- 1 - !"#$ %#& ## '( ) ! " # # $%%%" & ' ( ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $ # # # ) * +(+ &"& " %%%& & %%& , %&, & * ++ - # # ## "" %" ." % %" ( (# * ## - # # %""% # / # 0 # - - 3 - CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM " . +( ! 12 3245456728 19: ;5<2= 415: >854 32454567 :22?57@ 9 =582A456757412794B826;C97=9CB:4641282:367=274:46 2;;2A4A197@26;194997=919755712879C25782:32A4 6;9@85AB<4B89<<97=:D29857@B8E2F 6:&" "97=& 6; 9<5FB8B 5<<9@2 9:9D96D<5 985?282 9<B? 57 428C:6; 412;579<=2A82239::2=57# 6"" %"97=46:24 9:5=2 412 27=68:2C274 =942= %%%& 5::B2= DF 412 91:5<=98 2:367=274 6 &! 82GB5857@ 412 3245456728 46 386=BA2 97 "" :?24A1 9: 9 A67=54567 ;68 2;;2A457@ CB494567 12 3245456728 19: 9<:6 A19<<27@2= 412 A6CCB75A94567 =942= %%& 5::B2= DF 412 ::5:4974 6CC5::56728 2:367=274 6 ! 46 412 91:5<=98 3657457@ 6B4 A284957 9<<2@2= =5:A82397A52: 57 412 32454567280:933<5A94567;68CB494567 - 4 - #9A4:6;4129:29829:B7=28. 12 324545672819= 57:454B42= 9 :B54 ;68 39845456797= :2398942 36::2::567 57 6$ %"$ D2;682 412 A6C324274 5E5< 6B84 12 :B54 A9C2 46 D2 =2A822= 67 %""%" =2A<9857@ 412 32454567280::1982 57 412 ;9C5<F 386328452: 772HB82! & 12 :95= =2A822 >9: A98852= 57 93329< DF 412 =2;27=974: DB4 D641 412 82@B<98 93329<: A9C2 46 D2 =5:C5::2= DF IB=@C274 97= =2A822 =942= "$%%" 772HB82: 97= ! 41282DF A67;58C57@ 412 382<5C5798F =2A822 , BD:2GB274<F 412 3245456728 57545942= ;579< =2A822 386A22=57@: 57 # 6 "" %" >128257 412 C94428>9:9C5A9D<F:244<2=97=9A6C386C5:2=2A822>9: =89>7 67 "%%" 772HB82! 9<<64457@ 46 412 3245456728 " 9A82 &$ @B749: 57 F 6 & 97= 64128 ;9C5<FC2CD28:4125882:32A45E2:1982: - 5 - B8:B974 46 412 :95= A6C386C5:2 =2A822 412 3245456728:BDC5442=982382:27494567D2;68241291:5<=98 985?282 9<B? 82GB2:457@ CB494567 6; 1949 97= 91975 274852:5712879C25782:32A46;1289<<6442=3684567 $ 367 82A2534 6; 412 82GB2:4 412 91:5<=98 :6B@1441263575676;412==545679<6E287C274<29=28 >16B3672H9C57945676;412=2A82282A6CC27=2=4194 412CB494567D22;;2A42=57428C:6;41268=28:39::2=57 # 6"" %" A457@ B367 412 :95= 6357567 412 91:5<=98 9==82::2= 9 <24428 =942= ",%%& 46 412 ::5:4974 6CC5::56728 2:367=274 6!82A6CC27=57@93386E9< ;68A197@26;1949579AA68=97A2>541412=2A822 6>2E28 DF A6CCB75A94567 =942= %%& 772HB82! 412 ::5:4974 6CC5::56728 365742= 6B4 A2849579<<2@2==2;2A4:79C2<F. 12 2H4274 6; <97= 9! 9<<6442= B7=28 412 =2A822 97= 4194:16>757412=5=76449<<F- - 6 - 12 3245456728 19= 764 D! 386=BA2= 97 "" :?24A1 =2<5729457@:BD=5E5:567D6B7=9852:-97= 12 =6ABC274: 27A<6:2= A! >282 764 =B<F 9B412745A942= 7 A67:2GB27A2 412 91:5<=98 5::B2= 97 27=68:2C274=942=%%%& 772HB82(!A9<<57@B367 412324545672846386=BA297"":?24A146279D<2;B84128 386A2::57@6;412CB494567 "% 15: 5::B2 19: D227 2H427:5E2<F =29<4 >541 DF 415: 6B84 57 6 $& %, 97= =582A4567: 982 5::B2=46412857A53<22A82498F2E27B2 23984C274 "" A5E5< 6B84 =2A822 >124128 =2A<989468F 382<5C5798F ;579< 68 A6C386C5:2 A67:454B42: 9 <9>;B< 9AGB5:545676;85@14:J64128>5:2KB7=282A4567"6;412 987949?9 97= 2E27B2 A4 "$, 97= CB:4 D2 5CC2=5942<F 82;<2A42= 57 412 398274 B494567 D9:2= 67 :BA1 9 =2A822 5: 9 ;5:A9< 9A4 57427=2= 67<F 46 82A68= 9=IB=5A942= 6>728:153- 54 =62: 764 82GB582 38568 :BD - 7 - =5E5:5676897"":?24A17:5:457@6797"":?24A194 412 CB494567 :49@2 5C386328<F A67;<942: CB494567 >541 15::9386A22=57@:>15A1982:239894297=985:267<F>127 93984F:22?:57=5E5=B9< 19496857427=:469<5279429 :32A5;5A9<<F =2C98A942= 398A2< 2E27B2 9B41685452: 982 :494B4685<F D6B7= B7=28 2A4567: " 97= "& 46 9C27= 412 2A68= 6; 5@14: 57 A67;68C54F >541 IB=5A59< =2A<9894567: 97= A97764 36:43672 68 =5<B42 412 2;;2A4 6; :BA1=2A822:6742A175A9<68386A2=B89<@86B7=: " #95<B82 46 CB4942 79C2: D9:2= 67 9 D57=57@ =2A822 279D<2: 412 <6:57@ 3984F 46 2H3<654 6B4=942= 82E27B2 274852: A82942 4158=3984F 85@14: 97= ;8B:48942 IB=5A59< =2428C5794567: 41282DF B7=28C5757@ 412 ;579<54F 97= :B382C9AF 6; A5E5< A6B84 68=28: 5@549< <5C5494567: 57 9E285 % 68 166C5 A97764 6E2885=2 :494B468F =B452:- B745< :6;4>982 >68?;<6>: 982 B3@89=2= 46 9AA6CC6=942 =2A822D9:2= CB494567: 82E27B2 6;;5A28: CB:4 9AA234 31F:5A9< 933<5A94567: 97= 386C34<F 27428 412 =2A822 - 8 - 16<=28:0 79C2: 97= :1982: 57 412 398274 82:28E57@ 42A175A9<:BD=5E5:567;689<9428:49@2 "& #68 412 ;682@657@ 829:67: 97= 57 412 <5@14 6; 412 @B5=2<572: <95= =6>7 DF 415: 6B84 6$& %,415:6B84386A22=:4639::412;6<<6>57@. 5 854324545675: 55 1227=68:2C274=942=%%%&5::B2= DF 412 91:5<=98 97= 412 <24428 =942= %%& 772HB82! 5::B2= DF 412 ::5:4974 6CC5::56728 982 1282DF GB9:12= 555 12 82:367=274: 982 =582A42= 46 2;;2A4 CB494567 6; 412 32454567280: 79C2 57 412 82E27B282A68=:328495757@46B8E2F 6: &" " 97= & 6; 9<5FB8B 5<<9@2 9:9D96D<5 985?282 9<B? :485A4<F 57 9AA68=97A2>541412;579<=2A82239::2=57 - 9 - # 6 "" %" 97= 57 9AA68=97A2 46 412 @B5=2<572: <95= =6>7 DF 415: 6B84 57 6$& %, 5E 45:C9=2A<29841944125;412:6;4>98257 54: 382:274 ;68C =62: 764 9AA234 412 32454567280: 933<5A94567 >5416B4 9 "" :?24A1 9 31F:5A9< 933<5A94567 :19<< D2 9AA2342= DF 412 IB85:=5A45679< 491:5<=98 9: 9 67245C2 2HA234567 97= CB494567 :19<< D22;;2A42= E 12 91:5<=98 C9F 412829;428 67 97 933<5A94567:22?57@:BD=5E5:567A988F6B4 412 :BD=5E5:567 A6882:367=57@ 46 412 :32A5;5A 2H4274: 9<<6442= 46 412 82:32A45E2 398452: B7=28 412 =2A822 97= :19<< 9AA68=57@<F 5::B2 412 "" :?24A1 97= 5::B257=5E5=B9<?1949: vi. 12 274582 2H28A5:2 :19<< D2 A6C3<242= >54157 9 32856= 6; 25@14 >22?: ;86C 412 - 10 - =942 6; 82A2534 6; 9 A2845;52= A63F 6; 415: 68=28 *( ' ##) & ( 5:4 6."< 6."