- 1 - ! "# $! % &!$! % &!"&' " ! !$$ (') * ! ! " # " Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % # & ' ( ) $ % # !( #" "" (* $ % + ' ( "" "" , & ' ( ) $ " % " " -$% " # "# -( (' ( "!( (( &#./ !((((( &#/ " " # 0 123 0 - 3 - & $0 % 456 177819 56 :; <48 =915>12<6 ?5983 @238A 8=<5B2 -$% B? <48 B<BA 845=986 =< *'' $?BA 64BA< C<48 =<D% :852E 1EEA58F83 :; <48 G@3E>82< 123 1H1A3 31<83 ( (-(716683:;<48A52=5719825BA5F59@3E8123 191:@A1E5 52 B (' ( 688I52E 82412=8>82<B?=B>78261<5B216H899167A1;52E<B?16<82 951:595<;B2<48526@A12=8=B>712; "1=<6 E5F52E A568 <B <48 ?5952E B? <48 177819 :A58?9; 6<1<83 1A8 <41< B2 .( 38=81683 45F1641A121771 41A12@ H16 <A1F8952E 52 @>&@> $51EE5B&78% :81A52E B& &* :89B2E52E <B A867B2382<B12348H1665<<52EB2<48:1=I6538B?<48 F845=98#482<48F845=98A81=483281A123@AAB131?<8A =AB6652E <48 3A5F8A B? <48 6153 F845=98 3ABF8 <48 F845=98 52 A164 123 28E95E82< >1228A 123 F845=98 <@A283 <@A<983@8<BH45=438=81683?8993BH2B2<48AB13123 6@6<15283EA58FB@6:988352E52G@A586<B4564813123B<48A - 4 - 71A<6B?<48:B3;1236@==@>:83<B<4852G@A58682=8 <48=915>12<6?5983<48=915>78<5<5B2@238A8=<5B2..B? B<BA 845=986 =< :8?BA8 <48 915>6 A5:@219 688I52E =B>78261<5B2?BA<4852G@A5866@6<1528352<48AB13<A1??5= 1==5382< 4B@E4 2B<5=8 H16 3@9; 68AF83 A867B2382< BA8>152831:682<482=848H16791=8348 A867B2382<B&26@A12=8B>712;17781A83123?5983 HA5<<82 6<1<8>82< 382;52E <48 1F8A>82<6 >138 52 <48 =915>78<5<5B2 ! 2<48:1656B?<487981352E6B?<4871A<586<48 915>6A5:@219?A1>83<48566@86123<48A81?<8AA8=BA383 <488F5382=848=915>12<652BA38A<B7ABF8<48=168 =915>12< B EB< 8J1>5283 48A689? 16 #& 123 EB< 8J45:5<833B=@>82<621>89;J<BJ!2:8419? B?A867B2382<6B28H5<2866568J1>528316#123EB< >1AI83?5F83B=@>82<616J<BJ - 5 - 48915>6A5:@219:;<485>7@E283G@3E>82< 4893<41< <48 1==5382< <BBI791=8 B2 1==B@2<B? A164 123 28E95E82< 3A5F52E B? <48 3A5F8A B? <48 B??82352E @>&@> 123 38=81683 6@==@>:83 <B <48 52G@A586 6@6<1528352<481==5382<48A5:@219@7B2=B26538A52E <48BA191233B=@>82<1A;8F5382=8791=83:8?BA85<4893 <41< <48 =915>12<6 1A8 82<5<983 <B =B>78261<5B2 B? 6!( (( &19B2EH5<452<8A86<1<<48A1<8B?./71 12335A8=<83A867B2382<B<B387B65<<48=B>78261<5B2 123 8JB28A1<83 A867B2382< B ?AB> 71;52E =B>78261<5B2 852E 35661<56?583 H5<4 <48 K@12<@> B? =B>78261<5B2 123 688I52E <B ?16<82 951:595<; B2 <48 A867B2382< B 526<813 B? A867B2382< B <456 177819 416:882?5983 . 48981A283=B@2689?BA<48=915>12<6A15683<48 ?B99BH52E=B2<82<5B26 1% 48 981A283 =B@2689 ?BA <48 =915>12<6 =B2<82383<41<1<<48<5>8B?<481==5382<<48B??82352E F845=98 58 @>&@> $51EE5B&78% H16 =BF8A83 H5<4 - 6 - 526@A12=87B95=;F82<48A5:@219416E5F82?52352E<41< 38=81683 H16 1 EA1<@5<B@6 716682E8A <48 526@A12=8 =B>712; 56 951:98 <B 71; <48 =B>78261<5B2 1>B@2< H5<4 95:8A<;<BA8=BF8A?AB><48BH28AB?<48B??82352EF845=98 B <41< 8??8=< <48 981A283 =B@2689 416 A89583 @7B2 <48 G@3E>82<B?<4878JB@A<52<48=168 52B* ' ( 3567B683B?B2-(-( :% 16<9;<48981A283=B@2689=B2<82383<41<<48 =B>78261<5B2 1H1A383 :; <48 A5:@219 B2 199 <48 48136 1A8B2<489BH8A65381236B@E4<?BA82412=8>82<B?<48 =B>78261<5B2 - 81A283=B@268917781A52E?BAA867B2382<B & <48 26@A12=8 B>712; =B2<82383 <41< 38=81683 H16 <A1F8952E 52 <48 EBB36 F845=98 16 1 716682E8A 123 652=8 52G@A83 416 F5B91<83 <48 7B95=; =B235<5B26 <48 526@A12=8 =B>712; 56 2B< 951:98 <B 71; <48 =B>78261<5B2 48 A5:@219 416 A5E4<9; 8JB28A1<83 526@A12=8 =B>712; ?AB> - 7 - 71;52E =B>78261<5B2 <B <48 =915>12<6 82=8 7A1;83 <B 356>566<48177819 ' 81A3 <48 981A283 =B@2689 ?BA <48 71A<586 78A@683<48G@3E>82<1231H1A3 * < 56 2B< 52 3567@<8 <41< 38=81683 45F1641A121771 3583 52 1 AB13 <A1??5= 1==5382< B==@AA83 B2 .( 3@8 <B <48 52G@A586 6@6<15283 52 <48 1==5382<=1@683:;<483A5F8AB?<48B??82352EF845=9858 @>&@>$51EE5B&78%:81A52E8E56<A1<5B2B& & * 48 A5:@219 =B26538A52E <48 1E8 1FB=1<5B2 123 B<48A 1678=<6 416 A5E4<9; EA12<83 =B>78261<5B2 <B <48 =915>12<6 48 B??82352E F845=98 H16 526@A83 H5<4 <48 A867B2382< B + 26@A12=8 =B>712; 52=8 <48 B??82352EF845=9856=BF8A83H5<4F1953526@A12=87B95=;123 8F82 <4B@E4 38=81683 H16 <A1F8952E 16 12 @21@<4BA5L83 716682E8A <482 196B <48 526@A12=8 =B>712; 416 <B 71; <48 1>B@2< H5<4 95:8A<; <B A8=BF8A <48 61>8 ?AB> <48 BH28AB?<48B??82352EF845=98 - 8 - ( 2A8E1A3<B1:BF871A1BB?<48G@3E>82< B? B2D:98 78J B@A< 52 <48 =168 B? $% 56 8J<A1=<8316@238A ! " # " $ % & " 2F58HB?1?BA861537AB2@2=51<5B2B?35=<@>:; <48 78J B@A< <48 5>7@E283 G@3E>82< 123 1H1A3 A8K@5A86 >B35?5=1<5B2 <B <48 8??8=< <41< <48 526@A12=8 =B>712; 416 <B 71; <48 =B>78261<5B2 ?5A6< 123 <482 A8=BF8A<4861>8?AB><48BH28AB?<48B??82352EF845=98 - 9 - 2<48A86@9<<48?B99BH52E 1%4817781956 :% 48 G@3E>82< B? <48 915>6 A5:@219 56 >B35?583 <B <48 8J<82< <41< A867B2382< B& 26@A12=8 =B>712; 416 <B 71; <48 82<5A8 =B>78261<5B2 1>B@2< 19B2E H5<4 52<8A86< 1< ./ 71 :8?BA8 <48 A5:@219 H5<452 65J H88I6 ?AB> <48 31<8 B? A8=857< B? =B7; B? <456 BA38A H5<4 95:8A<; <B A8=BF8A <48 6153 1>B@2< ?AB> <48BH28AB?<48B??82352EF845=98 =% 48 A86< B? <48 BA38A B? <48 A5:@219 64199 A8>15252<1=< !+, ($!) & !+, ("&' ") & 56<B9B!(