Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 69474 (PNJ)
MOHAN SINGH AND ANR v. STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS
CWP/4504/2015 · 2025-02-05
Sureshwar Thakur, Vikas Suri
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 69474 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 69474 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!" #$% &' ' () #* +,,#$ % - .( / 0
% 12 ' 3 33 4 12 ' 3 543 3
!" # $%&#' (&)* +%(&( &) $& &) %, & &) +%(&#'* -%(-%&#'& # (&#' &#'. $ 666 33 40 '
" % *). /% ..'&,'0'#()%&12"313"4& 15"313"6 78% !" !69& .' *. ,'0 '#()%%'6:.;'/%'&"2<6 7..='."2<6>9 3
3 1 #0% 0.% %.'14"1133?%'6.'."2<6&. ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
'/%.(0% 152'"+("0(.#(( +(& &(@* &( '0,(&. %. *$&&!((&(& '0,( 4 - #*'00.;$&0,( '00. $& #0%'( 1<"1133:%':.'.) 156'6+(":0( (.#(( +(&&(@* &(& ' 0,( 6 #,),#'/%' &%0,. (*0,. #0.(. %'%#A(%&&( %,%( ''' ()& *,#(,('+.'/%(&%# %'% 0) , ( .0 '/% *,) #0%.'1?351332%'62. '."2<6&*%(*0.(0% 12'
"+("30(.#(( +(&(&(& ' 0,(;$&0,(&%'*"?""1332& *,) ,'0 ..'#() ''(% (%' '/% ' &*,)8' /%((7%9& '*.*) .(& /%(((&%'#,)%,B'*&( ,'0%0,)'0%) ? #,)'/%.(&#%(* ' $% ,) *) . * ( '$%,)*).$C"<1<4.1332&(D #.)E+ (. ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
(*( *,%'.$C ('/%*((*,)$%#":"113"3 $C"362.1332(D + *(#. )E('
(#. ":"113"3%! !"
#$
$
% &'
$ (
)* % + $
#$
#$ +$
,% &
+
( #$ #$
& - :
#,)B% 0":"113"3,) $%$C"362.1332&0.$C"362. 1332&'E,(%0$%,)*)..( ; 15<25!<22.13""(D # #.)E& ,%;&,'00,)F,(%0$% #"2""13"? 5 .7%98'0,)$%& %$C!"362!1332*.'/%..'#''(%#)&& ;' ,'00&%%.(,) '.(!(&*.(,B'%'?!. ' . "2<6& & * ( '' 0 '00%&%,%'.&(%' '/%' &%,'0/%&&( )(,)*#!(%''/%' & %'# %,B'( ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
2 %%'#(,)#!!#'/% %)& ;$& 0,(& # ( 3"3:13"1 %,0 (.'/%.(*'*.0 .() '/%(#*"?""1332(* # %((*/%.8'% %,('%B'*((, '/%,(#*..$%$C
"362.1332''' < *#& $ # ( "13513"1 ( %,0(.'/%.(& ( (%.$%&*/%,'/%&) *.''%(& ,((( ( (.!%'+*..' ( (. $ (,('+ .%'%#&( ((((!(.)*'/%& ,)( (. $*%(,'0#() 0'
"3 G0)& 0.%#(
"43<13"1/% $!800.0( ( . #*& $ .(
#* (' ":"113"3&*'*(( $%&&&$* ( .'/%.(*#&00&$%# 31""13"1& 0
#* (' %(()& 0.%#(133113"4&' /%$!800#*. ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
7%9.$%
#*('%%&
$#(3<3<13"4.0$ '(( ":"113"3/%*&*& .'14"1133?1<"1133:&/%& ,%(,)*)#'/% %)!'/%(& (/%0( (%' ..'/% ' ,8&(*'*'#* 7%9*0.(,)7%9# '/% %)&%*/%,!'/%&,)&) *%(.'(%,('%&(13513"1
"" *,'+ %..' ,'0%'0(').%'%.'( #0B'&.*''/%' * )133? "1 - #* ,#& #0 % .'12"313"4%'6.'."2<6&%. '/% (0% 643<'.#(( & +%(&(& @* G&(G& '0,(&'. . #(0 .
%( * $& %( $0(8 * (( ,' 0 '(% % & '00'(& '('(G& '0,(.'* %,(..'( A. #0#.' 41?13"4!6"2" 12"313"4 ( *() * 0()=0.>7 (931""13"4=0HB(> 7931""13"4 ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
"4 %%.'.'/%. (0% %,('..'%'6. '."2<6&%0,.(*.(,B'%'?!. '."2<6;'/%$(('',B' %,0'00 #0- #* '00.;$'00. $&% ,B'&,'0.(%'?!&% #0 ''%*'0000+ . '(%':.'."2<6
"6 0+ .'&/% * # (#.0'/%&()'%'%'%&.'%(, ''00B%*#(0(&*((, #.%% .#%#' ..%'% #(0(
"? B% 03?3<13"5&$%. *&( *,%'.'&0', $C! "?"4!13"?*.((* ,# ,%
(
& & #$
$ . #$
#$
+
'
/
+ $
#$ #$ +
& (
0
$
$
/ - ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
": ,'0'(( ,) $,. 8$%% .( ;7$9611<.13"<&*'$#( (4<"4.1316&*%,/%() % 015311316&%8$%&0( $%.!'&079
(# *. ,'08'. 1
2
%
$ $
) +$
)! 3 +
+
&0
,
$
$
+
%
& &
%
"
4
/0
$ $&#$
% +
+ %
$
#$
,
$
+0
%$ +
+
+
$
#$
&
+
& 3
/
-
"5 .(.''& .%, #(..'7$#(9!'%0!;'/%$(('& 0,(7;$&0,(9.(B,B'.( .('0-""1:173!":9.#(( +(& %&,B''%'(%&# %,B'))13"1.((*( '00'('(%;$&0,(&',B'.(,) '00(('0-
""1:173!":9&''%.8 (%. )%(.%'% #(0 $;07 $9&0(0 ').B'& ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
'00 ,B' ( % * .0 . ( /%.430* $&.&'00 '/%(.,B'&,%%,B''* *%(,(((A.'%'%&,% ,)&* '0&'0,& )(**%(,'0(%'%* #0&.' '00.;$&0,(& '00. $&%''/%(. 0*'(%':'( 15"313"6
"2 - #*'00.;'/% $(('&0,('00. $& #0 '.)('' ()&'(%':. '."2<6&*%,) #0#.' 15"313"6&% .) 4<<5'(.#(( & +(& (&@* G&(G& '0,( #.'."2<6&0*%,(..'( A . #0 # .' 41?13"4!6"G" 15"313"6(*()*0()&=8> 7 (943"313"6=%B,->7943"313"6 #.'."2<6&%'5.' ."2<6*%":3413"? "< *.'/%(( *(. *%'1""313":&%'0 0%
1&31&546!,'00/%. "/%.1&'00%'0 ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
%0 . 1&31&546! ,'0 0 7%9 0 '00%*%()0.%'0 .*.%,'0$%&"53?13"2%& (,)'#0 3.-7,,#$ #* )8 9),),#$ 13 79%,0&'. #0 '/% 4<<5'.(%.643<'.(& ,)( 4"1'(&*(% .'%': .'."2<6&%'((),(&"4 '*''&,%*%' .; '/%$(('&*%'00(.(& 8' E(&*,)B',B'. (!('' 1" .%%,0"4.(( '/% (( % 0 '/% %, (;'/%$(('F 78%!49*,);$'00.( .%,B' 11 .%%,0(%. *.((*((#(('(%/%*((,' 0.(.#!!#7 *)9&('')&* &* %()#,)%,('*+(0'&,) ',%.0(0 ,.
E%%,# %,('% ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
14 ,B'.#,',) ;'/%$(('&&(# .,'0 8'. /
+ %
+
+
$
$$
%
$ $. 1
&
#$
$ $$
+ 5
+
&
+0
+
& + $
$$
+
+
&
+ $&+
%
& +
"
$
+ $&*
& +
6
.. 4. 3 &
7
8$0 &$
"
" $
&$
$
6
. 4. 82
*4"
&$ &
(
8
(
9"
/ &
+
$&*
&"
$
&$ &
(
70 6 44.. :
/ 1" $
6 44..4. 3
&
(
;
;+
&$
%
)" / $
&
;+
% &
(+
<$
&$
%
+ $. 1
&
+
6
44..4. ). %
/ (
;
;+
&
$ %
&0
(+
;+
<$
$
%
&
$
2 %
(
+
==
5 &
:'
6$+
>
;
$
&$
) &0
6
.. 3
"
&$
$
&$
)
&0 6
..1
9"
? +
=)=
5
$ &$
)
&0
+
+
6
!.. &
(
8
8
7 2 %
<
&$
ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
$
&$
9
6
!!1. 2 &
&
+ +
$
$&+
&
+
< %
$ +
$ &%
$
#$
$$
$ (
8
(
6
.. 4. 82 *4"
$ &
& +
+ 5
$
*% & +
+
$ ++
+
#$
+
$&' +
$ &
+
$
% 1
9
9
? 9"
( $
&
(
8+ (
% +
$
*$ +
0
9
,
, (*(&
"
&
$ $
/
$
$ $
.&
%
/$
$
&
& @%+
$
$ A% $ - 16 , .&E'(0 . %,B' %'% , ( .0 '/% %,((.((* 1? %,B'(,'0(()%,B'(%' .
'/% ' & % '#() % .' '#() % ' 6 : . ' . "2<6& .'79 *.,'0'#()%14"1133?1<"1133: 1: .','0%'(( % (!(''&.( *,.$% (!((.(*, $C!"<1<4!1332&(& ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
D !"#$"%!"&E&,. $%'0!8'. !"
#$
$
% &'
$ (
)* % + $
#$
#$ +$
,% &
+
( #$ #$
& - 15 ,# 0' *.(,) '/%''(%#)&'(( 0,.8$%0%%''.%(&;& ,'0' ,'00,)E,(8$% #"2""13"? 12 .& %( *' 0 .0 ''(%# , & & * 79 ''& ,'0 ((*& ,% (. * * #!!# & * .( ,B' * '' '0.'/%( 1< % (,) ( ,'0 * % '/% %))'/%%,B'(&./%./%%,(' %.&('=,% &
+ (
#$ #$
& -
*' ''%7%98'#.B% 0,) $%.*&, 8& ,))% 7%9('*'''%,# 8'#&)'(!*.0 & %,/%()'/% %),.0!(%' ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
'/%' $()&..'.('&,% &(,),'0#!(%''/%' '.((%,B'(&*'*'#,#* &%'#..''(( .0.(! ( * ((*& ,% %,B' (!( %''.%(() .( ,B'('# '0&,'0.. 0 43 ''(%&.0&&,*0. ) #!!#).%''.%(''& ,.7%98'&.0! * !(%' '/%' &%'. ' . (& *' ,'0 '# * 0, . 7%9 ''(%#'$/%()&,.'& ('%(.''*#( %A,*%'/% %)!(%''/% ' '.%,B'%'% 4" 8.'%* , $C!"?"4!13"?&,.$%&&* .8'&%,'0 ,%
(
& & #$
$ . #$
#$
+
'
/
+ $
#$ #$ +
& (
0
$
$
ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
/ - 41 7%9,'0'(( ,) $% ( % ;7$9 611< . 13"<& *' $#( ( 4<"4 . 1316 * %,/%() % . 15311316&0,)8$%&(*0 $%(# ..0&0,)8 $%&% 8',#&,%!8'. 1
2
%
$ $
) +$
)! 3 +
+
&0
,
$
$
+
%
& &
%
"
4
/0
$ $&#$
% +
+ %
$
#$
,
$
+0
%$ +
+
+
$
#$
&
+
& 3
/
- 44 *''/%' ,'0(%' % %'..'%'6.'."2<6& 12"313"4.','0%'',)'(0 15"313"6&%':.'."2<6&*.%,B' *,'0%'1""313":&*&'00% '#() '0 %0 . 1&31&546! %0 . 1&31&546!,'0'#()#!!#, 46 *&$%/%,0 #(). 0+ .*0.
"1&' ,)8$%;7$9611<.13"<&*'$#( ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
(4<"4.1316*%,/%() &8 *,)0.'00%&() 00.#',)8$%&=$"% !'&"(!#"&"''")*(+,-"+".!/!"& &)+0/ "1(! "&2--
(-&) # % 9 '.0+ .'( %':.'."2<6&% $0 ') ; '/%& ,(
(0'&13"47.. ='.13"4>9'0.' ,9 C ,) # . %, ' ". '16.'.13"4(',( '9 C.#,'.13"4 (',((',( 9 C,))0,(),'0* ; '/% $((' ''& '%& ' %'."2<6%'* 0.%,'".'16.'.13"4 4? . #()#(,( . ,#8' ?&,'0,.0& 0,)E,(8$%&*,)&%E,(8 $%$%.0!80 !#(% ''.(',().B% 0,)8$% =$"%!'&"(!#"&"''")*(+,-"+" .!/!"&&)+0/ "1(! "&2--
(- ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
&%#!!#%,B'0&,( 7%9 %0
%(()&,) %0( ('.#0,%,'".'16. '.13"4,);'/%$(('&0+ %,B' *&,%,'00 ( 4: $/%()& $% /% , 80 ''*.B'.E,B' 45 (()% (;'/%$(('. ' ,B'.(,.0&%'?.'. "2<6&0(.(/% *' *',' ()%(!'%0!0'&%.''00 %,B'
42 *#& '00& 0 ,) ;
'/%$(('.( (/%,'0B',) '0%)% 0+ .0% B' .&B'.'00.$((' *,).( .%,B' (!(&0&.()%(' &,) %,B'',''00&%,%'/%00*& ,'0 %,%0 ( .#%,( &,'0(0,);'/%$((' 4< 0 ,) '0 %) *,) ''%'*0*(.;'/%$(('& *' * .#%,( & #()& .().%*0++ ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
I79%,B' ('0.()%(! '%0!0'(&%. .#(0.%( *$& %($0(8*((,'0 '(% % &'00'(&'('(G& ' 0,(I,9%.,%.0 .(/%. 430* 63 $/%()& 0 ,) '0 %)&*((.0&%,+%()%(& ,'0,) $((.0'' %(()&$%/%,/%,80 ''.()%(&$%/%&8' .B%'(#*.B' &8# 8(),) $((. 0''& .()%(&*& ,'0%' ').%,B' %,B''/%&) /%,%,# 0%,('% 6" .&0#&% %,B'%'% #(&% ,'0%. * & ,%*),'0&.$%
":"113"3&*,)(,),'0# '/% %)!'/%%,B'(&./%.%,# %,('% 61 .&(.#%,(&0 ,);'/%$(('&*%(0()(+* ()%(*'*'%(& #(, ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
8& ,) B' . ( ,) '0 %),''(%,*((0B' 64 '&().7%9&%() 0B'&*'()%').%,B' '%'&%0()/% )%,# /% %,('%.&.$%)'',B'7%9& .(,)&,)(#%,('%&% *%( ,'0 () BA& , ,) %,(' ,%#%('.*%(,'0 %,()%,# 66 %(()& $% ( 0 .& & .%,B'(, (.0'/%& '0 6? *#& ' . , ' . ,(0.(#(')
33 4
''
543 3 )8:8
8)8 9(;,$<= (#$"% =# 8)8 9# )(-:% =# ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment