Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66844 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER v. AKASH AND ANR
MFA/200745/2019 · 2025-12-04
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66844 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66844 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! !! "
#$"% &'
#
#
& #
'
! "#$
%%
" &
' % (
) * %
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+ +*
* + %",
* )
) +- +
* +*
) .+ + - &
') % /
(
0-'(
%
%
%
%
,,*
% . # & #
'
) * % + +1
* + %", &
') % (
- 3 -
* )
) +- +
* +*
) .+ + -
&
' % (
(
0-'(
%
%
%
,,*
%
. $
%
+
+ 2
%
2
%%
- 4 -
!
'+ 2
%
(
30"* 45 64789 :; <=8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; E=8@8A5 3* 45 64789 :; <=8 B7A4CA><?>98@ 8B<43> 0-'( 36 <=8
3<3@ 8=4B785 B< ,, '63@ 5=3@< #<=8 B<$( :84>F AFF@48G89 :; <=8 H?9FC8>< A>9 AEA@9 9A<89 DA5589 :; <=8 994<43>A7 8>43@ 4G47 %?9F8 A>9
8C:8@ 4HA;AD?@4> 3,,*4>B8<=8B=A778>F845<3 <=85AC8H?9FC8><:3<=<=8ADD8A75A@8=8A@9<3F8<=8@ A>9B3CC3>H?9FC8><45DA5589
AB<5 F4G4>F @458 <3 <=8 6474>F 36 <=8 ADD8A7 :@4867; 5<A<89 A@8 <=A< 3> "0 A< A:3?< 0+- E=8> IA5= A>9 A>9?@A>F E8@8 D@3B8894>F 6@3C <=84@ =3?58 <3 7A>9:; EA7I 3> <=85498 36 <=8@3A93>?>8 8C:?@>4 8@G4B8 3A9 A< <=A< <4C8 3>8 @?BI :8A@4>F 8F 3
* ,, BAC8 4> A @A5= A>9 >8F74F8>< CA>>8@ 9@4G8> :; 4<5 9@4G8@ A>9 9A5=89 <3 <=8C A5 A @85?7<:3<=687793E>A>95?5<A4>896A<A74>H?@485E=8@84>
- 5 -
IA5= 5?5<A4>89 4>H?@485 A>9 EA5 =35D4<A74J89 A>9 98B8A589A>9?@A>F5?BB?C:89<3<=84>H?@485 - =8B7A4CA><64789AD8<4<43>?>98@8B<43> 36<=8B<588I4>FB3CD8>5A<43>63@<=84>H?@4855?5<A4>89 4><=8@3A9<@A664BABB498><<EA5D78A989<=A<=85D8>< =?F8 AC3?>< <3EA@95 C894BA7 8KD8>585 B3>G8;A>B8 B=A@F85 A>9 3<=8@ @87A<89 B35<5 < EA5 6?@<=8@ D78A989 <=A< <=8 ABB498>< 3BB?@@89 53787; 3> ABB3?>< 36 @A5= A>9 >8F74F8><9@4G4>F36<=83668>94>FG8=4B78:;4<59@4G8@
D3> 58@G4B8 36 >3<4B8 <=8 @85D3>98><5 ADD8A@89<=@3?F=B3?>587A>964789<=84@58DA@A<8E@4<<8> 5<A<8C8><5 98>;4>F <=8 AG8@C8><5 CA98 4> <=8 B7A4C D8<4<43>
" ><=8:A54536<=8D78A94>F536<=8DA@<485<=8 7A4C5@4:?>A76@AC89<=8455?85A>9<=8@8A6<8@@8B3@989 <=8 8G498>B8 =8 @4:?>A7 :; <=8 4CD?F>89 H?9FC8>< A>9AEA@9=A5DA@<7;A773E89<=8B7A4CD8<4<43>A>9=879 <=A< <=8 B7A4CA>< 45 8><4<789 <3 A B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5* A73>F E4<= 4><8@85< A< <=8 @A<8 36 L DA
- 6 -
A>9 94@8B<89 @85D3>98>< 3 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; <3 98D354< <=8 B3CD8>5A<43> AC3?>< A73>F E4<= 4><8@85< 84>F AFF@48G89 <=8 D@858>< ADD8A75 =AG8 :88> 64789 :; <=8>5?@A>B83CDA>;A>9<=8B7A4CA><
=878A@>89B3?>58763@<=8>5?@A>B83CDA>; =A5@A4589<=863773E4>FB3><8><43>5+ A( 4@5<7; A7<=3?F= <=8 B7A4CA>< B7A4C5 <=A< =8 EA5 A 5<?98>< A>9 934>F AF@4B?7<?@A7 E3@I A>9 8A@>4>F 5* D8@ C3><= =8 =A5 >3< D@39?B89 A>; 93B?C8><A@;D@336<=8@836=8@4:?>A7=A5A5585589<=8 4>B3C8>3<43>A77;E=4B=453><=8=4F=8@5498 :( 8B3>97; <=8 @4:?>A7 B3>5498@4>F <=8 4>H?@485 5?5<A4>89:;<=8B7A4CA><A>98G498>B836<=893B<3@=A5 @4F=<7;A5585589<=8E=378:39;945A:474<;A<L B( =4@97; 3> ADD@8B4A<43> 36 3@A7 A>9 93B?C8><A@;
8G498>B8 A>9 B3>5498@4>F <=8 AF8 A>9 AG3BA<43> 36 <=8 98B8A589 <=8 3G8@A77 B3CD8>5A<43> AEA@989 :; <=8 @4:?>A7453><=8=4F=8@5498
- 7 -
9( 3?@<=7;4>@85D8B<3674A:474<;=8B3><8>989<=A<<=8 9@4G8@ 36 <=8 3668>94>F G8=4B78 EA5 =3794>F A 74F=< C3<3@ G8=4B789@4G4>F74B8>B8E4<=#@A>5D3@<$8>93@58C8><E=478 =8EA59@4G4>FA=8AG;C3<3@G8=4B784>B8<=89@4G8@36 <=83668>94>FG8=4B78EA5>3<=3794>FA9@4G4>F74B8>B8<3 9@4G8 <=8 =8AG; C3<3@ G8=4B78 A>9 54>B8 <=8 4>5?@89 =A5 G437A<89 <=8 D374B; B3>94<43> <=8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; 45 >3< 74A:78 <3 DA; A>; B3CD8>5A<43> =8@863@8 =8 B3><8>989 <=A< <=8 @4:?>A7 =A5 8@@89 4> =3794>F <=A< >5?@A>B83CDA>;4574A:78<3DA;<=8B3CD8>5A<43> 8( A5<7;4>74F=<36<=84G4543>8>B=98B4543>36<=45 3?@< 4> <=8 BA58 36 !
" !<=8@A<836 4><8@85< AEA@989 :; <=8 @4:?>A7 A< L DA 3> <=8 B3CD8>5A<43> AC3?>< 45 3> <=8 =4F=8@ 5498 4<= <=8 A:3G8B3><8><43>5<=878A@>89B3?>58753?F=<<3A773E<=8 ADD8A764789:;<=8>5?@A>B83CDA>; - 8 - 0 ><=83<=8@=A>9<=878A@>89B3?>58763@<=8 B7A4CA><=A5@A4589<=863773E4>FB3><8><43>5+ A( 4@5<7; <=8 B7A4CA>< A558@<5 <=A< =8 EA5 AF89 A:3?< ;8A@5 A< <=8 <4C8 36 <=8 ABB498>< A>9 =A9 A C3><=7; 4>B3C8 36 5* :; 934>F AF@4B?7<?@A7 E3@I =8 @4:?>A7 =A5 A5585589 <=8 C3><=7; 4>B3C8 A< 5* E=4B=453><=873E8@5498 :( 8B3>97; 9?8 <3 <=8 ABB498>< <=8 B7A4CA>< =A5 5?668@896@AB<?@836@4F=<78FC894A7CA77437AC6@AB<?@836 @4F=< A>I78 633< A>9 3<=8@ 4>H?@485 8 8KAC4>89 <=8 93B<3@A5 >=458G498>B8<=893B<3@98D3589<=A< B7A4CA>< =A5 5?668@89 F@48G3?5 4>H?@; A>9 A5585589 <=8 D8@CA>8><945A:474<;A<"L<3L<3<=8786<73E8@74C: =8 @4:?>A7 =A5 B3>5498@89 <=8 D8@CA>8>< 6?>B<43>A7 945A:474<;A<LE=4B=453><=873E8@5498 B( =4@97;9?8<3<=8ABB498><<=8B7A4CA><=A55?668@89 F@48G3?5 4>H?@485 A>9 =8 EA5 A9C4<<89 <3 <=8 =35D4<A7 A5 4>DA<48><63@AD8@43936,9A;58=A55?668@89A73<36 - 9 - DA4> 9?@4>F <=8 <@8A<C8>< 8 =A5 <3 5?668@ <=45 ?>=ADD4>855<=@3?F=3?<=457468 9( 3>5498@4>F <=8 8G498>B8 36 93B<3@ A>9 CA<8@4A7 3> @8B3@9 <=8 B3CD8>5A<43> AEA@989 :; <=8 @4:?>A7 ?>98@ <=8 =8A95 36 DA4> A>9 5?668@4>F 7355 36 AC8>4<485 A>9 3<=8@4>B498><A78KD8>585A@83><=873E8@54988>B8=8 53?F=< 63@ A773E4>F <=8 ADD8A7 :; 8>=A>B4>F <=8 B3CD8>5A<43> 8( 3?@<=7; 8G8> <=3?F= <=45 3?@< =879 <=A< 9@4G8@ 36 <=83668>94>FG8=4B78EA5>3<=AG4>FAGA749A>98668B<4G8 9@4G4>F 74B8>B8 4> @85D8B< 36 B7A4CA>< 45 B3>B8@>89 <=8 >5?@A>B83CDA>;=A5<3DA;<=8B3CD8>5A<43>AC3?>< E4<= 74:8@<; <3 @8B3G8@ <=8 5AC8 6@3C <=8 3E>8@ 36 <=8 3668>94>FG8=4B78 6( A5<7; B3>5498@4>F <=8 AF8 A>9 AG3BA<43> 36 <=8 98B8A589 <=8 3G8@A77 B3CD8>5A<43> AEA@989 :; <=8 @4:?>A7453><=873E8@5498A>9<=8@863@8=853?F=<63@ 945C455A736<=8ADD8A764789:;<=8>5?@A>B83CDA>; - 10 - , 8A@9 <=8 78A@>89 B3?>587 63@ <=8 DA@<485 A>9 D8@?589<=8H?9FC8><A>9AEA@936<=8@4:?>A7 < 45 >3< 4> 945D?<8 <=A< IA5= 5?5<A4>89 F@48G3?5 4>H?@485 4> <=8 @3A9 <@A664B ABB498>< 3BB?@@89 3> "0 9?8 <3 @A5= A>9 >8F74F8>< 9@4G4>F 36 <=8 3668>94>FG8=4B78:;4<59@4G8@ > @85D8B< 36 74A:474<; 45 B3>B8@>89 4< 45 >3< 4> 945D?<8 <=A< 9@4G8@ 36 <=8 3668>94>F G8=4B78 EA5 =AG4>F A 9@4G4>F 74B8>B8<3 9@4G8 A <@A>5D3@<G8=4B78 < EA5 455?89 3> 00 A>9 GA749 <477 00 63@ <@A>5D3@< G8=4B78>G48E36B3>5498@4>F<=8H?9FC8><36<=453?@< 4> <=8 BA58 36 #$# %&' ( )* +&, - -./0<=8@4:?>A7=A5 @4F=<7;=879<=A<9@4G8@36<=83668>94>FG8=4B78EA5=AG4>F A GA749 A>9 8668B<4G8 9@4G4>F 74B8>B8 <3 9@4G8 A <@A>5D3@< G8=4B78 A>9 @4F=<7; 64K89 <=8 74A:474<; 3> <=8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; =8 B7A4CA>< B7A4C5 <=A< =8 EA5 8A@>4>F 5* D8@ C3><= ?< =8 =A5 >3< D@39?B89 A>; - 11 - 93B?C8>< <3 5?:5<A><4A<8 =45 B7A4C =8@863@8 4> <=8 A:58>B8 36 D@336 36 4>B3C8 >3<43>A7 4>B3C8 =A5 <3 :8 A5585589 BB3@94>F <3 <=8 F?49874>85 455?89 :; <=8 )A@>A<AIA <A<8 8FA7 8@G4B85 ?<=3@4<; 63@ ABB498><5 3BB?@@894><=8;8A@>3<43>A74>B3C85=A77:8<AI8> A<5,0"* DC 5 D8@ E3?>9 B8@<464BA<8 <=8 B7A4CA>< =A5 5?5<A4>896@AB<?@836@4F=<78FC894A7CA77437AC6@AB<?@8 36 @4F=< A>I78 633< A>9 3<=8@ 4>H?@485 AI4>F 4><3
B3>5498@A<43> <=8 98D354<43> 36 <=8 93B<3@ A>9 4>H?@485 C8><43>89 4> <=8 945A:474<; B8@<464BA<8 A>9 B3>5498@4>F =45 AG3BA<43> AF8 E8 A@8 36 <=8 3D4>43> <=A< E=378 :39; 945A:474<;BA>:8A5585589A<,L=8B7A4CA><EA5AF89 ;8A@5 A< <=8 <4C8 36 <=8 ABB498>< A>9 C?7<4D748@ ADD74BA:78 <3 =45 AF8 F@3?D 45 #,$ =?5 <=8 B7A4CA>< 45 8><4<789 63@ B3CD8>5A<43> 36 ( ## & '5,0"MM,M,L( 3> ABB3?>< 36 27355 36 6?<?@8 4>B3C82 - 12 - - =8 >A<?@8 36 4>H?@485 4>94BA<85 <=A< <=8 B7A4CA><C?5< =AG8 :88>?>98@@85< A>9 <@8A<C8><63@ A D8@439 36 - C3><=5 3>58N?8><7; <=8 B7A4CA>< 45 8><4<789 63@ B3CD8>5A<43> 36 ( ) & '5,0"M- C3><=5( ?>98@ <=8 =8A9 #7355 36 4>B3C8 9?@4>F 7A49 ?D D8@439$ ?8 <3 <=8 ABB498><<=8B7A4CA><=A5 5?668@89 F@48G3?54>H?@485A>9A753?>98@F3>85?@F8@;3>5498@4>F <=8 D@373>F89 DA4> 9?@4>F <@8A<C8>< A5 E877 A5 <=8 6?>B<43>A7945A:474<;B8@<46489:;<=893B<3@E8A@84>B74>89 <3 8>=A>B8 <=8 B3CD8>5A<43> AEA@989 :; <=8 @4:?>A7 ?>98@ <=8 =8A9 36 2DA4> A>9 5?668@4>F52 6@3C 5* <3( &A>9?>98@<=8=8A9362735536AC8>4<485 A>96?<?@8?>=ADD4>85526@3C5* <3( *& " 3>5498@4>F <=8 >A<?@8 36 4>H?@485 <=8 B3CD8>5A<43>AEA@989:;<=8@4:?>A7?>98@3<=8@=8A95 45H?5<A>9@8A53>A:78 =?5 <=8 B7A4CA>< 45 8><4<789 <3 <=8 63773E4>F B3CD8>5A<43>+ - 13 - +,-./(012+/3/4.5 4266.5./1.04( (07054.4 891:. 5283/0; $( % (07054.4 891:2(+351 $( % A4>A>95?668@4>F5
894BA78KD8>585
355368A@>4>F9?@4>F 7A49?DD8@439
" 355366?<?@88A@>4>F3> ABB3?><36D8@CA>8>< 945A:474<; 000
" 35536AC8>4<485A>9 6?<?@8?>=ADD4>855
- <<8>9A><948< B3>G8;A>B8A>93<=8@ B=A@F85
+10; #
)
)#
0 ><=8@85?7<<=863773E4>F3@98@45DA5589+
A( =8ADD8A75A@80;;+7.42/-051 :( =8H?9FC8><36<=87A4C5@4:?>A745C3946489 B( =8 B7A4CA>< 45 8><4<789 <3 A <3<A7 B3CD8>5A<43> 36 ( )#& 9( 3773E4>F<=8H?9FC8><36<=84G4543>8>B=36<=45 3?@<4><=8BA5836< !='5?D@A(<=8
- 14 -
8>=A>B89 B3CD8>5A<43> 5=A77 BA@@; 4><8@85< A< L DA 8( =8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; 45 94@8B<89 <3 98D354< <=8 B3CD8>5A<43> AC3?>< A73>F E4<= 4><8@85< O L DA 6@3C <=8 9A<8 36 6474>F 36 <=8 B7A4C D8<4<43><477<=89A<836@8A74JA<43>E4<=4>AD8@43936 54K E88I5 6@3C <=8 9A<8 36 @8B84D< 36 B3D; 36 <=45 H?9FC8><
4& $ % ! 4& $! "% ! 45< 3+7 3+",