- 1 - !"#$% &$' " ($) ! " ## $ % &" ' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( !"( " !) ) " * ! ##)# " ( ( $ %" ' ( ( ( + ## , #)# *** , & " " *! " ( "" - - . & /01234040560170839:;4/3234040563<128=0640771:306> =>><03?39 :; 4/3 0@2A>639 5<93< 9=439 ## 2=11395651 =69065@ 5#)# /3 234040563<1 =<3 4/3 28=0640771 =69 4/3 <312569364014/3937369=64:375<34/35@@3<B0=85A<4 06 5@@3<B0=8 5#)# 743< 4/3 011A31 =<3 - 3 - 7<=@39=69<3B5<906>573?0936B35728=0640771"51 ,B=@345:370839:;4/328=064077145<3!52364/3B=13 :; <3B=8806> 4/3 5<93< 9=439 # =69 23<@04 4/3 28=0640771457A<4/3<B<511!3C=@063 64/3=7709=?041=BB5@2=6;06>4/3=2280B=40561"04 0114=439=42=<=><=2/!=1A693<- 1A:@044/=4"B=13D=125143975<4/3<511 3C=@06=4056 57 56 ### 6 4/=4 9=43 5A< B5A6138 B<511 3C=@0639 2=<48; 743< 4/=4" 5A< B5A6138 2<=;1 40@3 75< 7A<4/3< B<5113C=@06=405657A44/0156.:83B5A<4 654 >0?36 =6 5225<4A604; 45 7A<4/3< B<511 3C=@0634/3=692<=;3<D=1<3E3B4394/36 2514394/3B=1375<5:E3B405645=6975<706=8 =<>A@3641/313605<=9?5B=43D=1654733806> D388 56 ###" /5D3?3< 4/3 EA605< B5883=>A3 B<511 3C=@0639 2=<48; =69 =743< 4/=4 /3 2<=;1 40@3 75< 7A<4/3< B<511 3C=@06=4056 57 /01 56.:83 5A<4 4/3 2<=;3< 75< 7A<4/3< <3E3B439B<5113C=@06=4056574=F36=1608 =6925143975<706=8<>A@3641=695:E3B405645 /3B<5113C=@06=405657064/3=:5?3 B=13 01 ?3<; @AB/ 63B311=<; /36B3 2<=; 4/=4 4/0156.:835A<4@=;:3283=1394523<@04@; - 4 - B5A613845B<5113C=@06336B3"708394/3 =BB5@2=6039 =2280B=4056 45 <3B=88 4/3 =69 45 23<@04 45 B<511 3C=@063 4/3 06 4/3 =:5?3B=13 4 01 4/3 ?3/3@364 B564364056 57 83=<639 B5A6138 75< 4/3 234040563<128=0640771 4/=4 4/3 0@2A>639 5<93< 2=1139 :; 4/3 5@@3<B0=8 5A<4 01 0883>=8" 23<?3<13 =69 =<:04<=<; =69 4/3 5@@3<B0=8 5A<4 /=1 654 2<5?0939 =6 5225<4A604;454/328=0640771457A<4/3<B<511!3C=@063 =69 /=1 901@01139 4/3 =2280B=40561 @3B/=60B=88; D04/5A4 B561093<06>4/3=?3<@3641@=93064/3=7709=?041=663C39 45 4/3 =2280B=40561 6 4/3 =7709=?041 =BB5@2=6;06> 4/3 =2280B=40561" 0401 B83=<8; 14=439 :;4/328=064077 4/=4 106B3 4/3 13605< B5A6138 <32<3136406> 4/3 28=0640771 D=1 654 F33206> D388" 4/3 EA605< B5883=>A3 /=9 2=<48; B<511! 3C=@0639 =69 2<=;39 40@3 75< 7A<4/3< B<511! 3C=@06=4056 57 !" D/0B/ B=@3 45 :3 <3E3B439 :; 4/3 5@@3<B0=85A<4=694/3B<511!3C=@06=405657!D=1 4=F36=1608=692514394/3B=1375<5:E3B405645=69 75<=<>A@3641 - 5 - 4 01 7A<4/3< B56436939 :; 83=<639 B5A6138 4/=4 6542<5?0906>575225<4A604;454/328=0640771457A88;B<511! 3C=@063 D5A89 9=@=>3 4/3 B=13 57 4/3 28=0640771 /5A>/ 4/3 EA605< B5883=>A3 D=1 654 <3=9; 45 B<511! 3C=@063 " =4 4/3 06101436B3 57 4/3 5A<4" /3 /=9 2<5B3393945B<511!3C=@063062=<4=6915A>/440@3 45B<511!3C=@063!15=14536=:834/313605<B5A6138 45 7A<4/3< B<511!3C=@063 " D/0B/ D=1 3<<5635A18; <3E3B439:;4/35@@3<B0=85A<4=694/31=@3010883>=8" 23<?3<13=69=<:04<=<;3=<639B5A6138B56436914/=44/3 5@@3<B0=8 5A<4 /=1 654 855F39 0645 4/3 =?3<@3641 06 4/3=7709=?04=69=8154/3064364574/328=0640771457A<4/3< B<511!3C=@063 =69 4/=4 4/3 28=0640771 /=9 568; 2=<48; B<511!3C=@0639 ! /3<375<3" 654 2<5?0906> 57 5225<4A604;454/328=0640771457A<4/3<B<511!3C=@063! 932<0?314/3@573773B40?38;93736906>4/30<B=13:;B<511! 3C=@0606> ! 45 = 7A88 3C4364 6 4/313 ><5A691" 83=<639B5A6138133F145134=10934/30@2A>6395<93<=69 23<@044/328=064077145B<5113C=@063! - 6 - 3< B564<=" 83=<639 B5A6138 <32<3136406> 4/3 <312569364!937369=64 ?3/3@3648; 5225131 4/3 B5643640561 2A475<4/ :; 83=<639 B5A6138 75< 4/3 234040563<128=0640771 3 1A14=061 4/3 0@2A>639 5<93< :; B56436906> 4/=4 1A770B0364 5225<4A604; D=1 >0?36 45 4/3 28=064077145B<511!3C=@063=69067=B44/3=?3<@3641 @=93 :375<3 4/01 5A<4 =69 =815 06 4/3 =7709=?041 =BB5@2=6;06> 51 =69 =<3 654 4<A4/7A8 =69 654 B5<<3B4 75< 4/3 <3=156 4/=4 28=0640771 /=9 7A88; B<511! 3C=@0639 ! =1 23< 4/3 65406>1 06 4/3 5<93< 1/334 57 4/35@@3<B0=85A<4=694/33?0936B3<3B5<93957 A:13GA3648;" 4/3 B=13 D=1 251439 75< 5:E3B40561 45 =69=<>A@3641/3<3=743<"4/3234040563<128=064077170839 51 =6945<3!52364/3B=13:;<3B=8806>4/35<93< 9=439#=6923<@044/328=0640771457A<4/3<B<511! 3C=@063 /3 937369=641 70839 5:E3B40561 45 4/3 =2280B=40561 /3 5@@3<B0=8 5A<4 :; 4/3 0@2A>639 5<93<<0>/48;<3E3B439:54/4/3=2280B=405614017A<4/3< B56436939 :; 83=<639 B5A6138 75< 4/3 - 7 - <312569364937369=64 4/=4 2A<1A=64 45 4/3 <3E3B4056 57 4/313 4D5 =2280B=40561" 28=0640771 /=?3 654 =<>A39 4/3 @=443<":A44/3937369=64/=1=<>A394/3@=443<=694/3 @=06@=443<0165D25143975<EA9>@364 3=<639 B5A6138 75< <312569364937369=64 B5643691 4/=4 <93< * A83 57 4/3 593 57 0?08 <5B39A<3 01 2<0@=<08; = 2<5?01056 36=:806> 4/3 5A<4 45 B8=<07;=6;011A35<95A:4":;<3B=8806>=6;D046311304/3< 5< =4 4/3 <3GA314 57 =6; 2=<4;" 15 4/=4 4/3 5A<4041387B=62A4GA3140561=69380B04=61D3<13=<639 B5A61387A<4/3<B56436914/=40401654064369394536=:83 4/3 2=<4031 45 <3B=88 =6; D046311 75< /01 7A<4/3< 3C=@06=4056!06!B/037 5< B<511!3C=@06=4056 5< 45 28=B3 =9904056=8 @=43<0=8 5< 3?0936B3 D/0B/ B5A89 654 :3 2<59AB39D/364/33?0936B3D=1:306><3B5<93968311 4/3<3 01 15@3 3C4<=5<906=<; B=13 @=93 5A4 :; 4/3 28=0640771" 1AB/ =2280B=40561 6339 654 :3 =885D39 06 = <5A4063B=1A=8@=663< - 8 - 3=<639 B5A6138 7A<4/3< B5643691 4/=4 06 4/3 2<31364B=1356/=69"4/37=B416=<<=439:;4/328=0640771 =<3 654 B5<<3B4 312043 ><=6406> 5225<4A604; 45 4/3 28=0640771 45 B<511!3C=@063 !" 4/3 28=0640771 /=?3 654 9563 15 =69 4/3; /=?3 9<=>>39 56 4/3 @=443< D04/5A4 B<511!3C=@0606> =69 /=1 @=93 = 7=813 1A:@011056 4/=44/3;/=92=<48;B<511!3C=@0639=695225<4A604; :3 >0?36 45 7A<4/3< B<511!3C=@063 6 4/313 ><5A691"/3133F145901@0114/323404056 61A225<457/01B5643640561"83=<639B5A613875< <312569364937369=64 <38039 A256 4/3 75885D06> EA9>@3641- 0' &A9>@364 57 4/3 56.:83 A2<3@3 5A<4 06 4/3 B=1357 <325<439 06 # 68063 #) 00' &A9>@364574/015A<4064/3B=1357 06<043404056 557#% !('93B093956#4/ =<B/ # - 9 - /=?3 >0?36 @; 4/5A>/47A8 B561093<=4056 45 4/3 =<>A@3641=9?=6B39:;83=<639B5A6138175<:54/2=<4031 =6923<A1394/3234040562=23<1 6 23<A1=8 57 4/3 5<93< 1/334 @=064=0639 :; 4/3 5@@3<B0=8 5A<4" 04 01 1336 4/=4 D/36 5225<4A604; D=1 >0?36 45 4/3 28=0640771 45 B<511!3C=@063 !" 4/3; /=?3 654A40801394/31=@3=69/=?34<039459<=>564/3@=443< 06 4/3 >A013 57 4/3 3605< 5A6138 45 7A<4/3< B<511! 3C=@063!123<4/365406>1064/35<93<1/334"0401 13364/=4/=1:3367A88;B<511!3C=@0639/3<375<3" 28=0640771 B=6654:3 >0?36 563 @5<3 5225<4A604; 45B<511! 3C=@063 " 06 ?03D 57 4/3 2<5?010561 57 4/3 5@@3<B0=8 5A<41 B4" D/3<3 28=0640771 D5A89 /=?3 45 =9/3<306=BB5<9=6B3D04/4/3B4=69B5@28;D04/4/3B4 75<3C2390405A1 901251=8 57 4/3 B=136 4/32<31364B=13" 9312043 2<5?0906> =6 5225<4A604;" 28=0640771 /=?3 654 A4080H39 4/3 1=@3 36B3" 28=0640771 D5A89 654 :3 36404839 75<:363704574/32<5?01056157 <93<*A83574/3 593570?08<5B39A<3 - 10 - ) ;?03D0175<407039:;4/3EA9>@364064/3B=1357 <325<43906# 68063#)"D/3<3064/356.:83 A2<3@3 5A<4 /389 =4 2=<=><=2/1 51" =69 =1 A693<- */01 A83 2<5?0931 4/3 5A<4 D04/ = 25D3< D/0B/ 01 63B311=<; 75< 4/3 2<523< B569AB4 57 = B=13 7 04 =223=<1 45 = B5A<4 4<;06> 4/3 1A04 =4 =6;14=>3574/32<5B33906>14/=4040163B311=<; 45 <3B=88 =69 7A<4/3< 3C=@063 = D046311 04 B=6 =8D=;19515/0125D3<B=6:33C3<B01393?36 =44/314=>357D<0406>=EA9>@364:;4/3B5A<4 401"/5D3?3<"2<523<4/=44/0125D3<1/5A89654 :33C3<B013980>/48;=694/3<A83014/=4041/5A89 :3A13912=<06>8;=69063CB324056=8B=131568; /3 25D3< 01 45 :3 A139 75< <3@5?06> =@:0>A04031"75<B8=<07;06>4/314=43@364=69654 75< 4/3 2A<25131 57 708806> A2 4/3 8=BA6= 06 = 2=<4;.1 B=13 4 01 4<A3 4/=4 4/3 25D3< B=6 :3 3C3<B0139:; 4/3 5A<4 =4 041 5D6 06040=40?3 =69 @=;3?36:3159563=44/30614=6B357=2=<4; 3B4056 574/3?0936B3B42<5?09314/=4= &A9>3@=;065<93<45901B5?3<5<5:4=062<523< 2<557 57 <383?=64 7=B41" =1F =6; GA314056 /3 283=13106=6;75<@=4=6;40@357=6;D046311 - 11 - =:5A4 =6; 7=B4 <383?=64 /3 13B4056 7A<4/3< 2<5?09314/=44/32=<40311/=88654:33640483945 @=F3 =6; 5:E3B4056 45 =6; 1AB/ GA314056" 65< B<511!3C=@063 =6; D046311 A256 =6; =61D3< >0?3606<328;45=6;1AB/GA314056D04/5A44/3 83=?3574/35A<474/32<5?01056157 <93<) A83 =<3 <3=9 =856> D04/ 4/3 2<5?010561 57 3B4056 57 4/3 ?0936B3 B4 04 01 B83=< 4/=4 4/325D3<45<3B=88=69<3!3C=@063=D04631101 3CB8A10?38;4/=4574/3B5A<44<;06>4/31A04/3 2=<4031454/31A04B=66544=F3=6;5:E3B405645 4/3GA314056=1F3965<B=64/3;:323<@0443945 B<511!3C=@063=6;D046311D04/5A44/383=?357 4/3B5A<4 /01 5A<4 06 4/3 B=13 57 ? "%##' #@5<3 2=<40BA8=<8; 2=<=)/389=1A693<- ! " # $% #&'' %( ) % % %( %% ) % ( !" #$%#&''* %@2/=1011A228039' - 12 - 6 4/3 B=13 57++ % (? % ("%#' " 4/01 5A<4 901BA11394/325D3<574/35A<4A693< <93<) A83 57 4 D=1 /389 4/=4 4/01 25D3< 01 568;75<B8=<070B=4056034536=:835A<445B8=<07; =6; 011A3 5< 95A:4" 04 @=; /=?3 06 <3>=<9 45 3?0936B3839:;2=<4031:;<3B=8806>=6;D046311 154/=44/35A<4041387B=62A4GA3140561451AB/ D046311=69380B04=61D3<1/3<383?=642=<=1" #=69<3=9=1A693<- ," #$%#&!' % %% ( ! ! ) --! - ) % % % % " #$%#& %( %% !( ( ( %% ( .! ( ( %! . % " %% ! ! % ! (! ( . - 13 - #/" # $% #& ! ' % %% ( ! ! ) --! - ) % % % % " #$%#& %( %% !( ( ( %% ( .! ( ( %! . % " %% ! ! % ! (! ( . #,0 ( ! #1#" # $%#&!' %( %( ! 2! %% ! (! ' ) ' % 3 % ! ! % % ( %% % !( %% - 14 - ! - % ! % !! () %% ! 3 ! % % !%( ( ! % ( %( % % !) % % ( %( ! % ! ! % % % % ( * 45 % 6 ; ?03D 01 =815 75<407039 :; 4/3 EA9>@364 57 55<906=4336B/574/015A<4064/3B=1357 06 <04 3404056 557#% !('93B093956#4/ =<B/"# - 15 - # (5< 4/3 <3=1561 14=439 =:5?3" 2=11 4/3 75885D06>- 0' /32340405601+,-.,--/+ 00' 5D3?3<" 80:3<4; 01 <313<?39 45 4/3 234040563<128=0640771 45 =22<5=B/ 4/3 5@@3<B0=85A<445=99<3114/30<=<>A@3641 :; @=F06> =6 =2280B=4056" =1 4/3 @=443< 01 65D 134 95D6 75< EA9>@364 :375<3 4/3 5@@3<B0=85A<4 <93<39=BB5<906>8; +0 ( ") ' 0145-85-