Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66880 (KAR)

THE BRANCH MANAGER, THE NATIONAL v. SHARANAPPA AND ANR

MFA/201484/2018 · 2025-12-08

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"" ##$#%#" " &"!$'$($$# $!$((! )*+ $!$((! $!$((! " ! " # $ # % &! & % '( & ! ! % &) &( %'& Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & " # !* $ % +)#$ %! * ! ,! %! ' " ! " # $ # % ,) & % '( ! - 3 - ! % &) &( %' " # !* $ %+)#$ #-$ !%! *#.$ ! ,! !%! ' ' " ! " # $ # % / & % - 4 - '( ! ! % &) &( % ' " # !* $ % +) #$ #-$ %! *#.$ ! ,! %! ' ' & & 0 !'# 1232 -442-53 -62 78529 -:-8;3< - =>??>; @9:?2;< 9-<29 ! ,! 4-3329 8; > %! >%! ! -;9 >!%! ! .A <12 - 5 - 998<8>;-52;8>6 8B85@9:2-;9 -5-.@6-:8#7>631>6< C<12<68.@;-5D$>;<12:6>@;9>758-.858<A ! 12 -7>623-89 =5-8? 42<8<8>;3 E262 78529 .A <12 =5-8?-;<3 E1> E262 46>=2298;: 8; 6@8326 2?4> .2-68;: 62:83<6-<8>; >)!%, 3@3<-8;29 :682B>@3 8;F@6823 8; <12-==892;<>;G )! 62342=<8B25A12<68.@;-5-7<26 =>;389268;:<122;<8622B892;=2>;62=>69-E-6929-3@?>7 3+ % 3!/ % -;9 3! % -5>;: E8<1 8;<2623< -< <12 6-<2 >7 /H 426 -;;@? 76>? <12 9-<2 >7 42<8<8>; <855 62-58I-<8>; 62342=<8B25A 12 <68.@;-5 1-3 1259 <1-<6234>;92;<>3-;9!-62F>8;<5A-;932B26-55A58-.52 <>4-A<12=>?42;3-<8>;-;9<126234>;92;<>!839862=<29 <> 924>38< <12 -7>623-89 =>?42;3-<8>; E8<18; / 9-A3 76>? <12 9-<2 >7 4-338;: >7 <12 -E-69 ::682B29 .A <12 3-89 =>??>; @9:?2;< -;9 -E-69 <12 ;3@6-;=2 =>?4-;A 462726629<1232<1622-442-53 ) 12 ;3@6-;=2 =>?4-;A ?-8;5A =>;<2;929 <1-< <12 B218=52 E-3 - =>;<6-=< =-668-:2 426?8< -;9 @329 -3 - 3<-:2 =-668-:2 -;9 <12 32-<8;: =-4-=8<A 83 >;5A .@< - 6 - 4-332;:263 E262 =-66829 8;=2 <1262 83 B8>5-<8>; >7 <12 <26?3-;9=>;98<8>;3>7<124>58=A<12 ;3@6-;=2=>?4-;A83 ;><58-.52<>4-A<12=>?42;3-<8>; , 2-6;29=>@;325 7>6 <12 -44255-;< 7@6<126 -6:@29 <1-<-34262=<8>;+)#!$>7<12 ><>6218=523=<G 12 =5-8? -?>@;< 83 ?>62 <1-; 3 % 12 -442-5 78529 .A <12 =5-8?-;<3 -62 ?-8;<-8;-.52 ; <12 3<-<2?2;< >7 >.F2=<8>;3 <12 >E;26 >7 <12 B218=52%6234>;92;< >! 1-3 ;>< 46>B29 <12 -552:-<8>;3 -:-8;3<<12968B26 ;<12-.32;=2>76252B-;<9272;=2-.>@< ;>;4>332338;:<12968B8;:58=2;=2-;9<1278;98;:<1-<<1262 -62>;5A<1622=5-8?42<8<8>;3E1262-3<12-9?8<<2938<<8;: =-4-=8<A 83 @4 <> 4-332;:263 -3 426 <12 4>58=A <26?3 =>B2629 @;926 J, 2-6;29 =>@;325 7>6 <12 -44255-;< 625829 @4>; - =8<-<8>; >7 <12 >;D.52 @462?2 >@6< 8; <12 =-32 >7 624>6<29 8; !!" 8; E18=1 8< E-3 1259 <1-< <12 ;3@6-;=2 =>?4-;A 83 - 7 - 58-.52 <> 4-A <12 =>?42;3-<8>; <> <12 58?8<29 ;@?.26 >7 4-332;:263=>B2629@;926<124>58=A <837@6<126=>;<2;929<1-<8;-;892;<8=-5-442-5 8; >) %! G 9834>329 >7 >; , ! / <12 -442-5 -:-8;3< <12 6234>;92;< > E-3 983?83329 12 6234>;92;< >! 989 ;>< <-K2 3<243 7>6 62=-3<8;: >7 <12 833@23 >676-?8;: >7 <12 -998<8>;-5 833@23 .27>62 <12 -3 3@=1 ;>E <12A =-;;>< 62-:8<-<2 <12 833@2 .27>62 <183 >@6<E8<1>@<-;A2B892;=2-;9<1@362L@23<297>6983?833-5 >7<12-442-53 / 12 ?-8; =>;<2;<8>; >7 <12 52-6;29 =>@;325 7>6 <12 6234>;92;<%>E;26 >7 <12 B218=52 83 <1-< <12 32-<8;: =-4-=8<A>7<12>772;98;:B218=5283.@<<12=5-8?42<8<8>;3 -62 78529 >;5A 7>6 <1622 4263>;3%4-332;:263 -3 3@=1 <12 ;3@6-;=2=>?4-;A8358-.52<>4-A<12=>?42;3-<8>; + 2-6;29 =>@;325 7>6 <12 ;3@6-;=2 =>?4-;A =>;<2;929 <1-< <12 =1-6:23122< 83 78529 -:-8;3< <12 968B26 >7<12>772;98;:B218=52@;9262=<8>;>7 ><>6218=523 =< <83<12=-32>7C>D2;=28<83-78<=-32<>>6926 - 8 - 7>64-A-;962=>B26-3426<126-<8>5-899>E;8;<12=-32>7 (,--. ,/0 12 B3 *3/0 .4,1 !,45, ,/0 /1 624>6<298; )+$;426@3-5>7<1262=>693 8<31>E3<1-<<12968B26>7<12>772;98;:B218=52968B2;8< 8; - 6-31 -;9 ;2:58:2;< ?-;;26 -;9 8< <@6;29 <@6<52 >;389268;:<12?-<268-52B892;=2>;62=>69<1262E262) 8;?-<23 8; <12 B218=52 .@< >;5A <1622 4263>;3 1-B2 78529 <12=5-8?42<8<8>; 12 ;3@6-;=2=>?4-;A?-8;5A=>;<2;929<1-< <12 968B26 >7 <12 >772;98;: B218=52 1-3 ;> B-589 -;9 2772=<8B2968B8;:58=2;=2-33@=1<12A-62;><2;<8<5297>6 4-A-;962=>B26A G 183 >@6<78;938<F@3<-;962-3>;-.52<>9862=< <12 ;3@6-;=2 =>?4-;A <> 924>38< <12 -?>@;<3 -3 -E-6929.A<12<68.@;-5E8<18;>;2?>;<176>?<129-<2>7 <183>6926-;9>;3@=1924>38<<12=5-8?-;<3-62426?8<<29 <>E8<196-E<123-89-?>@;<3-5>;:E8<18;<2623<-==6@29 >; 8< -;9 <12 ;3@6-;=2 =>?4-;A 83 -< 58.26<A <> 62=>B26 <123-?276>?<12>E;26>7<12B218=52 - 9 - ==>698;:5A<127>55>E8;:>6926& # #8$ 12-442-53-62-55>E298;4-6<* #88$ 12 ;3@6-;=2 =>?4-;A 83 9862=<29 <> 924>38<<12=>?42;3-<8>;-?>@;<3-E-6929.A<12 <68.@;-5 8; -55 <12 =5-8? 42<8<8>;3 -5>;: E8<1 8;<2623< E8<18; >;2 ?>;<1 76>? <12 9-<2 >7 <183 >6926 -;9 5-<26 62=>B26 <12 3-?2 76>? <12 >E;26 >7<12B218=528;-==>69-;=2E8<15-E* #888$ ; 3@=1 924>38< <12 =5-8?-;<3 -62 426?8<<29 <> E8<196-E <12 -?>@;<3 -5>;: E8<1 8;<2623<-==6@29>;8<* #8B$ 12-?>@;<924>38<29.A<12 ;3@6-;=2 =>?4-;A 83 <> .2 <6-;3?8<<29 <> <12 <68.@;-5 7>6<1E8<1 20 )($$#+ '# 83<>&5>&))