012?<234->:.1231==8/12?34-;<8/6-<= 34-3/1.:34-0-=-20.23=1:-0.2.>>:1;.31<2820-//0-/ 8:- <= $$ 6--512? .7-207-23 <= 34- B/133-2 63.3-7-234-6.10.>>:1;.31<2;.7-3<A-<AC-;3-03<A9
- 3 -
34- >:.1231== ><2 ;<2610-/.31<2 <= 34- 6.10 .>>:1;.31<2 34-3/1.:$<8/34.0/-C-;3-034-6.7-B41;41634-68AC-;3 7.33-/<=3416>-3131<2
3 16 34- @-4-7-23 ;<23-231<2 <= :-./2-0 ;<826-: =</34-0-=-20.2334.334-17>8?2-0</0-/>.66-0A934- 3/1.:$<8/3161::-?.:>-/@-/6-.20./A13/./9.2034-6.7- 16 :1.A:- 3< A- 6-3.610- 3 16 =8/34-/ ;<23-20-0 A9 34- :-./2-0;<826-:=</0-=-20.2334.334-0-=-20.234.6A--2 12 >-.;-=8: ><66-661<2 .20 -2C<97-23 <= 34- 6;4-08:- >/<>-/39 =/<7 'DD! .20 6813 B.6 =1:-0 A9 34- >:.1231==<2' ' B41;4167</-34.2'9-./6=/<7 34-0.3-<=.;38.:><66-661<2<=34-0-=-20.234-234- 7.33-/B.66-30<B2=</./?87-23634-.>>:1;.31<2;.7- 3<A-=1:-06--512?.7-207-23<=34-B/133-263.3-7-23A9 12;</></.312? <2- >./.?/.>4 6--512? /-:1-= <= .0@-/6- ><66-661<2B41;4<8?433<4.@-A--2.::<B-0A934-3/1.: $<8/3
- 4 -
-./2-0;<826-:=</0-=-20.23=8/34-/;<23-20-0 34.334-3/1.:$<8/34.6;<7-3<34-;<2;:861<234.3B41:- >:-.012?/-:1-=<=.0@-/6-><66-661<234-0-=-20.237863 .0713 34- 313:- <= 34->:.1231== B41;416 1::-?.:.20 ;<23/./9 3< 34- B-::-63.A:164-0 >/12;1>:- <= .0@-/6- ><66-661<2
'316.:6<;<23-20-0A934-:-./2-0;<826-:34.3 34- 0-=-20.23 4.6 7.0- .2 .:3-/2.31@- 0-=-2;- A9 ;<23-2012? 34.3 12 34- -@-23 34- 0-=-20.23 16 82.A:- 3< -63.A:164 416 313:- 4- 4.6 >-/=-;3-0 416 313:- A9 .0@-/6- ><66-661<2 B41;4 ;.22<3 A- 0-21-0 4- 0-=-20.23 16 -2313:-0 3< 3.5- 01@-/?-23 >:-.6 13 16 =</ 34- $<8/3 3< 0-;10- .6 3< B4-34-/ 4- 68;;--06 </ 2<3 A83 ;.22<3 ;8/3.1:34-/1?436<=34-0-=-20.233<3.5-68;4>:-.612. B/133-2 63.3-7-23 .3 .29 63.?- 1= 6< >-/71661A:- 3 16 =8/34-/ ;<23-23-0 A9 :-./2-0 ;<826-: 34.3 34- 17>8?2-0 </0-/ >.66-0 A9 34- 3/1.: $<8/3 16 <>><6-0 3< :.B .20 =.;36
- 5 -
&
-./2-0 ;<826-: /-:1-0 8><2 34- =<::<B12? C80?7-2361268>></3<=416;.6-,
/-></3-0 12
! " ' # $
% $
/-></3-0 12
& ''( ( & %
)
/-></3-012/-></3-012* ++'" +"
:-./2-0 ;<826-: =</ >:.1231== 6863.126 34- 17>8?2-0 </0-/ A9 ;<23-2012?
34.3 34-/- 16 2< 1::-?.:139 </ >-/@-/6139 12 34- </0-/ >.66-0 A9 34- 3/1.: $<8/3 = 34- 0-=-20.23 ;:.176 34- /-:1-= <= .0@-/6- ><66-661<2 A9 B.9 <= .2 .7-207-23 =1/63:9 4- 4.6 3< .0713 34- <B2-/641> <= 34- >:.1231== 2 34- .A6-2;- <= 68;4 63.3-7-23 12 34- B/133-2 63.3-7-23 </ 12 34- .7-207-23<=34-B/133-263.3-7-2334-/-;.22<3A-.2 1668- <= .0@-/6- ><66-661<2 B41;4 16 34- >/17./9
- 6 -
/-E81/-7-23 B4-2 . >-/6<2 ;:.176 .0@-/6- ><66-661<2 <B-@-/ 34- 0-=-20.23 4.6 2<3 7.0- .29 ;.3-?</1;.: 63.3-7-23 12 416 .7-207-23 .>>:1;.31<2 6--512? .7-207-23 3< 12;:80- 34- /-:1-= <= .0@-/6- ><66-661<2 B4-/-12 4- 4.6 2<3 ;.3-?</1;.::9 .07133-0 34- <B2-/641> <=34-6;4-08:->/<>-/39;:.17-0A934->:.1231==4-3/1.:
$<8/3 4.6 .0C801;.3-0 34-6- .6>-;36 @-/9 ;./-=8::9 .20 ;.831<86:9 .20 A9 /-:912? 8><2 34- C80?7-23 <= 34- <2FA:- >-G $<8/3 4.6 /1?43:9 /-C-;3-0 34- .>>:1;.31<2 B41;40<-62<3;.::=</123-/=-/-2;-
-./2-0 ;<826-: =</ >:.1231== /-:1-0 8><2 34- C80?-7-23 <= <2FA:- >-G $<8/3 12 34- ;.6- <= ,$- , -. $
&-- & - /0/-></3-012 +! +' /
! "1268>></3<=416;.6-
'
-./2-0;<826-:=</>:.1231==.:6<;<23-20-034.3 34-/-162<7-/131234-.>>:1;.31<2=1:-0B41;416/1?43=8::9
- 7 -
/-C-;3-0A934-3/1.:$<8/3-2;-34->/-6-23>-3131<2.:6< 0-6-/@-63<A-0167166-0
4.@- 4-./0 34- :-./2-0 ;<826-: =</ >-3131<2-/ 0-=-20.23.20:-./2-0;<826-:=<//-6><20-23>:.1231==.20 >-/86-0 34- 17>8?2-0 </0-/ .20 34- C80?-7-236 /-:1-0 8><2A934-:-./2-0;<826-:6=</>./31-6
! 64</3><12334.3B<8:0./16-=</;<2610-/.31<216 34.3,
D4-/-162<016>83-3<34-=.;334.334->:.1231==4.6 =1:-0.6813=</0-;:./.31<2316.:6<2<312016>83-34.334- 0-=-20.234.6=1:-0416B/133-263.3-7-234-.7-207-23 6<8?43/-.06.6820-/,
!"#
!"#$
%
- 8 -
&!$ '$ (()
*
$ +
*
$, $+
$
=3-/ 68A63.231.: ./?87-236 B-/- .00/-66-0 A9 :-./2-0 ;<826-:6 =</ >./31-6 :-./2-0 ;<826-: =</ >-3131<2-/0-=-20.23=1:-0.7-7<B41;4/-.06.6820-/, -
. . %
$ + * *
% $
4- >-3131<2-/0-=-20.23 =1:-6 . 7-7< B4-/-12 4-4.6.07133-034-<B2-/641><=34-6;4-08:->/<>-/39.6 ;:.17-0A934->:.1231==B134<83>/-C801;-3<34-:-?.:/1?43 3<;:.17.0@-/6-><66-661<2
- 9 -
'316/-:-@.233<-G3/.;334-<A6-/@.31<267.0-.3 >./.6 ! D ' ' ' .20 & <= 34- C80?7-23 <= 34-<2A:- >-G$<8/31234-;.6-<=
.663.3-0.6=<::<B6, / 0$1
$ )$
*
%
$2 %
3 %1 4
5 6 2$ $ 7, 6 -87" (!(# 91 :)!$ ($ -
$
; 6
(< 44"44#$ '&$ +
$ -
$
+
- 10 -
*
$ 1
$
$ +
4
$ +
$ 6
= 3 > $ = $ 7 6
$-$7$ (: $ <0&$ -
?
+
7$)& $
' $ +
@ ('<
$+
= 3
- 11 -
'0
('<
= 3
$/ + @
14
? $-
$-
@
*
$A65 6 "#B ' $
C 4 3* $
4 6 -$8$7$04$!<&$-
4
$ +D
@ *
$
@
- 12 -
4
1 4 $ +
4 $ -
*
$ +
@
4
E
$ +
$ 'F$
$-
8 > 4 6 $ 6 4
=$-$G$ /HHHHH$$
- 13 -
-
% $
$
*
$/
"# :&$ +
$/
&316/-:-@.233<-G3/.;334-<A6-/@.31<267.0-.3 >./.6 .20 <= 34- C80?7-23 <= 34- <2A:- >-G $<8/3 12 34- ;.6- <= # $
% $
.663.3-0.6=<::<B6,
- 14 -
F$ 8
*
%
14
+ 4 $ + %
* $
%
14
+ 4 $
*
? *
%
$
%
$ +
? $ -
$
- 15 -
$
% *
$ !$+
D
= 6 = 4$ 8 $ $ $ 8 7 4$ =,I.64.&& '. (0< " (0<# F 644 :'&
4
$ 14
+ 4
D . ./- 2<3 .::<B-0 3< 3.5- 12;<26163-23>:-.61234-1/0-=-2;-H
2 ;./-=8: >-/86.: <= 34- :.B :.10 0<B2 A9 34- <2FA:- >-G $<8/3 12 34- C80?-7-236 /-=-//-0 4-/-12.A<@-B4.3827163.5.A:9-7-/?-61634.312 </0-/ 3<>/<@-34->:-.<=.0@-/6-><66-661<234-=<820.31<2<=
- 16 -
34->:-.4.63<A-/.16-01234->:-.012?6.2034-/-.=3-/ .2 1668- /-E81/-6 3< A- =/.7-0 8/68.23 3< B41;4 34- 6.7- 16 3< A- 3/1-0 A9 :-.012? 68==1;1-23 .20 6.316=.;3</9 -@10-2;-<=34-0-=-20.23
316.:6<2--0:-663<7-231<234.31=34-/-162< >:-./.16-034-234->./39/.1612?68;4/-:1-=B<8:02<3A- .A:- 3< 68;;--0 12 34- 7.33-/ 08- 3< :.;5 <= >:-.012?6 4-/-=</-34-=820.7-23.:E8-631<21634.334->./39B4< 7.5-6 68;4 . ;:.17 =</ . >./31;8:./ /-:1-= 4.6 3< 7.5- 2-;-66./9 >:-.012?6 12 34- B/133-2 63.3-7-23 .20 34- 6.7-4.63<A-7.0-.6.21668-<2B41;4-@10-2;-4.6 3< A- :-0 B41;4 <= ;<8/6- B<8:0 A- 68AC-;3 3< 0-21.: A9 34-<34-/610-316:-=33<34-$<8/3B4-34-/13.?/--6</ 2<3<268;47.3-/1.:6>:.;-0A934->./394-/-=</-1=. >./39 0<-6 2<3 7.5- . >:-. 4- B<8:0 2<3 A- .A:- 3< 68A63.231.3- 34- 6.7- .20 ;<26-E8-23:9 B<8:0 2<3 68;;--012>/<@12?68;4.>:-. - 17 -
316/-:-@.233<7-231<2.33416><12334.3B4.316 =1:-0A934->-3131<2-/0-=-20.231234-;.6-<24.2016.2 .>>:1;.31<2 820-/ /0-/ 8:- <= $$ 6--512? .7-207-23 7</- 6>-;1=1;.::9 .3 >./.
3< 34- B/133-2 63.3-7-23B41;416.:/-.09-G3/.;3-04-/-12.A<@-
9 @1/38- <= 3416 .7-207-23 34- 0-=-20.23 16 6--512?.0@-/6-><66-661<2.?.126334->:.1231==4-234- 7.33-/ B.6 A-12? ./?8-0 A-=</- 3416 $<8/3 34- =.;3 34.3 34- 0-=-20.23 4.6 2<3 ;.3-?</1;.::9 .07133-0 34- <B2-/641> <= 34- 6;4-08:- >/<>-/39 .6 ;:.17-0 A9 34- >:.1231== 08- 3< B41;4 =.;3 34.3 34- 3/1.: $<8/3 0167166-0 34- .>>:1;.31<2 .20 <2 34- E8-631<2 >83=</34 A9 3416 $<8/3 34- 0-=-20.23 4.6 =1:-0 . 7-7< .0713312? 34- <B2-/641> <= 34- 6;4-08:- >/<>-/39 .6 ;:.17-0 A9 34- >:.1231== B134<83 >/-C801;- 3< 34- :-?.: /1?43 3< ;:.17 .0@-/6-><66-661<24-/-=</-3416.6>-;34.63<A-3.5-2 123<;<2610-/.31<2A934-3/1.:$<8/3B41:-;<2610-/12?34- 7.12 6813 7</- 6>-;1=1;.::9 =</ 34- /-:1-= <= .0@-/6- ><66-661<2
- 18 -
! $<712? A.;5 3< 34- 17>8?2-0 </0-/ 34- .>>:1;.31<2 16 =1:-0 820-/ /0-/ 8:- <= $$ <B-@-//0-/8:-<=$$/-.06.6820-/, /+! &// 1 $2 + 4
%
4
$/
D3B<8:0A-/-:-@.233<7-231<2.3341663.?-34.3 34- .7-207-23 <= >:-.012?6 A9 34- >:.1231== .20 34- 0-=-20.2363.206<2.01==-/-23=<<312?.:3<?-34-/3162< 7</- 34.334-.7-207-23<=B/133-263.3-7-23 162<3?<@-/2-0A9-G.;3:934-6.7->/12;1>:-<0<8A3 34-?-2-/.:>/12;1>:-6./-.>>:1;.A:-3<34->:.1231==.2034-
- 19 -
0-=-20.23B134/-?./03<.7-207-236<B-@-/B4-2.2 .>>:1;.31<2 =</ .7-207-23 16 =1:-0 A9 34- 0-=-20.23 34- $<8/36 ./- /-E81/-0 3< ;<2610-/ .20 3< 3.5- . >/.?7.31;
@1-B <2 68;4 .>>:1;.31<26 :1A-/.::9 A9 2<3 /-C-;312? 13 <2 3-;421;.:/-.6<26
' $<712? 3< 34- .6>-;3 <= 0167166.: <= 34- .>>:1;.31<2 <2 34- ?/<820 34.3 34- 0-=-20.23 4.6 2<3 .07133-0 34- <B2-/641> <= >:.1231== <@-/ 34- 6;4-08:- >/<>-/39<B-@-/2<BA9@1/38-<=.7-7<=1:-0A-=</- 3416$<8/30.3-0 '' '34-0-=-20.234.6.07133-0 34- <B2-/641> <= 34- 6;4-08:- >/<>-/39 ;:.17-0 A9 34- >:.1231== B134<83 >/-C801;- 3< 34- :-?.: /1?43 3< ;:.17 .0@-/6-><66-661<2
' -/-:9 A-;.86- 34- 0-=-20.23 4.6 7.0- .2 .:3-/2.31@- >:-. <= .0@-/6- ><66-661<212 34-.7-207-23 .>>:1;.31<2 34.3 B<8:0 2<3 7-.2 4- 4.6 68;;--0-0 .20 >/<@-0 34- 6.10 >:-. <= .0@-/6- ><66-661<2 .6 34- 3/1.:
$<8/3 B<8:0 4.@- 3< =/.7- .2 1668- .20 34- 0-=-20.23
- 20 -
B<8:0 4.@- 3< >/<@- 34- 1668- B41;4 <= ;<8/6- 34- >:.1231== B<8:0 A- .3 :1A-/39 3< ;<23/<@-/3 016>/<@- .20 /-A83 34- 6.10 ;:.176 6< 7.0- A9 34- 0-=-20.23 83 .2 <>></38213916/-E81/-03<A-?1@-23<34-0-=-20.233<>83 =</34 416 >:-.012?6 12 34- B/133-2 63.3-7-23 A9 B.9 <= .7-207-234-.7-207-23<=>:-.012?6;.2A-7.0-A9 -134-/ >./39 .3 .29 63.?- <= 34- >/<;--012?6 =</ 34- >8/><6- <= 0-;1012?
34- /-.: ;<23/<@-/69 12 016>83- </ 1668- 12 016>83- .20 B41:- 0<12? 6< 6<7- <= 34<6- .7-207-236 ./- /-E81/-0 3< A- .::<B-0 B41;4 0< 2<3 ;.86- 12C8631;- </ ;4.2?- 34- 2.38/- <= 34- 6813 </ 3.5- .B.9 34- 0-=-2;- </ A- -/.6-0 A9 >./31-6 </ .29 .071661<26 34.3 ./- .:/-.09 7.0- B41;4 -28/- 3< 34- A-2-=13<=34-<34-/610-
''234->/-6-23;.6-.6B-::1=34-0-=-20.234.6 .:/-.09 7.0- .29 63.3-7-23 12 416 >:-.012?6 </ 12 34- -@10-2;- 34.3 ?<-6 12 =.@<8/ <= 34- >:.1231== 34- 6.7- ;.22<3 A- 3.5-2 A.;5 </ -/.6-0 A9 @1/38- <= 34- >/-6-23 .7-207-23<=34->:-.<=.0@-/6-><66-661<2.20.:6<.2
- 21 -
<>></382139 3< A- ?1@-2 3< 34- >:.1231== 3< /-A83 34- >:-. .2034--@10-2;-1=6<.008;-0A934-0-=-20.23
'&234-A.616<=34-C80?7-236/-:1-08><2A934- :-./2-0 ;<826-: =</ 34- >-3131<2-/0-=-20.23 .7<= 34- <>121<234.334-.>>:1;.31<2=1:-0=</.7-207-230-6-/@-6 3<A-.::<B-0.2034-3/1.:$<8/34.6;<77133-0.2-//</12 016716612? 34- .>>:1;.31<2 B41;4 16 2<B 6<8?43 3< A- /-;31=1-0 A9 .0713312? 34- <B2-/641> <= 34- >:.1231== <@-/ 34-6;4-08:->/<>-/39
' ;;</012?:9>.6634-=<::<B12?,
1 416>-3131<216 3I 11 4- 17>8?2-0 </0-/ 0.3-0 ! ' ' >.66-0 <2 < 12 <''' A9 * 00131<2.: $139 $1@1: .20 -661<26 +80?- -2?.:8/8 16 4-/-A9 6-3 .610- $<26-E8-23:9 <16.::<B-0I
- 22 -
111 4- >-3131<2-/0-=-20.23 16 >-/7133-0 3< ;.//9<83 34- .7-207-23 .6 6<8?43 =</ 12 <I 1@ 3 16 2--0:-66 3< 7-231<2 34.3 34- >-3131<2-/0-=-20.23 12 >8/68.2;- 3< 34- =1:12?<=34167-7<;.3-?</1;.::9.0713634- <B2-/641> <= 34- /-6><20-23>:.1231== <@-/ 34-68136;4-08:->/<>-/39
!*+ ( !#) '
$ 163<,:<,'