Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 67106 (KAR)
SMT. B.C. PARIMALA v. SRI. PUTTALINGAIAH
RFA/211/2016 · 2025-08-13
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 67106 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 67106 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"##"" $$
%$& '
! "
#
"$# % &
"'# ( &
)
Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"*#
&
))
+&
(
! "
"$*##
++ ,
(
( - (#"
./0'.$12$34$ *503678 95. :17 $;;788$3: $3< ./1/=$>02$. *503678 95. .76;53<73:6 " :5 # 1$=7 $;;7$.7</3;7.653
1/6 /6 $3 $;;7$8 9.52 :17 50.: 59 % <<8 /:4 /=/8?766/536(0<@773@$80.0",# ) 5.*53=73/73*7A66$>7:17;$.:/76$.7.797..7<:5 $6;7.:17/.6:$:06$3<.$3>/3@6'795.7:17./$850.:
- 3 -
B 17;8$/3:$=7.273:6$.7:1767- 2:$./2$8$ :17 <7973<$3: /6 :17 5C37. 59 $ ;.5;7.:4 '7$./3@ $:1$ 5+), 66766273: 5D,+ .5;7.:4 5B 6/:0$:7< $: $::$3$@7.7 /88$@7 73@7./ 5'8/
$E$.$E761C$./3$@$. $3@$85.7 50:1 $80> 1$=/3@ $*F0/.7< :17 6$27 03<7. $ .7@/6:7.7< $87 77< <$:7< B$3<:17>$:1$/66:$3</3@/317.3$27175997.7< :5 6788 :17 ;.5;7.:4 95. 17. 87@$8 37*766/:/76 17 ;8$/3:/99 377<7< ;.5;7.:4 95. 1/6 067 $3< '7379/: $@.77< :5 ;0.*1$67 :176$2795.$=$80$'87*536/<7.$:/539.779.5273*02'.$3*76 9:7. 37@5:/$:/53 :17 6$87 ;./*7 C$6 $@.77< $3< 9/G7< $:
6B &17<7973<$3:7G7*0:7<$3$@.77273:95.6$87 53 $3<$@.77<:56788:1760/:6*17<087;.5;7.:495. :17$@.77<6$87*536/<7.$:/533:17<$:7597G7*0:/5359:17 $@.77273: 95. 6$87 :17 <7973<$3: .7*7/=7< $<=$3*7 6$87 *536/<7.$:/53 59 6 & '4 C$4 59 *$61 9.52 :17 ;8$/3:/9917<7973<$3:<78/=7.7<%7.5G*5;/7659:176$87<77< 03<7. C1/*1 617 ;0.*1$67< :17 60/: ;.5;7.:4 17 '$8$3*7 *536/<7.$:/53 $2503: C$6 $@.77< :5 '7 ;$/< $: :17 :/27 59 .7@/6:.$:/53 59 :17 6$87 <77< : C$6 $@.77< '7:C773 :17
- 4 -
;8$/3:/99 $3< :17 <7973<$3: :1$: :17 :/27 6:/;08$:7< 95. :17 *52;87:/5359:176$8759:176*17<087<;.5;7.:4C$65384:1.77 253:169.52:17<$:759:17$@.77273:95.6$8717<7973<$3: $@.77<:57G7*0:7:176$87<77<C/:1/3:1.77253:169.52:17 <$:759:17$@.77273:95.6$87'4.7*7/=/3@:17'$8$3*7$2503: /39$=5.59:17;8$/3:/99 0'67F073:84:17<7973<$3:$;;.5$*17<:17;8$/3:/99$3< .7*7/=7<$90.:17.$<=$3*7$2503:59 6 &'4*$619.52 :17;8$/3:/99$3<$373<5.67273:C$62$<7:5:1$:7997*:/3:17 $@.77273: 95. 6$87 106 :17 <7973<$3: .7*7/=7< $ :5:$8 $<=$3*7 $2503: 59
6 & :5C$.<6 :17 6$87 *536/<7.$:/5359:1760/:;.5;7.:49.52:17;8$/3:/99 : /6 *53:73<7< :1$: :17 ;8$/3:/99 C$6 $8C$46 .7$<4 $3< C/88/3@ :5 ;7.95.2 1/6 ;$.: 59 :17 5'8/@$:/536 /7 :5 ;$4 :17 '$8$3*7 *536/<7.$:/53 $2503: $3< C$6 7$@7. :5 @7: :17 6$87 <77<59:176*17<087;.5;7.:4.7@/6:7.7</31/69$=5.5C7=7. :17<7973<$3:;56:;537<:176$2753537;.7:7G:5.$35:17. 73*7:17;8$/3:/99C$6*536:.$/37<:5/6607$87@$835:/*753 ) ) $3< *$887< 0;53 :17<7973<$3: :5 90.3/61 .787=$3: 5./@/3$8<5*0273:659:/:87/3.76;7*:59:176*17<087;.5;7.:4
- 5 -
17<7973<$3:9$/87<:5.7*7/=7:1735:/*7$3</:C$6.7:0.37< C/:1 ;56:$8 61$.$ 3:/2$:/53 <78/=7.7< <55. 85*>7< 35:
*8$/27< *5;4 59 :17 35:/*7 C$6 673: 03<7. 7.:/9/*$:7 59 56:/3@17<7973<$3:.7*7/=7<$*5;459:1735:/*7'0:</<35: .7;84$3<9$/87<:57G7*0:7$.7@/6:7.7<6$87<77<17;8$/3:/99 *53:73<7< :1$: :17 <7973<$3: 1$< 73:7.7< /3:5 $ '/3</3@ *53:.$*: 59 $@.77273: 95. 6$87 /3 .76;7*: 59 :17 60/: 6*17<087 ;.5;7.:4$3<1$<.7*7/=7<$60'6:$3:/$8$<=$3*7$2503:$3< /36:7$< 59 ;7.95.2/3@ 17. ;$.: 59 :17 5'8/@$:/536 03<7. :17 $@.77273:95.6$872$<7$::72;:6:5$8/73$:7:17;.5;7.:4:5 5:17.6 :5 *17$: $3< <79.$0< :17 ;8$/3:/99 3<7. :1767 */.*026:$3*76 :17 ;8$/3:/99 C$6 *536:.$/37< :5 :$>7 6178:7. 03<7. :17 50.: 59 8$C $3< 9/87< $ 60/: 677>/3@ :17 .78/79 59 ;7*/9/*7.95.2$3*7 9:7. 67.=/*7 59 :17 60/: 6022536 :17 <7973<$3: $;;7$.7< :1.50@1 17.
*503678 $3< 9/87< $ C./::73 6:$:7273: 176;7*/9/*$884*53:73<7<:1$::17:/278/2/:95.*52;87:/3@:17 :.$36$*:/53C$6$<2/::7<84:1.77253:169.52:17<$:759:17 $@.77273:95.6$87<$:7< 17;8$/3:/99</<35:615C $3/3*8/3$:/53:5*52;87:7:17:.$36$*:/53$3<:55>$<=$3:$@7
- 6 -
59 :17 5=7.3273: 5:/9/*$:/53 '$33/3@ .7@/6:.$:/53 59 <5*0273:6 .78$:/3@ :5 6;7*/9/7< :4;76 59 ;.5;7.:/76 : /6 $865 *53:73<7< :1$: :17 /@1 50.: 59 $.3$:$>$ 1$< 6:.0*> <5C3 :17 5:/9/*$:/53H 15C7=7. :17 ;8$/3:/99 </< 35: *527 95.C$.< C/:1 :17 '$8$3*7 ;0.*1$67 25374 $3< *52;87:7 :17 :.$36$*:/53 <76;/:7 .7;7$:7< .7F076:6 $3< <72$3<6 '4 :17 <7973<$3:
17 <7973<$3: 6;7*/9/*$884 *53:73<7< :1$: $ 35:/*7 C$6 /6607< 53 ) 673: '4 '5:1 .7@/6:7.7< ;56: $3< :1.50@1 *50./7. :7.2/3$:/3@ :17 $@.77273: 95. 9$/80.7 59 :17 ;8$/3:/99:5*52;87:7:17:.$36$*:/53/3:/27$3<:$>7'$*>:17 $<=$3*7 59 6 & ;$/< '4 :17 ;8$/3:/99 17 ;8$/3:/99 .79067<:5.7*7/=7:1735:/*7673:'4:17.7@/6:7.7<;56:C1/*1 C$6 .7:0.37< C/:1 $ ;56:$8 61$.$ 79067< 17 35:/*7 673: :1.50@1 *50./7. C$6 67.=7< 17.795.7 :17 <7973<$3: *53:73<7<:1$::17$@.77273:<$:7< /635853@7./3 7G/6:73*7 :17 6$27 1$=/3@ '773 =$8/<84 :7.2/3$:7< '4 :17 <7973<$3: 253@ 5:17. @.503<6 617 ;.$47< 95. </62/66$8 59 :1760/:
- 7 -
$67< 53 :17 $'5=7 ;87$</3@6 :17 ./$8 50.: 9.$27< /66076:17;$.:/7687<7=/<73*7$3<<5*0273:6C7.77G1/'/:7< 17 ./$8 50.: =/<7 (0<@273: $3< 7*.77 <$:7< ) D <7*.77< :17 60/: 73*7 :17 <7973<$3: 1$6 9/87< :17 ;.7673: $;;7$803<7.7*:/53+59
503678 ./0'.$12$34$ 60'2/:6 :1$: :17 (0<@273:$3<7*.7759:17./$850.:$.7*53:.$.4:58$C$3< 5;;567<:5:17<5*0273:$.47=/<73*753.7*5.< 7G: 17 60'2/:6 :1$: :/27 C$6 :17 76673*7 59 :17 *53:.$*:$3<:17;8$/3:/99</<35:*52795.C$.<:5@7::176$87 <77< 7G7*0:7< 73*7 :17 <7973<$3: C$6 *536:.$/37< :5 :7.2/3$:7:17$@.77273:53 ) 90.:17.60'2/66/53/62$<7:1$::17;8$/3:/99*508<35: 1$=77395.*7<:17$@.77273:95.6$87<$:7< 503678 =717273:84 *53:73<7< :1$: :17 <7973<$3: 6;7*/9/*$884<73/7<:177G7*0:/535973<5.67273:H*87$.846:$:7< /3 17. *1/79 7G$2/3$:/53 :1$: 617 1$< 37/:17. $99/G7< 17. 6/@3$:0.7 35. 17. :102' /2;.766/53 53 :17 73<5.67273:
- 8 -
73*7:17./$850.:1$67..7</3/397../3@:1$::17<7973<$3: 1$635:6;7*/9/*$884<73/7<17.6/@3$:0.753:1773<5.67273: 60'2/66/53/62$<7:1$::17./$850.:7..7</3158</3@ :1$: :17 <7973<$3: 1$< 17.6789 $<2/::7< .7*7/;: 59 $ 90.:17. $2503:59 6 &53 $3<1$635:6;7*/9/*$884 <73/7< 17. 6/@3$:0.76 $;;7$./3@ 53 G $3< G"9# $3< 173*735/2;5.:$3*7*$3'7$::./'0:7<:5:177=/<73*759 $3< $6:84 17 60'2/:6 :1$: =/7C7< 9.52 $34 $3@87 :17 (0<@273: $3< 7*.77 59 :17 ./$8 50.: /6 03:73$'87 $3< :17 6$27/68/$'87:5'767:$6/<7503678:17.795.760'2/:6:1$: :17$;;7$82$4'7$885C7<$3<:1760/:2$4'7</62/667<3 60;;5.: 59 1/6 *53:73:/53 *503678 ;8$*7< .78/$3*7 53 :17 95885C/3@<7*/6/536- /
// ! !" #$ %
- 9 -
///
" &
' '#
503678 ./1/=$>02$. 95. :17 .76;53<73:6 E06:/9/7<:17(0<@273:$3<<7*.7759:17./$850.:
7G: 17 60'2/:6 :1$: $9:7.
:17 7G7*0:/53 59 :17 $@.77273: 95. 6$87 :17 <7973<$3: .7*7/=7< $ 90.:17. $<=$3*7 $2503: 59 6 & $3< $**5.</3@84 $3 73<5.67273: C$6 2$<753 $3<:17:/27C$67G:73<7<95.$90.:17. :1.77253:169.52:1$:<$4 90.:17. 60'2/66/53 /6 2$<7 :1$: :17 ;8$/3:/99 37=7. .7*7/=7<:177.2/3$:/535:/*7<$:7< ) 503678 =717273:84 *53:73<7< :1$: :17 ;8$/3:/99 C$6 $8C$46.7$<4$3<C/88/3@:5;7.95.21/6;$.:59:17*53:.$*:: /6$86560'2/::7<:1$::17<7973<$3:</<35:/395.2:17;8$/3:/99 $'50: 8/9:/3@ :17 '$3 53 .7@/6:.$:/53 :5 73$'87 :17 ;8$/3:/99 :5 ;7.95.21/6;$.:59:17*53:.$*: $6:84 17 60'2/:6 :1$: :17 $;;788$3: 1$6 35: 2$<7 $34 @.503<6 :5 /3:7.97.7 C/:1 :17 (0<@273: 59 :17 ./$8 50.:
- 10 -
.@/3@5:17.@.503<6*50367860'2/:6:1$::17$;;7$82$4'7 </62/667< 503678 95. :17 .76;53<73:6 ;8$*7< .78/$3*7 53 :17 95885C/3@<7*/6/536- (
"
!%
$) % ' (( ! % ! "
'*' % * %
7$.<:17$.@0273:6$3<;7.067<:17$;;7$8;$;7.6$3< :17.7*5.<6C/:1*$.7 D 1795885C/3@;5/3:6C508<$./6795.*536/<7.$:/53- # 6:17.7$'/3</3@*53:.$*:'7:C773:17;8$/3:/99 $3<:17<7973<$3:I # /<:17<7973<$3:;.5=7:1$:617</<35:6/@3:17 73<5.67273:<$:7< I
- 11 -
)# $6:17<7973<$3:;.7673:7<6099/*/73:7=/<73*7 :5 <72536:.$:7 $ =$8/< :7.2/3$:/53 59 :17 *53:.$*:I B#
17:17. :17 ;8$/3:/99 /6 73:/:87< :5 :17 .78/79 59 ;7*/9/*7.95.2$3*7I , 1/6 7@08$./.6:$;;7$8/69/87<03<7.7*:/53+59 :17 $3< :1/6 50.: /6 :17 9/3$8 50.: 59 9$*:6 C1/*1 /6 7G;7*:7<:5.7$66766:1773:/.75.$8$3<<5*0273:$.47=/<73*7 53 .7*5.< 17 9$*:6 $.7 6099/*/73:84 6$/< $3< <5 35: .7F0/.7 .7/:7.$:/53 3 :1/6 *$67 :17 ;8$/3:/99 607< :5 7395.*7 :17 6;7*/9/*;7.95.2$3*759$53:.$*::57G7*0:7$*53=74$3*7/3 .76;7*:59:1760/:;.5;7.:4 17*$6759:17;8$/3:/99'795.7:17./$850.:C$6:1$:
:17<7973<$3:5997.7<:56788:176*17<087<;.5;7.:4/31/69$=5. 95.17.87@$837*766/:/76H17377<7<$;.5;7.:495.1/6067$3< '7379/: $@.77< :5 ;0.*1$67 :17 6$27 95. $ =$80$'87 *536/<7.$:/53 9.77 9.52 73*02'.$3*76 17 <7973<$3:J6 *$67 C$6 :1$: :17 ;8$/3:/99 C$6 855>/3@ 95. $ ;.5;7.:4 $3< $;;.5$*17<17.:5;0.*1$67:176*17<087<;.5;7.:4:/635:/3 </6;0:7:1$:$9:7.37@5:/$:/536:176$87;./*7C$6$@.77<0;53
- 12 -
$3< 9/G7< $: 6B & $3< $**5.</3@84 $3 $@.77273:95. 6$87 C$6 73:7.7< /3:5 53 : /6 6/@3/9/*$3: :5 35:7 :1$: :17 <7973<$3: 1$6 35: </6;0:7< 17. 6/@3$:0.7 $3< :17 :102' /2;.766/53 53 $@7 56 $3< ) 59 :17 $@.77273: 95.6$87"G#73*7/:*$36$9784'7178<:1$::17.7C$6$ '/3</3@ *53:.$*: '7:C773 :17 ;8$/3:/99 $3< :17 <7973<$3: $3< :/27C$6:1776673*759:17*53:.$*: + 7G: 87: 27 $36C7. :17 /6607 $'50: :17 73<5.67273: 17 ;8$/3:/99 *53:73<7< :1$: :17 <7973<$3: 1$< .7*7/=7<
6 & $3< 7G:73<7< :17 :/27
95. :17 ;7.95.2$3*7 59 :17 *53:.$*: '4 $35:17. :1.77 253:16 73<5.6/3@:176$2753 17<7973<$3:6;7*/9/*$884 <73/7< :17 73<5.67273: '4 *53:73</3@ :1$: 617 1$< 37/:17.
6/@37<:1773<5.67273:35.;0:17.:102';./3:3:1/6$;;7$8 617$<17.7<:5:176$/<*53:73:/53 17 ./=$8 *53:73:/536 $'50: :17 73<5.67273: $.7 35:7< C/:1 *$.7 17 ./$8 50.: 2$.>7< :17 :102' /2;.766/53 $3< :176/@3$:0.759:17<7973<$3:53:17$887@7<73<5.67273:$6 G"7#$3<"<#17:102'/2;.766/53$3<:176/@3$:0.759 :17<7973<$3:53GC7.72$.>7<$6KJKJ$3<K)J'4
- 13 -
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
C./:7 :17 F076:/537< 6/@3$:0.7 2$.>7< $6 G"<# 7 $865 5;/37< :1$: :17 ;7.653 C15 C.5:7 :17 $<2/::7< 6/@3$:0.7 2$.>7<$6B</<35:C./:7:17F076:/537<6/@3$:0.72$.>7<$6 G"@# 17 </6;0:7< :102' /2;.766/53 C$6 7G$2/37< '4 :17 0;7./3:73<73: 59 58/*7 /3@7. ./3: 0.7$0 $</C$8$
- 14 -
73@$80.0$3<$.7;5.:C$660'2/::7<53, )6:$:/3@ :1$: :17 :102' /2;.766/53 9503< $: $@7 56 $3< ) 59 G<57635::$884C/:1:17:102'/2;.766/539503<53:17 3<5.67273: <$:7< 17 522/66/537.A6 .7;5.: C$6$**7;:7<$3</:1$6$::$/37<9/3$8/:417;8$/3:/99</<35:
F076:/53 :17 522/66/537.A6 .7;5.: 3 :17 5.$8 7=/<73*7 :17 <7973<$3:$<2/::7<:1$:17.6/@3$:0.7C$62$.>7<53GH 15C7=7. 617 <73/7< :17 73<5.67273: $3< .7*7/;: 59
6 & $>/3@ 35:7 59 :17 5.$8 7=/<73*7 $3< :17 522/66/537.J6 .7;5.: /: *$3 '7 6$9784 *53*80<7< :1$: :17 <7973<$3:1$6;.5=7<:1$:617</<35:6/@3:1773<5.67273: 73*7 :17 ./$8 50.: *508< 35: 1$=7 ;8$*7< .78/$3*7 53 :17 73<5.67273: 3:17$'673*75973<5.67273::17;$.:/76$.7'503<'4 :17:7.26$3<*53</:/5366:/;08$:7</3:17$@.77273:95.6$87 $3<:1.77253:161$=7'773$885*$:7<95.:17;7.95.2$3*759 :175'8/@$:/536:1$6'773$.@07<53'71$8959:17<7973<$3:
:1$: :17 ;8$/3:/99 </< 35: *527 95.C$.< :5 *52;87:7 :17 :.$36$*:/53H173*7617:7.2/3$:7<:17*53:.$*:53 ) .1/=$>02$.*50367895.:17;8$/3:/9960'2/::7<:1$::17
- 15 -
;8$/3:/99</<35:.7*7/=7:17:7.2/3$:/5335:/*7 @55<<7$859 $.@0273: /6 $<<.7667< $'50: 353.7*7/;: 59 :17 :7.2/3$:/53 35:/*7$3<:1/650.:1$635:7<:176$27C/:1*$.7 6602/3@ $ C1/87 :1$: :17 ;8$/3:/99 C$6 35: /3 .7*7/;: 59 :17 35:/*7 15C7=7. :17 <7973<$3: 90.3/617< $ :.07 *5;4 59 :17 35:/*7 <$:7< ) $853@ C/:1 :17 C./::73 6:$:7273: 3 :17 C./::73 6:$:7273: :17 <7973<$3: 6;7*/9/*$884 *53:73<7< :1$: :17 $@.77273: <$:7< 5=72'7. /6 35 853@7. /3 7G/6:73*7 $6 /: C$6 :7.2/3$:7< '4 17. 0.;./6/3@84 :17 ;8$/3:/99</<35:$273<:17;8$/3:73*7:17*53:73:/53$'50: :17353.7*7/;:59:17:7.2/3$:/5335:/*7206:37*766$./849$/8 206: 6$4 :1$: :17.7 /6 7=/<73*7 :5 60;;5.: :17 <7973<$3:A6 *8$/2$'50::17:7.2/3$:/5359:17*53:.$*:$3<:176$271$6 '773;.5=7<'417. 6 ;7. G :/27 C$6 59 :17 76673*7 59 :17 *53:.$*:H :17 <7973<$3: :7.2/3$:7< :17 $@.77273: 17 $@.77273:95.6$87C$6$'/8$:7.$8*53:.$*:C17.7'5:1;$.:/76 2$<7;.52/676:57$*15:17./3*80</3@:175'8/@$:/53:5/395.2 :17 5:17.
;$.:4 59 6;7*/9/* $*:/536 5. 7=73:65 '7 ;.7*/67 :17.7C$6$'/8$:7.$8$@.77273:C/:1$;$.:/*08$.5'8/@$:/5395. - 16 -
/395.2$:/537G*1$3@7$6$'$353.7@/6:.$:/53C$6/3;8$*7 @.7$:<7$859$.@0273:1$6'773;.7673:7<.7@$.</3@:178/9:/3@ 59:17.7@/6:.$:/53'$317.7*5.<8$*>66099/*/73:7=/<73*7:5 *539/.2 :17 8/9:/3@ 59 :17 .7@/6:.$:/53 '$3 17 <7973<$3: :7.2/3$:7<:17*53:.$*:<07:5:17;8$/3:/99A69$/80.7:5277:/:6 5'8/@$:/536 /3*7 :17 *53:.$*: C$6 :7.2/3$:7< :17 ;8$/3:/99 /6 </673:/:87< 9.52 ;0.60/3@ :17 .727<4 59 6;7*/9/* ;7.95.2$3*777<8766 :5 6$4 :17 :7.2/3$:/53 59 :17 $@.77273: ;.7=73:6 :17 50.: 9.52 @.$3:/3@ 6;7*/9/* ;7.95.2$3*7$6:17*53:.$*:A6:7.2/3$:/5327$36:17*53:.$*:
/6 35 853@7. /3 7997*: $3< *$3A: '7 7395.*7< '4 6;7*/9/* ;7.95.2$3*717.795.7:1760/:/6</62/667<17<7973<$3:/6 </.7*:7< :5 .7903< :17 $<=$3*7 $2503: 59 6 &
" 0;776C5$>165384#:5:17;8$/3:/99C/:1/3537253:1 50367895.:17.76;7*:/=7;$.:/76;8$*7<.78/$3*753:17 <7*/6/536 .797..7< :5 60;.$ 0: <5 35: :1/3> :17 8$C /6 /3 <50': $*1 <7*/6/53 :0.36 53 /:6 5C3 9$*:6 $3< :17 ;.7673: *$67/6$865:76:7</3:178/@1:59:17$95.76$/<<7*/6/536
- 17 -
17(0<@273:$3<7*.77<$:7<) D ;$667< '4:1750.:59% <<8/:4/=/8?766/536(0<@773@$80.0
",#/35+ & /667:$6/<7
7608:$3:84:17 7@08$./.6: ;;7$8/6
)* %#""& # &
/6:5-+85-