Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 77009 (PNJ)
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA v. EX NK BABU RAM
CWP/20060/2024 · 2025-01-13
Sudeepti Sharma, Sureshwar Thakur
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 77009 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 77009 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"#$$# % & !$'#$#"
() )
!"##$%
*! +,*# )) )-
+,*)# )) )* &'()*+,- &./&/012320'./4.5.2*678/3) 97&3.):)323270)&; <<<< ) )-
.#
.&7('.3.)2053/03=&23:)3232703.):)323270)&5.)&)20 027079
0*2/:&/,597&3.)5)3320'/52*)793.)7&*)&*/3)* >! ?00)@(&) A /5 :/55)* +, 3.) B)/&0)* &C)* 7&8)5 &2+(0/B 8708)&0)*=.)&)+,53.)8B/2C79&)5:70*)037 97&3.)'&/0379 5)&628))B)C)03793.)*25/+2B23,:)0527097&3.)5)&628)&)0*)&)*+, .2C20)9)08))8(&23,7&:5?A./5+))0/BB7=)*+,870*7020' 3.)5.7&39/BB79!!9&7C3.)&)D(2523) >,)/&579D(/B29,20'5)&628)97& )/&020'5)&628):)05270203.) /&0%/1/&23%
)5:70*)037 =/5)0&7BB)*203.)
0*2/0&C,70
!# $#!/0*=/5*258./&')*3.)&)9&7C70! #)5:70*)03 7 =/5'&/03)*&)32&20':)05270/5/*C2552+B)37.2C/5:)&3.) )05270)'(B/32705.)&)/93)&&)5:70*)037 =/5&))0&7BB)*2037 )9)08))8(&23,7&:5?5)&628)A70#887&*20'373.) ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
:&)6/B)03:7B28,(:70/33/2020'3.)/')795(:)&/00(/3270&)5:70*)03 7 =/5*258./&')*9&7C5)&628)203.)70! #/93)& &)0*)&20'/5)&628)79 ,)/&5/0*!*/,5=.28.=/55.7&3+,!! */,557/537C/4)3.)57B*2)&)0/+B)*3787C:B)3)3.)D(/B29,20'3)&C 79 >,)/&597&3.):(&:75)79'&/03795)&628):)052703.(597&3.) 5)870*5)&628)&)0*)&)*+,.2C203.) ! )5:70*)03 7 =/5 *)02)* 5)&628) :)05270 +, 3.) 87C:)3)03/(3.7&23,97&.2507387C:B)320'3.)&)D(2523)D(/B29,20' :)&27*97&)/&020'5)&628):)05270203.)
))B20'/''&2)6)*&)5:70*)037 92B)*+)97&)3.) B)/&0)* &C)* 7&8)5 &2+(0/B 8708)&0)* =.)&)+,5 .) 8/53 / 8./BB)0')373.)/97&)5/2*&)1)832707&*)&.)5/2*+)8/C) /BB7=)*62*)7&*)&*/3)* >!.)7:)&/326):/&3793.)5/2* 7&*)&25)@3&/83)*.)&)20/93)&- @@@@ @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
! > ))B20'/''&2)6)*9&7C3.)/97&)5/2*7&*)&/5:/55)*(:70 3.)?5(:&/A+,3.)B)/&0)*&C)*7&8)5&2+(0/B8708)&0)*3.) :)323270)&027079
0*2/./592B)*3.)&)/'/20533.)2053/03=&23:)323270 +)97&)3.257(&3 ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
! )%4566 7081/ &% 170890606 #
.)B)/&0)*87(05)B97&3.):)323270)&55(+C2353./33.) B)/&0)*&2+(0/B./59/2B)*3787052*)&3./3203)&C579)'(B/3270 7 >793.))05270)'(B/3270597&3.)&C, $ /0*)'(B/3270 7793.))05270)'(B/3270597&3.)&C,#3.(570B,3.) 7C:)3)03(3.7&23,=/5)C:7=)&)*37870*70)3.)*)9282)08,203.) &)0*2327079D(/B29,20'5)&628)3.(5+,3.)57B*2)&97&.25+)87C20' )0323B)*375))43.))0*7=C)0379:)0527037.2C.)5/2*)'(B/32705 /&))@3&/83)*.)&)20/93)& ? $ A
"#$ %& '(
'(
)
"*+ '( "$
& ! ? #A ++ ,
-
"# & ./ '( 0 '( "$
'(
) ! 1 7&)76)&3.)20253&,79)9)08)62*)7B28,B)33)&7
?A;
;;?)0;7BA */3)*
" 205)&3)*8B/(5)?26A 20 3.) ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)'(B/32707793.))05270)'(B/327097&3.)&C,#.) &)B)6/03:/&3=.)&)7925)@3&/83)*.)&)20/93)&
# :)&(5/B793.)/97&)/C)0*C)03=7(B*C/4)238B)/&3./3 &)B2)9 D(/ 870*70/3270 79 *)9282)08, 20 &)0*23270 79 3.) /::7523) D(/B29,20'5)&628)2537+)/887&*)*70C)&2357/537)05(&)3./3/0 /&C,:)&5700)B25)B2'2+B)97&/3B)/5370)5)&628):)05270! "
$ .)B)/&0)*87(05)B97&3.):)323270)&59(&3.)&5(+C2353./3 3.)1(*'C)03793.)B)/&0)*&C)*7&8)5&2+(0/B&2082:/B)08. )=)B.2&)0*)&)*208/5)323B)*/5 #$ %& =/507387&&)83&/3.)&=/58703&/&,37B/=/0*9/835 3.)&)97&)07&)B2/08)7('.337./6)+))0:B/8)*703.)5/2*1(*'C)03 .)&)B)6/03:/&/'&/:.5/5788(&203.)6)&*283?5(:&/A/&))@3&/83)* .)&)20/93)& #, 23 #+4+#4" . '( 5
678)
9
:6"+4#44" ;++; ) 9:6 #44*#4"1< ( 7
< ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
> ( 8 < ( 6= 3 6>
? @?A*4#4"B41""#4"B2,
< ( 8 2, 9 ':6( < &&&& &&&& +
C 3
. '( D A '( ' (
6 78
"+ 8 8 , 8;E F78 ) 6 78 E FE 86 ; =GE : 7 : ) 3 6 : , '( ! '
‟‟‟‟ (
)
! " *
'(8 '( '(
,
! 7 #'#(2,
#441,
ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"+4#44" ;
"#7 7 ;'(
+
"
,-.-/"
0
/1-/-/2
'( ; '(
8 8
, 3 6F
'(D A'( ;+1
7 &7086%0#
208)3.))@:753(B/32705C/*)20:/&/'&/:.7 793.) 1(*'C)03&)0*)&)*+,3.)70E+B):)@7(&3208/5)323B)*/5 6 7 6// 08(#)% )6 38
/5/&):7&3)*20-/32
,-, :/&/'&/:.
=.)&)79 +)87C)5 )@3&/83)* .)&)20/93)&76)&87C)53.)*25/+B20')99)83529/0,795(:&/)@8):3270 7?26A/5+)8/C)205)&3)*62*):7B28,;B)33)&*/3)*
"3.(5 203)0*)*37=7&4/5/07+53/8B)&/3.)&/'/20533.)57B*2)&8B/2C20'&)B2)9 79870*70/3270203.)&)D(2523)5.7&39/BB795)&628)
"#
&
"# & = E 8,
, E #+H
"I$ ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"
"+ #44" &
,,
F
.)&)97&)3.)1(*282/B6)&*283?5(:&/A*7)5&)0*)&0)'/3)* 3.)5(:&//&'(C)03&/25)*+,3.)87(05)B97&3.):)323270)&53./33.) )C:7=)&C)0337870*70)3.)&)D(2523)5.7&39/BB+)87C)557B23/&2B, 6)53)*203.)7C:)3)03(3.7&23,)5:)82/BB,=.)03.).)&)20/+76) (0*)&B20)*:/&/'&/:.5/5788(&203.)6)&*283C/*)20)% )6 38 /5/+&//BB(*)*37203.)6)&*283C/*)20./C/ /(&E58/5)*7 206)531(&25*283270203.)&237(&3373.&7('.1(*282/B203)&6)03270 3.(5C/4)3.))5:7(5)*870*70/3270
705)D()03B,3.)8(C(B/326))99)83793.)/(3.7&23/326) 1(*282/B:&707(08)C)03/58/&&2)*203.)/+76))@3&/83)*:/&/'&/:. C/*) 20
)
" 3.(5 87C:B)3)B, 87(03)&6/2B5+73.3.)5(:&//&'(C)035&/25)*+)97&)3.257(&3+,3.) 87(05)B97&3.):)323270)&53.(597&*)0,20'373.)&)5:70*)033.) +)0)923793.)5)&628):)0527097&.255)&620'203.)C)&)B,703.) '&7(0*3./3.)./507387C:B)3)*3.)D(/B29,20':)&27*795)&628) +)52*)5703.)9(&3.)&9B2C5,'&7(0*3./370B,3.)87C:)3)03/(3.7&23, 25/(3.7&2F)*37870*70)3.)5/2*5.7&39/BB
! 70)3.)B)55 20 3)&C5 79 3.) *)8B/&/3270 C/*) 20 3.) .)&)20/+76) (0*)&B20)* :/&/ /5 8/&&2)* 20 3.) 6)&*283 ?5(:&/A 3.) 8B/2C579*(/B9/C2B,:)0527020/**23270373.)92&539/C2B,:)0527029 &)D(2&)*=7(B*+)&)53&283)*9&7C$ /5)0625/')*+,3.) 20253&,79)9)08))33)&*/3)*
"
! 6 /1 7086%0# ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
#
0/93)&C/3.3.257(&3920*507C)&23203.)=&23:)323270 /0*=23.7+5)&6/32705/+76)3.)5/C)25*25C255)*
> .)2C:('0)*7&*)&/5:/55)*+,3.)B)/&0)*&2+(0/B 8708)&0)*25C/203/20)*/0*/992&C)*
25:75)*79/B70'=23./BB:)0*20'/::B28/3270?5A29/0,
:) )- ;
:) )*; $'#$#"
01/B 8089/26 3</ ! < 80890/41 ! < ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document