- 1 - ! " #$# ! %!&$"" & ! !"! # $%! " & ' % % ' % # $% ! %& ' ( ' %! ! % !()( ' ' ! " ! )() ' '' %)))%( ' ! ' ' *% !! Digitally signed by SREEDHARAN BANGALORE SUSHMA LAKSHMI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ *% !!& ! +,-. -/!0+1,2 32245/ 5+,-2+. 64327+5 84- 9+1/1/42+- ,2. :1! ,5, %031+ 5+,-2+. ../1/42,5 4;+-2:+21 .;46,1+84--+7942.+211,1+! ! 0+9+1/1/42+-<04/7,--,/=2+.,7,6637+.4!/2-/:+ 4!)) 48 10+ -+7942.+21 45/6+ $-/:+ 4!() /2 60,-=+ 70++1& /7 >+84-+ 10/7 43-1 7++?/2= -+=35,- >,/5 84- 10+ 488+26+7 932/70,>5+ 32.+- +61/427)))@%-<(4810+2./,2 +2,54.+ $84- 704-1 A B& 9+2./2= 42 10+8/5+ 48 10+ ../1/42,5 /71-/61,2.+77/4273.=+,1,;+-//2!4!()(! !'()*+,-,.)+*-) ! 1/710+6,7+4810+9-47+631/4210,110+.+6+,7+.,81+- 0,;/2=7+9,-,1+.8-4:0/7</8+<,771,C/2=/2,-+21+. 0437+ 48 !( 84- 10+ 9,71 14 ) C+,-7! + 0,. :,/21,/2+.1<41-,614-784-0/75/;+5/044.,2.,5740,;/2= 42+:414-6C65+84-0/72+6+77/1/+7!+0,.,994/21+.1<4 .-/;+-7 2,:+5C /-,2 <04 /7 ,6637+. 4! ,2. 3..,99, <04 /7 ,6637+. 4!! 6637+. 4! 0,. >4--4<+. 0,2. 54,2 84- , 73: 48 7!))))@ 8-4: 10+ .+6+,7+.!0+.+6+,7+.704?<,7/27/71/2=10+,6637+. - 3 - 4!14-+9,C10+7,/.,:43214-+57+/1</55>+.+.361+. /210+7,5,-C!0+,6637+.4!<,7320,99C,>43110+ 7,/..+;+549:+21,2.0+6421,61+.410+-1<4,6637+.14 +5/:/2,1+10+.+6+,7+.!664-./2=5C,6637+.47!,2. 144? ,-31/ </81 6,- ,2. <+21 /2 10+ 7,/. 6,- 2+,- 42.4D/ -477 ,2. <+-+ <,/1/2= 84- 10+ ,--/;,5 48 10+ .+6+,7+.! 6637+. 4! 144? 10+ .+6+,7+. 14 10+ 7,/. 95,6+4210+9-+1+E148704</2=10+5,2.84-10+93-947+ 48 93-60,7+ 10+-+ ,55 10+ ,6637+. 0,;+ 64::/11+. :3-.+- 48 10+ .+6+,7+.! 0+-+,81+- ,55 10+ ,6637+. /2 4-.+-14.+71-4C10++;/.+26+10-+<10+.+,.>4.C/214 10+9/1,2.>3-/+.10+7,:+! (! 0+ 64:95,/2,21 >+/2= , 71-,2=+- 0,. 7++2 10+ .+,. >4.C <0+2 0+ <,7 =4/2= 10-43=0 10+ 7,/. 84-+71 ,2. /284-:+. 10+ 945/6+ /2 10,1 -+=,-.! %,7+. 42 10+ 7,/. 64:95,/2110+D3-/7./61/42,5945/6+0,;+-+=/71+-+.,6,7+ ,=,/271 32?24<2 9+-7427 ,2. 10+-+,81+- .3-/2= /2;+71/=,1/4210+C8432.10,110+,6637+.0,.64::/11+. 10+ :3-.+- 48 10+ .+6+,7+. ,2. 5,/. 10+ 60,-=+ 70++1 ,=,/27110+,6637+.! - 4 - ! 1 /7 10+ 73>:/77/42 48 10+ 5+,-2+. 64327+5 84- 10+ 9+1/1/42+- 10,1 10+ +21/-+ 6,7+ /7 >,7+. 42 10+ 6/-63:71,21/,5 +;/.+26+! 0+ 9+1/1/42+- ,2. ,2410+- ,6637+. >410 <+-+ <4-?/2= ,7 .-/;+-7 14 10+ 1-,614-7 4<2+.>C10+.+6+,7+.04<+;+-10+C0,;+>++28,57+5C /:95/6,1+./210+6,7++;+21043=010+C<+-+241-+5,1+. 1410+6,7+! F! 1 /7 83-10+- 73>:/11+. 10,1 10+ 9+1/1/42+- /7 ,--,C+. ,7 ,6637+.4!,2.0+<,7,--+71+.42G!)!)!0+ -+7942.+21 945/6+ 0,;+ :,.+ , 8,57+ ,55+=,1/42 ,=,/271 10+9+1/1/42+-!0+9+1/1/42+-/7,=+.,>431C+,-7,2. 0+<,7<4-?/2=,7,6445/+!80+/7/2D3./6/,563714.C84- , 542=+- 9+-/4. 0/7 8,:/5C :+:>+-7 <435. 7388+- 0,-.70/9 10+-+84-+ 0+ :,C >+ +25,-=+. 42 >,/5 >C /:947/2= 73/1,>5+ 642./1/427! ,?/2= 7360 73>:/77/427 10+5+,-2+.64327+584-10+9+1/1/42+-9-,C714,554<10+ 9+1/1/42! G! +- 6421-, 10+ 5+,-2+. 84- 10+ -+7942.+21@ 1,1+ ;+0+:+215C49947+.10+7,/.9+1/1/42,2.73>:/11+.10,1 10+ 8,61 /7 10,1 ,6637+. 47! ,2. <+-+ <4-?/2= ,7 .-/;+-7 14 10+ 1-,614-7 4<2+. >C 10+ .+6+,7+.! 3-/2= - 5 - /2;+71/=,1/42/1-+;+,5+.10,1,6637+.4!0,.>4--4<+. 7!))))@ ,7 , 0,2. 54,2 ,2. 10,1 /7 10+ -+,742 84- 64::/11/2=10+:3-.+-4810+.+6+,7+.! ! 1/783-10+-73>:/11+.10,110+,;+-:+2174810+60,-=+ 70++1 <435. 65+,-5C /2./6,1+ 10,1 ,6637+. 4! /2.36+. 10+ .+6+,7+. ,2. 144? 0/: 14 10+ 95,6+ <0+-+ ,6637+. 47! ,2. <+-+ <,/1/2= 84- ,--/;,5 48 10+ .+6+,7+.! 0+-+84-+ 10+ 9-/:, 8,6/+ 6,7+ 0,7 >++2 +71,>5/70+. ,=,/271 10+ 9+1/1/42+-! +26+ 0+ /7 241 +21/15+. 84- ,2C -+5/+8 ,7 9-,C+. 84-! ,?/2= 7360 73>:/77/427 10+ 5+,-2+.9-,C714./7:/7710+9+1/1/42! ! 81+-0,;/2=0+,-.10+5+,-2+.64327+584-10+-+79+61/;+ 9,-1/+7 ,2. ,574 9+-37+. 10+ ,;+-:+217 48 10+ 60,-=+ 70++1 /1 <435. /2./6,1+ 10,1 10+ ,6637+. 4! <,7 <4-?/2= ,7 .-/;+- 48 42+ 48 10+ 1-,614-7 4<2+. >C 10+ .+6+,7+.! )! 0++21/-+6,7+/7>,7+.4210+6/-63:71,21/,5+;/.+26+! 0+6,7+0,7>++2-+=/71+-+.,=,/271 32?24<29+-7427! 3>7+H3+215C .3-/2= /2;+71/=,1/42 10+ /2;45;+:+21 48 10+,6637+./784-1064:/2=/210+60,-=+70++1!,;/2= 6427/.+-+. 10,1 10+ 6,7+ /7 >,7+. 42 10+ 6/-63:71,21/,5 - 6 - +;/.+26+/1/7,99-49-/,1+14=-,210/:>,/5>C/:947/2= 73/1,>5+642./1/427! ! +26+9-46++.149,7710+84554</2= $/& 0+-/:/2,5 +1/1/42/7 $//& 0+9+1/1/42+-/74-.+-+.14>++25,-=+.42>,/5/2-/:+ 4!()4810+-+7942.+21 45/6+1,1/4242+E+631/2=, 9+-742,5 >42. 84- , 73: 48 7!)))))@ $39++7 2+ 5,?0 425C&</1042+73-+1C84-10+5/?+73:1410+7,1/78,61/424810+ -/,543-173>D+611410+84554</2=642./1/427 ,& 0+9+1/1/42+-70,55,99+,->+84-+10+-/,543-1 42,550+,-/2=.,1+7</104318,/5! >& 0+9+1/1/42+-70,552415+,;+10+D3-/7./61/4248 10+43-11/5510+./7947,54810+6,7+! 26,7+/810+9+1/1/42+-;/45,1+7,2C4810+>,/5642./1/427 /:947+.>C10/743-15/>+-1C/7-+7+-;+.1410+9-47+631/4214 8/5+2+6+77,-C,995/6,1/4284-6,26+55,1/4248>,/5! "/0 1" 2 $ 2/714!54!(