- 1 - ! "# $ %#& $ %#& "&'" $$ ($)$ * + ! " #$ " % " $ " &#!'! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ " ' " &#!'! ( %) " &#!'! %* " &#!'! " %! &#!'! * " " +#*!'! # " " &#!'! , ! # , ) , , " , %) %'!) , - 3 - , $ " , , , $ -, " , , " . . &# . /0123342501605478974:4;<0=9)=6 60547>? </4 35209<066 ;/25549@09@ </4 A87@B49< 297 74;:44 72<47 !'(%'%( 321147 09 =%) %'!) >? 490=: 0C05 87@4D,0972@0 % /4 35209<066 /21 60547 2 180< 6=: 32:<0<0=9 297 1432:2<4 3=114110=9 09 =%) %'!)</4180<;2B4 <= >4 255=E47 32:<5? >? A87@B49< 297 74;:44 72<47 - 4 - !'(%'%( 409@ 2@@:04C47 >? </4 12B4 </4 35209<066 /2160547</01233425 $ 6<4: 14:C0;4 =6 9=<0;4 <= :413=9749<1 09 </01 233425</432:<0412:4:43:4149<47>?</40:;=891451297 60547 2 ;=B3:=B014 34<0<0=9 8974: :74: %$ 854 $ E !!=6 ( 55</432:<0412:43:4149<>46=:4</01=8:<297 /2C4 >449 0749<06047 >? </40: :4134;<0C4 ;=891451 /4 32:<041 /2C4 2@:447 <= </4 14<<54B49< 21 34: </4 ;=B3:=B014 34<0<0=9 "4 2:4 12<016047 E0</ </4 ;=B3:=B014 49<4:47 09<= >4<E449 </4 32:<041 /4 ;=B3:=B01434<0<0=9014F<:2;<47>45=E ,#$# $ )+ !!' $!- ! ,=: </4 12G4 =6 ;=9C49049;4 </4 32:<041 /4:409 1/255>4:464::47<=09 <4:B1=6</40::29G2971<2<81 >46=:4</4:025=8:<09 =%) %'!) =9 </4 6054 =6490=:0C0587@4297, % /01:4@852:14;=972334250160547>?</4 5209<066 ;/25549@09@</4 A87@B49< 297 74;:44 72<47 - 5 - !'(%'%(32114709 =%) %'!)=9</4 6054 =6 </4 490=: 0C05 87@4 297 , 2< 970 32:<5? 74;:4409@ </4 ;=89<4: ;520B =6 74649729< =$ 74;52:09@</2<74649729<=!<=/2C09@! </1/2:4 09</43:=34:<041741;:0>4709;/47854+=635209<297 3:=34:<041 2< =! <= * =6 E:0<<49 1<2<4B49< 60547 >?</474649729<=$ $ /2< 35209<066 297 255 </4 74649729<1 2:4 54@25 /40:1 297 >45=9@ <= </4 ;=BB=9 29;41<=: 74;42147 2552332 2<05E/=</4/81>297=6</44649729<=! ( /4 74649729<1 :413=9749<1 2:4 14:C47 E0</ 9=<0;41 297 784 <= 09<4:C49<0=9 =6 4574:1 297 E455 E01/4:1 =6 </4 35209<066 297 </4 74649729<1 /2C4 B8<8255?2@:447<=14<<54</470138<42B0;2>5?>?E2? =6 ;=B3:=B014 /4 32:<041 <= </4 3:=;44709@1 /2C4 14<<547</470138<42< </40: =E9 E055 297 7410:4 E0</=8< >409@ 0965849;47 >? </:42<H ;=4:;0=9 =: B01:43:4149<2<0=9 /4 32:<041 <= </4 233425 /2C4 2@:447<=:478;4</40:<4:B1 =6 8974:1<29709@ 09 </4 6=:B=63:4149<;=B3:=B01434<0<0=9 /2< </4 32:<041 <= </4 233425 /2C4 2@:447 <= 14<<54255</470138<41>? </40: =E9 ;=9149< 297 /2C48974:1<==7</4<4:B1=6</43:4149<;=B3:=B014 297/2C438<</40::4134;<0C410@92<8:4 /2< 23345529< 35209<066 297 255 </4 :413=9749<1 74649729<1 18>B0<1 ;=B3:=B014 34<0<0=9 3:2?09@ </01 =9.>54 =8:< >4 354214 <= :4;=:7 </4 - 6 - 3:4149< ;=B3:=B014 297 74;:44 </4 233425 09 </4 <4:B1=6</46=55=E09@ ;=B3:=B014>4<E44932:<041 * /2<</012334250160547>?3345529< 5209<0669 C04E =6 </4 6=55=E09@ ;=B3:=B014 </4 3:=34:<041 1/=E909;/47854+>45=E2:425:427?093=114110=9 =6 5209<066 297 /01 1=91 E064 297 9=E 4F;5810C45? @0C49<= </41/2:4297<0<54=6 5209<066A=09<5?E0</255 :4B20909@ 1 =6 35209<066 >:29;/ 297 @0C49 83 18::4974: /01 49<0:4 1/2:4 09 </4 ;/47854+ D 3:=34:<041<=74649729<1%<=:4134;<0C45? ./$$ 0$123145367883944:36:713$875945 (#7:79436: )7887227$7458; 8 ") )$84 <4394 =13(*>947 (* '5887?3 78>@7 56415=4 ! %% !( (+!* 970 970 0A2?238: % $#$ %+ =8< =6 '(+ 9;58709@ !89<2 2:2> <=E2:71 E41< 1074 970 970 0A2?238: $ 5=< =(# =8<=6 =$%' ''!'!% /0:129@ 970 0A2?238: ( 5=< =* =8<=6 =$%' ''!'!% /0:129@ 970 0A2?238: 5=< =# =8< IJ KLIM$%' ''!'!% /0:129@ 970 0A2?238: 5=< =$ =8< =6 IJ KLIM$%' ''!'!% /0:129@ 970 0A2?238: * 5=< =* =8<=6 =$%' ''!'!'! /0:129@ 970 0A2?238: - 7 - 8 ") )$84 <4394 =13(*>947 (* '5887?3 78>@7 56415=4 # 5=< =# =8<=6 =$%' ''!'!'! /0:129@ 970 0A2?238: ) 5=< =%* =8<=6 =$%' ''!'!'! /0:129@ 970 0A2?238: # /4 3:=34:<041 1/=E9 09 >45=E ;/47854+ >45=E 2:425:427?093=114110=974649729<$2 <=$7 297 9=E 0< 01 4F;5810C45? @0C49 <= </4 1/2:4 297 <0<54 =6 74649729< = $2 <= $7 A=09<5? 297 @0C49 83 18::4974: </40: 49<0:4 1/2:4 09 </4 ;/47854+ 3:=34:<041 <= 35209<066 297 ;/47854+ 3:=34:<041 <= 74649729<=%(297:4134;<0C45? %A$$" 0$123145367883944:36:7133629B394(7* 339B794(7*4(B*($13C78747 :1336:758 $15D79@7E56:F717D7*; 5 = 5=< = F<49< ;:4 89<2 0552@4 258G2 01<:0;< ! $#% ! %+%* 970 970 0A2?238: % (' #( % 5=< =#( % ('-%' 970 970 0A2?238: )/43:=34:<?1/=E909>45=E;/47854+>45=E0109 3=114110=9=6 5209<0662979=E%;:4=8<=6(;:4 89<21<=E2:7121<014F;5810C45?@0C49<=</41/2:4 <0<542973=114110=9=674649729<1=%(297>? 70C010=9 21 1/=E9 >45=E 09 ;/47854+ 297 </4 - 8 - 74649729< = % ( 297 /2C4 @0C49 83 18::4974: </40: 49<0:4 1/2:4 09 2>=C4 ;/47854+ :=34:<041 =6 35209<066 297 ;/47854+ 3:=34:<041 =6 74649729< = $2 <=7 %A$$" 0$123145367883944:36:713339B794 79B (6:7:71745E#79G>87; 5 = 5=< = F<49<;:4 89<2 0552@4 258G2 01<:0;< ! $#$ %;:4=8<=6 '(;:4+ 89<21 =E2:71 21<4:9074 970 970 0A2?238: ) /2< </435209<066/4:409012@:447<=542C4 @0C4 2 ;2:<E2?09/011/2:4=6</4?=$#$=69700552@4 970258G01<:0;<0A2?238:B4218:09@%+=8<=6 ( <=E2:71 E41< <= 421< 09 </4 9=:</ 1074 =6 </4 3:=34:<? 297 74649729< = % ( 297 /2C4 251= 2@:447<=542C4 @0C4 2;2:<E2?09</40:1/2:4=6</4 ?= $#$ =6 970 0552@4 970 258G 01<:0;< 0A2?238:B4218:09@%+'=8<=6(<=E2:71E41< <=421<09</49=:</1074=6</43:=34:<?<=233:=2;/ </4 3:=34:<041 =6 74649729<1 = % ( 297 297 <= 74649729< =$2 <= 7 255=<<47 1/2:4 5297 09 ?=$#% ! =6 970 0552@4 701<:0;< 0A2?238: B4218:09@ %+%* /2< 32:<041 /4:409 /2C4 9= =>A4;<0=91 <= 49<4: </4 1207 ;2:< E2? 09 </4 C0552@4 B23 >? :4C4984 28</=:0<041 >? 40</4: =6 </4 32:<041. 23350;2<0=9,8:</4:</432:<0411/2559=<=>1<:8;<</4 ;2:< E2? 42;/ =</4: 6=: 814 297 6:445? B=C4B49< =6 - 9 - 2@:0;85<8:4 3:=78;<1 297 =</4: 38:3=14 09 :4134;< =6 </4;2:<E2?B49<0=947/4:409 !'/2<</474649729<=!01</4E064=674;42147 2552332 2<05 297 1207 2552332 2<05 E21 =C< :0B2:? 42;/4: 297 26<4: /01 742</ </4 74649729< =! 01 :4;40C09@ </4 34910=9 6:=B =C4:9B49< 49;4 74649729< =! /21 :4509N801/47 /4: 1/2:4 09<4:41< 297 :0@/<1 09 </4 180< 1;/47854 3:=34:<041 09 62C=8: =6 35209<066 297 =</4: 74649729<.1 = % <= /4:409 21 2>=C4 1207 /2< 09 ;=91074:2<0=9 =6 :4509N801/09@/4:1/2:409<4:41<297:0@/<109</4180< 1;/47854 3:=34:<041 </4 35209<066 297 74649729< =% <= 4N8255? 1/255 <2G4 ;2:4 =6 :410749;4 E455 >409@ /425</50C450/==7=6</474649729<=! !! /2< </4 2>=C4 ;=B3:=B014 2::0C47 2< >46;:4 4574:5?34:1=912970<016=:</4>49460<29709<4:41<=6 255 </4 32:<041 <= </01 233425 <=E2:71 6855 297 60925 14<<54B49< 09 :4134;< =6 255 180< 1;/47854 3:=34:<041 1/=E9 09 2:2 = # 994F8:4+ =6 </4 A87@B49< 09 %) %'!) =6 =9 </4 6054 =6 490=: 0C05 87@4 297 ,970 !% 09;4 , = !! %'%( 01 349709@ >46=:4 </4 490=: 0C05 87@4 297 , 297 </4 32:<041 /4:409 1/25518>B0<</01;=B3:=B01434<0<0=9297</474;:44 321147 09 </01 60:1< 233425 >46=:4 </4 , =8:< 6=: 3:=;44709@12977:2E6092574;:4409</4<4:B1=6</01 ;=B3:=B01449<4:47>4<E449</432:<041/4:409 - 10 - !$/432:<041<=</4233425 ;=B3:=B01434<0<0=92:4 49<0<547 <= :4;=:7 </4 B8<2<0=91 =6 </4 :4134;<0C4 3:=34:<041@0C49<=</40:1/2:409</40:92B412134: </42>=C4<4:B1=6</4;=B3:=B0146=:E/0;/29? =6 </432:<041<=</01233425/2C49=29?=>A4;<0=91297 1/255>42:</40:=E9;=1<1O /4 2>=C4 233425 01 7013=147 =6 09 <4:B1 =6 ;=B3:=B01434<0<0=9 660;4 01 70:4;<47 <= 7:2E 60925 74;:44 09 <4:B1 =6 ;=B3:=B01434<0<0=9 B) ($ * & B) ("&'"* & 01<=!5=!%