Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 79095 (PNJ)
JAGDISH AND ORS v. STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
CWP/24263/2021 · 2025-02-13
Jagmohan Bansal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 79095 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 79095 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!" #$#%&#'() * * %()(+),#'() * * --
--
--
--
"./0"*-"-0
!" ##
$
%&'()(*+(,(-. / 0
" 1 0
"/2
"
#
$
%&'(-3*(,(). 2/
# 4 5 2 / 5/
/ /
$ 0 36 %&'()(*+(,(-. $ 0 -7(* %&'()(*+(,(-. 8888 Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"-0
1*
-
&'()(*+(,(-
&'(-3* (,()
$
/ ! / ' $
$ $! $ ! $ &'()(*+(,(- (
/ / ((*9((:$& /$;
-3,:(,(- %</ (+. ! =/
/
> ? /!;
$ $
+
"
; %$
@;A.
/ (,,-(,--
/
!# $/
-7,:(,,-%</ -.$
$4$$ # $$ $ ! $$
$
$ &
$
&
$ 2 $
$
/
! $4
& ! ; /! ; /
> ;
B &/ ! $ 2 ? 2
/ $/!;
$ ;
$/! ;
! $ $; 2
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
-3,+(,(- %</ -6. /
/
! /!;
$ / $ $; $
&'0:6(+$(,(-!$ &/
$
,7,)(,(-
! 3
$
/
-3,:(,(-
"
$
*
&/ $
/! C
$/ # & ? 4
%$ @4A. 4 & /"! / %$ @A. ! $4 2
4
& !/"! / /
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$ / $ $;
/
4
&
< /
; /
$ -)$& /$ ;
$ > ;
B &/ ! $2
$$ $ > ;
B &/ ! ! $ $;
/
$
$
/ /
;
"
D$$
$/"! /
D$$
$ "
! -7*-
/"! / / $ /
D$$ ! # $
$2 # / $2 $;
$2
:
" 2#4 /! $;
/ $ / $ # $; $ ! !# $ ;
!$ %3,E.
$ %3,E.! $ ;$ ! $ B$;
! B$; $ ! 2
D$$
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
?/!;
! 2 $
! /
$! $;/
! $ 4 ? ! $! $& ? $$ $ $ ? &
? 7 5
2 / 5/ / /! $/ ! $3(
$;
/ !! $;
$ $/!;
0 $;
!/
! $4 4
! /
$;
$
! $
!/
!! $
$ ;
/
! $ ;/
! $ $ /!
$ 6 ;
/ $
/ $ ! / ! -, ? / $! / $
$ ;
! /
! & # # Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$ $BD; /
! $;
$/ ! $ $ ! !BD;-,,E $ ! ! !BD;3,E !$
3,E!$ $ /<
! !# & # $ /! ! $ ! ! / D $ & # ! $! $ ! # /! $
$$ /
$;
2//
$ ! $& ! 0! $! $4
& ! /!; /! ; ; ! $! / $$
!&
? $/ ! $ $ ! $ $& ! ;
! ! $ $ /
$; ! $; /
$
/
$/!;
/ /
$ $;
#
$/!;
$ / $ $;
--
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
!/"! /
$ /"! /
$$
! $ $4
/
$ / / ! $ 2 ? 0
$ $
/ /
! $;
/"! / /
$ $;
#
4
4 &
! /"! -7*- 4 (,,:%$ @(,,:A.
/"! /
/"! /
2
# $ / $
$ ;
4F&
2 /
!$$ $ /
4
& -( /$
;
/ $& # $ ! ! !& # $ $ $& # ;$
=/ !& # #
! $; !/
! /$$ / < !&
? ! /
/ ! $ / $$
! Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
2
;
D$$
$2//
$
/
!4 /
2//
$ ! $
! /
; $
;
$; ! 2//
$ -+ ? / $
/ $! #
;
$& # $ $
# ;&/ -7,:(,,-$& # / ! #
$$%&'($$)$(&)&(((%"**+, -
*
. /
0
#1$23&(($
.
-
/
4 *
"
*56 -
/
*56
7
5$8((((((()%+5
,
-
*56
9% Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
2
+, : * 5 +*5, 6
-
*
*56 6
;(<
;(<
4 -
6 =
7
-
*
> = 0 0 0 7%% *?** +, 04-
7
*56 4
7
6 7 6 4-
/
6
7%7
4@ 6 *
7 47
-
@ 6 %
-
7
-
* 4-
7 * 56 +, 1 $AAA . *56
6
"
5 1
+ 0 7%***,
*5 6 0
B*56
+ , 5
* 5 6CD
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
4
". . /
04- =
. /
0
& -
*
7
5 6 -
*
B 4-
B6
= 4 -
-
8 4 6 =
4 -
B
6
E
*56
0
. /
0
-
6
;
. *1 #
2AE)F% )&(($
8'&(($ *1 1#
$&A8) ***)&(($
$G'&(($ G/ $$/ 4 )% +41, : 4
-
*
#
8($&&$E! Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
; $ ! / $
! $ ! !& # /
! ! ! # & # $ /$
/ #
/! $$
$ & # ; $ ! $
$ & # # ! / $ -) # $ / $& #
(7,6(,,- ! (7,6(,,- / ! H? ? &
F #4 42
2 # $ 4 & 0-*9+-9(,,-)4#; 2
&
(7,6(,,- /!"
$; $ $4 $ / 0:779 ( 2
(*,7(,,-
/!"
! ( # $ 4
;
4
#$; 0;;(:,9-,((,,,?;;%. -7,:(,,- + # $4 $/
<<<< $$9 /9<<<<<9'
=/ / I</$$
$$ '
$$ $$ &
- % -,,,,-3(,,. 4
& - % /
. % *3,,-,3,,. ; - % *3,,66,,. D$$ - % 7,,,-+3,,. & + % -,,,,-3(,,.
& 3 % +,3,)36,. ;( % 33,,6,,,. ( % 3,,,:73,. 2/ : % 7,,,-+3,,. -
+,3,)36,. & ! (* % +,3,3+(3. 0/
- % )3,,*,,,. Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
; : % *3,,66,,. 4
& ) % ),,,*,,,. ;(+ % 33,,66,,. ;-7 % -)3,*,,,. 4
& -*, % ),,,*,,,. J<<<<*:3 % <<<<<<<. '9&<<<<-3 % (33,+(,,. -3 % (33,+(,,. & () % (*-,+3),. 2! 7 % (*-,+3),. ! : % (*-,+3),. 6+* : ++ )
? $! /
$
$ # /
/
$ & ! & $& /
! ; D$$ $ $ $& ! ; $
-7*-
D / ! 0"" *#.F# 51F5 0F- 5H6%6 4/5*"05FF#I:.054) 4/5*.0#-:50. 04F40*#*5) *4.0*0601" 4 *F *4.0*0601" *F40* #*4.0*06011*45*II5 40F /05H0#0 @/ 4F "/H4*0 40#1051 0#1 F1:0* #0J:0**0* #05F04:#1F59 /F*-/;K%$$L F1:0* #$&10F 6*5/EG2$ Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
/F/046FF#1F05F1.F1*0H*6H/F. )0.6 #8(;(&0#1/*4/050F50#10#FF1F#4/0F 6FF# F5**F1 6H 1)4" II5 0#1 /F *4 /F5F6H 0"" *#F104F." 505H #406F*#*#1*05F4F5F 600* # @*/ FF 5 . $'(G(& 0# *# /F "0H 40F 548(;(%2;%E8&;F6%$((%;8&;/F*40 F1*#1*0 5F4F5F600* # #406:05H# 82A0#11F05F1 040.F.6F5 5F:#1F50; $2G$/F*4F4F1 @*//F" @F54:#* #40#1"5**F-F4 " *F *F54/F/046FF#F#*4F1 #/F #1** #/0 /F@*6F:H6 :#10#106*1F/F""50#1 /F5 5:F4)*#45:* #4*44:F16H/F- 5 .*.F *.F *1F#**0* #.05I49% $405 #0#IF &
*0-5FF@*//F06 F 4*-#0:5F /F0#1*10F ..0#10# *#1*05F4F5F600* # 6/ #14*+-:5-0 #,! -3 0$4
& ! ;; ;
$ & ! $4
& ! $/
$;9;$
/! =/
$
$/
/! ! /
/ $
3(
$; ;% . /
! $$
& ! $ D$$ /
!! $
$
/ C
/ /
!! $; Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
& ! ! -*
/
,6,7(,((
$$
/
/
!
/
HA *
7
%4 ) )7
9% +, @ * 5 6
/ "
M * 5)4
)*
+, @ / 0
"
* 5 6
M +, 0 B 4
* 4 : 4
* 5 6
/ " M +, @
* 56
M +, @
B / 0 4* 4 * *
56
1 " )/0") / 5
"
) M +, 1
1 0 5 4 0
"
6 4
&8 Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
/ "
0 &(('
5
0&(('
+, @ *
>N- +. @
,
- +. @
, -
5/ 0
"
"
M +, @4* /
" +,
*
M +7, @ * 5 6 > ) B
4 5 6 6
6 4 >
/ "
" "
5
M 1 =>
+7, @
* 56
1"
)
1
"
)/0")
"
) M +7, @ 4* *
/ 0
"
)
" +
, 4/ ) ? >) ) )"4 M +7, @ *
56 >
"
M Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
+7, @
)/ )0
4
*
)4 *
)*
/ "
M! -: )$4 (,,:%$ @(,,:A.
$ //! /
/ C
# ! /
! $ ;
/ / C
! / 4 $$ &
%$ @4&A.
$ /$
! / ! ! $ 6*$(,,: /"! /
! !$
/ / $
/
)
6*
/ ! ! !"
4
0% +$, B >
4 -
*
"
4 4N +&, >
% > B
/ 44 >
/ "4
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
+8,
N +E,
#$ !"
+$,"
0$2G$+0;
$2G$, 4
/
+&, #
B
0
B
0 +8, 0 0
0 +E,
" "
5
"
0 $2G$+0;
$2G$,
4
/
0
0! -7 ? / $!=/
# C $
C ! C!
!/ /C
/4&
C /4 /! &
%$ @4&A.
$ /
! !# 2 4 #
4 &
!# /$ ! $ !4& 4&; $ Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$ / ; $ ; /
$& # /
$ $&
? $
/
&
? # $$ C
4 %0#C
D . / (,-:%$ @(,-: / A.$
/
(,,: # C
$/ /
; -6 $ $& ! ;
/"! / #
$$
> &2
?$ $ $$ ! $ $ $/!;
; > ?; / $$$$ > ? !; >
$$$ ! $ $/ $; / -+-3
/ -+-*$/"! / $; / ! H%&%' ( ) * +
! +$, 5 4 4% *
B *
$;0
1*
% - 4
"
$8$;+$, 5 4 4%*
-
5"
*
%-
"
0 *
%- -
5" Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
2
1 *
%-
B
4
"
*
%- /B
N
O
4
1 *
%-
*
%-
+&, 4
*
% -
PO+
$8$;+&,,
1*
-
4
N 0 * - -
5" 4%*
*
%-
1*
%-
0 *
% - -
5"
=
$&82+$,
=
$8$'
4
4%*
*
%- $8$'+$,
1 *
%-
0 *
%- -
5 "
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*
%-
N
1*
%-
0 *
% - -
5" +8,@
PO 1 *
%-
0 *
%- -
5 "
+
,
*
%- "
7
1 *
%- 0 *
%- -
5" +E,4%*
PO
4% *
PO
% 4
PO
@
PO
%&%$ +
, -
!
+$,4 B
*
PO
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$8$ 4
F
* +&,
B
*
PO
$8E
B 4
%$8$& +$,
PFO
B PO
B
* +8, #
PO
*
%- @
PO 1 *
%- =
*
%- K (,
$/ /
$
> ?;
$ $ ! &/ $ !/
$ ! $
/
/
$$/
$ / L/
$ / &/ . " (
/
0
,12345567 %5 88 %
/&/
! $ ! < $"/ / ! H;A
)
=
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
7
0
=
7
B 7
7
G(*
9 : 345567 4 88 $' 1
6
3
; , +
""
<" 3%#=&7 4 88 $'52 < 9, ,"
+ 3%#=7 & 88 4%2
0
3%#=$7 4 88 62 98 ," 307
>
3%#657 & 88 4#
? :
- ,,
@ ? 3455$7
88 %&4
9 39 :
345567 4 88 $'2 4'($E, +, -
N +,
7
N +,
-
N + ,
-
N Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
+,
-
N +, B
! ! (,-
$
$/
!#
$ $
!(,,:
/
! $;$ / $ $;
!/ &/ $ ! #
! $; > ? $/
$
$
$
! <
/ $
! %% 4
4 &
! $ 4 &
/ $# &
# &
$ / $ $; /$ $ ! /
! "
$ ! $4 ! $4
& $ Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$$
! / $ # $# / $2 # $ ! / $& # / $; 2 9
# &
/"! / 4F &
&
!/
!(,-:/
/ +$(,-:/
$ /! $
/ -($(,-:/
$ $
D$$
/ +F-(
& 9
,
! 4 ?!! A ? 9
"
-
B
%4
"" !"
+$,
> %
+, - + ,
N +, - + ,
- 5"
N +, / 0
"
N +,
"
! Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
<$(,-:/
$/ /
4F&
/
4
&
< $ (,-: /
/ !
H33#)'45 -##+6# 0 0 -%* (* #$47)894()(: 3($9 +;<#%(:($9$ -,86#(:8= 4)$* #%;8)#)9 #;3(%8%= (986 - ( + ) 3 * - ;
+)+ ((, 3*+ ))6,,-)(),, ( /!;
**( *-, -(:( +3),,--(),, +
/! ;
(+:6 -(+: +*-* (6(,,6(+,, ) 4 & ! +)++ (:,( *-+3 (33,,7--,, 3 & ! -76(+ -(:6* +-:-6 (-:,,*6-,, (986
8%=8)8%;#'(64,# -%* (* #$47)894() (:3($9 +;<#%(:($9$ -,86#(:8= 4)$* #%;8)#)9 #;3(%8%= (986 - ( + ) 3 * - ;
33 () :6 ))6,,-)(),, ( /! ;
-3* :3 (+- +3),,--(),, +
/! ;
(+( 3) (7* (6(,,6(+,, ) 4 & ! 73( )6( -+)) (33,,7--,, 3 & ! )(66 (-,+ *),( (-:,,*6-,, (986 2
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
(&#%);#)9846>8=(64,# -%* (* #$47)894() (:3($9 +;<#%(:($9$ -,86#(:8= 4)$* #%;8)#)9 #;3(%8%= (986 - ( + ) 3 * - ;
-7 ( (, ))6,,-)(),, ( /! ;
-6 -- +, +3),,--(),, +
/! ;
--3 --7 -++ (6(,,6(+,, ) 4 & ! -3, )7 -67 (33,,7--,, 3 & ! -,,3 +,6 -+-) (-:,,*6-,, (986
2 8%=8)8(64,#(;;8)'( -%* (* #$47)894() (:3($9 +;<#%(:($9$ -,86#(:8= 4)$* #%;8)#)9 #;3(%8%= (986 - ( + ) 3 * - ;
: , : ))6,,-)(),, ( /! ;
-) , -) +3),,--(),, +
/! ;
+, , +, (6(,,6(+,, ) 4 & ! ), , ), (33,,7--,, 3 & ! +6) , +6) (-:,,*6-,, (986
(-
/
$2$;
$/ /$
/
! #
$ 2
$
/! ! 2
!/"! /
$2
!4 / (,,(
! $
$$ Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
!/ ;
$; ! $ $ 2
! $ $ 2
$ $;
D $&/
/ / $
$
$2
/
! ;
$
$$
$$ / $
$ F 2
/
! / &/ < $ / ((* $ & / $ ;
/ /
$$ / $ $2;
$
! $ ! $ / ; /
&/
/!
/ $ / ;
$$$
$! /! /
!$ &/ ((
=/
! &/ ,6,7(,(( $
$$
(-,((,(+
$
! $;
$; D$$ 2
C
9
9 B
/
A
/
2D9D$$
/
/ $
/ Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
2 $
$
/ $ $ / 9
/
/ $
/ F
/
/
/
=/
! # $; (+ $$
(-,((,(+$
! $/
$ /
! $ ;
/
$ > ;
B &/ $ / $ $ # $ ; /
(7,*(,-+
# 9
/
$
/!! /
$ /
!/
/ !$$$ $ / ! $$$ ! /
;$$ ! $ $
0 ! $ ; / $! $2 # 4 &
()
$
/ /
! $ ; ; ! $/ ! $; /
! !& / /"! /
! $ Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
2
4 $ $
/"! /
/ $
$ / /
/"! / $/"! /
$
$
$
$$
/! $
$ & ! /
$ ; ; ; !/
! /
(3
$
$
$
! $; $# &
$ ;
/
! $# &
;! $$
/
!&/
! # $ $ $$! $;/
$ $# &
! ! &/ $# &
! $# & 2
! $ $ F
/ $
! $;
D$$ ! $ ;$
$$$ ! 2
! $# & /
! $ # &
! /
2
Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
/ $
!2
! $ ; D$$ $
F
/ ! $# & (*
/ $;
/
! $# & ! / /
$$ $ ! $4
&
;
/
(,,- 4 (,,:$ $,---(,,7(+ $ $
(,-:/ $ $ ,7,3(,-: # 4 &
?
# &
# # ;
&/
/ ; $# &
;/ /
/
/ $ C (: & # $ ; ! $;! / ;$$
# & # &
/
/
; ;$ & #
$;$ / $ 4 # /
! !/
$ ! $ ; $ / $4 ; ;
$ /
! =/ ; Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
! $ F
! ! $; ! ;
D$$ $
(7
/
/ &
/ /
/ $$ 9/
C
/
!/"! $/ ! $
C
/
$
/ $ ? /!;
$
;
! $ C
/
! $
$$ 9 $ ? ;$ $
! ! $ /& / /
/ $$/
(6 ;$! /
$
! 0
+,
% . $
$
"-0
-+,((,(3 ?" ' 9
G 90 ' ! G 90 Asgar Ali 2025.02.13 16:03 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document