Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 6899 (KAR)
MS KOUSALYA D/O LATE DIVOJIGOUDA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/102635/2024 · 2025-01-24
S Rachaiah
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 6899 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 6899 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"
$ %#!! %
!" #"
" $% & " '
"
&%' %%
(!! "
"
"
!" #"
" $
%
& "
)
"
'
%
" *+&'
"%"" +, &
" *&' !'
%
"
" "!*&
"!* %
'
%
"!*!*!-
"*%"
Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
. "
"
&%
. "
"'
" /01213"040501067/018/29:;84/7<:1=/>3>3:8/1082 ?>" 070 @;>/ 7/018/2 223>3:807 :5/18?/8> 25:90>/ <:1 >@/ 1/4=:82/8> :" ( >0>/ 082 1308;?0/22A7/018/29:;84/7<:11/4=:82/8>:""
" @34=/>3>3:834<37/2BA>@/=/>3>3:8/1C@:34>@/20;D@>/1 :< >@/ 2/9/04/2 9:?=703808> 4//E38D <:1 9089/770>3:8 :< B037D108>/238<05:;1:<1/4=:82/8>:"099;4/2:" 3813?/:"!*:<:E0=:739/4>0>3:8"
&'()*+,+-(*),()&(
" > 34 >@/ 904/ :< >@/ =1:4/9;>3:8 >@0> >@/ 2/9/04/2 9:?=703808> @02 1/F;/4>/2 >@/ :8>109>:1 >: 384>077 9:891/>/ 1:02 >: >@/ 1:02 C@39@ C04 B/38D ;4/2 BA >@/ =;B739"@/:8>109>:104E/2@3?>:1/?:5/>@/B:;72/1 4>:8/4 C@39@ C/1/ @/0=/2 ;= 38 <1:8> :< >@/ @:;4/ :< 1/4=:82/8> :"" @/ 2/9/04/2 9:?=703808> @02
- 3 -
1/F;/4>/2 1/4=:82/8> :" >: 1/?:5/ >@/ 4>:8/4 @:C/5/1 3> C04 8:> 1/?:5/2" 8 "!"!* 01:;82
"!! ="?" >@/ 9:?=703808> C04 D/>>38D >@/ 4>:8/4 1/?:5/2 <1:?
>@/ =709/ 38 :12/1 >: <09373>0>/ >@/ :8>109>:1 >: 70A >@/ 9:891/>/ 1:02" 8 >@/ ?/08>3?/ 1/4=:82/8> :" 082 @34 4:8 :B6/9>/2 >: >@/ 4032 C:1E 0824>01>/2F;011/738DC3>@>@/9:?=703808>"
*" > 34 4>0>/2 >@0> B:>@ 1/4=:82/8> :" 082 @34 4:8 @02 0440;7>/2 >@/ 2/9/04/2 9:?=703808> 082 90;4/2 386;13/4 >:@3?"??/230>/7A>@/9:?=703808>C044@3<>/2>:>@/ @:4=3>07<:1>1/0>?/8>"4>0>/?/8>C04?02/38>@/4032 @:4=3>07 B/<:1/ >@/ =:739/" @/ 6;134239>3:807 =:739/ 1/D34>/1/2 0 904/ 38 13?/ :"!* 0D0384> B:>@ =/14:84 <:1 >@/ :<</89/4 ;82/1 /9>3:84 * !* !- * :< >@/ 82308 %/807 :2/ &<:1 4@:1> G%H'" :C/5/1 :8 >@/ 2/0>@ :< >@/ 2/9/04/29:?=703808> /9>3:8!:<%@04B//8389:1=:10>/2"
" >34>@/4;B?3443:8:<7/018/29:;84/7<:1>@/=/>3>3:8/1 >@0> >@/ 1/4=:82/8> :" @04 9:??3>>/2 0 @/38:;4 :<</89/ >@:;D@ @/ 4/9;1/2 B037 :8 >@/ 4>1/8D>@ :< @34
- 4 -
:5/1>09>>@/B037C04B/38D?34;4/2BA@3?>@/1/<:1/ >@/ B037 D108>/2 >: >@/ 1/4=:82/8> :" @04 >: B/ 4/> 0432/"
-" >34<;1>@/14;B?3>>/2>@0>>@/1/4=:82/8>:"34>1A38D >:38>/1</1/C3>@>@/>1307082074:>1A38D>:38<7;/89/>@/ C3>8/44/4>:2/=:4/:8@34B/@07<"8:>@/1C:124@/34 >0?=/138D>@/=1:4/9;>3:8C3>8/44/4"
," >34<;1>@/14;B?3>>/2>@0>D108>38DB037384;9@0@/38:;4 :<</89/ C:;72 1/F;31/ >: B/ 05:32/2 04 >@/ :93/>A 34 C0>9@38D>@/=1:9//238D4:<>@/:;1>"8:>@/1C:1243> C:;72 8:> @05/ 0 D::2 3?=09> :8 >@/ :93/>A" 0E38D 4;9@4;B?3443:847/018/29:;84/7<:1>@/=/>3>3:8/1=10A4 >: 077:C >@/ =/>3>3:8 082 9089/7 >@/ B037 D108>/2 >: 1/4=:82/8>:""
" /018/2223>3:807 :5/18?/8> 25:90>/ <:1 1/4=:82/8> :" (>0>/02:=>/2>@/4;B?3443:84:<7/018/29:;84/7 <:1 =/>3>3:8/1 082 =10A4 >:077:C >@/ =/>3>3:8 082 9089/7 >@/B037D108>/2>:1/4=:82/8>:"" +"
7/018/2 9:;84/7 <:1 1/4=:82/8> :" 5/@/?/8>7A :==:4/2 4032 4;B?3443:84 082 @/ <;1>@/1
- 5 -
4;B?3>>/2 >@0> >@/ D108>38D :< B037 34 0B4:7;>/7A 0 23491/>3:801A =:C/1 :< >@/ :;1>" 89/ 4;9@ B037 34 D108>/23>9088:>B/9089/77/2;87/44>@/9:823>3:8401/ ?34;4/2"
!" > 34 <;1>@/1 4;B?3>>/2 >@0> ?/1/ ?0E38D 077/D0>3:8 :< >0?=/138D :1 @0?=/138D >@/ =1:9//238D4 :< >@/ :;1> >@0> ?0A 8:> B/ 0 D1:;82 >: 1/6/9> >@/ B037 D108>/2 BA >@34 :;1>" 8 <09> >@/ :5/1> 09> 0>>13B;>/2 0D0384> 1/4=:82/8> :" C:;72 382390>/ >@0> 1/4=:82/8> :" 34 /8>3>7/2<:1B037":1/:5/1@/34080D/2=/14:8082@/34 4;<</138D <1:? 0D/ :72 037?/8>4" @/1/<:1/ >@/ =/>3>3:8 <37/2 BA >@/ =/>3>3:8/1 @04 >: B/ 1/6/9>/2" 0E38D 4;9@ 4;B?3443:84 7/018/2 9:;84/7 <:1 1/4=:82/8> :" =10A4 >:1/6/9>>@/=/>3>3:8"
" 0538D 9:8432/1/2 >@/ 13507 4;B?3443:84 :< 7/018/2 9:;84/7 <:1 >@/ 1/4=/9>35/ =01>3/4 3> 34 1/7/508> >: 1/</1 >@/6;2D?/8>:<>@/:8.B7/;=1/?/:;1>38>@/904/:<
38 =010D10=@:4" !082 1/0204;82/1
1 (2024) 4 SCC 222
- 6 -
! " ## $ " %&" '" (&) *&" +
!"& , -$ - +#" ' ! *&" + ' & ' ## # $ *&" + " - #- '
(&--"-+" # ' ./0 (( ! '+ ! *&" + #"&" !- 1 2
!"&, ((##3/4/5$# 5406 75 " ( # 888$ 5.926 +#- (& - (& ' " : &" #! "!
5.9206 +#- (& " : #- ! "! &" ( #888 ' (" ! " " ++"&":#- ! " &" # ; : &"' '! $ ! ":$ $ 26 &" +& !: !:
"&
+ + :$ 26 ' - & ' $ 26 +# +# -
"
-$ 26
- "& + - -&" +# + $ 26<"'' &:$26 +#+ <+' !:
&" &"
!+ & ! :$
- 7 -
26 +# # +' !:" ' &:$ &" & " = & ! ! " &" #
/3206 '
"' & '
#&
+#
=:" : '"' &" !: ' ' 4$ #& + : < ! " &" ! &" ! &"
++"
4! ! '' " : +
"+++&": -$ 4+" $ -&" =# : &" "" 2 &! ', 6 >#'#-
(& &"
5.9206
! ""!:(&;& 2'6 / ;& (&
&: =# "
#
" '! &"("$ &" & "'' '+ (" ' (+ "&$ ?9? 2' 7 " ("@6 "&" "#' -4 A4 #- ' & " ! (& !" &"12((##0.405$# /6
- 8 -
B/ 5.9 ' - (" ' # #-
(&(&' " ! - #&" 59?(('"(" :$ ' '& ! &" #$
(&(&'+ :" ' ' ! ### + :$ &" 5.9206 ' -("$ (&(& ' + : " : # - ! "! ! "
" ++" &": " ("$ 59?206 - -"" +- "'' & -
" (& (& ' + : & :#- ! "+"! &"&!4 26! " "+ :+++ &": -"$ &" 59?206 ' " ("$ # - " ! "+" ! !: (& &" ! ++" &": : !: (& + :$ ' # - "+" ! !: (& ' $ - : (&' &"++ + &": &# #- ' + ' ## ' ++ #$
- 9 -
": "+" ! $ &":$ '" - (" &" 5.9206 " 5.9206 ' - (" (& + : ++ # " !
&" ( # 888!: :&&" (& ' &":$ ' < ### "+&$-$ ! + " (& ' ! - ": ! " !: (& & - &+ "& # ' ' &" # ! "+"! !:
(& '$ -$ (& '
"
"+"
&" # ! $ - # + : + %&" ' -&+ - - <-
" :$'$ (& + : - ## (& ! &# & &" 5.9206 ++ &" &": $ -$ "!:
" ' %&" ! " -&+ ##" &# =#
":="$'&' +%&" "
- 10 -
+# - +
(& ' ' ! # '- '+ &!" # ' (& ' 4A4
(&C 3 =$ #' ! " &# " ' (&& +! " $ (& " 2(( # .5>$ # 6 # ' " &*&'"$
#
"
!&:
"'' '+ " ' ! &"
&"
+"&" +' ! & ' + &# &+ - &
" D
+ ' ;&* $4%&" ,'(&
" ' " ## " '&" -"!-- # ' ' ! - ## $ (& "
"! " ## = ' #- &" 5.9206 ' (" ## $- ""!' (& (& " " !: ## " !- # +' '! " ' ! , - ''+ ## " "- & !" - + ! < " !: &
- 11 -
" ' ! $ + + <
""& ! "&!*&: !: ## & " - -&"&"./0'(" $ (& #" '
" ' ' ! #$ + ! & : !: &# & " ' + ' - !: +& ? ! ' " ##$(&" * 'E * ' $ !" 1 2(( # ?F/$# 96 B9G "!-
# '
"
&*&'"$ #" " ' " ' ! &"
&"
+"&" +'
&# &+ - & '" ! # # " + $ ! &" !: &#&C 9'$#' " &*&'"$ # "
"'''+#' ' !
&"' &")+"& - " ' &' " ' ' ! - H& &
- 12 -
" #& ' ' " " -&" # !' & " ! : ! " &"'! : -!: &&#&- " ! "!: +& 0F $ #"
" '" + + & # !' (& < ' ! &" ! - ! " !: # !: +# ' ' $ + " & " "& ' &" &$ # " :' ' ! " H&" ! " ! " &" ' ! # - & "+ -&" &
' ! &+ !& " "" ' : & - ! - +&"!: #4 &"'$ (& &" " " #
" "! &"'! # - 0 #" ## ' - - + ! ' : "#" ' !: &$&$ !'
" &:#$'&&'' " ' # : ' ' + & " & #&
"' ' "# ! "
- 13 -
+"'" = " - *&" + " " ! !-"!:&# & *&" + " " ! ' : =# # (" ' + ./0'("# ! : -' "#" '!:& & =#
" &: ! ' + !:&@ I - - " !: ' *&" +
"" !: (& " ' ' ! " ' :
"'' , " &" : ! " ' (& '" ' ! "! 1 2 6 &" +&" !:
"+J 2!6'&""'! "J 26 ! - " ' &: # #- ' (& ! J 2"6 ! - #&" !: +# ' &" # $ ' & ="@
" 0538D 9:8432/1/2 >@/ 239>;?
:< >@/ :8.B7/ ;=1/?/ :;1> 3> 34 >: B/ 8:>/2 @/1/ >@0> B037 D108>/2 >: >@/ 099;4/2908:87AB/9089/77/23<>@/:;1>3440>34<3/2>@0>
- 14 -
0<>/1B/38D1/7/04/2:8B037>@/099;4/2@04?34;4/2>@/ 73B/1>AD108>/2>:@3?:1<7:;>/2>@/9:823>3:84:<>@/B037 :12/1 :1 B037 C04 D108>/2 38 3D8:1089/ :< >@/ 4>0>;>:1A =1:5343:841/4>139>38D>@/=:C/14:<>@/:;1>>:D108>B037 :1>@/B037C04=1:9;1/2;82/1>@/?341/=1/4/8>0>3:8:1 <10;2"
" 0538D9:8432/1/2>@/=13893=7/470322:C8BA>@/:8.B7/ ;=1/?/ :;1> 4>0>/2 4;=10 8:C 3> 34 1/7/508> >: 9:8432/1>@/=1/4/8>=/>3>3:8"@/=1/4/8>=/>3>3:8>@:;D@ 3>34<37/2<:19089/770>3:8:<B037>@/D1:;824;1D/238>@34 =/>3>3:8C:;72382390>/>@0>>@/1/4=:82/8>:"34>1A38D >: >0?=/1 >@/ =1:4/9;>3:8 C3>8/44/4 082 074: >1A38D >:
@0?=/1 >@/ =1:9//238D4 :< >@/ :;1>" :C/5/1 8: 2:9;?/8>01A=1::<34=1:2;9/2>:4;B4>08>30>/>@/40?/" 8 >@/ 0B4/89/ :< 08A 9:D/8> 2:9;?/8>4 :1 /532/89/ 1/D01238D >0?=/138D :< >@/ =1:4/9;>3:8 C3>8/44/4 3> 34 8:>40</>:9089/7>@/B037D108>/2BA>@34:;1>/0173/1" *" 8>@/73D@>:<>@/:B4/150>3:84?02/0B:5/0?:<>@/ 9:8432/1/2 :=383:8 >@0> >@/ =/>3>3:8 2/4/15/4 >: B/ 1/6/9>/2"
- 15 -
" /89/=1:9//2>:=044>@/<:77:C38D
@/13?3807%/>3>3:834*"
!./
0! 1 #
44 34>:" +7:"