- 1 - ! "# $$ %&' () $$ %&' ( ) % &)!&' !" # ## Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % #& #' # # !%' # (( $ ))*) ) # $ ##$ ( ) # ## $ # +!) % & !&' ! +! - 3 - +") " + +!) +!) *$ % #& #' # # !%' # (( # ) # # ' ))*) ) , # # $ )) # - # $ . # /$ # - 4 - &# % /$ #' 0121 345 6771682 691 :; 301 54<192 5= 301 6>:?86<@1@688A<BA<C?123A5<301A>7?B<1DE?DB>1<36<D 6469D D631D ))*) A< 5) 76221D :; 3015359@@AD1<386A>29A:?<68;2591%=5920593-301 9A:?<68.'5<8A6:A8A3; 01 D631 5= 6@@AD1<3 6<D A<F58F1>1<3 5= 301 F10A@81 691 <53 A< DA27?31& 301 5<8; A22?1 62 719 301 6771886<320191A<A2306330191A2<57522A:A8A3;5=@6?21=59 D1630 5= 4A=1 5= 301 @86A>6<3 :; <6>1 >3 9@06<6 5< 301 @5?<3 3063 301 6@@AD1<3 5@@?991D 5< ())* 6<D 201 :916301D 019 8623 5< )) 2 719 301 7523>5931> 917593 301 @6?21 5= D1630 462 D?1 35 9127A96359;=6A8?91@5<21C?1<335@5>78A@63A5<25=52319A59 1F192A:81<@1706857630;;<D95>14A300A2359;5= ! 169D 9A A2046<630 1BD1 8169<1D @5?<218 677169A<B =59 301 6771886<3 A< # 5"") - 5 - 6<D9A 1<G636<696;6<68169<1D@5?<218677169A<B =59 301 6771886<3 A< # 5")) 6<D 9A ?:0620 06<D96 521 8169<1D @5?<218 677169A<B =59 91275<D1<3 5A<:5306771682 * 9A A2046<630 1BD1 6<D 1<G636<696;6<6 E5A<38; 2?:>A331D 3063 30191 A2 <5 <1B8AB1<@1 5< 301 7693 5= 301 D9AF19 5= 301 6>:?86<@1 :169A<B91BA23963A5< 5 +)+*)3A25<8;D?135 301<1B8AB1<3D9AFA<B5=301D9AF195=301)(>:?86<@1 0191 691 <5 21F191 A<E?9A12 2?236A<1D :; 301 D1@1621D 405 462 6>:?8631D A< 6>:?86<@1 :185<BA<B 35 301 6771886<3 01 86D; 462 2?==19A<B =95> 219A5?2 A88<122 0191A2 <5 795HA>631@6?21 35 8A<G 301 A<E?9; 624188 62 D1630 A< 59D19 35 058D 3063 301 D1630 @6?21D D?1 35 301 6@@AD1<3017523>5931>917593%H!'>1918;26;23063 <1A3019A<E?9A12<59=96@3?9125<301:5D;5=D1@1621D6<D 301 @6?21 5= D1630 462 D?1 35 9127A96359; =6A8?91 @5<21C?1<3 35 @5>78A@63A5<2 5= 52319A59 1F192A:81 <@1706857630;;<D95>14A300A2359;5= - 6 - 52?:236<3A631301A9@86A>3018169<1D@5?<218 =59 301 6771886<32 A< :530 301 6771682 2?:>A331D 6 :9A1= 2;<572A22363A<B6:5?3301DA6B<52A26<D4063A252319A59 1F192A:81 <@1706857630; ;<D95>1 %' 2 719 301 2;<572A2 2?778A1D :; 301 6771886<3 52319A59 1F192A:81 <@1706857630; ;<D95>1 %' A2 6 @8A<A@5I96DA585BA@68 2;<D95>1 @0696@319AJ1D :; 016D6@01 21AJ?912683191D>1<3682363?26<DFA2?6885225>>5< 39ABB19A<B =6@3592 5= <@8?D1 :855D 79122?91 =8?@3?63A5<291<68=6A8?9113@6<D2?:>A323063301@6?21 5=D1630A2D?1359127A96359;=6A8?9140A@0062<530A<B35 D54A303016@@AD1<3019A:?<68062<53@5<2AD191D30A2 6271@3 5= 301 >63319 6<D 301 795@11D1D 35 6469D @5>71<263A5< 058DA<B 3063 301 D1630 A2 D?1 35 6@@AD1<3 @@59DA<B8;25?B033568854301677168 " 5:?339122301A969B?>1<32:530301@5?<2182 A<:5303016771682918A1D5<301E?DB>1<35=AB05?93 5=?<E6:6<D69;6<6A<301@6215= - 7 - 35@5<31<D 3063A<30126AD@62191=1991DK301@6?215=D1630A2D?1 35 @69DA59127A96359; =6A8?91 A< 6 @621 5= ?796@5<D;869 #96@3?9181=32AD140A81<3?:63A5<5=<123012A6L<301 26AD @621 301 AB0 5?93 5= ?<E6: 6<D 69;6<6 462 5= 30157A<A5<306330191A2<5@5<<1@3A5<:13411<301D1630 6<D 301 6@@AD1<3 62 719 H I 7523>5931> 917593 6<D 301 @193A=A@631 D12@9A:1D 62 @6?21 5= D1630 A22?1D :; 301 1DA@68 ==A@19 AB0 5?93 A271<269; ?>:6A 62 719 H!01A<E?9;@6?21D:;3012?719@5<D;869=96@3?915< 81=3 2AD16<D 627193017523>5931> 917593 301 @6?215= D1630 462 @69DA5+9127A96359; =6A8?91 < 3063 FA14 5= 301 >63319 301 5</:81 AB0 5?93 5= 69;6<6 6<D ?<E6: @5<=A9>1D 301 59D19 76221D :; 301 9A:?<68 40A@0 A2 @86A>1DA<301@86A>713A3A5< < A22?6<@1 5= <53A@1 :530 301 6771886<32 6771691D 6<D =A81D 301A9 23631>1<3 5= 5:E1@3A5<2 01 6771886<3 A< # 5"") D1<;A<B 301 6F19>1<32 5= 1 %)*'<8A<1M* - 8 - 301 @86A> 713A3A5< @5<31<D1D 3063 301 6@@AD1<3 462 <53 @6?21DD?13530196206<D<1B8AB1<3D9AFA<B:;0A>:?3A3 462 D?1 35 301 9620 6<D <1B8AB1<3 D9AFA<B 5= )( 6>:?86<@1 :169A<B 91BA23963A5< 5 +)" +)" 01 F10A@81 462 A<2?91D 4A30 91275<D1<3 5 6<D 301 6771886<3A<# 5"")062B53F68AD6<D1==1@3AF1 D9AFA<B 8A@1<21 62 5< 301 D631 5= 6@@AD1<3 1275<D1<3 5 A1 301 6771886<3 A< # 5")) =A81D 0A2 23631>1<3 5= 5:E1@3A5< A< 68>523 688 918;A<B 4A30 301 23631>1<3 5= 5:E1@3A5< =A81D :; 91275<D1<3 5 D1<;A<B 1<3A91A<@AD1<3A2D?13596206<D<1B8AB1<35<30176935= 301 D9AF19 5= 6>:?86<@1 :169A<B 5 +) +*) @@59DA<B8;25?B0335DA2>A22301677168 ( 01 @86A>6<391275<D1<3 5 A< :530 301 6771682A<59D1935795F1301@6211H6>A<1D626<D 795D?@1D*D5@?>1<3240A@04191>69G1D62H235 *01D9AF195=3016>:?86<@14621H6>A<1D62 6<D3015==A@195=91275<D1<3 54621H6>A<1D62 - 9 - 6<D 301; 06F1 795D?@1D 5<1 D5@?>1<3 6<D 301 26>1 A2 >69G1D62H 01 :9A1= 5?38A<1 5= =6@32 816DA<B 35 =A8A<B 5= 30121677168269162?<D19 # 5"))A2:;30154<195=3016>:?86<@1 6<D# 5"")A2:;301D9AF195=3016>:?86<@1 :169A<B 5 +)++*)0635<())*636:5?3 )()) 401< D1@1621D 9@06<6 6 2AH >5<302 791B<6<3 86D; 462 2?==19A<B =95> =1F19 6<D :1A<B 6>:?8631D A< )( 6>:?86<@1 :169A<B 5 +)" +)" =95> 6B69 35469D2 ;2?9? 3 3063 3A>1 6<53019 6>:?86<@1 :169A<B 91BA23963A5< <?>:19 5 +) + *)D9AF1<:;A32D9AF19A<696206<D<1B8AB1<3>6<<19 @6>1 =95> 301 :10A<D 6<D 0A3 301 0A<D 7593A5< 5= >:?86<@14019A<>39@06<64626>:?8631D?135 301 A>76@3 >3 9@06<6 2?236A<1D A<E?9A12 6<D 462 20A=31D A< 6<53019 6>:?86<@1 35 9A<D6F6< 527A368 ;2?9?0A81?<D1939163>1<3201:916301D01986235< )) 01 758A@1 91BA23191D 6 @621 6B6A<23 301 - 10 - D9AF195=3016>:?86<@1:169A<B 5 +)++*)A1 6771886<3 A< # 5"") 6<D 2?:21C?1<38; =A81D @069B12011301@86A>6<391275<D1<3<50191A<=A81D @86A>713A3A5<211GA<B@5>71<263A5<=59301D16305=>3 9@06<6A<301956D396==A@6@@AD1<3 ) 01 9A:?<68 2?:21C?1<3 35 @5>7813A5< 5= 301 7816DA<B2=96>1D30911A22?1240A@0916D262=588542 013019 301 713A3A5<19 795F12 3063 0A A2 301 D171<D1<3 5= D1@1621D >3 9@06<6 405 DA1D A< 6 956D 396==A@ 6@@AD1<3 69A2A<B 5?3 5= ?21 5= F10A@81 :169A<B 91BA23963A5< 5 +) + *) 5@@?991D 5< ())* 63 6:5?3 ()) 6> D?1 35 301 6@3A5<6:81 <1B8AB1<@1 5< 301 7693 5= 30191275<D1<3 5N 013019 301 713A3A5<19 A2 1<3A381D =59 @5>71<263A5<N = 25 63 4063 1H31<3 6<D=95>405>N ! 0639D1959918A1=N 01 9A:?<68 6=319 0169A<B 301 7693A12 6<D 5< 67791@A63A5< 5= :530 5968 6<D D5@?>1<369; 1FAD1<@1 6<24191D A22?1 5 A< 6==A9>63AF1 A22?1 5 A< 76938; - 11 - 6==A9>63AF1 6<D 6469D1D @5>71<263A5< 5= 2""))+ 685<B4A30A<3191236330196315="O7196<<?>=95>301 D631 5= 713A3A5< 3A88 A32 9168AJ63A5< 2363A<B :530 301 6771886<32 A< :530 301 6771682 0191A< 691 E5A<38; 6<D 21F19688; 8A6:81 35 76; 301 @5>71<263A5< 3 A2 30A2 E?DB>1<36<D6469D76221D:;3019A:?<68@06881<B1DA< 30121 6771682 :; 301 D9AF19 62 4188 62 301 A<2?919 5= 301 6>:?86<@1:169A<B<?>:19 +)+*) 6FA<B0169D3018169<1D@5?<218=593017693A12 6<D719?21D3011<3A916771687671926<D3019A685?93 1@59D2 301 5<8; C?123A5< 3063 45?8D 69A21 =59 @5<2AD1963A5<A2 K013019 301 9A:?<68 A2 E?23A=A1D A< 7622A<B 30159D196<D6469DA<B301@5>71<263A5<L ! ;6<2419353016:5F175A<3=59@5<2AD1963A5< A2A<-6==A9>63AF1.=59301=58854A<B - 12 - * =319 B5A<B 3095?B0 301 1<3A91 E?DB>1<3 301 9A:?<680627957198;@5<2AD191D3011<3A91>6319A68786@1D :1=591 A3 6<D 6469D1D 6779579A631 @5>71<263A5< 058DA<B 3063 :530 301 91275<D1<32 691 8A6:81 35 76; 301 @5>71<263A5< 6<D =?93019 058DA<B 3063 301 6@@AD1<3 062 912?831D A<D1630 5= >3 9@06<6 01 D631 5= 6@@AD1<3 :1A<B())*301D6315=D16304624A30A<301276< 5= ) D6;2 6<D 301 @6?21 5= D1630 62 719 7523 >5931> 917593 A2 D?1 35 9127A96359; =6A8?91 @5<21C?1<3 35 @5>78A@63A5<2 5= 52319A59 1F192A:81 <@1706857630; ;<D95>1 %' 4A30 0A2359; 5= 01 2;<572A2 2?:>A331D :; 301 6771886<32 @81698; 236312 6:5?3 4063 A2 52319A59 1F192A:81 <@1706857630; ;<D95>1 62 30191 691 @5>>5< 39ABB19A<B =6@3592 5= 40A@0 A<@8?D12 A<@91621 A< 301 :855D 79122?91 =8?@3?63A5<2 91<68 =6A8?91 13@01E?DB>1<3@A31D:;3016771886<32D5<53@5>135 301A96AD=593012A>78191625<3063301A<E?9;2?236A<1D:; 301D1@1621DA<30126AD@62146262?719@5<D;869=96@3?91 - 13 - 5<81=32AD140A@0062<5DA91@36@@122D?1353016:21<@1 5= 6<; >6319A68 191A< A< 301 @621 301 758A@1 91@59D2 @81698;205423063301@6?215=D1630A2D?135301A<E?9; 2?==191D :; 301 D1@1621D 62 201 462 6 791B<6<3 86D; 2?==19A<B=95>219A5?2016830A<=A9>A3A126<D3016@@AD1<368 205@G 6<D 396?>6 40A@0 062 6@@1819631D 301 @5>78A@63A5<2 ?83A>6318; 912?831D A< 019 D1630 @@59DA<B8; 30A2 5?93 =A<D2 <5 A<=A9>A3A12 A< 301 59D19 76221D:;3019A:?<68 D>A331D8; 301 D1@1621D 462 6 791B<6<3 45>6< 2 719 >1DA@68 2@A1<@1 30191 691 25 >6<; 059>5<68@06<B123540A@030145>6<45?8D:12?:E1@31D D?9A<B 301 791B<6<@; 2 301 791B<6<@; 6==1@32 >6<; 59B6< 2;231>2 6<D @6?212 2AB<A=A@6<3 70;2A585BA@68 @06<B12 3063 691 >6A<8; @6?21D :; @06<B12 A< 069>5<1 81F18227192@A1<3A=A@912169@06<D1221<3A68DA2@5F19A12 40A@0 A<@8?D12 @06<B12 A< 91<68 01>5D;<6>A@2 @68@A?>705270595?2 81F18 F69A63A5<2 30;95AD B86<D 0;71939570; @06<B1D =?<@3A5< 6<D @69DA5F62@?869 - 14 - 6D67363A5<2 01 91FA14 5< 2@A1<3A=A@ 912169@0 6825 6DD91221D 054 21H 069>5<12 6==1@3 A>>?<585BA@68 91275<212 1>7062AJA<B 301A9 A>75936<@1 =59 @5<DA3A5<2 8AG1 >?83A781 2@81952A2 DDA3A5<688; A>76@3 A2 301 B62395A<3123A<68 396@3 40A@0 912?832 A< 2;>735>2 8AG1 <6?216 6<D 01693:?9< 91B<6<@; 6==1@32 68>523 1F19; @5>75<1<3 5= GAD<1; =?<@3A5< 1<68 6<D 2;231>A@ 01>5D;<6>A@2691D1<531D:;F625DA863A5<6<D2AB<A=A@6<3 F58?>1 1H76<2A5< @A1<3A=A@ DA2@5F19A12 91F1682 3063 181F63A5<25=()O6<D)OA<30191<687862>6=854%#' 6<DB85>19?869=A83963A5<9631%#'691<531D@5>7691D35 791+791B<6<@; F68?12 28AB03 9A21 A< 79531A<?9A6 6<D B8?@52?9A6 6 =688 A< 219?> 52>5868A3; 6<D 6 D1@91621 A< :855D 25DA?> 81F182 912?83 =95> >5D123 6831963A5<2 A< 3?:?869 6@3AFA3; 6<D 301 795@122A<B 5= 46319 6<D 181@3958;31291B<6<@;918631D=8?AD9131<3A5<@6?212301 GAD<1;2 35 1<869B1 6<D =91C?1<38; 912?832 A< 70;2A585BA@ 0;D95<170952A2 F1< 30191 691 =8?@3?63A5<2 A< :855D 79122?91624188622?B6981F18201791B<6<386DA121F1< - 15 - <53 BAF1< A>>1DA631 >1DA@A<1 4A305?3 795719 >1DA@68 1H6>A<63A5< =59 6<; 2A@G<122 D?9A<B 301 791B<6<@; 301 91625< :1A<B 301 26>1 062 B53 6< A<DA91@3 1==1@3 5< 301 =13?2A<30145>:256825@01>A@68916@3A5<206771<A<BA< 301791B<6<386D;F1<6@@59DA<B353016771886<32301 D1@1621D 462 2?==19A<B =95> 6@?31 A88<122 6<D 462 6>:?8631D353010527A368=590AB01939163>1<301758A@1 91@59D22716G6:5?3301@6?215=D1630A2D?1353019620 6<D <1B8AB1<3 D9AFA<B 5= 301 D9AF19 405 462 <5<1 53019 306<3016771886<3A<# 5)")6<D:?3301@069B1 2011346286AD6B6A<233016771886<3A<# 5""))) " 015<8;@5<31<3A5<5=3016771886<3A23063301 @6?215=D1630622054<A<3017523>5931>917593A2D?1 35 301 9127A96359; =6A8?91 @5<21C?1<3 35 @5>78A@63A5<2 5= 40A@0062<5DA91@3@5<<1@3A5<4A30D16306<D301 6@@AD1<327193012;<572A22?:>A331D:;3016771886<3 1H786A<A<B @5>78A@63A5<2 @A31D A< 301 7523>5931> 917593 40A@081D353019127A96359;=6A8?91A152319A591F192A:81 <@1706857630; ;<D95>1 062 :11< @81698; 1H786A<1D - 16 - 3063A3A26@8A<A@5+96DA585BA@682;<D95>1@0696@319AJ1D:;6 016D6@01 21AJ?912 683191D >1<3682363?2 6<D FA2?68 8522 13@ 5>>5< 39ABB19A<B =6@3592 5= A<@8?D1 :855D 79122?91 =8?@3?63A5<2 91<68 =6A8?91 13@ D>A331D8; 301 D1@1621D46262AH>5<302791B<6<32?==19A<B=95>6@?31 A88<122 01 6@@AD1<3 062 @6?21D 396?>6 912?83A<B A< 52319A59 1F192A:81 <@1706857630; ;<D95>1 %' 6<D?83A>6318;912?831DA<9127A96359;=6A8?91 3 A2 5< 91@59D 3063 D1@1621D 462 219A5?28; A88 6<D 2?==19A<B =95> 21F1968 A<=1@3A5<2 6<D 462 6>:?8631D 6<D91=1991D350AB0190527A368=5979571939163>1<301 6@@AD1<3 6<D 301 A<E?9A12 2?==191D 2?7196DD1D 40A@0 912?831D A<=1@3A5<2 816DA<B 35 205@G 912?83A<B A< D1630 62 201462<53A<6752A3A5<3591275<D35301A<319F1<3A5<:; 301>1DA@68316>A<3010527A3686<D?83A>6318;2?@@?>:1D 4A30A< 6 276< 5= 2AH D6;2 < 30121 @A9@?>236<@12 301 6?3572; 917593 40A@0 A2 >69G1D 4A305?3 30191 :1A<B 6<; 5:E1@3A5<91C?A91D35:1@5<2AD191D058DA<B3063301D1630 - 17 - A2 D?1 35 9127A96359; =6A8?91 %55G91=1991D ?336.2 1H3:55G 5= 4A30 301 0187 5= 9 P60AD A< 1H786A<A<B' ( 0A2 5?93 786@12 A32 67791@A63A5< =59 6:81 622A236<@1B?AD6<@1 6<D 6DFA21 91<D191D :; 9 P60AD C:68 1DA@68 ==A@19 A271<269; AB0 5?93 5= 69<636G6 686:?6BA1<@0A<59D1935699AF1636795719 @5<@8?2A5<35058D3063301A<E?9A122?==191D@6?21DD?135 205@G 40A@0 062 6BB91B63AF1D A<=A9>A3A12 40A@0 301 D1@1621D462=6@A<B401<2014626>:?8631D #59301=59B5A<B91625<230A2@5?93795@11DA<B 7622301=58854A<B A' 5303016771682691! AA' 01 6>5?<3 A< D1752A3 >6D1 :; :530 301 6771886<32A<:5303016771682:1396<2>A331D35 301@5<@19<1D9A:?<68=59DA2:?921>1<3 - 18 - AAA' 01 6771886<32 691 DA91@31D 35 D1752A3 1<3A91 @5>71<263A5< 6>5?<3 A<@8?2AF1 5= 6>5?<3 D1752A31D685<B4A30"O76=95>301D6315= 713A3A5< 3A88 9168AJ63A5< :1=591 301 @5<@19<1D 9A:?<68 4A30A< 6 719A5D 5= 2AH 411G2=95> 301 D6315=91@1A735=59D195=30A259D19 AF' A2:?921>1<3A26271930159D1976221D:;301 9A:?<68 F' 559D196235@523 +( %' # A23 5