Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 67974 (KAR)
SRI B.J. JAGADISH v. THE CHIEF SECRETARY
WP/19589/2015 · 2025-10-30
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 67974 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 67974 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
$%&!&
'( ) ** '!( * '!(
* '!(
)
! ! "! "
# $ $
! % &
'
(
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
# '
# '
'
'
)
! %
&
"
'
'
# )(
" #
! # # *
)
#
) ' +
'
**)
'
)
- 3 -
'
"
'
)
)
"
" )'
#
"
!, '
,
"
!)! "
) '
) $$
! ! ! '
'
- 4 -
,)
'
''
!! ! ,
"'
"
'
'
! &+(
! "
)
' )
'
,
- 5 -
)),! '"
"
,
! "
# - . $$
! &
'
(
# '
# '
'
#
#
- 6 -
'
)
'
"
! '
'
,
"
'
&
"
'
'
# /
'
#
/
'
#
,(
- 7 -
" #
! # # *
)
) ' +#
#
'
*
)
'"
"
"
,
' &(
! '
'
+
" ,
'
"
!'
)
&
'
(
- 8 -
# '
# '
'
#
#
'
)
'
"
! '
'
- 9 -
,
"
'
&
"
'
'
# /
'
# /
'
#
,/ '
(
" #
! # # *
)
) ' +#
# 0
'
*
)
)
)
! 1
- 10 -
"
)
#
)
)
&
( , ,
)
'
'
"
"
&
'
(
# '
# '
'
#
#
- 11 -
'
)
'
"
! '
'
,
"
'
&
"
'
'
# /
'
# /
- 12 -
'
,(
" #
! # # *
)
) ' +#
#
'
# 00
"
1 1
0
"2 , 345367847793:;52<=><3?3:
?@7 :=?A<7 25 B7<?32<=<3 ?2 CA=4@ =: 3DEA;:78 :2?3B7 344A78 FG <74E2:87:? 2)@=4368=< F7=<3:; 2# 8=?78)
"2 !! 34 53678 52< = ><3? 3: ?@7 :=?A<725B7<?32<=<3?2CA=4@=:3DEA;:782<87<E=4478FG
- 13 -
<74E2:87:? 27DF7< 7B<7?=<G :79=6 6=::3:;
A?@2<3?G F7=<3:; 2 ) 8=?78 )
"2!) 34 53678 52< = ><3? 3: ?@7 :=?A<725B7<?32<=<3?2CA=4@=:3DEA;:782<87<E=4478FG <74E2:87:?
27DF7<7B<7?=<G :79=6 6=::3:; A?@2<3?G 3: 2 ) 8=?78 ) )
"2!), 34 53678 52< = ><3? 3: ?@7 :=?A<725B7<?32<=<3?2CA=4@=:3DEA;:782<87<E=4478FG <74E2:87:? 27DF7<7B<7?=<G :79=6 6=::3:; A?@2<3?G 3: 2 ) 8=?78 )
@7E7?3?32:7<3:"2 , B6=3D4?2 @=H7EA<B@=478=43?7F7=<3:;2)3:=6=G2A?=EE<2H78 FG ?@7 :79=6 6=::3:; A?@2<3?G 3: G 24) ) ))!),) ) )) , , , ) =:8
- 14 -
43?A=?78=?@=:8=EA<='366=;7??3F7672F63 :79=6=6A97:;=6A<A<F=:
34?<3B? @7E7?3?32:7<4 3: "2 !! =<7 =642 EA<B@=47<42543?74F7=<3:;24! , )"74?7<:E2<?32:2543?72 ,),)3:?@7 =52<74=38 6=G2A? 74E2:87:? 2 @=8 B=:B76678 ?@7 6=G2A? E6=: 3: 7I7<B347 25 E2>7< A:87< 7B?32: !&
( 25 ?@7 =<:=?=9= 2>: =:8 2A:?<G 6=::3:; B? 3:
H37> 25 ?@7 2<87< E=4478 FG <74E2:87:? 2) A:87< 7B?32:4!=:8!25?@7=<:=?=9==:8752<D4B? 3: <74E7B? 25 G2 =:8 ) 25 @=:8=EA<= '366=;7 ? 34 ?@34 B=:B766=?32: >@3B@ 34 B@=667:;78 3: ?@34 ><3?E7?3?32:
! @7E7?3?32:7<43:"2!) B6=3D?2 @=H7 EA<B@=478 43?7 24 ) =:8 , 3: ?@7 =52<74=38 6=G2A? 74E2:87:? 2 @=8 B=:B76678 ?@7 6=G2A? E6=: 3: 7I7<B347 25 E2>7< A:87< 7B?32: !&
( 25 =<:=?=9=2>:=:82A:?<G6=::3:;B?3:H37>25?@7 2<87<E=4478FG<74E2:87:?2)A:87<7B?32:4!=:8
- 15 -
!25?@7=<:=?=9==:8752<D4B?3:<74E7B?25 G24 =:8 ) 25 @=:8=EA<= '366=;7 ? 34 ?@34 B=:B766=?32:>@3B@34B@=667:;783:?@34><3?E7?3?32: , @7 E7?3?32:7<4 3: "!), B6=3D ?2 @=H7EA<B@=47843?74F7=<3:;24,=:8 3:?@7 =52<74=38 6=G2A? 74E2:87:? 2 @=8 B=:B76678 ?@7 6=G2A? E6=: 3: 7I7<B347 25 E2>7< A:87< 7B?32: !&
( 25 =<:=?=9=2>:=:82A:?<G6=::3:;B?3:H37>25?@7 2<87< E=4478 FG ?@7 <74E2:87:? 2) A:87< 7B?32: ! =:8!25?@7=<:=?=9==:8752<D4B?3:<74E7B?25 G24 =:8 ) 25 @=:8=EA<= '366=;7 ? 34 ?@34 B=:B766=?32:>@3B@34B@=667:;783:?@34><3?E7?3?32:
?=EE7=<4?@=?E<2B7783:;4A:87<7B?32:4! =:8 ! 25 ?@7 =<:=?=9= =:8 <752<D4 B? >7<7 3:3?3=?78 3: <74E7B? 25 G2 D7=4A<3:; ) ;A:?=4 =:8 G2) D7=4A<3:; ! =B<74 25 @=:8=EA<= '366=;7??3F7672F63=:8B2:47CA7:?6G=:2<87<F7=<3:;
2#&(&,()! 8=?78 ! >=4 E=4478 FG <74E2:87:? 2 @7 E7?3?32:7< B6=3D4 ?@=? @7 >=4 :2? - 16 -
=>=<725?@74=38E<2B7783:;42>7H7<<74E2:87:?2) 344A78 = :2?3B7 F7=<3:; 2# 8=?78 ) ?2@=:82H7<E24474432:25?@743?7EA<B@=478 FG ?@7 E7?3?32:7< @7 E7?3?32:7< 34 ?@7<752<7 F752<7 ?@34 2A<?B@=667:;3:;?@74=38:2?3B7 @7 67=<:78 B2A:476 52< ?@7 E7?3?32:7<4 4AFD3??78 ?@=? ?@7 2<87< E=4478 FG ?@7 4434?=:? 2DD34432:7< =:;=62<7 2A?@ A:87< 7B?32: ! =:8 ! 25 ?@7 =<:=?=9= =:8 752<D4 B? 3:
#&(&,()! 8=?78 ! >=4 B@=667:;78 F752<7 ?@7 =<:=?=9= EE766=?7 <3FA:=6 3: =EE7=6 2) =:8 ?@=? ?@7 <3FA:=6 3: ?7<D4 25 =: 2<87< 8=?78 ) 47?
=4387 ?@7 2<87< E=4478 FG ?@7 4434?=:? 2DD34432:7< =:8 @768 ?@=? ?@7 E<2B7783:;4 A:87< 7B?32:4 ! =:8 ! @=H7 =F=?78 3: H37> 25 ?@7 2D34432:257B?32:4!=:8!25?@7=<:=?=9==:8 752<D4 B? H387 :2?353B=?32: F7=<3:; 2 )@=4=:=8=?78EAF634@783:
?@7 =<:=?=9= ?=?7 =J7??7 8=?78 7
- 17 -
?@7<752<7B2:?7:84?@=??@73DEA;:78:2?3B7=4>766=4?@7 2<87<4E=4478A:87<7B?32:!&
(25?@7=<:=?=9=2>: =:82A:?<G6=::3:;B?=<763=F67?2F747?=4387 @7 67=<:78 883?32:=6 2H7<:D7:? 8H2B=?7 <7E<747:?3:; ?@7 2553B3=6 <74E2:87:?4 =5?7< E7<A43:; ?@7 2<87< E=4478 FG ?@7 =<:=?=9= EE766=?7 <3FA:=6 3:
=EE7=6 2) 4AFD3??78 ?@=? ?@7 <3FA:=6 @=4 3:8778 47? =4387 ?@7 2<87< E=4478 FG ?@7 4434?=:? 2DD34432:7< A:87< 7B?32:4 ! =:8 ! 25 ?@7 =<:=?=9==:8752<D4B? : H37> 25 ?@7 =52<74=38 4AFD34432: ?@747 E7?3?32:4 8747<H7 ?2 F7 =662>78 =:8 =BB2<83:;6G =<7 =662>782:47CA7:?6G?@7:2?3B7F7=<3:;# 8=?78 ) 344A78 FG <74E2:87:? 2) 34 CA=4@78 397>347 ?@7 2<87< F7=<3:; 2 )8=?78)344A78FG
- 18 -
<74E2:87:? 2 &:79=6 6=::3:; A?@2<3?G :79=6( 34 CA=4@78
) @72>:7<4@3E=:8?3?6725?@7E7?3?32:7<43: <74E7B?25?@73<<74E7B?3H7E<2E7<?3744?=:8<74?2<78=4E7< ?@73<?3?6787784 !+) '&( &
34?21621)