Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 76982 (PNJ)
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA v. MADHU KUMARI AND ANOTHER
CWP/22010/2024 · 2025-01-13
Sudeepti Sharma, Sureshwar Thakur
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 76982 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 76982 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"## $ % !&##"
'( (
)! *+)# (( (,
*+)(# (( () !"#$%&' () )*+,-,*!().(/(,$012)-# 31 -(#4#-,-,1*# 5
6666 ( (,
-#
( 1"!(-(#,*/-)*-7 ,-4#-,-,1*-(#4#-,-,1*# /(# #,*
*,1*13*$,)4 )&/31 -(#/#--,*!)/,$#13-(#1 $# $)-#$898 :**#;" # < )/ 4)//#$ %& -(# =#) *#$ >#$ 1 2#/ ,%"*)= 21*2# *#$7(# #%&/-(#2=),>13 #/41*$#*-131 -(#! )*-13 /# 0,2##=#>#*-13-(#$,/)%,=,-&4#*/,1*31 -(#/# 0,2# #*$# #$%&(,/ ("/%)*$ ,* #3#*2# #2" ,-& 1 4/ :< ()/ %##* )==17#$ %& 21*$1*,*!-(#/(1 -3)==138?$)&/3 1>-(# #@",/,-#A&#) /13 @")=,3&,*!/# 0,2#31 #) *,*!/# 0,2#4#*/,1*,*-(# .%/$.0.%12$
(#("/%)*$13 #/41*$#*-*17)/#* 1==#$,*-(#*$,)* >&1*9??)*$7)/$,/2() !#$-(# #3 1>1*899# 7)/! )*-#$ #-, ,*!4#*/,1*)/)$>,//,%=#-1(,>)/4# -(##*/,1* #!"=)-,1*/ (# #)3-# -(# ("/%)*$ 13 #/41*$#*- 1 7)/ ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
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
##=,*!)!! ,#0#$ #/41*$#*-13,=#$
%#31 #-(# =#) *#$ >#$ 1 2#/ ,%"*)= 21*2# *#$ 7(# #%&/ /(# 2)/- ) 2()==#*!#-1-(#)31 #/),$ #+#2-,1*1 $# (#/),$
%#2)># )==17#$0,$#1 $# $)-#$898(#14# )-,0#4) -13-(#/),$ 1 $# ,/#;- )2-#$(# #,*)3-# '
!"
#
$ % &
'()"%
*$ % $
+! , -!$
!#. ! "
! $
$ % %$ "
"
/!$0 ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
8 A ##=,*!)!! ,#0#$3 1>-(#)31 #/),$1 $# )/4)//#$"41* -(#
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
#
! 2! "#
! "
! %!+! 3& #
! *%
%
"
%
! %
!$%""%$ ! %! $ 0 : C< && . %
"
%
4! %$%"!$
"% $! % 56
#
! 2!7
#
! *%
ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
#
"
! %! +! 0 8 1 #10# -(#,*,/- &13#3#*2#0,$#1=,2&=#--# 1 :<555:#*51=< $)-#$B?
,*/# -#$2=)"/#:,0< ,* -(# #!"=)-,1*113-(##*/,1*#!"=)-,1*31 -(# >&C(# #=#0)*-4) -7(# #13,/#;- )2-#$(# #,*)3-#
C 4# "/)=13-(#)31 #)>#*$>#*-71"=$>).#,-2=#) -()- #=,#3 @") 21*$1*)-,1* 13 $#3,2,#*2& ,* #*$,-,1* 13 -(# )441/,-# @")=,3&,*!/# 0,2#,/-1%#)221 $#$1*># ,-/1)/-1#*/" #-()-)* ) >&4# /1**#=,/#=,!,%=#31 )-=#)/-1*#/# 0,2#4#*/,1* ! " 9 (#=#) *#$21"*/#=31 -(#4#-,-,1*# /3" -(# /"%>,-/-()- -(#+"$!>#*-13-(#=#) *#$ >#$1 2#/ ,%"*)= ,*2,4)=#*2( #7#=(, #*$# #$,*2)/#-,-=#$)/"#
"$ %& 7)/*1-21 #2- )-(# 7)/21*- ) &-1=)7)*$3)2-/ -(# #31 #*1 #=,)*2#1"!(--1()0#%##*4=)2#$1*-(#/),$+"$!>#*- (# #=#0)*-4) )! )4(/)/122" ,*-(#0# $,2-:/"4 )<) ##;- )2-#$ (# #,*)3-# . 2! ""%9! : $
$&&!$ !5 # ;! "
%
'()
<+! $% $
=>' & ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
A ?&&
$%? +! " $
=>' 38@
"# (! %
!"$"%
! $
$! $ ! "$@ # )! "
"%
$ %
$! $ $!"@ # '-!$
: ' A BC3
8
"%9. %
@ # )9. !"%= >'#
! @
& ! ! ! ""<! $$
! D:
< !$ ! ! 5
#
E! C # ! !% $# 2! %
$$"
'
(! %) &%$ ! %
"%) ! )! "%
. "! $ )? "%FG" (!$)! +$
"
%
!%
'
(! %)"% FG" F )! ' ?!-"HF% > ( > +$ % "%
"! : ' >. !#
' ‟‟‟‟
( )
" ! *
" ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
B
#) !""
"# #
. "! $ $ %
2! $
2!$ %
$0! "%(
#
$9. "! 8.! "
% $
! ! ! ! " $& %
? (!( ?$ !#
"
!+! ,"-."-/! 0
/1"-/"-/2
"
#
? #
"
! % ! "%) ! )! !"
. "! : ' G! %
#E! C # ?&8
" 6 %6/75$/#
,*2#-(##;41/-"=)-,1*/>)$#,*4) )! )4(113-(# +"$!>#*- #*$# #$%&-(#1*D%=#4#;1" -,*2)/#-,-=#$)/ 5 6 5.. /7'#($ (5 27
.4. #41 -#$,*-/32
,-, 4) )!
)4( 7(# #13 %#21>#/ #;- )2-#$ (# #,*)3-# 10# 21>#/-(#$,/)%=,*!#33#2-/,3)*&13/"4 )#;2#4-,1* 1:,0<)/%#2)>#,*/# -#$0,$#41=,2&5=#--# $)-#$B?-("/ ,*-#*$#$-171 .)/)*1%/-)2=# )-(# )!),*/--(#/1=$,# 2=),>,*! #=,#3 1321*$1*)-,1*,*-(# #@",/,-#/(1 -3)==13/# 0,2#
$
2! %
"% $ ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
? !$
"
"%$! %
-! F )!. "! ! %
"
"
! !"
. "! F
$ &I!,*
! &!! !"
$! ! $
.. "! "! % G
(# #31 #-(#+"$,2,)=0# $,2-:/"4 )<$1#/ #*$# *#!)-#$ -(#/"4 )) !">#*- ),/#$%&-(#21"*/#=31 -(#4#-,-,1*# /-()--(# #>417# >#*--121*$1*#-(# #@",/,-#/(1 -3)==%#21>#//1=,-) ,=& 0#/-#$,*-(#1>4#-#*-"-(1 ,-&#/4#2,)==&7(#*-(#(# #,*)%10#
"*$# =,*#$4) )! )4(/)/122" ,*-(#0# $,2->)$#,*($ (5 27 .4.*%.)=="$#$-1,*-(#0# $,2->)$#,*()>))" D/2)/#$1 ,*0#/-+" ,/$,2-,1*,*-(# ,-1" --1-( 1"!(+"$,2,)=,*-# 0#*-,1* -("/>).#-(##/41"/#$21*$1*)-,1*
1*/#@"#*-=&-(#2">"=)-,0##33#2-13-(#)"-(1 ,-)-,0# +"$,2,)=4 1*1"*2#>#*-)/2) ,#$,*-(#)%10##;- )2-#$4) )! )4( >)$# ,* )
! -("/ 21>4=#-#=& 21"*-# 0),=/%1-(-(#/"4 )) !">#*-/ ),/#$%#31 #-(,/1" -%&-(# 21"*/#=31 -(#4#-,-,1*# /-("/31 $#*&,*!-1-(# #/41*$#*--(# %#*#3,-13-(#/# 0,2#4#*/,1*31 (,//# 0,*!,*-(#># #=&1*-(# ! 1"*$-()-(#()/*1-21>4=#-#$-(#@")=,3&,*!4# ,1$13/# 0,2# %#/,$#/1*-(#3" -(# 3=,>/&! 1"*$-()-1*=&-(#21>4#-#*-)"-(1 ,-& ,/)"-(1 ,E#$-121*$1*#-(#/),$/(1 -3)== ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
C 8 1*#-(#=#// ,* -# >/ 13 -(# $#2=) )-,1* >)$# ,* -(# (# #,*)%10# "*$# =,*#$ 4) ) )/ 2) ,#$ ,* -(# 0# $,2- :/"4 )< -(# 2=),>/13$")=3)>,=&4#*/,1*,*)$$,-,1*-1-(#3, /-3)>,=&4#*/,1*,3 #@", #$71"=$%# #/- ,2-#$3 1>9)/#*0,/)!#$%&-(# ,*,/- &13#3#*2##--# $)-#$?8 5 .0 6/75$/#
*)3-# >)-(-(,/1" -3,*$/*1># ,-,*-(#7 ,-4#-,-,1* )*$7,-(1%/# 0)-,1*/)%10#-(#/)>#,/$,/>,//#$ A (#,>4"!*#$1 $# )/4)//#$%&-(#=#) *#$ ,%"*)= 21*2# *#$,/>),*-),*#$)*$)33, >#$ B ,/41/#$13)=1*!7,-()==4#*$,*!)44=,2)-,1*:/<,3)*&
9( (, :
9( (): &##"
*+)= (#-(# /4#).,*!5 #)/1*#$ ' #/51 (#-(# #41 -)%=# ' #/51 ANJAL GUPTA 2025.01.15 10:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document