- 1 - ! "#$## #% &'(&)*+,&** - ! "#$ % &' ( ! ' #) * ** ! #$ % &' ( ! + *&(+&( # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ## + ' & ( + ' ! $$$ ' $# ! ! + $)$$# ' !+ ! $ $ + !! + ++ ' + ' ! , , ! +! ! ! -'! !! & -'! !!( ./0123456/78/94:4562/3434564:;4</7=>3./100?:/7 1::14<46@3./0560?88/63A?7@B/63:8/67/8/7=>3./5?83: =/<5C C./8/46 3./ 2/343456/8 100?:/7 4: 0569403/7 ;58 3./ 5;;/60/ 2?64:.1=</ ?67/8 /03456 5; /@5341=</ 6:38?B/63:03&;58:.583D 03D(1674::/63/60/735 ?67/8@5:4B2</4B284:56B/63;583.8//B563.:1673521> 1 ;46/ 5; :*$$$ 46 7/;1?<3 35 ?67/8@5 :4B2</ 4B284:56B/63;583.8//B563.: - 3 - +58 3./ :1E/ 5; 0569/64/60/ 3./ 21834/: 18/ 8/;/88/718/351:2/83./48816E46@=/;58/3./3841<5?83 ./;103:</1746@353./01:/18/1:?67/8 ./ 05B2<146163 46:343?3/7 1 284913/ 05B2<1463 ?67/8 /03456 $$ 5; 3./ 57/ 5; 84B461< 850/7?8/ * 1<</@46@ 05BB4::456 5; 16 5;;/60/ 2?64:.1=</ ?67/8 /034565;3./ /@5341=</6:38?B/63:03 ./ 01:/ 5; 3./ 05B2<146163 46 =84/; 4: 3.13 3./ 100?:/7 =/46@ C/<< 10F?1463/7 C43. 3./ 05B2<146163 1228510./7 .4B;581.167<5165;$$$$$ "C.40.C1:179160/7 13 140.?8 56 $$ 6 10E65C</7@B/63 5; .1946@ 8/0/49/73./:147:?B3./100?:/7/G/0?3/71285B4::58> 653/ 46 ;195?8 5; 3./ 05B2<146163 ?67/831E46@ 35 8/21> 3./ <516 1B5?63 C43. 463/8/:3 13 3./ 813/ 5; H 2/8 166?B/:243/8/2/13/7581<7/B167:1671C8433/6</@1< 65340/ 713/7 *$*$ 3./ 100?:/7 ;14</7 35 74:0.18@/ 3./<41=4<43>:3./5?3:316746@1B5?63460<?746@463/8/:3 :3557 13 *$$$ " 3./ 05B2<146163 4::?/7 1 :/0567 - 4 - </@1< 65340/ 56 $$$$ 3.85?@. 7/B16746@ 8/21>B/63 # 6 8/:256:/ 35 3./ :147 65340/ 3./ 100?:/7 4::?/7 1 0./F?/ =/1846@ 5$$$$$ 713/7 )$$ 781C6 56 + '16E 140.?8 '8160. ;58 1 :?B 5; *$$$ "46;195?85;3./05B2<1461635C/9/8C./6 3./ 05B2<146163 28/:/63/7 3./ :147 0./F?/ ;58 /601:.B/6343C1:8/3?86/7?62147C43.16/6758:/B/63 467401346@ I46:?;;404/63 ;?67:J 46 3./ 1005?63 5; 3./ 100?:/7 56:/F?/63<> 3./ 05B2<146163 01?:/7 4::?160/ 5;1:313?358>65340/713/7$$?67/80<1?:/&=(5; 3./28594:535/034565;3./ 0301<<46@?2563./ 100?:/7 35 B1E/ 21>B/63 5; 3./ 0./F?/ 1B5?63 C43.46 3./28/:084=/7:313?358>2/8457460/3./100?:/7;14</735 05B2<> 3./ 05B2<146163 C1: 056:38146/7 35 ;4</ 3./ 28/:/63 284913/ 05B2<1463 ?67/8 /03456 $$ 5; 8 ://E46@ 285:/0?3456 5; 3./ 100?:/7 ;58 3./ 5;;/60/ 2?64:.1=</?67/8/034565;3./ 03 - 5 - 256:/8940/5;:?BB56:3./100?:/7/63/8/7 122/18160/ 167 0563/:3/7 3./ 2850//746@: ?846@ 3./ 05?8:/ 5; 3841< 3./ 05B2<146163 /63/8/7 3./ C436/:: =5G 1678/43/813/73./19/8B/63:5;3./05B2<14632857?046@ 3./584@461< 0./F?/ =16E /6758:/B/63285B4::58> 653/ 1670524/:5;3./</@1<65340/:1:750?B/6318>/947/60/ ./ 100?:/7 3.85?@. ./8 05?6:/< 085::/G1B46/7 3./ 05B2<146163167133/B23/7350563/673.133./0./F?/46 F?/:3456 .17 =//6 B4:?:/7 3 C1: 1<</@/7 3.13 3./ 05B2<146163.175=3146/70/83146=<16E0./F?/:;85B3./ .?:=1675;3./100?:/7167.17;4<</7?256/5;3./B35 ;54:3 1 ;1<:/ 01:/ 6 3.13 =1:4: 3./ 100?:/7 :5?@.3 35 74:2?3/ 3./ /G4:3/60/ 5; 16> </@1<<> /6;580/1=</ 7/=3 58 <41=4<43> ) 5C/9/8 12183 ;85B :?@@/:3456: 2?3 ;583. 7?846@ 085::/G1B4613456 3./ 100?:/7 747 653 0.55:/ 35 /63/83./C436/::=5G58177?0/16>8/=?331</947/60/35 :?=:3163413/ 3./ 7/;/60/ 3./58> 5; B4:?:/ ./ </186/7 !1@4:3813/ ?256 7?/ 1228/0413456 5; 581< 167 - 6 - 750?B/6318> /947/60/ ;5?67 3.13 3./ 05B2<146163 .17 :?00/::;?<<>2859/73.133./0./F?/46F?/:3456C1:4::?/7 35C187: 1 </@1<<> /6;580/1=</ 7/=3 ./ /G/0?3456 5; 3./ 285B4::58> 653/ 3./ 4::?160/ 5; 3./ 0./F?/ 167 3./ 74:.565?8 ;58 46:?;;404/60> 5; ;?67: :3557 /:31=<4:./7 => ?64B2/10./7 /947/60/ 6 3./ 1=:/60/ 5; 16> 8/=?331< /947/60/ 3./ </186/7 !1@4:3813/ 4695E/7 3./ :313?358> 28/:?B23456 ?67/8 /03456: &1( 167 5; 3./ 03 .5<746@ 3.13 3./ 100?:/7.17 ;14</7 3574:0.18@/ 3./ 56?: 5; 8/=?3346@ 3./ 28/:?B23456 167 10058746@<> 0569403/7 3./ 100?:/7 ;58 3./ 5;;/60/ 2?64:.1=</ ?67/8 /034565;3./ 03 * @@84/9/7 => 3./ 0569403456 167 :/63/60/ 3./ 100?:/7 28/;/88/7 16 122/1< =/;58/ 3./ </186/7 /::456: ?7@/ ./ 122/<<13/ 5?83 56 16 467/2/67/63 167 05B28/./6:49/ 8/1228/0413456 5; 3./ 581< 167 750?B/6318>/947/60/0560?88/7C43.3./;46746@:5;3./ 3841< 5?83 3 ./<7 3.13 3./ 05B2<146163 .17 74:0.18@/7 3./ 464341< =?87/6 5; 285946@ 3./ 3816:103456 167 3./ - 7 - /G/0?3456 5; 3./ 0./F?/ C./8/1: 3./ 100?:/7 .17 ;14</7 35 8/=?3 3./ 28/:?B23456 /43./8 => 085::/G1B4613456 58 => 177?046@ 25:4349/ /947/60/ 56:/F?/63<> 3./ 122/<<13/5?83;5?676546;48B43>488/@?<1843>584<</@1<43> 46 3./ A?7@B/63 5; 0569403456 8/67/8/7 => 3./ </186/7 !1@4:3813/16710058746@<>74:B4::/73./122/1<3./8/=> 1;;48B46@ 3./ 0569403456 167 :/63/60/ 4B25:/7 ?256 3./ 100?:/7 34:1C/<<:/33</72846042</5;<1C3.13560/3./ /G/0?3456 167 4::?160/ 5; 1 0./F?/ 18/ 17B433/7 58 2859/71:313?358>28/:?B23456184:/:?67/8/03456 5; 3./ 03 3.13 3./ 0./F?/ C1: 4::?/7 35C187: 74:0.18@/46C.5</584621835;1</@1<<>/6;580/1=</7/=3 58 <41=4<43> ./ =?87/6 3./6 :.4;3: ?256 3./ 100?:/7 35 8/=?3 3./ :147 28/:?B23456 => </1746@ 05@/63 167 056946046@/947/60//43./8=>177?046@748/03/947/60/58 => /:31=<4:.46@ 1 285=1=</ 7/;/60/ 56 28/2567/8160/ 5; 285=1=4<434/: 6 3./ 46:3163 01:/ 3.5?@. 3./ 100?:/7 133/B23/7 35 :?@@/:3 3.13 3./ 0./F?/ C1: B4:?:/7 65 - 8 - 316@4=</ /947/60/ C1: 2<10/7 56 8/0587 35 :?=:3163413/ :?0.12</1 ./100?:/76/43./8/G1B46/7./8:/<;65816> C436/:: 658 2857?0/7 16> B13/841< 35 74:<57@/ 3./ 28/:?B23456 1914<1=</ 35 3./ 05B2<146163 ?67/8 /03456: &1(167 5;3./ 03 6 3./ 1=:/60/ 5; 8/=?331< /947/60/ =53. 3./ 3841<5?831673./122/<<13/5?83C/8/A?:34;4/746.5<746@ 3.13 3./ 05B2<146163 .17 2859/7 3./ 46@8/74/63: 056:343?346@3./5;;/60/?67/8/034565;3./ 03 =/>567 8/1:561=</ 75?=3 ./ 0560?88/63 ;46746@: 8/0587/7 => 3./ 5?83: =/<5C 18/ =1:/7 56 2852/8 1228/04134565;</@1</947/60/16775653:?;;/8;85B16> 2/89/8:43> 4<</@1<43> 58 B4:122<4013456 5; <1C C18816346@ 463/8;/8/60/ => 3.4: 5?83 46 /G/804:/ 5; 8/94:4561< A?84:7403456 $ 0058746@<> 3./ 8/94:456 2/343456 =/46@ 7/9547 5; B/843 :3167: 74:B4::/7 ./ 0560?88/63 ;46746@: 167 A?7@B/63:5;3./5?83:=/<5C056940346@3./100?:/7;58 - 9 - 3./ 5;;/60/ 2?64:.1=</ ?67/8 /03456 5; 3./ /@5341=</6:38?B/63:0318/./8/=>1;;48B/7 .+ &##* $ ' 4:3 5< 5* 3:4