- 1 - ! !" " # $ %!! $ ! " # " ! " $%&" ' """ %('(&" " "" $) ($ ") ($" # " " * Digitally signed by SREEDHARAN BANGALORE SUSHMA LAKSHMI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * ! ' +,-. -/ ,0,1,-,2 ,34,5,3/ 6+,-7+. 89:70+6 ;9- 5+3/3/97+- ,7. <3 /-/2, /-+<,34 6+,-7+. /=4 9:-3 91+-7<+736+,.+-;9--+0597.+73>3,3+ 4+5+3/3/97+-?49/0,--,/=7+.,0,88:0+.9'/7-/<+ 9) ($ 9; 34+ -+0597.+73 > 96/8+ /0 @+;9-+ 34/0 9:-3 0++A/7= -+=:6,- @,/6 ;9- 34+ 9;;+78+0 5:7/04,@6+ :7.+- +83/97 %( '(& 9; 34+ 7./,7 +7,6 9.+ ;9- 049-3 BC! 5+7./7= 97 34+ ;/6+ 9; 34+ ../3/97,6 /03-/83 ,7. +00/970 :.=+ ,3 4,-?,. /7 9$) ($ &'()*+,+-(*),( % 4+ <934+- 9; 34+ 5+3/3/97+- 4,. 69.=+. , 89<56,/73 03,3/7= 34,3 04+ 4,. 5+-;9-<+. 34+ <,--/,=+ 9; 34+ 5+3/3/97+-?/3404?,-4+5+3/3/97+-03,D+.,697=?/34 4/< ;9- 97+ D+,- ,7. 34+-+,;3+- 04+ 399A ./19-8+ ,7. <,--/+. 97+ ,66,/,4 /-+<,34 4+ 89:56+ 4,. 3?/7 84/6.-+77+9;34+84/6.-+7@+8,<+4,7./8,55+.4+ 5+3/3/97+- 399A ./19-8+ ;-9< 4+- 0+897. 4:0@,7. ,7. - 3 - 03,-3+. 6/1/7= ?/34 34+ 89<56,/7,73 /7 4+- 49:0+ ,697= ?/3434+84/6.-+7 $ :-/7=4+-03,D/74+-49:0+34+5+3/3/97+-:0+.394,1+ ,7 /66/8/3 -+6,3/9704/5 ?/34 ,4:6 0 9 ,4+04 +-,.,6 +05/3+ /703-:83/970 @+/7= =/1+7 39 0395 ,66 /66/8/3 -+6,3/9704/5034+5+3/3/97+-4,.8973/7:+.34+0,<+3 /003,3+.34,334+,88:0+.9/70/03+.34+5+3/3/97+-39 6+,1+34+84/6.-+7,7.,889<5,7D4/<,7.,609,00:-+. 4+-34,34+?9:6.3,A+8,-+9;4+-7++.0 E :84 @+/7= 34+ ;,83 97 ()(($ ,-9:7. $(( 5< 34+5+3/3/97+-399A4+-84/6.-+73934+69;339=+334+<39 ;++. -9:7.(E(( 5< 34+ 89<56,/7,73 4,. @++739 34+3+<56+4+89<56,/7,73 4,.-+8+/1+.,5497+8,66 03,3/7=34,3,4,7,34+84/6.9;34+5+3/3/97+-;+66.9?7 ;-9<34+69;3,7.0:03,/7+./72:-/+04+?,0,0A+.39=9 3934+4905/3,64+89<56,/7,73?+733934+4905/3,6,7. 0,? 34,3 34+ 84/6. ?,0 .+,. 4+-+;9-+ 04+ 69.=+. , 89<56,/734+2:-/0./83/97,6596/8+,;3+-897.:83/7=34+ /71+03/=,3/970:@</33+.34+84,-=+04++3 3 /0 34+ 0:@</00/97 9; 34+ 6+,-7+. 89:70+6 ;9- 34+ 5+3/3/97+-34,334+,66+=,3/970<,.+/734+89<56,/73,-+ - 4 - @,0+6+00 ;9- 34+ -+,097 34,3 349:=4 34+ 84/6.-+7 ?+-+ @9-7 39 34+ 0+897. 4:0@,7. 9; 34+ 5+3/3/97+- 04+ 399A 34+84/6.-+7394+-8:039.D,7.8,<+9:39;34+49:0+9; 4+-4:0@,7.,;3+-9@3,/7/7=34+./19-8+,.04+4,.34+ /73+73/973903,D,697+?/344+-6:0304+?9:6.7934,1+ @-9:=4334+84/6.-+7,697=?/344+- F 3/0;:-34+-0:@</33+.34,3,034+84/6.4,.;,66+79734+ 89897:3 =-,3+- ,7. 0:03,/7+. /72:-/+0 /3 ?,0 3,A+7 39 4905/3,6 ;9- /<<+./,3+ 3-+,3<+73 49?+1+- .:+ 39 :7,19/.,@6+8/-8:<03,78+034+84/6../+.4+5+3/3/97+- @+/7= 34+ <934+- 9; 34+ 84/6. 4,0 793 89<</33+. 34+ <:-.+-9;34+84/6.9?+1+-34+89<56,/7,73@+/7=34+ <934+- 9; 34+ 5+3/3/97+- 97 ?-97= 793/97 69.=+. , 89<56,/73?4/84/0@,0+6+00,7.;,60+ ) 3/0;:-34+-0:@</33+.34,334+5+3/3/97+-@+/7=,?9<,7 04+4,0393,A+8,-+9;,7934+-84/6.,0,<934+-4+ ?9:6.,@/.+34+897./3/970/<590+.@D34/09:-3/734+ +1+73 9; 4+- -+6+,0+ 97 @,/6 ,1/7= 0,/. 34:0 6+,-7+. 89:70+6;9-5+3/3/97+-5-,D039,669?34+5+3/3/97 & 6+,-7+. /=4 9:-3 91+-7<+73 6+,.+- 1+4+<+736D95590+.34+@,/65+3/3/97@D03,3/7=34,334+ - 5 - 89<56,/7,73 /0 797+ 934+- 34,7 34+ <934+- 9; 34+ 5+3/3/97+- 4+ 4,0 7,--,3+. 34+ 84,-,83+- 9; 34+ 5+3/3/97+-4+5+3/3/97+-4,.6+;34+-3?94:0@,7.0,7. 04+ ?,0 03,D/7= ?/34 34+ 89<56,/7,73 ,7. 04+ ?,0 <,/73,/7/7= 34+ /66/8/3 -+6,3/9704/5 ?/34 ,88:0+. 9 /7 05/3+9;34+-+0/03,78+@D34+;,</6D<+<@+-0 '( 3/0;:-34+-0:@</33+.34,3,05+-34+,1+-<+7309;34+ 89<56,/73 ,88:0+. 9 /70/03+. 34+ 5+3/3/97+- 34,3 04+ 049:6. 6+,1+ 4+- 84/6.-+7 ,7. ,889<5,7D 4/< ?9:6. /7./8,3+ 34,3 04+ 4,. /73+73/97 39 A/66 34+ 84/6. ?49 /0 4,7./8,55+.7934+-84/6.?,05-+0+73,697=?/344+- 4,.?/37+00+.34+8-:+6,839;34+5+3/3/97+-4+-+;9-+ 34+5+3/3/97+-.+0+-1+0790D<5,34D<:846+0004+7++.0 39 @+ 5:7/04+. ,1/7= 0,/. 34:0 6+,-7+. /=4 9:-3 91+-7<+736+,.+-5-,D039./0</0034+5+3/3/97 '' ,1/7= 4+,-. 34+ 6+,-7+. 89:70+6 ;9- 34+ -+05+83/1+ 5,-3/+0 ,7. ,609 5+-:0+. 34+ ,1+-<+730 9; 34+ 84,-=+ 04++3/3,55+,-0;-9<34+-+89-.34,334+5+3/3/97+-?,0 3,A/7=8,-+9;34+84/6.?49/04,7./8,55+.,7.,60997 34,3 5,-3/8:6,- .,D 04+ 4,. /7;9-<+. 34+ 89<56,/7,73 34,3 /7 9-.+- 39 ;++. 34+ 84/6.-+7 04+ ?,0 3,A/7= 34+< - 6 - 3934+69;3,7.34+-+,;3+-9734+0,<+.,D,-9:7.F(( 5< 5+3/3/97+- 8,66+. 34+ 89<56,/7,73 34,3 34+ 4,7./8,55+. 84/6. ;+66 .9?7 97 34+ 89897:3 =-,3+- ,7. 0:03,/7+./72:-/+0,7.,0A+.34+89<56,/7,7339=93934+ 4905/3,6 ' 7 =9/7= 34-9:=4 34+ ;,830 ,7. 8/-8:<03,78+0 9; 34+ 8,0+/3/086+,-34,334+5+3/3/97+-/<<+./,3+6D04/;3+.34+ 84/6. 39 34+ 4905/3,6 ;9- 3-+,3<+73 ?9:6. /7./8,3+ 34,3 <,.+9:3,8,0+39=-,73@,/6 '% 889-./7=6D5-98++.395,0034+;9669?/7=# /! 4+-/</7,6+3/3/97/0 //! 4+5+3/3/97+-/09-.+-+.39@++76,-=+.97@,/6/7-/<+ 9) ($9;34+-+0597.+73>96/8+3,3/9797+G+8:3/7=, 5+-097,6 @97. ;9- , 0:< 9; 0'((((( # :5++0 7+ 6,A4 976D!?/3497+0:-+3D;9-34+6/A+0:<3934+0,3/0;,83/979;34+ -/,69:-30:@2+833934+;9669?/7=897./3/970 ,! 4+5+3/3/97+-04,667931/0/334+49:0+9;4+- +03-,7=+. 4:0@,7. > ,66,/,4 /-+<,34 ,7. ,60934+89<56,/7,733/66./0590,69;34+8,0+ - 7 - @! 4+ 5+3/3/97+- 04,66 793 34-+,3+7 34+ 5-90+8:3/97 ?/37+00+0 ,7. ,609 793 4,<5+- 34+5-98++./7=09;34+89:-3 78,0+/;34+5+3/3/97+-1/96,3+0,7D9;34+@,/6897./3/970 /<590+.@D34/09:-36/@+-3D/0-+0+-1+.3934+5-90+8:3/9739 ;/6+7+8+00,-D,556/8,3/97;9-8,78+66,3/979;@,/6 !./ 0! 1 % 00 /039'&69$