Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 7897 (KAR)

SHANTAPPA S/O KASTURI KATTIMANI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/103471/2024 · 2025-02-03

S Rachaiah

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #!# ! $!%&"" % ! ! " # ! $ % &$ ' ( %! ( &% %! " #!&' ( )*+ (!!!& #!)* (& *' !) !! ** ) ( ! ! ,& * ) ( (( )*& )& )& * & * & *)& *& )& #'& *)& +%)+ ( ! $ $ )! ! & ( ( & & ( % - Digitally signed by SREEDHARAN BANGALORE SUSHMA LAKSHMI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - .!, ! ' # .!, ! ' ! /012 13! 435067801 0209020:3& ;/01</2 =>7<?/; @>1 A4/ B/A3A3></1 0<2 8A! 0;0 47A/& ;/01</2 223A3><0;>5/1<8/<A25>=0A/@>1A4/1/?B><2/<A-A0A/! ! 4/ B/A3A3></1 3? C/@>1/ A43? >71A ?//63<: 1/:7;01 C03;3<138/>!* )>@1/?B><2/<A->;3=/A0A3><@>1A4/ >@@/<=/? B7<3?40C;/ 7<2/1 /=A3><? *)& )*& )& )& * & * &*& +19)+>@ ! !()*+,-.-/*,+.*+(* *! A3?A4/=0?/>@A4/B1>?/=7A3><A40AA4/93@/>@A4/ =>8B;03<0<A0<2A4/93@/>@!%!01/A4/?3?A/1?>@!%! 0<20;;01/1/;0A35/?!4/@083;D>@A4/=>8B;03<0<A402/<83AD 93A4A4/0==7?/2-0A4D0BB00<243?@083;D8/8C/1?!4/?032 /<83AD 402 2/5/;>B/2 3< A4/ D/01 /::71 53;;0:/ B0<=40D0A4 /;/=A3>< 0<2 =><A3<7/2 /5/< 0@A/1 ?/5/10; D/01?! 4/ :10<2?>< >@ 0==7?/2 >! 53E!& 0:01 F 0:010BB0 402 >7A10:/2A4/8>2/?AD>@></40<6010550&94>3?A4/93@/>@ - 3 - !%!0<20;?>>7A10:/2A4/8>2/?AD>@></417A43&94>3? A4/207:4A/1>@A4/=>8B;03<0<A! )! < ! ! ) 01>7<2 !* B!8!& ></ 0<G7<0A4 0<780<A400;0:0BB0=0;;/2!%!*0<20?6/2438A>=>8/ A> A4/ B;0=/ 94/1/ 4/ 402 3<?A17=A/2 A> 1/?>;5/ A4/ 23?B7A/?! ==>123<:;D&3227F3220BB0&0<G7<0A40<220D402C//< A>A4/B;0=/94/1/A4/D9/1/3<?A17=A/2A>:>!4/1/0@A/1&A4/ ?032 0<G7<0A40 0;0:0BB0 >;0 0<2 >A4/1? 3<?A/02 >@ 1/?>;53<: A4/ 23?B7A/? C/A9//< A4/ @083;3/?& A4/D ?A01A/2 H7011/;;3<: 93A4 A4/ 3<G71/2! < A4/ ?08/ 20D& 94/< 0;; A4/ A41// B/1?><? 9/1/ :>3<: A> A4/31 4>7?/& 0;; A4/ 0==7?/2 1/?A103</23227F3220BB0&0<G7<0A40<220D0<2?A01A/2 0??07;A3<:3<A43?/<83AD0<2=07?/23<G713/?A>0;;>@A4/8!4/ ?032 3227 F 3220BB0 23/2 3< A4/ ?032 3<=32/<A! >9/5/1& !%!-0<G7<0A40<2!%!*-20D?7?A03</2?/5/1/3<G713/?! 4/1/@>1/& A4/ =>8B;03<A =08/ A> C/ 1/:3?A/1/2 CD A4/ =>8B;03<0<A 0:03<?A 0;; A4/ 0==7?/2 3<=;723<: A4/ B/A3A3></1! 4/ G713?23=A3><0; B>;3=/ 0@A/1 1/:3?A/13<: A4/ =0?/ 3< 138/ >!* )& =><27=A/2 A4/ 3<5/?A3:0A3>< 0<2 ?7C83AA/2 A4/ =401:/?4//A! - 4 - ! A3? A4/?7C83??3><>@A4/;/01</2=>7<?/;@>1A4/ B/A3A3></1A40AA4/B/A3A3></13?3<<>=/<A>@A4/0;;/:/2>@@/<=/? 0<24/40?C//<38B;3=0A/23<A4/@0;?/=0?/! ! A3?@71A4/1?7C83AA/2A40AA4/>5/1A0=A0AA13C7A/2 0:03<?A A4/ B/A3A3></1 3? A40A 4/ 402 0??07;A/2 A4/ 2/=/0?/2 93A40<31><1>2><C>A4A4/40<2?0<20;?>;/:?!>9/5/1&A4/ B>?A8>1A/8 1/B>1A 9>7;2 3<23=0A/ A40A A4/ 2/0A4 90? 27/ A> A4/4/023<G71D! ! A3?@71A4/1?7C83AA/2A40AA4/B/A3A3></140?C//< 3< G723=30; =7?A>2D ?3<=/ ! ! )! 43? >71A 3< 1383<0; /A3A3><>! )&1/G/=A/2A4/C03;><A4/:1>7<2A40A A4/ >5/1A 0=A 0AA13C7A/2 0:03<?A A4/ B/A3A3></1 3? ?/13>7? 3< <0A71/!>9/5/1&>A4/10==7?/294>01/?A0<23<:><A4/?08/ @>>A3<: <08/;D 0:01& 080<0BB0 0<2 4350<0<20 405/ 0;?> C//<2/<3/2C03;! ! A3?@71A4/1?7C83AA/2A40AA4/B/A3A3></13?0D>7<: B/1?><0<24/3?A4/><;D/01<3<:8/8C/1>@A4/@083;D!/ 93;;0C32/CDA4/=><23A3><?38B>?/2CDA43?>71A3<A4//5/<A >@ 43? 1/;/0?/ >< C03;! 063<: ?7=4 ?7C83??3><?& ;/01</2 =>7<?/;@>1A4/B/A3A3></1B10D?A>0;;>9A4/B/A3A3><! - 5 - +! & ;/01</2 223A3><0; >5/1<8/<A 25>=0A/5/4/8/<A;D>BB>?/2A4/?032?7C83??3><?0<2@71A4/1 ?4/ ?7C83AA/2 A40A A4/ B/A3A3>< 3? 0 ?7==/??35/ C03; B/A3A3><! 4//01;3/1C03;0BB;3=0A3><90?1/G/=A/20@A/14053<:=><?32/1/2 A4/ :1053AD 0<2 ?/13>7?</?? >@ A4/ >@@/<=/! 4/ B1/?/<A B/A3A3>< =><A03<? <> =40<:/2 =31=78?A0<=/?! 7=4 C/3<: A4/ @0=A& =><?32/13<: A4/ C03; B/A3A3>< >< A4/ ?08/ :1>7<2? 9>7;2 <>A 013?/! 4/1/@>1/& A4/ ?08/ 40? A> C/ 1/G/=A/2! 063<: ?7=4?7C83??3><?&A4/;/01</2223A3><0;>5/1<8/<A25>=0A/ B10D?A>23?83??A4/B/A3A3><! ! 053<:4/012A4/;/01</2=>7<?/;@>1A4/1/?B/=A35/ B01A3/? 0<2 0;?> B/17?/2 A4/ 05/18/<A? >@ A4/ =401:/ ?4//A 0<20;?>A4//01;3/1C03;B/A3A3><0<23A?10A3>&3A3?1/;/50<AA> <>A/ A40A A4/ B1/?/<A B/A3A3>< @3;/2 @>1 :10<A3<: >@ C03; A> 0==7?/2 >!) =><A03<? <> =40<:/2 =31=78?A0<=/?! 5/< 0??783<: A40A A4/ >5/1A 0=A 0AA13C7A/2 0:03<?A A4/ B/A3A3></1 4/1/3<3?<>A?>?/13>7?&A4/@0=A1/803<?A40A3@A4/B/A3A3></13? /<;01:/2 >< C03;& A4/1/ 9>7;2 C/ 0 A41/0A A> A4/ B1>?/=7A3>< 93A</??/?! - 6 - ! < B/17?0; >@ A4/ =401:/ ?4//A& 3A 0BB/01? A40A A4/1/01/A9>93A</??/?94>405/?7@@/1/23<G713/?3<A4/?032 3<=32/<A!4/D01/A4/80A/130;93A</??/?A>A4/=0?/!3;;A4/ =>8B;/A3>< >@ A4/31 /532/<=/& 3A 3? <>A 0BB1>B130A/ A> =><?32/1 A4/C03;>@A4/B/A3A3></1! ! /<=/& B1>=//2A>B0??A4/@>;;>93<:- #3' 4/1383<0;/A3A3><?A0<2? #33' 3C/1AD3?1/?/15/2A>A4/B/A3A3></1A>0BB1>0=4A43? >71A@>1C03;0@A/1=>8B;/A3><>@A4//532/<=/>@%?!&0<2 *! "01 2" 3 & ?? 3?A>!+;>!