- 1 - !" # $ % %% &"' ( !"#" $ %% & ' ( ) " ' ' * '" !"#" ' ' '+#+ %! '% %% '% '( * "#" $ % & ' ' ( , ( #-#"#" ") ' "-+&")( % ) ' (-#"' ' % (* * Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ' %% ' * " #-#" % ( -#" % (* * ' ' % .! ' ./ ###### '"/ ' %% ' * ( ' '0 *% ' $ " 123 455647 23 58696886: ;< =16 >742?4@= 4A42@3= =16 *B:A?6@= 4@: 4C48: :4=6: " #-#" 2@ ( D-#" ;< =16 ::2=2D@47 4@: %82@>2547 6@2D8 2E27*B:A64@: * 2:48&9D8 31D8= F=16 =82;B@47G) 366H2@A 6@14@>6?6@=D9=16>D?56@34=2D@ 16 2@IB86: >742?4@= 9276: >742? 56=2=2D@ ;69D86 =16 =82;B@47 366H2@A >D?56@34=2D@ D9 3###### 47D@A C2=1 2@=6863= 4= =16 84=6 D9 " / 568 4@@B? 16 =82;B@47 49=68 >D@32:682@A =16 6@=286 6E2:6@>6 D@ 86>D8: 4C48:6: 3B? D9 3 .! 47D@A C2=12@=6863= 4= =16 84=6 D9 / 568 4@@B? 98D? =16 :4=6 D9 56=2=2D@ =277 =16 :4=6 D9 86472J4=2D@ AA826E6:;<=16342:*B:A?6@=4@:4C48:=16 >742?4@=58696886:=1658636@=4556474@:?42@7<>D@=6@:6: - 3 - =14= =16 4?DB@=3 A84@=6: B@:68 =16 *B:A?6@= 4@: 4C48: 4864:6KB4=6 + =233=4=6:=14==16>742?4@=C43648@2@A43B? D9 3!###;<74;DB8CD8H4@:16C43<648343D@=16 :4=6 D9 =16 4>>2:6@= 16 D>=D8 4336336: =16 :234;272=< 4= !/ =D =16 82A1= 72?; ;B= =16 =82;B@47 >D@32:686: #/ 2@>6=16>742?4@=2343H2776:74;DB86816>4@@D=:D74;DB8 CD8H49=68=164>>2:6@=4@:=1B3=169B@>=2D@47:234;272=<23 =D ;6 =4H6@ 4= "##/ B8=168 7648@6: >DB@367 9D8 =16 >742?4@=4556774@=3B;?2=3=14==164?DB@=3A84@=6:B@:68 :299686@= 164:3 486 ?64A68 4@: =16869D86 86KB63=3 9D8 6@14@>6?6@=D9=16>D?56@34=2D@ ! 1DBA1 =16 >742?4@= 143 3=4=6: =14= 16 C43 648@2@A 4 3B? D9 3!### 16 143 @D= 58D:B>6: 4@< 2@>D?6 58DD9 '6 ?6= C2=1 4>>2:6@= D@ #.##" 3 568 =16 AB2:672@63 D9 =16 48@4=4H4 =4=6 6A47 68E2>63 B=1D82=< 9D8 =16 <648 #" 123 2@>D?6 23 =D ;6 =4H6@ 4= 3 ### 568 ?D@=1 16 >742?4@= 143 58D:B>6: CDB@: >68=292>4=6 ?48H6: 4= L%! 16 CDB@: >68=292>4=6 31DC3 - 4 - =14= =16 >742?4@= 3B99686: >8B31 2@IB8263 =D 82A1= 4@H6 ?643B82@A "#M. >? >B= 4@: 74>684=6: 2@IB8263 =D 82A1= 76A ?643B82@A!M+4@:!M>?>D?5DB@:984>=B86D9=2;244@: 92;B74 :6A7DE2@A 82A1= 4@H76 4@: 984>=B86 D9 @: 4@: !=1 ?6=4=48347D982A1=9DD=16>742?4@=143@D=58D:B>6:=16 M84< 865D8= 3 568 =16 :234;272=< >68=292>4=6 ?48H6: 4= L%" =16 D>=D8 D;368E6: =14= =16 >742?4@= 3B99686: 16476: D5684=2E6 3>4 DE68 82A1= 76A 4@: 9DD= =6@:68@633 58636@=4@=47A2>A42=58636@=31D8=6@2@AD9>?358636@= 3 568 =16 4:2D7DA< 865D8= :4=6: #.#"#" =1686 23 ?47B@2=6:984>=B86D9=2;244@:92;B74D@32:682@A=164;DE6 4356>=3 =123 DB8= 92@:3 2= 8643D@4;76 =D >D@32:68 =16 :234;272=<4= /2@3=64:D9#/ '6@>6 =167D33 D9 9B=B86 648@2@A>454>2=<;643B@:68 3 ###M"M"M/N 3+.#### 16 =82;B@47 4C48:6: 4 3B? D9 3!".! =DC48:3?6:2>476L56@363C12>1@66:3@D2@=689686@>616 >742?4@= C43 1D352=472J6: 9D8 " :4<3 D@32:682@A =16 @4=B86 D9 2@IB8263 D>>B54=2D@ D9 =16 >742?4@= 4@: D=168 - 5 - 8676E4@=94>=D83=123DB8=92@:32=8643D@4;76=DA84@=43B? D9 3-### =DC48:3 542@ 4@: 3B99682@A3 3B? D9 3### =DC48:3 7D33 D9 4?6@2=263 4@: 4 3B? D9 3! ###=DC48:37D33D92@>D?6:B82@A742:B55682D:23 47864:< 4C48:6: ;< =16 =82;B@47 16@>6 @66:3 @D 2@=689686@>6123DB8=92@:32=8643D@4;76=D4C48:43B?D9 3+#### =DC48:3 =84@35D8=4=2D@ 6L=84 @DB8231?6@= 4@: 4==6@:4@=>148A63'6@>6=16=D=47>D?56@34=2D@CDB7:;6 43B@:68 ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /412 " D33D99B=B862@>D?6 3+.#### %42@4@:3B99682@A3 3-### + D33D94?6@2=263 3### ! D33D92@>D?6:B82@A742:B5 5682D: 3! ### 84@35D8=4=2D@ 6L=84 @DB8231?6@= 4@: 4==6@:4@= >148A63 3+#### . 6:2>476L56@363 3!".! 2+) - 5 . 16>742?4@=236@=2=76:9D8=D=47>D?56@34=2D@D9 3#.! 47D@A C2=1 2@=6863= 4= =16 84=6 D9 ./ 568 4@@B?98D?=16:4=6D956=2=2D@=277=16:4=6D986472J4=2D@43 4A42@3= 3 .!4C48:6:;<=16=82;B@47 - 6 - - 648@6: >DB@367 9D8 =16 @3B84@>6 >D?54@< 3B;?2=3 =14= =16 @3B84@>6 >D?54@< 143 :65D32=6: =16 >D?56@34=2D@ 4?DB@= 47D@A C2=1 2@=6863= 4C48:6: ;< =16 =82;B@47 >>D8:2@A7<=169D77DC2@A &2) 1645564723477DC6:2@548=, &22) 16 >742?4@= 23 6@=2=76: 9D8 =D=47 >D?56@34=2D@D9 3#.!47D@AC2=12@=6863= 4= =16 84=6 D9 ./ 568 4@@B? 98D? =16 :4=6 D9 56=2=2D@ =277 =16 :4=6 D9 86472J4=2D@ 43 4A42@3= 3 .!4C48:6:;<=16=82;B@47, &222) 16 @3B84@>6 >D?54@< 23 :286>=6: =D :65D32==166@14@>6:>D?56@34=2D@D9 3"### 47D@A C2=1 2@=6863= C2=12@ 4 5682D: D9 D@6 ?D@=1 98D?=16:4=6D9=12356=2=2D@, - 7 - &2E) @ 3B>1 :65D32= =16 >742?4@= 23 568?2==6: =D C2=1:84C =16 6@=286 >D?56@34=2D@ 4?DB@=47D@AC2=12@=6863=4>>8B6:D@2= -,5 &% ' $ (' 23=D"7D+#