- 1 - !"#"" "$ %&'(%)*+ &,%** - ! " # $ % ! " # $ & ' & ( &! (! ( Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ( ( !!% & !& ) ) ' *( # *( $ +, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 5,/26 4+, 78890,: /2 1!% & 12 4+, ;/<, 1; 4+, <,7-2,: ::/4/127< ,2/1- /./< (9:6, 72: ( /:7- /0 /=3962/26 4+, >9:6=,24 1; 812./84/12 72: 1-:,- 1; 0,24,28, :74,: ! 812./84/26 +/= ;1- 4+, 1;;,28, 392/0+75<, 92:,-,84/12!&1;4+,,614/75<,204-9=,24084#;1- 0+1-4 ? 84@$ 72: 0,24,28/26 41 37A ;/2, 1; 0 BC/4+:,;79<40,24,28,C+/8+C70812;/-=,: /2 -/=/27< 33,7< 1! 5A 4+, <,7-2,: ::/4/127< /04-/84 72: ,00/120 (9:6, /:7- ./:, >9:6=,24 :74,: &! - 3 - ,7-: -/ 74/0+ 9=7- 7:D7- <,7-2,: 81920,< ;1- 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 72: -/ 7261</ 767227<,7-2,:81920,<;1-4+,-,0312:,24 ,-90,:4+, =74,-/7<012-,81-: & 2./,C1;4+,095=/00/120=7:,5A4+,<,7-2,: 81920,< ;1- 4+, -,./0/12 3,4/4/12,- 4+, 31/24 4+74 C19<: 7-/0,;1-=A8120/:,-74/12/0 A720C,-414+,751.,31/24/0/24+,;1- 4+,;1<<1C/26 4 /0 4+, 8124,24/12 1; 4+, 81=3<7/2724 5,;1-, 4+, -/7< 19-4 4+74 +, C70 D21C/26 4+, 78890,: .,-A C,<< C+1 -,E9,04,: ;1- <172 1; 0 B 881-:/26<A +, <,24 4+, 7=1924 1; 0 B 70 4+, - 4 - 78890,: 76-,,: 41 -,37A 4+, 07=, 70 ,7-<A 70 3100/5<, .,2 7;4,- 12, A,7- 4+, 78890,: +7: 214 -,37/: 4+, 7=1924594C+,24+,81=3<7/2724/20/04,:;1--,37A=,24 1; 7=1924+,+7: /009,: 4+, 3104 :74,:8+,E9,5,7-/26 1&! :-7C2 12 -7674+/ -/0+27 -7=/27 72D /:7- :74,: % +, 8+,E9, C70 3-,0,24,: ;1- ,2870+=,245944+,07=,C70:/0+1219-,:704+,-,C70 /209;;/8/,24 ;92: /2 4+, 7881924 1; 4+, 78890,: +, <,67< 214/8, 70 3,- F & C70 /009,: 41 :/;;,-,24 7::-,00,0 1; 4+,78890,:5944+,;/-04214/8,C70-,49-2,:92B0,-.,: 70 4+, 78890,: -,;90,: 41 -,8,/., 4+, 07=, 72: 4+, 0,812: 214/8, C70 -,49-2,: 92B0,-.,: 70 4+, 7::-,00,, +7:7<-,7:A<,;4.,27;4,--,;907<1;4+,<,67<214/8,4+, 78890,:+7:214-,37/:4+,8+,E9,7=192421--,3</,:41 4+, 07=, 72: 4+,-,5A 81==/44,: 4+, 1;;,28, 392/0+75<, 92:,-,84/12!&1;4+,84881-:/26<A+,;/<,:4+, 3-/.74,81=3<7/24/2 1!G& +, -/7< 19-4 411D 8162/H728, 1; 4+, 1;;,28, 72: 09==12,: 4+, 78890,: 5A -,6/04,-/26 - 5 - 1!!% & +,78890,:733,7-,:5,;1-,4+, -/7< 19-4 72: 3<,7:,: 214 69/<4A ;1- 4+, 1;;,28, 392/0+75<, 92:,- ,84/12 !& 1; 4+, 84 +, 81=3<7/2724 ,F7=/2,:+/=0,<;70 '!72:614=7-D,:F0 !41 I +, 78890,: :,2/,: 7<< 4+, /28-/=/274/26 =74,-/7<0 7.7/<75<, 12 -,81-: ,F7=/2,: +/=0,<; 70 '! 72: 614 =7-D,: F0! 41 /2 09331-4 1; +/0 8124,24/12 +, -/7< 19-4 7;4,- 47D/26 /241 8120/:,-74/12 7<< 4+,0, =74,-/7<0 12 -,81-: 87=, 41 4+, 8128<90/12 4+74 4+, 81=3<7/2724 /0 0988,00;9< /2 3-1./26 4+, 69/<4 1; 4+, 78890,: 5,A12: -,701275<, :1954 881-:/26<A 4+, /=3962,: >9:6=,24 1; 812./84/12 72: 1-:,- 1; 0,24,28, 87=,415,3700,: % ,/26766-/,.,:5A4+,07=,4+,78890,:+70 3-,;,--,:-/=/27<33,7<1! +,/-0433,<<74, 19-412-,B733-,8/74/121;4+,=74,-/7<012-,81-:;192: 4+74 4+, 81=3<7/2724 /0 0988,00;9< /2 3-1./26 4+, 69/<4 1; 4+, 78890,: 5,A12: -,701275<, :1954 72: 7881-:/26<A - 6 - :/0=/00,: 4+, 733,7< ,/26 766-/,.,: 5A 4+, 07=, 4+, 78890,:/05,;1-,4+/019-4 I 4/0 4+, 03,8/;/8 8124,24/12 1; 4+, 81=3<7/2724 4+74 78890,: +7: 51--1C,: 7 +72:<172 1; 0 B 72: 41C7-:0 -,37A=,24 1; 4+, 07=, +, +7: /009,: 8+,E9,703,-F !F /04+,-,49-2=,=1/009,:5A 4+, 72D C+/8+ 0+1C0 4+74 4+, 8+,E9,BF ! C70 :/0+1219-,: 70 4+,-, C70 /209;;/8/,24 ;92: F & /0 4+, 813A1;4+,<,67<214/8,/009,:5A4+,81=3<7/2724414+, 78890,:/2;1-=/26+/=75194:/0+1219-1;4+,8+,E9,72: 87<</269312+/=41-,37A4+,8+,E9,7=1924F0 72: 7-,4+,4C131047<-,8,/34072:F0 %72: I7-,4+, 92B0,-.,:31047<81.,-003,-F %4+,31047<,2.,<13, C70 -,;90,: 5A 4+, 7::-,00,, /, 4+, 78890,: 0 3,- F I 4+, 31047< ,2.,<13, C70 92B0,-.,: 70 4+, 7::-,00,, +70 7<-,7:A <,;4 4+, 7::-,00 F0 %#7$ 72: I#7$7-,4+,1-/6/27<<,67<214/8,0;192:/2F0 %72: I ,7-2,: 81920,< ;1- 4+, 78890,: +70 8-100B ,F7=/2,: '! 74 <,264+ 4 /0 0966,04,: 4+74 4+, - 7 - 81=3<7/2724+7:041<,24+,8+,E9,<,7;72:4+,07=,C70 =/090,: +/00966,04/12/0:,2/,:5A '! G +, 78890,: +70 ;/<,: +/0 7;;/:7./4 /2 </,9 1; ,F7=/274/12 /2 8+/,; 94 04-726,<A 4+,-, /0 214 ,.,2 7 C+/03,- -,67-:/26 '! 04,7</26 4+, 8+,E9, /2 E9,04/12 57<:7;;/:7./4/0;/<,::,2A/264+,8124,24/1247D,25A4+, 81=3<7/2724 1C,.,- :9-/26 8-100B,F7=/274/12 4+, 78890,:7:=/44,:4+74F !5,<126041+/0572D7881924 +,07/:8+,E9,<,7;C70;192:=/00/2672:/24+74-,67-: +, +70 C-/44,2 7 <,44,- 41 4+, -728+ 7276,- :9-/26 (7297-AB,5-97-A ! 4/03,-4/2,2441214,4+744+,8+,E9,/0:74,: % F 4+, 72D ,2:1-0,=,24 /0 :74,: !& +,<,67<214/8,/0:74,: 72:4+, <,67< 214/8, C70 -,49-2,: 70 -,;90,: 70 3,- F % 12 ! % 944+,81=3<7/24/007/:41+7.,5,,2;/<,: 5A4+,78890,:-,67-:/26=/00/261;4+,8+,E9,<,7;C/4+ 4+,-728+7276,-:9-/26(7297-AB,5-97-A - 8 - !! +, 78890,: +70 214 6/.,2 4+, :,47/<0 1; 4+, 81=3<7/272404,7</264+,8+,E9,<,7; +,-,/07501<94,<A 21 ,F3<7274/12 70 41 C+A +, +70 214 ;/<,: 81=3<7/24 /==,:/74,<A +,-,;1-,+/0:,;,28,8722145,788,34,: ! '+,2 4+, 78890,: 7:=/40 4+74 F !B8+,E9, 5,<126041+/072D788192472:/45,7-0+/00/62749-,4+, 3-,09=34/12 92:,- ,84/120 !! 72: !&G 1; 4+, 84 C19<: 7-/0, +, 59-:,2 /0 12 4+, 78890,: 41 -,594 4+, 07=, +, 07/: 59-:,2 /0 214 :/08+7-6,: 5A 4+, 78890,: ,/4+,- C+/<, 8-100B,F7=/2/26 '! 1- C+/<, ,F7=/2/26 +/=0,<; 70 '! 2:,- 098+ 8/-89=04728,0 4+, 78890,: /0</75<,;1-812./84/12 !& +7.,612,4+-196+4+,/=3962,:>9:6=,241; 812./84/1272:1-:,-1;0,24,28,3700,:5A4+, -/7<19-4 4+7047D,2/2418120/:,-74/127<<4+,=74,-/7<012-,81-: 72: +70 7--/.,: 74 7 -/6+4 8128<90/12 .,2 4+, /-04 33,<<74, 19-4 12 3-13,- 733-,8/74/12 1; =74,-/7<0 12 -,81-: :/0=/00,: 4+, 8-/=/27< 733,7< :1 214 ;/2: 72A -,701241/24,-;,-,C/4+4+,07=, - 9 - ! 881-:/26<A 720C,- 4+, 751., 31/24 /2 4+, 72:3-18,,:4137004+,;1<<1C/26 -/=/27<-,./0/123,4/4/12/0 .+ %""* # /041!<1