Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 67124 (KAR)
SM SHARATH v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/4093/2017 · 2025-12-11
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 67124 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 67124 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$
%#&!&
'!(
! "
#
$
"
"
""
$" % $ &
""
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
'
!#
"
! $ ( $ '( $ # & $" $ " $
)" $ " ''* '%
!"+"#
$ ,,"
& "- - ,." . /0 10232345067 /890 :/8;;05<0= 85 46=06 >08635< 4 =820=18770=>? 2/0607145=0524>?@/3:/2/0A/8282/827244=352/058B0
- 3 -
4C 905=46 4C 2/0 10232345067 @87 :85:0;;0= /0 10232345067 /8908;7474D</2C468=0:;86823452/82607145=0524/8754 ED637=3:2345 46 8D2/4632? 24 0F06:370 14@067 :45C0660= D5=06 0:23454C2/0865828A8D53:318;46146823457:2% !/05:0C462/60C0660=2487,:2%,#
!3# 630C;?72820=2/0C8:27871;08=0=8602/822/0 1641062? >08635< D53:318; /828 4 % 732D820 82 D6<3<D=3 0F2057345 /398B4<<8 @87 1862 4C 8 ;86<06 8608 @/3:/ @87 4@50= 85= 14770770= >? 450 B2 /8B1D>83 G D5=868837/0/8935<1D6:/870=3235206B74C878;0=00= =820= **% /0 74;= 2/0 783= 1641062? 24 63 5E858 8B 3@86345%*C2062/0=082/4C635E8588B 3@863 8 7D32 35 4 %% @87 C3;0= >? /37 C8B3;? B0B>067C4618623234585=701868201477077345 /0783=7D32 @87 =0:600= 85= 2/0 1641062307 @060 =393=0= 8B45<72 2/600 74574C635E8588B 3@863504C2/074574C635E858 8B 3@863 58B0= 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 <42 2@4 1641062307B087D635<,F,85=2@46073=05238;/4D70785= 8542/06 1641062? B087D635< !'H# F 8206 2/0 783= 638A7/B35868?858 3@8630F0:D20=878;0=00=35C894D64C
- 4 -
B2 D7/00;8 83 35 60710:2 4C 2/0 1641062? 35 ID072345 35 206B74C878;0=00==820=%% !33# /010232345067:;83B2/822/060905D005263077244= 35 2/0 58B0 4C 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 542@32/7285=35< 2/0 78;0 35 C894D6 4C B2 D7/00;8 83 @/4 0F1360= 45 %;08935<>0/35=/06=8D</206B2/85=68168>/8 /0 783= B2 /85=68168>/8 74D</2 :/85<0 4C A/828 35 /06 C894D6 35 206B7 4C 2/0 601607052823457 =820= * 85= /00672@/3;032?D53:318;4D5:3;/398B4<<8 4>28350= 85 4135345 C64B 8 ;8@?06 60<86=35< 601607052823457 C3;0=>?B2/85=68168>/8870=452/0;0<8;41353452/0 2/0532?D53:318;4D5:3;/398B4<<826857C0660=2/0A/828 4C 2/0 1641062? 35 ID072345 24 B2 /85=68168>/8 45 /0 10232345067 :;83B 2/82 2/0? 1D6:/870= 2/0 1641062? C64B B2 /85=68168>/8 35 206B7 4C 8 78;0 =00= =820= /0608C206 2/0? 811648:/0= 2/0 32? D53:318;4D5:3;C4626857C064CA/828242/03658B07 /032? D53:318; 4D5:3; /398B4<<8 2/05 26857C0660= 2/0 A/828 4C 2/01641062?242/03658B0745% /0C82/064C2/0 10232345067/8=8;741D6:/870=8>324C;85=B087D635<% 7IC2C64BB2/85=68168>/835206B74C878;0=00==820=
- 5 -
%* 85= 2/0608C206 /0 0F0:D20= <3C2 =00= =820= 35 C894D6 4C 2/0 10232345067 /0 A/828 4C 2/0 8C460783=1641062?7244=26857C0660=242/058B074C10232345067 45 24 850F2052 4C % 7I C2 /0 10232345067 2/060C460 :45205= 2/82 2/0? 860 2/0 4@5067 4C 2/0 1641062? B087D635<',F*,/8935<8:ID360=2/078B035206B74C2/0 78;0=00=85=<3C2=00=60C0660=8>490 !333# /0 10232345067 :45205= 2/82 2/0 607145=052 4 811648:/0=2/0607145=0524'8;;0<35<2/822/0A/828352/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 85= 35 2/0 58B0 4C 2/0 10232345067@873;;0<8;85=:;83B0=2/822/01641062?>0;45<0= 242/0D53:318;4D5:3;85=2/060C460A/828B8=04D2352/0 58B0 4C 2/0 10232345067 7/4D;= >0 6094A0= /0 607145=052 4' 377D0= 8 5423:0 24 2/0 10232345067 85= 2/036 905=46 B2 /85=68168>/8 45 85= :8;;0= D145 2/0B 24 7/4@ :8D70 35 60710:2 4C 2/0 8;;0<823457 B8=0 >?
2/0 607145=052 4 /01023234506785=B2/85=68168>/87D>B3220=2/036 601;?4@09062/0607145=0524'@6420242/0607145=052 4 700A35< C46 8 :;863C3:82345 87 24 @/02/06 /0 :4D;= 28A0 72017D5=060:2345'4C2/0:2%246094A02/0A/828
- 6 -
!39# /0 10232345067 :;83B 2/82 >0C460 2/0 A/828 @87 B8=0 4D2 35 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 2/0 2/05 32? D53:318;4D5:3; /398B4<<8/8=1D>;37/0=85423:03593235< 4>E0:23457 3C 85? 60<86=35< 2/0 26857C06 4C 2/0 A/828 4C 2/0 1641062? 35 /06 58B0 2 @87 2/0608C206 2/82 2/0 A/828 @87 46=060=24>026857C0660=242/058B04CB2/85=68168>/8 2 37 :45205=0= 2/82 3C 2/0 32? D53:318; 4D5:3; /8= 85? 3520607249062/01641062?32@4D;=/890C3;0=4>E0:2345785=32 @4D;= 542 /890 26857C0660= 2/0 A/828 35 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 /060C460 32 37 :;83B0= 2/82 2/0 ID072345 4C 60930@466094:823454C2/0A/828822/37143523523B0373;;0<8; 85=4116077390 !9# /0 10232345067 :;83B 2/82 2/0 01D2? 4BB37734506 607145=052 4 C3;0= 8 60937345 10232345 >0C460 2/0607145=05243560;82345242/0A/82826857C0660=352/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 @/3:/ @87 26857C0660= 24 2/0 10232345067 /0 10232345067 @060 1862307 35 2/0 164:00=35<7 >0C460 2/0 607145=052 4 /0 10232345067 8110860= >0C460 2/0 607145=052 4 85= 68370= 709068; 377D07 35:;D=35< ED637=3:2345 4C 2/0 607145=052 4 24 052062835 8 60937345 10232345 /0 607145=052 4 164:00=0= 24 052062835 8
- 7 -
60937345 10232345 C3;0= >? 2/0 607145=052 4 85= 18770= 3B1D<50=46=06:85:0;35<2/0A/828B8=04D2352/058B04C 2/0 905=46 4C 2/0 10232345067 /0 10232345067 :45205= 2/82 607145=0524/8=18770=2/03B1D<50=46=06>870=452/0 =0:60018770=354' %%85=4%% %%2 37 :45205=0= 2/82 2/070 =4:DB0527 @060 542 CD6537/0= 24 2/0 1023234506785=2/060C4602/010232345067@060A012352/0=86A 85=2/03B1D<50=46=06@8718770=8<835722/0B /0?8;74 :45205=2/82352/046=0618770=>?2/0607145=05242/060 @060 60C0605:07 24 4* %'4' %* 85= 4*' @/3:/244@060542CD6537/0=242/010232345067 /0?:;83B0=2/822/0?/8=1D6:/870=2/01641062?C64BB2 /85=68168>/8 8C206 9063C3:82345 4C 2/0 232;0 =00=7 85= 42/06 BD53:318;=4:DB0527 /0?:45205=2/8287452/0=8204C2/0 1D6:/870 4C 2/0 1641062? 2/0 BD53:318; 60:46=7 7244= 35 2/0 58B04CB2/85=68168>/885=2/0?8C206=D0=3;3<05:0/8= 1D6:/870=2/01641062? !93# /010232345067860>0C4602/374D62:/8;;05<35<2/0 46=0618770=>?2/0607145=0524
- 8 -
!3# /0 ;08650= :4D570; C46 2/0 10232345067 7D>B3220=2/822/014@062460930@466094A08A/828>64D</2 8>4D23560710:24C2/01641062?3790720=352/04BB37734506 4C2/0607145=0524'8716493=0=D5=060:2345'4C2/0 :2 % 0 :45205=0= 2/82 2/37 37 7D>E0:2 24 2/0 2@35 :45=3234558B0;?2/82327/4D;=>0>?2/04BB37734506032/06 45 2/0 811;3:82345 46 7D4 B42D 85= 32 7/4D;= >0 @32/35 2/600 ?0867C64B2/0=8204CB8A35<4D22/0A/8280:45205=72/82 2/0 607145=052 4 :4D;= 542 /890 60930@0= 46 6094A0= 2/0 A/828 4@0906 2/0 607145=052 4 /8= ;4=<0= 8 601607052823458;;0<35<2/82A/828B8=04D2352/058B04C2/0 10232345067 @87 3;;0<8; 85= 2/82 2/0 1641062?
2/82 @87 2/0 7D>E0:2 B82206 4C 2/0A/828>0;45<0=24 2/0 4614682345 0 :45205=7 2/82 607145=052 4 68370= 8 =371D20 >0C460 2/0 607145=052 4 @/4 260820= 32 87 60937345 10232345 D5=06 0:23454C2/0:2%0:45205=72/823560710:24C 2/0 A/828 32 37 2/0 4BB37734506 8;450 @/4 :85 0F06:370 ED637=3:234585=5422/0607145=0524 /060C4602/046=06 18770= >? 2/0 607145=052 4 37 @32/4D2 ED637=3:2345 85= 37 ;38>;024>0702873=00359320=2/08220523454C2/04D6224 98634D7 164:00=35<7 >02@005 2/0 160=0:07746 35 232;0 4C B2
- 9 -
D7/00;8832/0B42/064CB2/85=68168>/887@0;;872/0 164:00=35<735323820=>?B2D7/00;88385=:45205=72/823C 2/0607145=0527/89085?35206072352/01641062?35ID072345 32372/0607145=0524'@/4/8724<4242/0393;4D6285= 0728>;37/327>0220663</257D114624C2/37:452052345/0/87 60;30=D1452/0C4;;4@35<ED=<B0527- !3# 63
D5368ED 97 /0 10:38;
01D2? 4BB3773450685=42/067J'K !33# 3?8L 87/8 97 4BB37734506 85<8;460 32? 4614682345 85= 8542/06 J%** 5350 86 K !333# /3B4<8 8<863A8 32/8 8A7/858 0=3A0<8;8 AD228 !0<=#97 2820 4C 865828A8 85= 42/067 J&4* K !39# B2
D7/18 97 6D/82 85<8;460 8/858<868 8;3A0 !# 85<8;460 85= 42/067 J535086'*K !9# .8<8=007/ 0==? 97 /0 .4352 4BB37734506 85= 8542/06 J&4% 85= :4550:20= :8707K !93# /0 4BB37734506 85= 8542/06 97 8A7/B85 84 85=42/067J&4* %K
- 10 -
!933# 85247/ADB86 /39<45=8 823; 85= 42/067 97 8;878/0> DA868B /098;0 85= 42/067 J % !D11#'K !9333# 7864E<05:30797 /028204C865828A885= 8542/06J&4*' %%K
!33# 0 =60@ 2/0 822052345 4C 2/0 4D62 24 85 4>706982345 B8=0 >? 2/0 4D62 35 4' %* 85= :45205=0=2/822/04D62/8=28A05:4<53L85:04C2/078;04C 2/01641062?B087D635<',F*,>?638A/B35868?858 3@863 35C894D64CB2D7/00;883 /D7/0:45205=72/822/06037 54 =371D20 60<86=35< 2/0 232;0 4C B2 D7/00;8 83 35 2/0 1641062?B087D635<',F*,4570ID052;?2/0A/828B8=0 4D2 35 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 85= 2/0 A/828 B8=0 4D2352/058B04C2/010232345067/0603537ED723C30= ' !3# /0 @632 10232345 37 411470= >? 2/0 607145=052 4 @/4 /87 C3;0= 8 =0283;0= 72820B052 4C 4>E0:23457 2/0 07705:0 4C @/3:/ 860 2/82 8C206 63 8A/B35868?858 3@863 70:D60= 1641062? 82 8 186232345 87 :;83B0=>?/3B/0C3;0=87D32354' %%8<835722/0 2/05 4@5 D53:318;32? /398B4<<8 C46 106102D8; 35ED5:2345 @/3:/@87=0:600=85=4' %C3;0=2/0608<83572@87
- 11 -
=37B3770=85=4* %@878;;4@0=85=2/0:870@87 60B3220= >8:A 24 2/0 110;;820 4D62 85= D;23B820;? 2/0 7D32 :8B0 24 >0 =37B3770= 4%% %% @/3:/ @87 C3;0= 2/0608<83572@878;74=37B3770=237:45205=0=2/8235 4%% %% 2/37 4D62 /8= 5423:0= 2/82 2/060 @87 8 5423C3:82345 D5=06 0:2345 4C 2/0 85= :ID3732345 :2 35 60710:24C2/0;85=35?44C3;;8</822893;;8<085=2/82 A02/@86 60<37206 35 60710:2 4C ?4 7/4@0= 85 05=4670B052 2/82 2/0 ;85= @87 8:ID360= C46 0F2057345 4C 2/0 93;;8<0>?
4@5D53:318;32?/398B4<<885=@8726857C0660= 242/049065B05287@8720;85=D5=068546=064C2/0D> 39373458;CC3:06=820='%2378;74:;83B0=2/822/37 4D62/8=5423:0=2/822/060@060709068;/4D707:45726D:20= 35 D6<3<D=30F2057345 85= 2/82 32 0728>;37/0= 2/0 :870 4C 2/0 D53:318;32? 2/82 ;86<0 0F2052 4C ;85= 35:;D=35< ?4 4C 3;;8</822893;;8<0@878:ID360=C462/01D614704CC46B823454C 6073=05238;860835D6<3<D=3F2057345/398B4<<82378;74 :45205=0=2/822/0783=638A7/B35868?858 3@863=D635<2/0 105=05:?4C2/07D32354' %/8=74;=814623454C 2/01641062?24B2D7/00;88345%%82062/0 783= 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 85= 42/067 C3;0= 8 7D32 35
- 12 -
4* %'C46=0:;86823454C232;085=106102D8;35ED5:2345 85= C46 8;206582390 60;30C 4C 1477077345 35 60710:2 4C 2/0 1641062? >08635< D53:318; 446 47
85= 877077B052 47% %' 85= % @/3:/ @060 732D820 82 D6<3<D=3 F2057345 /398B4<<8 /0 783= 7D32 @87 =0:600= 45%*52/0B085@/3;0B2D7/00;883/8=8;74 C3;0=4' %C46106102D8;35ED5:23453560710:24C2/0 1641062?8;;0<0=;?1D6:/870=>?/06C64B638A7/B35868?858 3@863 /0 783= 7D32 @87 =37B3770= 45 %* 85= 4 %*C3;0=2/0608<83572@87=371470=4CC35930@4C8 B0B4 C3;0= >? /06 2/82 4*' C3;0= >? 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 8<83572 2/0 ED=<B052 85= =0:600 35 4' %*@87105=35<:4573=068234552/0B085@/3;0 4*' @/3:/ @87 C3;0= >? 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 8<83572 2/0 ED=<B052 85= =0:600 18770= 35 4' %*@87=37B3770=45 !33# B2 D7/00;8 83 735:0 =0:0870= 6016070520= >? /06 ;0<8; 60160705282390 B2 /85=68168>/8 C3;0= 4% >0C4602/374D62 700A35<2460930@2/0ED=<B052 =820=18770=>?2/374D62354*'
@/3:/@878;74=37B3770=87542160770=45*35930@
- 13 -
4C2/0B0B4C3;0=242/00CC0:22/822/0B82206@877022;0=4D2 4C 4D62 2 37 :45205=0= 2/82 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 /8935<C3;0=87D32C4635ED5:2345/8=18620=8@8?814623454C 2/0 1641062? 35 ID072345 85= 2/0608C206 /0 C3;0= 8 7D32 C46 =0:;86823454C/37232;0@/3://0;472 /D73237:45205=0=2/82 B2D7/00;883=3=542=0639085?63</2232;0463520607235 2/0 1641062? 35 ID072345 85= 735:0 2/0 63</2 4C 2/0 32? D53:318; 4D5:3; /3B4<8 @87 D1/0;= C64B 23B0 24 23B0 B2D7/00;883=3=542<0285?232;052/0B085@/3;02/0 C82/06 4C 2/0 10232345067 /06035 @/4 877DB0= 4CC3:0 4C 2/0 8?464C2/0607145=0524'B858<0=24<022/0A/8284C2/0 1641062?35ID072345352/058B04CB2/85=68168>/82/0 =8D</206 4C B2 D7/00;8 83 85= 2/0608C206 /0 <42 2/0 1641062?26857C0660=242/058B074C/372@4745758B0;?2/0 10232345067/0603585=:4570ID052;?2/0@8726857C0660= 35 2/036 58B07 &32/ 2/070 85= 42/06 :4520523457 2/0 607145=052 4 :;83B7 2/82 @/82 @87 2/0 1641062? 4C 2/0 607145=052 4' @87 B8=0 4906 24 2/0 10232345067 2/64D</ :062835D5:457:3458>;0=00=785=/05:02/0607145=0524 45:4B35<24A54@4C2/03;;0<8;3230735>635<35<8>4D22/0 352/058B074C2/0102323450673560710:24C81641062?@/3:/
- 14 -
>0;45<0=242/0D53:318;32? 32?D53:318;4D5:3;/3B4<<8 /8= 35323820= 164:00=35<7 >0C460 2/0 607145=052 4 @/4 260820=328786093734510232345D5=060:23454C2/0:2 %85=18770=2/03B1D<50=46=06
08650= :4D570; C46 2/0 607145=052 4 @/3;0 6032068235<2/08>490:4520523457 359320=2/08220523454C2/37 4D62 24 :062835 4>7069823457 B8=0 >? 2/0 4D62 4C $3672 ==323458;D573CC/3B4<835327ED=<B052=820=%* 18770=354' %C3;0=>?B2D7/00;8838<83572 2/0 0672@/3;0 32? D53:318;32? /3B4<8 @/060 32 @87 /0;= M
N ! 4' %%# 0 CD62/06 359320= 2/0 822052345 4C 2/37 4D62 24 2/0 98634D7 4>7069823457 B8=0 >?
2/0 4D62 4C 2/0 ==323458; 37263:2 .D=<0/3B4<835327ED=<B052=820=%350<D;86 1108; 4' %* 863735< 4D2 4C 2/0 ED=<B052 85= =0:600 =820=%*18770=>?2/0635:318;393;.D=<0/3B4<8 35 4* %' @/060 32 /0;= M
O02/060C460:45205=0=2/8263
- 15 -
8A7/B35868?858 3@863@/4/8=C3;0=4' %%/8= 18620= @32/ 8 1462345 4C 2/0 1641062? @/3:/ @87 2/0 7D>E0:2 B82206 4C 2/0 783= 7D32 24 /37 737206 58B0;? B2 D7/00;8 8385=7/0C3;0=87D32354' %0:45205=72/82 2/0 7D32 35 4' %% C3;0= >? 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@8638<83572D53:318;32? 4@5D53:318;4D5:3;/3B4<8 >0C460 2/0 D573CC /3B4<8 C46 106102D8; 35ED5:2345 @87 =37B3770= 45 % 85= 2/0 C3672 81108; 35 4' % C3;0= >? 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 8<83572 2/0 783= ED=<B052 87 @0;; 87 2/0 70:45= 81108; 35 4%% %% C3;0= >? /3B 85= 42/067 @060 8;74 =37B3770= 0 :45205=7 2/82 2/0 7D32 35 4' % C3;0= >? B2D7/00;8 83 @87 8;74 =37B3770= 0 2/05 359320= 2/0 822052345 4C 2/37 4D62 24 2/0 ED=<B052 =820= '% 18770= 35 4%% %% @/060 2/37 4D62 /8= 5423:0= 2/822/0052360?44C3;;8</822893;;8<0@878:ID360=C46 2/01D614704CC46B823454CD6<3<D=3F205734502/060C460 :45205=7 2/82 2/0 1641062? :;83B0= >? 2/0 1023234506 =3= 542 0F372 4502/0;077 8C206 2/0 7D32 35 4' %% @87 =37B3770= 2/0 783= 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 85= 42/067 8<835 C3;0= 7D32 35 4* %' 8<83572 32? D53:318;
- 16 -
4D5:3;/3B4<8>0C4602/04D624C2/0635:318;393;.D=<0 /3B4<8C46=0:;86823454C 2/036232;0 3560710:24C81641062? @/3:/=3=542>0;45<242/0B /0783=7D322/4D</353238;;?@87 =0:600= 85 81108; 35 4' %* 160C0660= >? 2/0 32? D53:318; 4D5:3; /3B4<8 @87 8;;4@0= >? 2/0 ==323458; 37263:2.D=<0/3B4<835206B74C2/0ED=<B05285==0:600 =820=%85=4*' @/3:/@87C3;0=>? 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 8<83572 2/0 783= ED=<B052 85= =0:600@87=37B3770=4502/060C460:45205=7 2/82 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 85= B2 D7/00;8 83 @060 D58>;0240728>;37/2/036232;0242/01641062?35ID072345D235 2/0 B085@/3;0 2/0 4C 2/0 1641062? 2/82 7244= 35 2/0 58B0 4C 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 @87 74D</2 24 >0 26857C0660= 24 B2 /85=68168>/8 8C206 2/0 =082/ 4C B2 D7/00;88352/3760<86=85811;3:82345@87C3;0=>?B2 /85=68168>/8 C46 26857C06 4C 85= 2/0 32?
D53:318;
4D5:3; 4>28350= 4135345 C64B 327 =94:820 @/4 @32/4D2 60C0605:0242/08>490CD6537/0=8541353452/82:4D;= >0 B8=0 4D2 35 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 08650= :4D570; :45205=7 2/82 2/37 @87 =450 82 2/0 357285:0 4C 2/0 C82/06 4C 2/0 10232345067 @/4 @87 2/05 8 8?46 4C 2/0
- 17 -
607145=0524'85=2/0@87:;85=072350;?B8=04D235 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 8206 2/0 1641062? @87 26857C0660=242/058B074C2/010232345067/0603535206B74C8 78;0=00==820=02/060C460:45205=72/822/0 1641062?@/3:/@87:457372052;?/0;=24>02/01641062?4C2/0 32? D53:318; 4D5:3; /3B4<8 85= @/3:/ @87 8:ID360= C46 2/0 1D61470 4C C46B82345 4C D6<3<D=3 F2057345 @87 :;85=072350;?B8=04906352/058B074C2/010232345067>?2/0 C82/06 4C 2/0 10232345067 @/4 @87 2/05 2/0 8?46 4C 2/0 607145=052 4' >? B37D735< 2/0 14@06 85= :4B10;;35< 2/0 4CC3:38;7 4C 2/0 607145=052 4' 24 =4 74 08650= :4D570;
2/060C460 :45205=7 2/82 2/0 607145=052 4 /8= ;4=<0= 8 :4B1;8352 35 2/82 60<86= 87 2/0 1641062? /8= 24 >0 6072460= >8:A242/032?D53:318;4D5:3;/3B4<8>?:85:0;;35<2/0 $4;;4@35<2/0;08=7CD6537/0=>?2/0607145=0524 607145=052 4 35323820= 164:00=35<7 >0C460 2/0 607145=052 4 @/4 8C206 :4573=0635< 2/0 052360 B820638; 45 60:46= 85= 2/01872164:00=35<7>02@0052/01862307/0;=2/822/0 @87 C68D=D;052;? >64D</2 4D2 35 2/0 58B07 4C 2/0 10232345067 85=2/036905=4685=:4570ID052;?607145=0524164:00=0= 24:85:0;2/0350F06:3704C/37609373458;ED637=3:23450
- 18 -
:45205=7 2/82 2/4D</ 2/0 4BB37734506 /87 2/0 14@06 D5=06 0:2345 ' 4C 2/0 :2 % 24 :4573=06 2/0 :8707 4C >64D</2 8>4D2 C68D=D;052;? 46 2/64D</ B3760160705282345 2/0 1641062?35ID072345>0;45<0=242/0282085=2/078B0/8= 90720=352/032?D53:318;4D5:3;85=2/060C460607145=052 4 @87 :4B102052 24 ;4=<0 8 :4B1;8352 >0C460 2/0 607145=052 4 85= 2/0 607145=052 4 @87 05232;0= 24 0F06:370 /37 609373458; ED637=3:2345 24 D57022;0 85 3;;0<8;
>64D</2 8>4D2 35 2/0 58B07 4C 2/0 10232345067 0 CD62/06 :45205=72/823C2/0052360164:0=D608=4120=>?2/010232345067 35 >635<35< 8>4D2 2/0 35 2/0 58B0 4C 2/036 905=46 85= 7D>70ID052;? 3524 2/036 58B07 @87 =63905 >? C68D= 2/05 2/0 607145=052 4 @87 ED723C30= 35 0F06:3735< ED637=3:2345 35 D5=435<7D:/C68D=0:45205=72/8209053C2/374D62@060 24 /4;= 2/82 2/0 607145=052 4 =3= 542 /890 ED637=3:2345 @/05 32 37 >64D</2 24 2/0 5423:0 4C 2/37 4D62 2/82 2/0 >64D</2 4D2 35 2/0 58B07 4C 2/0 10232345067 37 =450 C68D=D;052;? 2/37 4D62 7/4D;= 60C6835 C64B 0F06:3735< ED637=3:2345 D5=06 623:;0 4C 2/0 457232D2345 4C 5=38 08650=:4D570;357D114624C/37:452052345760;30=D1452/0 C4;;4@35<ED=<B0527-
- 19 -
!" # $ % &'(# ) **+,
!" # -.
/ &'(# 0 ) 102+,
!" 3
4 ( ) 5 6 7
' 8 5 &'(# ) 99+,
!" :; <;
:< &!=" 1 )) *>*+
02/060C460:45205=72/822/03B1D<50=46=06/8760=00B0= 2/0 :;83B 4C 2/0 607145=052 4' @/3:/ @87 D1/0;= >? 2/0 4D627C64B23B02423B085=2/060C4602/374D627/4D;=542 0F06:370ED637=3:234524D57022;046D5=42/0B3728A0:4BB3220= >?2/0C82/064C2/010232345067@/4@872/052/08?464C2/0 607145=0524'35>635<35<8>4D22/0352/058B074C 2/01023234506785=2/036905=46
/0 607145=052 2820 /87 C3;0= 72820B052 4C 4>E0:23457 85= /87 60C0660= 24 086;306 ;323<823457 >02@005 2/0 186230785=:45205=0=2/8232?D53:318;4D5:3;/3B4<837 2/0 4@506 4C 2/0 1641062? 35 ID072345 85= 2/82 2/0 3B1D<50= 46=06 18770= >? 2/0 607145=052 4 37 ED723C30= 85= 8::46=35<;?74D</2C46=37B3778;4C2/0@63210232345
- 20 -
08650===323458;49065B052=94:82081108635< C46607145=0524724603206820=2/08>490:452052345785= 74D</224ED723C?2/03B1D<50=46=06
* 08650= :4D570; C46 607145=052 4' @/3;0 7D1146235< 2/0 :4520523457 4C 2/0 ;08650= :4D570; C46 607145=0524:45205=0=2/822/063</24C2/032?D53:318;
4D5:3; /3B4<8 37 D1/0;= 2/64D</4D2 2/0 164:00=35<7 35323820=>?638A7/B35868?858 3@863C64B2/0?086%%23;;
2/0 ?086 85= 8;74 35 2/0 164:00=35<7 35323820= >? B2 D7/00;8 83 C64B 2/0 ?086 % 23;; 2/0 ?086 0 2/060C460 :45205=7 2/82 5032/06 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 546B2D7/00;883=06390=85?232;0242/01641062?:;83B0= >?2/0B85=2/060C460B2/85=68168>/8=3=542=0639085? 232;04@090628A35<8=98528<04C2/078;0=00=35C894D64C B2 D7/00;8 83 85= :4;;D=35< @32/ 2/0 C82/06 4C 2/0 10232345067@/4@872/0588?464C2/0607145=0524'2/0 @87 >64D</2 4D2 35 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 >870=4535/063285:04C2/01641062?35ID0723450:45205=7 2/82 8C206 <02235< 2/0
35 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/82/010232345067>035<2/074574C2/00672@/3;0 8?46 4C 2/0 607145=052 4' 4>28350= 8 78;0 =00= 35 2/036
- 21 -
58B0785=B858<0=244>2835352/03658B073560710:2 4C81641062?@/3:/=3=542>0;45<242/0B>D2>0;45<0=242/0 32? D53:318; 4D5:3; 0 2/060C460 :45205=7 2/82 2/0 3B1D<50=46=0618770=>?2/0607145=0524D5=3=8@645< =450>?81067453514@06@/4B37D70=/378D2/4632?24>635< 8>4D283560710:24C81641062?2/82>0;45<0=242/032? D53:318;4D5:3;02/060C460:45205=72/822/060375406646 :4BB3220=>?2/0607145=0524350F06:3735<2/0ED637=3:2345 D5=060:23454C2/0:2%
% /890 :4573=060= 2/0 7D>B3773457 4C 2/0 ;08650= :4D570; C46 2/0 10232345067 85= 2/0 60710:2390 ;08650= :4D570;
C46 2/0 607145=052 4' 85= 607145=052 4 85= ;08650= ==323458; 49065B052 =94:820 81108635< C46 07145=052 4724
/0C8:27871;08=0=16070528106C0:2:87072D=?24 D5=067285= @/82 37 B37:/3094D7 ;323<82345 85= /4@ ;323<82345 :4D;= >0 186A0= 35 4D62 24 =68@ >050C32 /0 1;08=35<7 45 60:46==820>8:A242/0?086*%@/054%* *%% @87 C3;0= >? 450 63 D5=D 84 8206 32 8110867 2/82 2/0 1641062?35377D0352/07D32@8718624C?44C3;;8</8228
- 22 -
93;;8<0281108672/8214623454C?44C3;;8</8228@87 8:ID360= >? 2/0 2820 49065B052 C46 2/0 >050C32 4C 2/0 D53:318;32? C46 C46B82345 4C D6<3<D=3 F2057345 35 2/0 ?086 %42@32/7285=35<2/08:ID37323454C2/0783=;85=45063 8A7/B35868?858 3@86385=42/067:;83B35<24>02/04@5067 4C2/01641062?35?4C3;0=4' %%>0C4602/0 4D624CD573CC/3B4<8C46106102D8;35ED5:23458<835722/0 4@5 D53:318; 4D5:3; /3B4<8 /0 783= 7D32 @87 353238;;?
=0:600=>?2/04D624C2/0D573CC/3B4<835206B74C2/0 ED=<B052 =820= % 85= 2/0 783= ED=<B052 85= =0:600@87:45C36B0=>?2/04D624C2/0393;.D=<0/3B4<8
$3672110;;8204D62354' %C3;0=>?2/0 4@5 D53:318; 4D5:3; /3B4<8 /0608C206 2/0 4@5 D53:318;
4D5:3; 811648:/0= 2/37 4D62 35 4* % :446=35820 05:/ 4C 2/37 4D62 >? 327 ED=<B052 =820= '%*702873=02/0=0:60018770=>?2/0$3672110;;820 4D6285=60B85=0=2/0:870242/0$3672110;;8204D62@32/ 8 =360:2345 24 :4573=06 2/0 093=05:0 45 60:46= >42/ 468; 85= =4:DB05286? 85= 60:46= 327 C35=35< 87 24 2/0 232;0 4C 2/0 1641062? 85= 8;74 327 3=05232? 85= =371470 4C 2/0 81108; 35 8::46=85:0 @32/ ;8@ "145 60B85= 2/0 $3672 110;;820 4D62
- 23 -
=37B3770=2/07D3235206B74C2/0ED=<B052=820=%% 85=4%% %%C3;0=8<835722/0783=ED=<B0524C2/0 $3672110;;8204D62@878;74=37B3770=>?2/374D6235206B7 4C 2/0 ED=<B052 85= =0:600 =820= '% /0 783= 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 =D635< 2/0 105=05:? 4C
4' %%:4590?0=814623454C2/01641062?24/37737206 B2 D7/00;8 83 45 %% 905 8C206 7D:/ 78;0 2/0 783= 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 85= 42/067 C3;0= 4* %' 8<83572 2/0 32? D53:318; 4D5:3; /3B4<8 C46 =0:;8682345 4C 232;0 85= 106102D8; 35ED5:2345 35 60710:2 4C 2/0 906? 78B0 1641062? /4D</ /0 28720= 7D::077 353238;;? 2/0 32? D53:318; 4D5:3; :/8;;05<0= 2/0 ED=<B052 85= =0:600 =820= %* 18770= 35 4* %' >0C460 2/0 ==323458; 37263:2 .D=<0 /3B4<8 35 4' %* /0 783= 81108; @87 8;;4@0= >? 2/0 $3672 110;;820 4D62 45 % >? 702235< 873=0 2/0 ED=<B052 85= =0:600 =820= %* 18770= >? 2/0 635:318; 393; .D=<0 /3B4<8 35 4* %' 5 2/0 B085@/3;0 B2 D7/00;8 83 8;74 C3;0= 4' % >0C460 2/0 4D62 4C $3672 ==323458; D573CC /3B4<8 C46 106102D8; 35ED5:2345 8<83572 2/0 32? D53:318;32? /3B4<8 5 930@ 4C 2/0 =37B3778; 4C
- 24 -
4' %% 85= 8;74 28A35< 3524 8::4D52 2/0 C8:2 2/82 B2 D7/00;8 83 /8= 1D6:/870= 2/0 1641062? C64B 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 =D635< 2/0 105=05:? 4C
4' %% 2/0 7D32 C3;0= >? B2 D7/00;8 83 @87 8;74 =37B3770=>?2/0$3672==323458;D573CC/3B4<835206B74C 2/0 ED=<B052 85= =0:600 =820= %* /0 C3;0= 4 %* 8<83572 2/0 783= ED=<B052 85= =0:600 >0C460 2/0 4D62 4C ==323458; 393; .D=<0 !6 5# /3B4<8 5 2/0 B085@/3;0 2/0 ;0<8; 601607052823907 4C 2/0 =0:0870= 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 85= 42/067 C3;0= 4*'
>0C460 2/37 4D62 :/8;;05<35< 2/0 ED=<B052 85= =0:600 =820= % 18770= >? 2/0 ==323458; 37263:2 .D=<0 /3B4<8 354' %*B2D7/00;8832630=2413<<?>8:A63=0 452/081108;C3;0=>?2/0;0<8;6016070528239074C2/0=0:0870= 638A7/B35868?858 3@863354*' 85=C3;0=8 B0B4354 %*>0C4602/0==323458;393;.D=<0!6 5# /3B4<8 700A35< 24 =3714704CC2/0 81108; >?
=360:235< 2/0186230724B8352835 ? 85=7D>E0:2242/04D2:4B0 4C 4*' /081108; C3;0= >? B2 D7/00;8 83 @872/060C460:;470=85=547201@8728A05>?/06C466093935< 4 %* 5 2/0 B085@/3;0 4*' C3;0=
- 25 -
>? 2/0 ;0<8; 601607052823907 4C 2/0 =0:0870= 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863 @87 8;74 =37B3770= >? 8 :446=35820 05:/ 4C 2/37 4D62 45 !# 4%
C3;0=>?74B04C2/01862307354*' 8<835722/0 ED=<B05285=46=06=820=18770=2/060358;74@87 =37B3770= >? 2/0 45,>;0 10F 4D62 45 /0 8C460783= @4D;= 0728>;37/ >0?45= =4D>2 2/82 63 8A7/B35868?858 3@863/8=;472232;0242/01641062?@/3://0 :;83B0= 85= :4570ID052;? B2 D7/00;8 83 8;74 =3= 542 =0639085?232;0242/01641062?@/3:/7/0:;83B0=4@090632 8110867 2/82 8C206 2/0 =082/ 4C B2 D7/00;8 83 /06 =8D</206 B2 /85=68168>/8 C3;0= 85 811;3:82345 C46 26857C06635<2/04C2/01641062?>870=452/078;0=00= 0F0:D20= 35 C894D6 4C /06 B42/06 B2 D7/00;8 83 @/3:/ @87 6010820=;? /0;= 24 >0 D505C46:08>;0 >? 2/0 4D627 /0 4CC3:38;74C2/032?D53:318;4D5:3; /3B4<82/054>28350= 4135345C64B2/036=94:820@/4<8908541353452/822/0 4C 2/0 1641062? :4D;= >0 B8=0 4D2 35 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 /D7728620=878<84C746273587BD:/872/0 4C 2/0 1641062? @87 >64D</2 4D2 35 2/0 58B0 4C B2/85=68168>/8 @32/4D2 60C0605:0 24 98634D7 164:00=35<7
- 26 -
>02@005 /06 B42/06 85= /06 D5:;0 85= 2/0 32? D53:318; 4D5:3;85=2/04C2/01641062?@87>64D</24D2352/0 58B04CB2/85=68168>/81186052;?2/37@87542>870= 45 2/0 232;0 4C B2 D7/00;8 83 >D2 @87 >870= 45 85 D505C46:08>;0 78;0 =00= 0F0:D20= 35 C894D6 4C B2 D7/00;8 83 C206 2/0 @87 052060= 35 2/0 58B0 4C B2 /85=68168>/8 2/0 1641062? 74;= >?2/0 10232345067 @/4 860 2/0:/3;=6054C63863?8118@/4@87850672@/3;04D5:3;;46 4C2/0607145=0524'85=88?464C2/0607145=0524'82 74B0 14352 35 23B0 2 37 2/060C460 81186052 2/82 2/0 2/8237>64D</2352/058B04C2/01023234506737:4;4D68>;085= 37 =073<50= 24 4D2@32 2/0 D53:318;32? @/3:/ /8= :457372052;? 7D::00=0=3598634D7;323<823457C64B2/0?086%% /0:;83B 4C2/0607145=05242/822/0C82/064C2/010232345067@/4 @872/04D5:3;;464C2/0607145=0524'/8=87@8?49062/0 164:00=35<7 :85542 >0 =37>0;3090= /060C460 32 :85 D5/07328235<;?>0/0;=2/822/03560710:24C2/01641062? 2/82 37 >64D</2 4D2 35 2/0 58B07 4C 2/0 10232345067 85= 2/036 160=0:07746@87542>870=4585?232;0>D2@87>?86B2@37235< 2/04CC3:38;74C2/0607145=0524'85=32@873560710:24C8
- 27 -
1641062?@/3:/>0;45<0=242/0607145=0524'32?D53:318; 4D5:3;
760<86=72/0:4520523454C2/0;08650=:4D570;C46 2/0102323450672/822/0609373458;14@067:4D;=542/890>005 0F06:370= >? 2/0 607145=052 4 @32/4D2 60746235< 24 14@06 D5=060:2345'4C2/0:2%37:45:0650=2/4D</2/0 78B0 8110867 24 >0 8::0128>;0 82 C3672 >;D7/ 32 500=7 24 >0 5420= 2/82 2/0 >64D</2 4D2 35 2/0 58B07 4C 2/0 10232345067@872/0607D;24C8C68D=D;0528:285=8>D704C2/0 164:0774C;8@763</2;?:45205=0=>?2/0;08650=:4D570;C46 2/0 607145=052 4 3C 2/0 10232345067 /890 B37D70= ;8@ 85= /89035=D;<0=35C68D=D;052B085735>635<35<8>4D2835 60710:24C81641062?@/3:/2/0?=3=5421477077>D2>0;45<0= 242/032?D53:318;4D5:3; 607145=0524'2/078B0=407 542@86685285?35206C0605:045;?452/0B060<64D5=2/822/0 607145=0524=3=542/890ED637=3:234524D57022;02/0 /37 4D62 37 8;74 B35=CD; 4C 2/0 C8:2 2/82 2/0 1641062? 35 ID072345@87086;3068:ID360=C462/0C46B823454C850F2057345$ 58B0;?
D6<3<D=3 F2057345 35 /3B4<<8 85= 14@06 D5=06 0:23454C2/085=:ID3732345:2*%'@870F06:370=2 2/060C460 B0857 2/82 2/0 1641062? @/3:/ 37 :;83B0= >? 2/0
- 28 -
102323450672/06035@8718624C81641062?@/3:/>0;45<0=242/0 2820 49065B052 85= @/3:/ 7244= 90720= 35 2/0 607145=052 4'>?9362D04C4106823454C;8@ /060C4602/0607145=052 4 =3= 542 ;470 703735 4906 2/0 1641062307 4C 2/0 2820 49065B052@/3:/@060352/0/85=74C2/0607145=0524' 4570ID052;? 2/0 607145=052 4 @87 35 8 @8? ED723C30= 35 0F06:3735< 609373458; ED637=3:2345 24 D57022;0 8 @645< =450 >? B37D735<2/0164:0774C;8@
5930@4C2/08>4905435206C0605:037@8668520= 352/37@6321023234585=8::46=35<;?3237
0C460186235<C64B2/0:870323760;09852245420 2/82 8 1641062? @/3:/ 90720= 35 2/0 607145=052 4' 37 052@350= 35 ;323<82345 35 450 C46B 46 2/0 42/06 C64B 2/0 ?086 %% 85= 23;; =820 2/0 607145=052 4' 37 5428;;4@0= 24 D70 2/0>050C3274C2/0C35=35<760:46=0=>?2/04D627C64B23B024 23B0
' 0232345067@/4:;83B24>02/01607052 85=2/04@50674C2/01641062?35ID072345/89024B8A0@8? 85=7D6605=062/036:;83B242/0607145=0524'$D62/063237 7005 2/82 2/37 1641062? /87 <0506820= 7D>7285238; ;323<82345
- 29 -
>0C460 2/0 4D627 C64B 23B0 24 23B0 85= 2/060C460 32 37 50:07786? 2/82 2/0 1862307 860 1D2 45 206B7 24 057D60 2/82 2/060 37 54 CD62/06 ;323<82345 35 60710:2 4C 2/0 1641062? 35 ID072345
5 930@ 4C 2/0 8C460783= 2/37 4D62 =360:27 2/0 607145=052 4' 24 B8A0 81164163820 0526307 35 2/0 1641062? 60<37206 35 60710:24C 2/0 1641062? 35ID072345 35 2/0 58B0 4C 2/0 607145=052 4' 85= 28A0 3BB0=3820 B087D607 24 28A0 4906 1477077345 4C 2/0 1641062? /0 10232345067 85= 2/036 160=0:07746735232;0 860 607268350= C64B 353238235< 85? B460 ;323<823453560710:24C2/01641062?35ID072345>0C46085?4D62 4C;8@4685?42/06D2/4632? !)* '&( &
86824'!3# 186847'!33#23;;2/005= 3724-;4-'