- 1 - ! "#$% &$'! !" ($) ! " # $% & ' ! " ! " # " " " ( % "! !) &&! ) '" ( Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " ( ! " ! ! * * + ,-./ ,-.0,/ 12304,5 62. 78, 9,7:7:20,. -4 ;,55 -4 5,-.0,/12304,562.78,.,4920/,07 8:4 9,7:7:20 :4 6:5,/ <= 78, 9,7:7:20,.>3/?@,07 /,<72. /,6,0/-07 :0 78, 43:7# 9.-=:0? 72 4,7 -4:/, 78, 2./,. /-7,/ % 20 2 :0 A 2 && 9-44,/<=78,//5 ,0:2.:B:53/?,!8-/.-B-78: & 7 :4 78, 1207,07:20 26 5,-.0,/ 12304,5 62. 78, 9,7:7:20,. 78-7 78, .,4920/,0795-:07:66 8-/ 6:5,/ 2 $C 62. 49,1:6:1 9,.62.@-01, 26 -?.,,@,07 26 4-5, /-7,/C $ %-0/78,4-:/43:71-@,72<,/,1.,,/-4 9.-=,/62.2078,<-4:42678,12@9.2@:4,9,7:7:206:5,/<= 78,9-.7:,47278,43:7 078,12@9.2@:4,9,7:7:20,07,.,/ :072 <= 78, 9-.7:,4! 1,.7-:0 7,.@4 -0/ 120/:7:204 ;,., - 3 - 47:935-7,/<-4,/20;8:1878,43:71-@,72<,/,1.,,/ 7 ;-4 -?.,,/ <= 78, /,6,0/-07 78-7 8, ;235/ 9-= - 727-5 43@ 26 4 !!' 72 78, 95-:07:66 -0/ 237 26 ;8:18 /,6,0/-07 9-:/ 4 !' <= ;-= 26 1-48 -0/ 4 !'<=;-=2618,D3,2078,/-7,26,A,137:2026 78,12@9.2@:4,9,7:7:20-0/-?.,,/78-78,;235/9-=78, <-5-01,4-5,1204:/,.-7:20-@2307264 $!!'202. <,62., 78, ,0/ 26 2B,@<,. & "3.78,. 15-34, -//,/ 78-7 :6 78, /,6,0/-07 6-:54 72 9-= 78, -@2307 -4 -?.,,/! 78, 95-:07:66 ;235/ <, -7 5:<,.7= 72 ?,7 78, .,?:47.-7:20 26 78,43:79.29,.7:,4-49,.78,4-5,-?.,,@,07 0B:,;26 78, 6-17 78-7 78, /,6,0/-07 /:/ 027 @-E, ?22/ 78, 9-=@,07 26 78, <-5-01, -?.,,/ -@2307 20 2. <,62., 78, ,0/ 26 2B,@<,.'&! 78, 95-:07:66 :0:7:-7,/ A,137:20 9,7:7:20&&62.,A,137:202678,/,1.,,-?-:04778, /,6,0/-07;82;-45:-<5,729-=4 $!!'<378-/027 9-:/:7 078,,A,137:209.21,,/:0?4!78,A,137:0?23.7 9.21,,/,/72-992:07 78,23.7 2@@:44:20,.72,A,137, -0/ .,?:47,. 78, 4-5, /,,/! ;8:18 ;-4 -112./:0?5= /20, - 4 - -0/-.,?:47,.,/4-5,/,,/8-4<,,0,A,137,/:06-B23.26 78,95-:07:66 3.43-0772;8:1878,95-:07:66/,1.,,825/,. 6:5,/ -0 -995:1-7:20 30/,. ./,. )) 35, & 26 4,,E:0? :443-01, 26 /,5:B,.= ;-..-07 -?-:047 78, 9,7:7:20,. >3/?@,07 /,<72. 0 8,-.:0? 78, 9-.7:,4! 78, A,137:0? 23.7 9-44,/ 78, :@93?0,/ 2./,. /:.,17:0? :443-01, 26 /,5:B,.= ;-..-07 -?-:047 78, 9,7:7:20,.>3/?@,07 /,<72. 72 /,5:B,. 78, 9,7:7:20 418,/35, 9.29,.7= 72 78, /,1.,, 825/,.! ;8:18 :4 D3,47:20,/<=78,9,7:7:20,.8,.,:0 C 7 :4 78, 1207,07:20 26 5,-.0,/ 12304,5 62. 78, 9,7:7:20,.>3/?@,07/,<72.78-78,8-/@-/,?22/-43@ 264 !!'7278,/,1.,,825/,.2078,/-7,2678, 12@9.2@:4, /,1.,, -0/ 78,.,-67,. 8, 8-/ /,924:7,/ -0278,. 4 !!' <,62., 78, 7.:-5 23.7 4:01, 78, /,1.,,825/,..,634,/72.,1,:B,78,4-@, 09-.-?.-98 C2678,9,7:7:20!9,7:7:20,.>3/?@,07/,<72.47-7,/78-7 8, 8-4 9-:/ 4 !!' 72;-./4 78, /,1.,,7-5 -@2307 -0/ <-5-01, -@2307 /3, :4 205= 4 !!' -0/ 8, :4 - 5 - .,-/=-0/;:55:0?729-=78,<-5-01,-@23077278,/,1.,, 825/,. 8,.,62.,! 8, 4,,E4 72 4,7 -4:/, 78, :@93?0,/ 2./,.26:443-01,26/,5:B,.=;-..-07 ,-.0,/12304,562.78,.,4920/,07/,1.,,825/,. B,8,@,075= 1207,0/4 7,.@4 -0/ 120/:7:204 26 78, 12@9.2@:4, 9,7:7:20 ;,., 027 -/8,.,/ 72 <= 78, 9,7:7:20,.>3/?@,07 /,<72. ,A1,97 9-=:0? 4 !!' 20 78, /-7, 26 78,,A,137:2026 78,12@9.2@:4, 9,7:7:20 4 9,. 78, 12@9.2@:4, 9,7:7:20! :7 ;-4 -?.,,/ -0/ 9.2@:4,/ 78-7 9,7:7:20,.>3/?@,07 /,<72. ;235/ 9-= 78, <-5-01,-@2307264 $!!'202.<,62.,78,,0/26 2B,@<,. &! ;8:18 7:55 /-7, 8-4 027 <,,0 9-:/ -0/ :06-17 02 -@2307 8-4 <,,0 9-:/ <= 78, 9,7:7:20,. >3/?@,07 /,<72. 72 78, /,1.,, 825/,. -9-.7 6.2@ 78, 9-=@,07264 !!' 8,-B,.@,072678,9,7:7:20,. :09-.-?.-98'C2678,9,7:7:20:4@:45,-/:0?-402-@2307 ;-4266,.,/-0/0,:78,.-0=-@2307:49-:/7278,/,1.,, 825/,.-67,.:0:7:-7:202678,,A,137:209,7:7:20 8,.,62.,! :7:41207,0/,/78-793.43-077278,6:5:0?2678,,A,137:20 - 6 - 9,7:7:20!78,4-5,/,,/8-4<,,0,A,137,/78.23?8-23.7 2@@:44:20,. -0/ 78, -542 47-0/4 :0 78, 0-@, 26 78,/,1.,,825/,. 8,205=9.21,4402;5,67:4/,5:B,.=26 9244,44:20!62.;8:188,8-46:5,/-0-995:1-7:20-0/78, 4-@,:4-552;,/<=78,A,137:0?23.7!;8:18/2,4027 1-55 62. :07,.6,.,01, ,01, 8, 4,,E4 /:4@:44-5 26 78:4 9,7:7:20 $ 8-B,8,-./5,-.0,/12304,562.78,9,7:7:20,.-0/ 5,-.0,/12304,562.78,.,4920/,07 8, 92:07 78-7 -.:4,4 62. 1204:/,.-7:20 :0 78, 9.,4,079,7:7:20:4;8,78,.78,:@93?0,/2./,.9-44,/<= 78, A,137:0? 23.7 1-554 62. -0= :07,.6,.,01, <= 78:4 23.7 % =522E:0?:07278,6-174-0/1:.13@47-01,42678, 1-4, -0/ 78, -/@:77,/ 6-17 26 78, 12@9.2@:4, 9,7:7:20 ,A,137,/-0/12@9.2@:4,/,1.,,<,:0?/.-;0<=78,7.:-5 23.7-0/:093.43-01,26;8:18,A,137:209,7:7:208-B:0? <,,0 6:5,/ -0/ 78, 4-5, /,,/ ,A,137,/ :0 6-B23. 26 78, - 7 - .,4920/,07-0/-5428-B:0?<,,07.-046,..,/:078, 0-@, 26 .,4920/,07! 0278:0? 63.78,. .,@-:04 72 <, 1204:/,.,/ <= 78, A,137:0? 23.7 ,A1,97 72 9.21,,/ 63.78,. :0 78, @-77,.! :0 B:,; 26 78, 6-17 78-7 78, 9,7:7:20,. 8-4 027 18-55,0?,/ 78, 12@9.2@:4, /,1.,, :0 -0= 278,. 62.3@ B,0 02;! 78, 9,7:7:20,. :4 .,-/= -0/ ;:55:0? 72 9-= 78, <-5-01, -@2307 /3, 72 78, /,1.,, 825/,.! <37 78, /,1.,, 825/,. ;82 :4 9.,4,07 <,62., 78, 23.7:4027.,-/=72-11,9778,4-@, 06-17!02-@2307 ;-4 9-:/ <= 78, 9,7:7:20,.>3/?@,07 /,<72. ,B,0 -67,. 6:5:0?2678,,A,137:209,7:7:20-9-.76.2@8-B:0?9-:/>347 4 !!'-778,7:@,26,A,137:202678,12@9.2@:4, 9,7:7:20 8,.,62.,! 78, 9,7:7:20,. 8-4 45,97 2B,. 78, @-77,. ;:78237 <278,.:0? 72 @-E, ?22/ 78, <-5-01, 9-=@,07-4-?.,,/:078,12@9.2@:4,9,7:7:20-0/8-4027 482;0 /:5:?,01, :0 @-E:0? ?22/ 78, 9-=@,07 2. 266,.:0? 78, 4-:/ 9-=@,07 9.:2. 72 78, 6:5:0? 26 78, ,A,137:20 9,7:7:202./3.:0?78,9,0/,01=2678,,A,137:209,7:7:20 - 8 - F 0/,. 78, 1:.13@47-01,4! 78,., :4 02 12?,07 .,-420 2. ?22/ ?.230/ @-/, 237 <= 78, 9,7:7:20,. 72 :07,.6,.,;:7878,:@93?0,/2./,.9-44,/<=78,A,137:0? 23.7 112./:0?5=!9-4478,62552;:0?* 8,9,7:7:20:4*+,-+,,.* !*/ ( !") ' :472 * 52 *