- 1 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS !" # $% !" &$ !" &% !" ' !" (# ) ! "# ) $ % " ! "# ! "" ! &$ Digitally signed by RAKESH S HARIHAR Location: High Court of Karnataka, Dharwad Bench - 2 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS " ! $ ! !# ' %" & % " % ( &$ $ " " &$ " % " &$ " ) $ $%# ) * + ! "$ + ! "# - 3 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS ) $ % %! ! &$ " " " ! "$ ! !# ' %" & % " % ( %" &$ $ ! ' $$ " % ! ), " ( % "" "' ' &$# ) - 4 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS " &$$$ " ! "# ) $ % " ! "# ! ""# &$ " ! "$ !! " ! ( "" " " ! ! %" $ % " ! " "$ ! !% $-, !# - 5 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS ' % " & % " % ( %" &$ $ ), ( % " &$ ) " )" % ' " % ! % " % %" " ) &%# ) " !! " + ! "# ) $ % %! ! - 6 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS &$ " " " ! "$ ! !# ' %" & % " % ( %" &$ $ ! ' $$ " % ! ), " ( % "" "' ' '# ) !" + " " + ! "# - 7 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS ) $ % %! ! &$ " " " ! "$ ! !# ' %" & % " ( %" &$ $ ! ), " (% "" "' ' " % .. ' / " / .+ " - 8 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS 0121 31454567182 09:1 9 ;6<<67 =851:97;1 97> 40158 =851:97;1 52 ?540 401 645@5;94567 >941> &$ 522A1> A7>18 1;4567 BC 6@ 401 987949D9 8641;4567 6@ 7418124 6@ 136254682 57 %5797;59E 249FE520<1742 ;4 B@68 20684 C 01 31454567182. 3863184512 09:1 F117 9449;01> 81;68>57=40129452@9;4567409440529449;0<174?6AE> F1 71;12298G 46 38641;4 401 574181242 6@ 40621 ?06 09:1 >1362541> @A7>2 ?540 2 098<90997 !5:5>06>>1209 6A098>9 "66318945:1 5<541> B@68 20684 C 97> 81;68>57= 401 F1E51@4094401"66318945:1 6;514G092F117A21>92 9;67>A5446<6F5E5H1<6751297>3A8;0921>5@@18174 386318451257;EA>57=40138631845123A8;0921>FG401 31454567182 052 "6A84 67 &*$ 092 =89741> 574185< 68>18 57 401 ?854 31454567 57 ' 6$$$ >581;457= 401 9A406854512 764 46 49D1 - 9 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS 97G 381;5354945:1 9;4567 A7>18 401 5<3A=71> 645@5;9456797>25<5E9868>18209:1F117=89741>57 9EE40164018314545672 85 9I9201D98401E19871> ;6A721E ?06 E19>2 401 64018 E19871> ;6A721E2 67 81;68>@68401314545671822AF<54240944052"6A84?5EE 09:1 46 57418@181 97> 214 925>1 401 5<3A=71> 645@5;94567>941>&$F1;9A21/ 401386;11>57=298157545941>94401572497;1 6@ 97 57>5:5>A9E ?06 092 ;98851> 9 ;9A21 9=9572440131454567182386<641826@401"6 6318945:1 6;514G 97> 4052 52 2117 764 IA24 57@5E57=40157@68<94567@68;6<<17;1<174 6@ 40121 386;11>57=2 FA4 9E26 @68 ;6<<17;1<1746@3179E386;11>57=2?5409 57 1J18;521 6@ 401 36?182 A7>18 401 ;4 9 E5KA5>9468 52 93365741> ?06 52 6:1821157= 401 922142 6@ 401 "66318945:1 6;514G 46 172A81 9<67=24 640182 401 386;11>2 981 - 10 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS 81;15:1> FG E5KA5>9457= 401 "66318945:1 6;514G.292214297> 401 3863184512 09:1 F117 9449;01> 25<AE49716A2EG 85 9I9201D98;97:9221281EG57=A3674019@681 4094 401 ;67;1871> 092 922A<1> IA852>5;4567 ;674898G 46 E9? 9E406A=0 26<1 31454567182 09:1 9;KA581> 401 922142 FG 570185497;1 1:17 F1@681 401 "66318945:1 6;514G ?92 57;68368941> 85 ! 05:981>>G 401 E19871> >>545679E 6:187<174 >:6;941520198>57401E5=046@401212AF<5225672 052"6A84<A246F218:14094?014018401 3145456718209:19;KA581>4013863184GFG570185497;1 38568 46 401 "66318945:1 6;514G F157= 57;68368941> 68 ?014018 401 386;11>57=2 981 57545941> F1;9A21 6@ ;184957:57>5;45:1;9<395=7<A24F11J9<571>FG401 31;59E "6A84 57 418<2 6@ 1;4567 $ 6@ 401 ;4 2 2A;0 401 31454567182 09:1 9 81<1>G ?54057 401 2494A468G @89<1?68D 97> 401 31;59E "6A84 ;97 - 11 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS 1J9<5719EE@9;4A9E<9485J46@57>6A4?01401840181 <A24F197G9449;0<1746@4013863184512;E95<1>FG 40131454567182 %A840185@401314545672<A24F1>523621> 6@ 67 401 =86A7> 6@ 9E4187945:1 81<1>G 4052 "6A84 <A24 9E26 6F218:1 4094 1:17 401 KA124567 6@ IA852>5;4567 F921> 67 401 922184567 4094 401 386;11>57=2 09:1 9E819>G F1=A7 A7>18 401 ;4 ;97 9E26 F1 1J9<571> 57 2A;0 9E4187945:1 386;11>57=2 052"6A84523182A9>1>76446KA920401645@5;94567 >941>&$FA446>5236216@401314545672?540 E5F184G 46 401 31454567182 46 9:95E 401 81<1>G A7>18 1;4567$BC6@401;4 4 4052 249=1 85 9I9201D98 97> 401 64018E19871>;6A721E2@68401314545671822AF<544094 4052"6A84<9G1J417>401F171@546@38641;45674094 092F1174640131454567182.9>:9749=157401E924@6A8 97> 9 09E@ G1982 052 81KA124 52 ;6725>181> 57 401 E5=04 6@ 401 386:525672 6@ 1;4567 $ 6@ 401 ;4 01 - 12 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS 31;59E"6A842AFI1;446401386;1>A81;6741<3E941> A7>18 1;4567$ 6@401;4;97 :98G68<6>5@G401 9449;0<174 A7>18 1;4567 6@ 401 ;4 01 31454567182 <A24 @5E1 40158 6FI1;45672 67 401 ;67457A94567 6@ 401 9449;0<174 ?540 401 31;59E "6A8497>5@6FI1;4567298126@5E1>401 31;59E"6A84 ?5EE09:1461J9<571?0140184019449;0<174<A24F1 <9>19F26EA4168:9851>01 31;59E"6A84A36797 57:1245=94567 A7>18 1;4567 $BC 6@ 401 ;4 <A24 >1;5>1 ?014018 401 574185< 9449;0<174 <A24 F1 ;67@58<1>68:9851> & 052 "6A84 52 6@ 401 :51? 4094 401 31454567182 <A24 @5E1 6FI1;45672 @68 9 >1;52567 @68 81E19216@40181231;45:13863184512@86<9449;0<174 97>401 31;59E"6A84<A24>1;5>1674016FI1;45672 92 198EG 92 36225FE1 01 ;4 <97>9412 97 574185< 68>18?54057671G198@86<401>9416@81;15346@401 933E5;94567FA4=5:1740131;AE598;58;A<2497;12401 31;59E "6A84 52 ;9EE1> A367 46 >1;5>1 ?54057 25J - 13 - HC-KAR NC: 2025:KHC:51989 WP No. 15190 of 2021 C/W WP No. 13701 of 2021 WP No. 14032 of 2021 AND 2 OTHERS <67402 @86< 401 >941 6@ 401 6FI1;45672 01 31454567182 209EE 09:1 401 9>:9749=1 6@ 401 574185< 68>18 4094 092 F117 26 @98 97> 401 31;59E "6A84 209EE >1;5>1 67 401 6FI1;45672 A757@EA17;1> FG 401 574185<98897=1<1744094092381:95E1>452711>E122 46 6F218:1 4094 401 31454567182 981 81E1=941> 46 401 9E4187945:1 81<1>G ?540 9EE ;6741745672 F157= E1@4 6317 013145456722497>>523621>6@9;;68>57=EG > "