- 1 - ! "" #$% & !!"#$ %&& '$$($&() $ & & ( $($ & !!$ $ **( & * !!!$ %& '+( &) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "')$($ && , !-& &,($ ') ($" ! $!$! . $ && ( / / 0$ $$ 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =742>4?< 4556774?< 366@2?A 8BC 6?14?=6>6?< B8 =B>56?34<2B? 43 56C DE9A>6?<4?94F4C9$!$!543369:;<16BEC< B8 <16 B<BC (612=763 ==296?< 742>3 C2:E?47 6?A47ECE 2<; '16C62?48<6C C686CC69 43 GC2:E?47H8BC31BC<H)3B473B843<6?2?AB8724:272<;<B<16 6I<6?< B8 !- <BF4C93 =B?<C2:E<BC; ?6A72A6?=6$ 16 94<6 B8 4==296?< 2?JB7J6>6?< B8 J612=76 4?9 2?DEC263 3E3<42?694C6?B<2?9235E<6$16B?7;9235E<62?<123 - 3 - 455647 23 8BC 2?496KE4<6 =B>56?34<2B? 3B 473B !- =B?<C2:E<BC; ?6A72A6?=6 3=169E769 B? <16 4556774?< =742>4?<$ $ 64C9 C2 *$($ 1;4> &C4349 764C?69 =BE?36745564C2?A8BC<164556774?<$16C635B?96?<3 <1BEA1 36CJ69 C6>42?69 E?C65C636?<69 62<16C 56C3B?477;BC<1CBEA1<16BJ6C?>6?<9JB=4<6$ "$ C2 *$($ 1;4> &C4349 764C?69 =BE?367 45564C2?A8BC<164556774?<<4@2?A<123BEC<<1CBEA1 <16 DE9A>6?< 4?9 4F4C9 543369 :; <16 C2:E?47 J616>6?<7; 3E:>2<<69 <14< <16 4556774?< 23 4 =BB726 :;4JB=4<2B?$164==296?<B==ECC69B?$!$!$ 356C<162?=B>682I69:;<16*4C?4<4@4<4<66A47 6CJ2=6 E<1BC2<; 8BC <16 ;64C ! 2? C6356=< B8 E?3@2776974:BEC233$!!! 56C>B?<1$ $ 6 8EC<16C 3E:>2<3 <14< <16 C2:E?47 =B?3296C2?A <16 4JB=4<2B? B8 <16 4556774?< BEA1< <B 14J6<4@6?<169234:272<;4<!!-43<B<1654C<2=E74C 72>:4356C<166J296?=6B8<16B=<BC233<4<694< - 4 - " -$164556774?<1493E886C698C4=<EC6B8:B<1<16 :B?63B8C2A1<76A4?9E?96CF6?<C2A1<<2:24F2<1 4?9 7B=@2?A :B7< B? "$!$! 4?9 16 F43 923=14CA69 B? !$! $!$ 6 F43 2?54<26?< 8BC 4 56C2B9 B8 94;3$ 16? 16 F43 6I4>2?69 :; <16 B=<BC B? L$!"$! 2< F43 8BE?9 <14< <16 9665 <6?96C?6335C636?<$16C6F43>E3=76F43<2?A?B<69 B? <16 C2A1< <12A1 4?9 =478 C63<C2=<2B? B8 C2A1< @?66 4?94?@76DB2?<>BJ6>6?<$356C<16,C4;C65BC<B8 C2A1< 76A 9288E36 B3<6B56?24 ?B<69 BJ6C <16 :B?63 J23E472M69$162>574?<34C62?36C<692?<16B56C4<69 4C64 4?9 <16 4556774?< 23 3E886C2?A 8CB> 9234:272<; <B <16 6I<6?< B8 " - <B <16 C2A1< 7BF6C 72>:$ 16 C2:E?47 143 842769 <B =B?3296C <16 =436 B8 <16 4556774?< 8BC 4F4C92?A 455CB5C24<6 =B>56?34<2B? E?96C 477 <16 16493 F12=1 C6KE2C63 C6=B?3296C4<2B? 4?9C696<6C>2?4<2B?$ $ EC<16C161433E:>2<<69<14<<16C2:E?47 2? <16 4:36?=6 B8 4?; >4<6C247 B? C6=BC9 843<6?69 - 5 - !-?6A72A6?=6:;F4;B8=B?<C2:E<BC;?6A72A6?=6B? <16 4556774?<$ B<12?A 923=E3369 2? <16 2>5EA?69 DE9A>6?<6I=65< <16 36?<6?=6<14< <16CB49 F16C6 <164556774?<149=CB3369<16C6F43?B5CBJ232B?<B =CB33 <16 34>6 :; 4 56963<C24?$ BF6J6C 2? <16 4:36?=6B84?;6J296?=6BC=B?<C4>4<6C247574=69:; <16C635B?96?<3<16C2:E?476CC692?843<6?2?A!- ?6A72A6?=6:;F4;B8=B?<C492=<BC;?6A72A6?=6B?<16 4556774?< 4?9 <16 34>6 C6KE2C69 <B :6 36< 43296$ ==BC92?A7; 16 3BEA1< <B 477BF <16 455647 4?9 6?14?=6 <16 =B>56?34<2B? :; 36<<2?A 43296 !- =B?<C2:E<BC;?6A72A6?=6843<6?69B?<164556774?<$ $ 4J2?A 164C9 <16 764C?69 =BE?367 8BC <16 4556774?< 56CE369 <16 6?<2C6 455647 5456C3 47B?A F2<1<16C247BEC<C6=BC93$ $ 16 5B2?<3 <14< FBE79 4C236 8BC =B?3296C4<2B?2?<1234556474C643E?96C/ - 6 - ! ; 4?3F6C <B 5B2?< B$ 2? <16 ?6A4<2J6 4?9 5B2?< B$ 54C<7; 2? <16 4882C>4<2J6 8BC <16 8B77BF2?A/ L$ B 84C 43 <16 ?6A72A6?=6 4356=< 23 =B?=6C?69 C635B?96?< B$ <16 65E<; B>>2332B?6C B8 &B72=6 <1BEA1 36CJ69 C6>42?69 6I54C<6 :68BC6 <16 C2:E?47$ 635B?96?< B$ *4C?4<4@4 BJ6C?>6?<?3EC4?=6 654C<>6?<'*) 149 45564C69 4?9 82769 FC2<<6? 3<4<6>6?< 96?;2?A <16 4J6C>6?<3 B8 <16 56<2<2B? <4@2?A 4 356=282= =B?<6?<2B? <14< <16 4556774?< F43 ?B< =CB332?A <16 >42?CB492?<16356=282=M6:C4=CB332?A72?64?9<16 4==296?< F43 =4E369 9E6 <B 3B76 =B?<C2:E<BC; ?6A72A6?<4=<B8<164556774?<$ - 7 - #$ BF6J6C C635B?96?< B$ ?62<16C 6I4>2?69 4?; F2<?633 ?BC 5CB9E=69 4?; 9B=E>6?<3 <B 3E:3<4?<24<6 2<3 =B?<6?<2B? <4@6? 2? <16 FC2<<6? 3<4<6>6?<$ 14< 454C< <16 C296C B8 <16 J612=76 :67B?A3<B<16&B72=6654C<>6?<4?916F434&B72=6 B?3<4:76$ 62?A <16 >6>:6C B8 4 8BC=6 16 31BE79 14J6 4916C69 <B 477 <16 <C4882= 32A?473 4?9 CE763 5C63=C2:69 :; <16 34>69654C<>6?<$ 16C296C :62?A >6>:6CB8<168BC=631BE7914J6:66?>BC65CE96?< 4?9 =2C=E>356=< F1276 C292?A <16 >B<BC =;=76 B? 4 :E3;CB49$1635B<3@6<=14?935B<>414M4C=764C7; 31BF<14<<16C296CB8<16>B<BC=;=76:62?A<16&B72=6 B?3<4:76F43?B<C292?A<16>B<BC=;=762?472>2<69 35669$ !$ B?3296C2?A <16 84=< <14< <16 35B< B8 <16 4==296?< 23 4 :E3; CB49 2?JB7J2?A 164J; <C4882= 2? <1636=2C=E>3<4?=63<16C2:E?47B?7;B?<16ACBE?9 <14< <16C6 F43 ?B M6:C4 =CB33 8BC <16 56963<C24? <B =CB33<16CB49843<6?69!-=B?<C2:E<BC;?6A72A6?=6 - 8 - B? <16 4556774?< 2? <16 4:36?=6 B8 4?; 6J296?=6 <B <14< 6886=< :; <16 C635B?96?<3$ ? <1636 =2C=E>3<4?=63 <16 82?92?A B8 <16 C2:E?47 23 6CCB?6BE3 C6KE2C69 <B :6 36<43296 4?9 4==BC92?A7; <1634>62336<43296$ $ 16 C296C B8 <16 >B<BC =;=76 724:76 8BC<16 4==296?< 4?9 4?3F6C2?A 233E6 B$ 2? 4882C>4<2J6 2?3<649B854C<7;2?4882C>4<2J6:;<16C2:E?47$ $ B84C43<16KE4?<E>B8=B>56?34<2B?23 =B?=6C?69<16C2:E?4786772?6CCBC2?=B?3296C2?A<16 9234:272<;4<-<B<16F1B76:B9;2$6$ "C9B8<16 9234:272<;<B<1654C<2=E74C72>:$ "$ ? <16 5C636?< =436 <16 4556774?< 23 4 =BB726$356C<169234:272<;=6C<282=4<6233E69:;<16 B=<BC&$F12=13564@34:BE<<16=B?92<2B?B8<16 4556774?<$ 62?A =BB726 <16 4556774?< C6KE2C63 =B?3<4?< 3<4?92?A F1276 9B2?A 123 FBC@$ ? <1636 =2C=E>3<4?=63<1634>64886=<31234JB=4<2B?28?B< 8E77; :E< 4<7643< <B 4? 6I<6?< B8 !- 43 4A42?3< <16 - 9 - 9234:272<; <B <16 54C<2=E74C 72>: 43 :B<1 :B?63 4C6 8C4=<EC694?9F43B56C4<69:;2?36C<2?A2?574?<3$ $ ? <1636 =2C=E>3<4?=63 <123 BEC< 86673 <14< 28 !- B8 <16 9234:272<; <BF4C93 <16 54C<2=E74C 72>:234557269<B<16F1B76:B9;2<FBE79>66<<16 6?93 B8 DE3<2=6$ ? J26F B8 <16 34>6 <123 BEC< 5CB=6693 <B C696<6C>2?6 <16 =B>56?34<2B?$ ? C6=B?3296C4<2B? B8 <16 >4<6C247 B? C6=BC9 =B>56?34<2B? B? C696<6C>2?4<2B? FBC@3 BE< 43 8B77BF3/ 7$ B$ &4C<2=E74C3 B>56?34<2B? $ B33B88E<EC62?=B>6 '!!!IILIL !!) L"!! $ B33B82?=B>69EC2?A<16 7429 E5 56C2B9 4?9 4<<6?94?<=14CA6 '>B?<13I!!!) !!!! "$ B?J6;4?=6=14CA63 !!!! $ &42?4?93E886C2?A3 !!!! $ BB9?BEC231>6?< 4<<6?94?<=14CA63 !!!! - 10 - $ B33B84>6?2<263 "!!!! $ 692=47:2773 ! L$ E<EC6692=47:2773 !!!! ' ( $ ==BC92?A7; <16 4556774?< 23 6?<2<769 8BC 3$LL! F12=123CBE?969B88<B3$L#!!! 434A42?3<3$"! F2<12?<6C63<4<<16C4<6B8 -56C4??E>8CB>94<6B856<2<2B?<2772<3C6472M4<2B?$ $ 16 6?14?=69 =B>56?34<2B? FBE79 =B>6 <B3$#!! F12=131477=4CC;2?<6C63<4<<16C4<6 B8 - 56C 4??E> 8CB> <16 94<6 B8 56<2<2B? <277 2<3 C6472M4<2B?$ $ ==BC92?A7; <16 5B2?<3 8BC =B?3296C4<2B? 4C64?3F6C69433<4<693E5C44?9<123BEC<5CB=6693 <B5433<168B77BF2?A/ 2$ 5564723 $ 22$ 16 2>5EA?69 DE9A>6?< 4?9 4F4C9 94<69 $!$! 543369 2? ( B$" ! - 11 - :; <16 ,( 992<2B?47 E9A6 4?9 B<BC ==296?<3 742>3 C2:E?47 BEC< B8 >477 4E363 ') 4< 6?A47ECE 23 >B928269$ 222$ 16 =B?<C2:E<BC; ?6A72A6?=6 B8 !- 843<6?69B?<164556774?<2336<43296$16 6?<2C6?6A72A6?=623843<6?69B?<16C296CB8 <16>B<BC=;=76$ 2J$ 16 4556774?< 23 6?<2<769 8BC 6?14?=69 =B>56?34<2B? B8 3$#!! 47B?A F2<1 4==CE69 2?<6C63< 4< <16 C4<6 B8 - 56C 4??E> 8CB> 94<6 B8 56<2<2B? <277 2<3 C6472M4<2B? 2? 4992<2B? <B F14< 143 :66? 47C649;4F4C969:;<16C2:E?47$ J$ 16 C635B?96?<3 31477 965B32< <16 6?<2C6 6?14?=69 =B>56?34<2B? B8 3$#!! F2<12?<6C63<4<<16C4<6B8 -56C4??E> 8CB> <16 94<6 B8 56<2<2B? <277 C6472M4<2B? :68BC6 <16 =B?=6C?69 C2:E?47 F2<12? 4 - 12 - 56C2B9B832IF66@38CB><1694<6B8C6=625< B8=6C<28269=B5;<123DE9A>6?<$ J2$ ? 965B32< B8 6?<2C6 4>BE?< !- 47B?A F2<14==CE692?<6C63<@65<2?82I69965B32< 2?4?;?4<2B?472M69BC3=169E7694?@8BC4 56C2B9 B8 " ;64C3 4?9 <16 C6>42?2?A !- 47B?A F2<1 4==CE69 2?<6C63< 31477 :6 C6764369 2? 84JBEC B8 <16 4556774?< B? 5CB56C296?<282=4<2B?$ )( #% & 23<B$/7B$/L