- 1 - ! "#"$ %#! !!!&& '( ) *+ !!!&& '( ) * + ! " " #$ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % & ' % $ ( % ) &* + , * &!,#"-$ (-"-( . % * + ( " ' "& - 3 - ## *$#--", " ' &- ) "&-,"-"$ " , (!! (-"-( &!,#"-$ - 4 - . % / / 0 # 123245678827937:2;<:2=42;7>7<?34412@A;>B2?4 7?; 757:; ;742; (-"-( <? 6&!,#"-$ 87332; CD 412 646: ==<;2?4 97<B3 :<CA?79 7?>796:2 *E6:316:4F412:<CA?79. " 6 ,-#"-"- <3 E<92; CD 412 6:86:74<6? =799<?> <? GA234<6? 412 GA7?4AB 6E =6B82?374<6? 6? 412 =6A?44174412824<4<6?573E<92;A?;2:2=4<6?# 6E412 646:21<=923=4(!!E6:316:4F=4.12 6 ("-"" <3 E<92; CD 412 =97<B7?43 322H<?> 2?17?=2B2?46E=6B82?374<6? 12:<CA?797E42:=6?3<;2:<?>4128927;<?>37?; ;6=AB2?43>:7?42;=6B82?374<6?6E3$-&$--*796?> - 5 - 5<41 <?42:234 74 412 :742 6E (I 82: 7??AB 12 =6B82?374<6?757:;2;<36?412=6A?441747B2?;B2?446 2=4<6? # 6E 412 =4 56A9; C2 :24:6382=4<J2 <? 2EE2=4 <? J<25 6E 7K2442 64<E<=74<6? ;742; ""-$"-! & 4 <3 3ACB<442; CD 412 927:?2; =6A?329 E6: 412 6:86:74<6?4174412:<CA?791732::2;<?975<?7889D<?> 7K244264<E<=74<6?7?;757:;<?>41296336E;282?;2?=D 743$-----*652J2:412=97<B7?437:22?4<492;E6: =6B82?374<6? A?;2: 412 =6?J2?4<6?79 127; 7 3AB 6E 3($--* <?3427; 6E 3&$--* ? J<25 6E 412 8:6J<3<6?3 8:<6:46 412 7B2?;B2?4412;282?;2?=D <3 46 C2 =79=A9742; 6? 412 <?=6B273 34742; <? 412 =12;A92* 2J2? <E 3&----* 82: 7??AB 51<=1 <3 412 =78 9<B<4 <3 47H2? <?46 =6?3<;2:74<6? 412 =6B82?374<6? 56A9; C2 9233 417?3$-----*73173C22?757:;2;CD412:<CA?79 $ 12:273 412 788279 <? 6 ("-"" <3 E<92;CD412=97<B7?436?412>:6A?;4174<?J<256E412975 97<;;65?CD4126?.C9282L6A:4<?412=7326E - 6 - ! "! 412 7B2?;B2?4<?2=4<6?# 6E=4CD57D6E7K2442 64<E<=74<6?;742;""-$"-!56A9;7889D:24:6382=4<J29D 1282L6A:451<92=6?3<;2:<?>412<33A2=6?E<:B2;412 6:;2: 6E 412 <>1 6A:4 7?; 129; 4174 412 7B2?;B2?4 C:6A>14 <3 7889<=7C92 :24:6382=4<J29D <2 2J2? 46 412 7==<;2?451<=11736==A::2;8:<6:46=6B<?><?46412E6:=2 6E 412 37<; 7B2?;B2?4 A:412: 6? 412 =6A?4 4174 412 7B6A?4757:;2;A?;2:412=6?J2?4<6?79127;316A9;17J2 C22? 3($--* <?3427; 6E 3&$--* 73 173 C22? 757:;2;CD412:<CA?79 # 27:; :< 7>7:7@7 927:?2; =6A?329 78827:<?> E6:412 7882997?4<? 6 ,-#"-"- E6: 412 6:86:74<6? 7?; :< 742231 927:?2; =6A?329 78827:<?> E6: 412 7882997?43 <? 6 ("-"" 2:A32;4122?4<:27882798782:3 1 2024 SCC OnLine SC 4983 - 7 - , 7J<?>127:;412927:?2;=6A?329E6:41287:4<23 7?;82:A32;412:2=6:; 412 6?9D GA234<6? 41747:<323 E6: =6?3<;2:74<6?6E41<36A:4<3/ 12412:412:<CA?79<3@A34<E<2;<?757:;<?>412 =6B82?374<6?M ! D7?352:4641286<?4<387:49D<?7EE<:B74<J2 4<3?6B6:2 <?J<256E97597<;;65?CD412 6?.C9282L6A:4<?412=7326E !"!3A8:7 1282L6A:41736C32:J2;41744127B2?;B2?4C:6A>14 46 2=4<6? # 6E 412 =4 CD 7K2442 64<E<=74<6? ;742;""-$"-!<3:24:6382=4<J2=6?E<:B3412@A;>B2?4 6E 412<>1 6A:4 ?J<256E 41237B2 41<3 6A:4E<?;3 4174412:<CA?79173?64=6BB<442;7?D2::6:<?7;684<?> 412 7K2442 64<E<=74<6? 7?; 757:;<?> =6B82?374<6? 6E 3$-----* A?;2: 412 127; F633 6E 282?;2?=D. 652J2:<?J<256E=12;A92* 412=6B82?374<6?A?;2: 412 =6?J2?4<6?79 127;3 56A9; C2 3($--* <?3427; 6E 3&$--* <2 3"---* 4657:;3 EA?2:79 2L82?323 3$---* 4657:;3 9633 6E =6?36:4<AB 7?; 3"$--* - 8 - 4657:;396336E234742 ?J<256E41297597<;;65?CD 412 6?.C92 82L 6A:4 ?641<?> B6:2 3A:J<J23 E6: 7;@A;<=74<6? 6? 412 @A;>B2?4 7?; 757:; 87332; CD 412 :<CA?79 ( 441<3347>2927:?2;=6A?32978827:<?>E6:412 6:86:74<6? <? 6 ,-#"-"- 3ACB<43 4174 412 <?42:234757:;2;CD412:<CA?79<374412:7426E(I82: 7??AB 5<416A4 412:2 C2<?> 7?D B742:<79 6? :2=6:; 7?; 36A>1446:2;A=2412<?42:23412:2<3?641<?>6?:2=6:; E6: 412 :<CA?79 46 757:; <?42:234 N (I 82: 7??AB 7?; 2J2? 412 :<CA?79 173 ?64 ><J2? 7?D J79<; :2736? E6: 757:;<?><?42:23474412:7426E(I82:7??AB ?J<256E 412 37B2 412 3ACB<33<6? 6E 412 927:?2; =6A?329 E6: 412 6:86:74<6? <3 7==2847C92 7?; 412 <?42:234 :2GA<:23 46 C2 :2;A=2;E:6B(I46#I - ?J<256E412:2736?334742; 41<36A:4 8:6=22;468733412E69965<?>/ - 9 - < 64141278827937:2!! #) << 12788279E<92;CD4126:86:74<6?<? 6 ,-#"-"- <3 !! # 412:2CD 6?9D:2;A=<?>412<?42:23486:4<6?E:6B(I 46#I6?412=6B82?374<6?757:;2;CD412 :<CA?79 <<< 12 788279 E<92; CD 412 =97<B7?43 <? 6 ("-"" <3 7936 !! # 412:2CD 2?17?=<?> 412 =6B82?374<6? 46 3$---*A?;2:412=6?J2?4<6?79127; <J ==6:;<?>9D 412 7882997?43 7:2 2?4<492;E6: 46479 =6B82?374<6? 6E 3$-($--* 73 7>7<?34 3$-&$--* 757:;2; CD 412 :<CA?79 7?; 2?17?=2; =6B82?374<6? 6E 3$---*=7::D<?42:23474412:7426E#I 82: 7??AB E:6B 412 ;742 6E 824<4<6? 4<99 :279<K74<6? J 12 7B6A?4 <? ;2863<4 B7;2 CD 412 7882997?4 O 6:86:74<6? <? 6 ,-#"-"- C2 4:7?3B<442; 46 412 =6?=2:?2;:<CA?79E6:;<3CA:32B2?4 - 10 - J< 12:2386?;2?4O6:86:74<6?31799;2863<4 412 C797?=2 =6B82?374<6? 7B6A?4 5<41 <?42:234 C2E6:2 412 =6?=2:?2; :<CA?79 5<41<?782:<6;6E3<L522H3E:6B412;742 6E:2=2<846E=68D6E41<36:;2: J<< 66:;2:7346=634 !,* ' ) # <346/96/# /