Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 73694 (PNJ)

KUMAR PAL & ORS v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS

CWP/8912/2016 · 2025-01-23

Harsimran Singh Sethi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

1 ! " # " $%& "'" (()*+,-. / 0*1+23+ 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 $& 777 +89(:33+ 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 $-& / ;<*3+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $7& / 9*+(+9(:33+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $/& -- $;& +*0*1+3+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 2 $ & % !2<9(:3 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $%& / >?+9(:33+ 44((+ 5+* 9'+,3+ 446 $& 7 $;& 313+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+*:3(:(++3+ 446 $& %7 :69(:3 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $ & 77 +60*1+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $& / 13 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 3 $& / 5(0*1+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $-& ?30*1+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $7& / 98(+9(:3 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $/& 7 9*,0*1+3+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $ & 8(23+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $%& -7/ 93+(13+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 4 $& -// (+0*1+3+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $& 7-7 ;(>23+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $ & 77%/ 0*269(:33+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $& 7 / !+(+3+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $& =3+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $-& -%7 ;(( 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 5 $7& 7%- =(9(:33+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $/& %- ;(30*1+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $ & %% 93(893?(3+ 44((+ 5+* 9'+,3+ 446 $%& - !28(+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $& - ?33+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $& - < 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 6 $- & -7 +60*+3+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $-& 7%/ <+9(:33+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $-& - 7 - (+0*1+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+.33+ 446 $--& /%77 +<*9(:33+ 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 $-7& -7 (@0*1+3+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $-/& %% 1+?33+ 44((+ 5+* 3:(+++2.(:3*+'*<=+,3+ 446 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 7 $- & - ;<3+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $-%& - / $;& 9:+0*1+3+ 44((+ 5+* 3*<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $-& /- ;:13+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $-& - 23+ 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 $7 & / % +89(:3 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 $7& // % +89(:3 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 8 $7& - (319(:3 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 $7-& 7- - +*3+ 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 $77& - -$;& 9*++3+ 44((+ 5+* 9'+,3+ 446 $7/& %7 - 9623+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $7 & 7 ;3(0*1+3+ 44((+ 5+* *<=+,(:3*+3+ 446 $7%& / - :+9(:3 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 9 $7& /7 - +?39(:3 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 $7& -/ 7 +89(:3 44((+ 5+* ('(3+ 446 $/ & --7 7$;& 960*1+3+ 44((+ 5+* 9'*<=3+ 446 ;) A!>;49 9; 99 !"##$"% &'((#$## !()$#$#)* + ((!(#$## !& , &# &#$"' )& "#$#(* - "#$"$#$#) . / 0 1 "(('&#$## 2 0 ")&&" "()(% )%& #$## + 3 + 4 "$ $&#$## HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 10 -5 5 6+ + +5 78 "$'#! ""$'( ""( ( ""&$! ""&"! "" %! ,"!"& #$##* 6 95 /35 %" )#$#$* + "$#& #$## - 1 ##)#%#$## #%('&#$## 0 /+ :; ; 1 "''%"#$## , #%)%##$#)* < + )%#(#$#)* : #"'("#$#)* 5 "%)'( , ## )$#$##* ; + &!$! "%## )$% , ")(& #$##* + "$ "( , ""!!(#$##* :3 9 < #)(!$#$##* : 0 ;5 / ")(! #$## "(%"&#$##* ; / !&)" !"'' , "$%))#$##* 0 " %"(#$##* - #$))(#$#(* HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 12 0 6 5 5 + 5 ) !& , &# &#$"' + 0 5 + 5 ; > 1 + !()$#$#) )& "#$#( @ < & % !()$#$#)* 0 < & % !"##$"% !"!)#$"% # ( !&#$"' &# &#$"'* -5 + .; 0 < % !&#$"'* ; / < # ) #)(!$#$## )%#( #$#)* + 05 2+ ")(& ,")&&"#$##* 0 5 5 < ">?= !"##$"% &# &#$"' %" )#$#$ ((!(#$## !"!)#$"% )& "#$#(* 3 /+ < # , ) #$))(#$#( 9; 994$ >& " -3 &$ 5 + + + 55 5 A 5 + 5 # = + + 3 ;+ . > 1 + 55 23 1 ;+ 5 === =: 3 3 . HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 13 ) = 5 3 5 1 + 5 3 ;+ 3 5 3 ( 1 + 3 ;+ . > 1 + + +5B 3 53 5+ 3 + 3 / + 5 +5B @ 3 1 3 ;+ . > 1 + +5B + 553 53 @ 5 3 553 53 & > 5 5 . > 1 + ;+ 553 +5 ;+ = 53 + 5 ;+ 3 5 553 +5 5 +5B HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 14 53 5+5 5 ;+ 5 ++ A +5B + 55 % 9 5 + 5 > 1 + 55 +5B 53 55 ;+ A 53 / = A A 5 A +5B 55 ; ;+ 53 ; A 553 53 + 5 5 ' 9 5 > 1 + + > = 5B A 5 53 ; . > 1 + 53 5 5 + 3 5 5 3 5 6 5 5 5 /5 = A ( 553 . + + 9 5 5 /5 = 3 9 6 / = ## $" #$#& 55 / = HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 15 ! 9 5 5 /5 = 3 5 > 1 + 3 5 5 5 5 5 5+ 5 ( 53 + "$ 0+ A + + 3 53 ;+ . + A +5B 53 5B 55 + 5 +5B 5 ( 553 + / = / = 53 ;+ 53 5+ 55 + 5 @ 3 + ( 553 @53 5 5 3 "" 1 > 1 + 55 23 2+ + A @ A + . > 1 + A 5 5 5 > = 3 = 3 A . 9 6 / HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 16 = A @ A 5 "# = 3 ; A ( 553 5 > 1 + ; + + 5 5 53 + 5 53 @ 55+ 553 3 . > 1 + 5 5 53 ;+ 5 55 5 +5B 553 53 55 ") 0+ A ;+ 53 55 ;+ 3 . > 1 + . 6+ > 1 + A 55 55 ; + 3 ;+ @ 3 ; C 3 55 5 3 5 53 3 53 ;+ ;+ 5 5 5 5 53 5 3 5 53 553 "( < + + + 3 53 ;+ . HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 17 55 23 3 5 53 5+ 5 +5B C + 53 + + 55 3 5 53 + + +3 + ; @ 53 ;+ 5 55 "& 9 5 + 5 . 23 ; + 55 + . "% 9 5 53 + + + . 23 53 ; + + +3 55 3 + 53 ; + + 5 3 + + 53 + "' 9 5 + + + + 3 55 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 18 " 9 5 + + 53 +5B +5B+ 3 + ; 55 ; 3 + 5 +5B 3 + 53 55 "! - + 3 ;+ 3 - ;+ . 23 55 + 53 . 53 3 + 3 ++ . + 53 ;+ 3 #$## 1 + 3 3 #$## 3 A + +5B ;+ 3 3 5 +5B 5 3 . #$ 1 + +5B 53 55 3 53 53 5+ HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 19 2D5 = !"# " 2D5 = 5 53 E 5 $ #%&! 53 53 5+ E ;+ + 3 53 + 53 5 A + 5 53 5 5 +5B #" C 5 5 5 +5B 53 3 2+ @ 5 53 3 A 23 +5B 53 5 +5B+ ## 5 +5B 53 + 1 5 .53 + 13 ; + ? F53 5 #$"% 53 5 #) 0+ 53 53 5+ A @ HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 20 5 55 55 ; A @ 3 ; 53 C 53 5+ 55 5 3 53 3 55 55 @ 3 1 53 ;+ 5 . 55 5 53 ;+ + 53 3 55 5 55 + 53 + 53 ; 2 3 53 3 55 @ 3 . ; 5 #( 0+ 55 5 5 5 +5B ; A 5 +5B + $#%&! 1 5 ; @ 3 3 53 ;+ 5 23 2+ + 3 3 . ;+ 55 3 23 3 1 ; 3 A 5 +5B + A 55 ;+ 5 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 21 ;+ 3 ;+ 5 . + = 53 + ;+ E 553 53 ;+ 53 . ;+ + 3 55 ; + 5 + +5B 553 5 + 5 +5B #& G ; 3 . + 53 5 55 5 5 53 + + +3 + . 3 A +5B + 2D5 = $#%&! 1 53 + 5; ? + + 5 +5B 5 ;+ 53 + ;+ 5 . + 55 53 A3 A A 55 5 ; A +5B ;+ + 2D5 = HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 22 $#%&!3 = 3 + 3 2D5 = A +5B 53 5 + $#%&!" 53 A + ;+ A5 3 3 5 + 5+53 53 +5B ; 5 + + 5 + +5B ' + 5 5 ;+ . + + A A5 3 A5 ; 53 + 3 3 5+ 5 # 9 5 3 E5 + + 55 3 3 3 5E 3 5 @ 55 @ 55 ;+ + 5 3 #! 1 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 23 )$ 5 55 5 + 3 5 )" 3 5 5 *+,-. / $ 9; 99& " ;+E 4 5 4 HARSHA RANI 2025.01.30 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document