Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 76040 (KAR)
WILFRED IMMANUEL D SOUZA v. ASHWATH KUMAR
CRL.A/1861/2024 · 2025-12-17
G Basavaraja
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 76040 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 76040 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%&%
"''
()
*
! "#$ % & '
" (
"
)
#$ &
" $*'+( ""
"
"
! ",
%%% !"
"
"
" ""
" *
"**
"
! -
"-
!" ! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%"
./0 122314 /0 5/436 78 9.3 1223441:9;<=241/:1:9 73/:>1>>?/3@36789.3AB6>=3:9<51;CB/991461936%%% 210036/:""
<%+%%789.3!""<B?91:>14B?B
'5<?0.<?9D9.39?/14"<B?9D( % .3 <:743 B2?3=3 "<B?9 /: 9.3 ;103 <5
"
"@
"?32<?936/:
%%""
"%1921?1>?12.<59.3AB6>=3:9 .10<703?@3610B:63?-
D
! " # $
! ! %
&
! %
! '
! ! ( )*+ , D
:9.34/>.9<5 9.3<:743B2?3=3"<B?90?3;3:9 ;41?/5/;19/<: <5 9.3 43>14 2<0/9/<: /9 /0 :<E 3@/63:9 9.19 9.3 1223441:9 73/:> 9.3 ;<=241/:1:9 B:63? 3;9/<: * <5
- 3 -
3><9/1743 :09?B=3:90 ;9 ** /0 140< 3:9/9436 9< 5/43 1:
122314 1>1/:09 9.3 AB6>=3:9 <5 1;CB/9914 210036 78 9.3 9?/14
"<B?9735<?39.3300/<:0"<B?90/:;3.3/0;<:0/63?369<731 @/;9/= 5 9./0 "<B?9 E3?3 9< 2?<;336 9< .31? 1:6 63;/63 9.3 122314199./0091>3/9;<B46632?/@39.321?9/30<51:1@1/41743 5<?B=/39./0"<B?95<?5B?9.3?;.1443:>3 + /=/41? @/3E .10 733: 91F3: 78 9.3 />. "<B?9 <5 :6.?1 ?1630. /: "
?32<?936/:%%""
%*G789.3/>. "<B?9 <5 16.81 ?1630. /:
@
?3:63?36 /: "?/=/:14 22314 <H<5%%63;/636<:?6!B48%%G1:6/:9.3;103<5
@
?32<?936/:
%% ""
+**G 1:6 /: @ ! ?3:63?36"?/=/:1422314
<*$%<5%%% 63;/636 <: %09 !B48 %%G 9.3 63;/0/<: <5 />. "<B?9 <5
".199/0>1?. /:
@ ?3:63?36 /: ",
< + <5 %* 63;/636 <: 9. !B48 %%; 1:6 /:
@! ?3:63?36/:",
<H* <5%H63;/636<: 9.!B48%%G9.3AB6>=3:9<59./0"<B?9
- 4 -
/:9.3;103<5
@ ?3:63?36/:
"
<%%%*63;/636<:09!B48%% 1:6/: @
! ?3:63?36 /:
"?/=/:1422314
<+ <5%63;/636<:%?6!B48%%G9.3 63;/0/<:<5/>."<B?9<5 34.//:9.3;103<5
" @ ?3:63?36 /: "?/=/:14 22314 < H+ <5 % 63;/636 <: 9. <@3=73? %% 1:6 9.3 63;/0/<:?3:63?36789.3"<#<?6/:1933:;.<59./0"<B?9/:9.3 ;103 <5
@
?3:63?36 /: "?/=/:14 22314
<$ <5 % 63;/636<:%+9. <@3=73?%%:<@3?144100300=3:9 <5 9.3 15<?3091936 63;/0/<:0 ?3@3140 9.19 9.3 63;/0/<: <5 9.3 <:743 B2?3=3 "<B?9 /: 9.3 ;103 <5 "
" '0B2?1( .10 733: ?34/36 B2<: 78 9./0 "<B?9 10 E344 10 <9.3? />."<B?901;?<009.3;<B:9?8
"<:0/63?/:> 9.3 17<@3 /9 /0 633=36 5/9 9.19 9.3 2?303:9122314739?1:053??369<9.3;<:;3?:36122344193"<B?9 <5300/<:01:673;<:0/63?36101:122314B:63?9.32?<@/0< 9<3;9/<:+<5
%%'5<?=3?483;9/<:$%<5"?"(
- 5 -
1:6:B=73?361;;<?6/:>48;;<?6/:>482?<;3369<21009.3 5<44<E/:>-
/ 3>/09?8 /0 6/?3;936 9< 9?1:053? 9.3 3:9/?3 ?3;<?6 <5 9.3 ;103 /:;4B6/:> 9.3 ?3CB/0/9/<:36 ;<2/30 <5 9.3 9?/14 ;<B?9 3;<?60 9< 9.3 ;<:;3?:36 ?/:;/214 /09?/;9 I 300/<:0 !B6>3 E.< =18 100/>: /9 9< 9.3 ;<:;3?:36 22344193
"<B?9 .1@/:> 9.3 AB?/06/;9/<: 1:6 5<? E./;. 2B?2<03/9E<B46734/0936735<?39.3?/:;/214
/09?/;9I300/<:0!B6>3G // .3 ;<:;3?:36 9?1:053?33 ;<B?9 /0 6/?3;936 9< /00B3"<B?9:<9/;39<7<9.9.321?9/309<12231? 735<?39.3;<:;3?:36"<B?91:69.3;<:;3?:36
"<B?9 9.3?31593? 0.144 2?<;336 E/9.
9.3 ;103 /:1;;<?61:;3E/9.41EG /// : ;103 9.3?3 1?3 1224/;19/<:0 23:6/:> 5<? ;<:6<:19/<: <5 63418 <? 1:8 <9.3? 23:6/:> 1224/;19/<:0 9.3 01=3 140< 73 9?1:053??36 9< 73 ;<:0/63?36 78 9.3 431?:36 !B6>3 <5 9?1:053?33"<B?9/:1;;<?61:;3E/9.41EG /@ "<:0/63?/:> 9.3 =1993? .10 733: 23:6/:> 5<? ;<:0/63?1743 9/=3 9.3 22344193 "<B?9 /0 ?3CB309369<=1F31:3:631@<B?9<6/02<03<5 9.3=1993?103J236/9/<B048102<00/743G
- 6 -
@ .3 1223441:9 /0 23?=/9936 9< ;1??8 <B9 :3;3001?8 1=3:6=3:9 /: 9.3 ;1B03#9/943 1:6 140<9.32?<@/0/<:09.3?3<5G @/9/0=163;431?9.199./0"<B?9.10:<9=163 1:8 <703?@19/<:0 10 9< 9.3 =3?/90 <5 9.3 ;103 1:6144?/>.901:6;<:93:9/<:0<59.321?9/301?3 4359 <23: 9< 73 1>/91936 735<?3 9.3 "<B?9 ;<:;3?:36
:9.34/>.9<59.317<@3<703?@19/<:1:66/?3;9/<:0 122314091:606/02<036<5
+, (&%) %
/09
<-%4
<-%