- 1 - ! "" #$% & !"#$ # # % % #& ## #' (! ! )% ! " "* " ''+'+ # $ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ,+ $ " # )) " '' # " # # "#+' '+# # # # " - #- . # /01 233425 01 60547 89 :/4 ;520<2=: 2334552=: 2>20=1::/4?@7><4=:2=72A2B772:47''0="# C+' '+ 321147 89 :/4 770:0C=25 C:CB ;;074=:1 #520<1 B08@=25 2=7 770:0C=25 4=0CB #0D05 @7>4 E # 2: 2<2=2>2B2 6CB 1/CB: FB08@=25G$ 144H0=> 6CB 4=/2=;4<4=:C6:/4;C<34=12:0C= /4 72:4 C6 2;;074=: 0=DC5D4<4=: C6 :/4 D4/0;540=?@B0411@1:20=4789:/4;520<2=:2=7:/45028050:9 :C 329 :/4 ;C<34=12:0C= 2B4 =C: 0= 7013@:4 /4 C=59 7013@:40=:/0123342501:/4I@2=:@<C6;C<34=12:0C= + 42B7 B0 ! /2=:/2B2? 542B=47 ;C@=145 23342B0=> 6CB 2334552=: 2=7 B0 CD0=72B2?2= 542B=47 - 3 - ;C@=145 6CB B413C=74=: C =1@B2=;4 #C<32=9 2=7 34B@147:/4B4;CB71 % B0! /2=:/2B2?542B=47;C@=14523342B0=>6CB :/42334552=::2H0=>:/01#C@B::/BC@>/:/4?@7><4=:2=7 2A2B732114789:/4B08@=25D4/4<4=:59;C=:4=747:/2: :/4 72:4 C6 2;;074=: A21 ''+ 2=7 :/4 2334552=: A21 2>47 942B1 2: :/4 :0<4 C6 2;;074=: /4 B08@=25 /21 :2H4= 0=;C<4 21 1''' 34B <C=:/ 0=1:427 C6 1''' 34B<C=:/A21;520<4789:/42334552=:2=7 251C 1@8<0::47 :/2: :/4 ;C<34=12:0C= 2A2B747 @=74B 255 C:/4B /4271 4J;43: <470;25 4J34=141 2B4 C= :/4 5CA4B 10742=7B4I@0B41B4;C=1074B2:0C= 4/216@B:/4B1@8<0::47:/2:2134B:/40=;C<4 60J4789 :/4!2B=2:2H2 :2:44>25 4BD0;4@:/CB0:9 6CB 1/CB: F! G$ 0= B4134;: C6 @=1H05547 528C@B 6CB :/4 942B '+ 01 1)''' 34B <C=:/ /4 B08@=25 /21 =C: ;C=1074B47 :/4 A2>4 60J47 89 :/4 ! :/4 12<4 B4I@0B41:C84;C=1074B472=7:/4;C<34=12:0C=2A2B747 - 4 - 89 :/4 B08@=25 84 B474:4B<0=47 2=7 /4=;4 1C@>/: :C 255CA:/4233425 46@:0=>:/41@8<0110C=1C6:/4542B=47;C@=145 6CB:/42334552=: B0CD0=72B2?2=542B=47;C@=1456CB :/4 B413C=74=: K =1@B2=;4 #C<32=9 D4/4<4=:59 1@8<0::47:/2:0=:/42814=;4C62=93BCC6C60=;C<4:/4 2334552=:840=>942B1:/4B08@=25/213BC34B59:2H4= 0=;C<42:1''' 34B<C=:/2=72A2B747233BC3B02:4 ;C<34=12:0C=@=74B255:/4/42712=7:/412<47C41=C: ;255 6CB 0=:4B64B4=;4 4=;4 /4 1C@>/: :C 701<011 :/4 233425 , 2D0=>/42B7:/4542B=47;C@=1456CB:/432B:041 2=7 C= 34B@125 C6 :/4 4=:0B4 3234B1 :/4 C=59 3C0=: :/2: 2B01416CB;C=1074B2:0C=846CB4:/01#C@B:01- - 5 - 9 2=1A4B :C :/4 28CD4 3C0=: 6CB ;C=1074B2:0C= 01 32B:590=2660B<2:0D46CB:/46C55CA0=>- ) 7<0::4759 :/4 2;;074=: C;;@BB47 0= :/4 942B '+ =D04AC6:/40=;C<460J4789:/4! 0=B4134;: C6 @=1H05547 528C@B 2: 1)''' 34B <C=:/ 6CB :/4 942B '+ :/4 12<4 0=;C<4 01 ;C=1074B47 21 2>20=1: :/4 0=;C<4 :2H4= 89 :/4 B08@=25 2: 1''' 34B <C=:/ /4 2334552=: /21 1@1:20=47 6B2;:@B4 C6 B0>/: 64<@B A0:/ <@1;545C112=752;4B2:47AC@=7CD4B:/4B0>/::/0>/2=7 /4@=74BA4=:0=:4B5C;H0=>=20560J2:0C=401@=2854:C7C /01B4>@52B2;:0D0:0412134B:/44D074=;4C6C;:CB /4 2334552=: 01 1@664B0=> 6BC< 70128050:9 :/2: 0=:4B64B41 A0:/ /01 =CB<25 729:C729 2;:0D0:041 :/4 1207 70128050:9 /21844=211411472:L:C:/4A/C548C79 = D04A C6 :/4 0=;C<4 60J47 89 :/4 ! $2=7/2D0=>=C:47:/2::/4;C<34=12:0C=2A2B747 @=74B 255 :/4 /4271 4J;43: <470;25 4J34=141 2B4 C= :/4 - 6 - 5CA4B 1074 :/01 #C@B: 3BC;447 :C B474:4B<0=4 :/4 ;C<34=12:0C=:/412<4ACBH1C@:216C55CA1- 5 C 2B:0;@52B1 #C<34=12:0C= @:@B4 5C11 C6 42B=0=> C= 2;;C@=: C6 34B<2=4=: 70128050:9 )''' & & ) & ''$ ,%)''' CC7 C@B01/<4=: 2::4=72=: ;/2B>41 2=7 ;C=D492=;4 '''''' + 20=2=71@664B0=> %'''''' % 207@334B0C7 )'''J%<C=:/1$ +''''' C11C62<4=0:0412=7 4=?C9<4=:C65064 +'''''' 470;254J34=141 +''' '() * +, *+ ' ;;CB70=>59 :/4 2334552=: 01 4=:0:547 6CB 1%% 21 2>20=1: 1+%++, 2A2B747 89 :/4 B08@=25 /4 4=/2=;47 ;C<34=12:0C= ACBH1 C@: :C 84 1)' A/0;/1/255;2BB90=:4B41:2::/4B2:4C6L - 7 - 34B2==@<6BC<:/472:4C634:0:0C=:0550:1B4250M2:0C=CB :/46CB4>C0=>B421C=1:/01#C@B:A0553BC;447:C3211:/4 6C55CA0=>- 0 3342501 00 /4 ?@7><4=: 2=7 2A2B7 72:47 '' 321147 0= "# C+' '+ 89 :/4 770:0C=25 4=0CB#0D05@7>4E#2=7C:CB;;074=:1 #520<1 B08@=25 2: 2<2=2>2B 01 /4B489 <C706047 2=7 4=/2=;47 :C 1)' 25C=> A0:/ L 6BC< :/4 72:4 C6 34:0:0C= :055 0:1 B4250M2:0C= 0= 2770:0C= :C :/4 ;C<34=12:0C= 2A2B74789:/4B08@=25 000 413C=74=: C =1@B2=;4 #C<32=9 1/255 743C10: :/4 4=:0B4 4=/2=;47 ;C<34=12:0C= 2<C@=: C6 1)' A0:/ 0=:4B41: 2: :/4 B2:4C6L34B2==@<6BC<:/472:4C634:0:0C= :055 B4250M2:0C= 846CB4 :/4 ;C=;4B=47 B08@=25 - 8 - A0:/0= 2 34B0C7 C6 10J A44H1 6BC< :/4 72:4 C6 B4;403:C6;4B:06047;C39C6:/01?@7><4=: 0D = 743C10: C6 4=:0B4 2<C@=: 'L 25C=> A0:/ 2;;B@470=:4B41:1/25584H43:0=260J47743C10: 0= 2=9 =2:0C=250M47 CB 1;/47@547 2=H 6CB 2 34B0C7C6+942B12=7:/4B4<20=0=>'L25C=> A0:/2;;B@470=:4B41:1/25584B45421470=62DC@B C6:/42334552=:C=3BC34B074=:060;2:0C= D CCB74B21:C;C1:1 -. #% 01:C- 5C-% #-