Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66813 (KAR)

ERAMMA v. CHETAN AND ANR

MFA/203131/2024 · 2025-11-05

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$ %!&!'!! !!'' (#) * ! "## $#% & ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # &! "# $###'( & !)&&!# % '' &) $&%'# ' # *!+! # !& ' ' ' , # -&! )) ## ## ' . . /# & & 01-2334251-6154789:04;521<2=:2>21=-::04 ?@7><4=: 2=7 2A2B7 72:47 *!+! 32--47 89 :04 4=1CB 1D15 @7>4 2=7 4A2B>1 E6CB -0CB: FB18@=25GH 1= C !& -44I1=> 4=02=;4<4=: C6 ;C<34=-2:1C= 04 1=?@B47 ;521<2=: 2>47 942B- <4: A1:0 2= 2;;174=: C= &)&!! 2=7 -@-:21=47 >B14DC@- 1=?@B14- 4=;4 -04 61547 2 ;521< 34:1:1C= 846CB4 :04 - 3 - B18@=25 -44I1=> ;C<34=-2:1C= C6 -& *!!!! 04 B18@=25 26:4B ;C=-174B1=> :04 4=:1B4 4D174=;4 C= B4;CB7 2A2B747 :04 ;C<34=-2:1C= C6 - )* A1:0 1=:4B4-: 2:*J34B2==@<6BC<:0472:4C634:1:1C=:155B4251K2:1C= 2=771B4;:47B4-3C=74=:C=-@B2=;4C<32=9:C329 :04 ;C<34=-2:1C= >>B14D47 89 :04 -217 2A2B7 :04 2334552=:;521<2=:02-3B464BB47:01-233425 42B7 2B>@<4=:- C6 8C:0 :04 32B:14- 2=7 34B@-47:04<2:4B125-2D2152854C=B4;CB7 04<21=;C=:4=:1C=C6:042334552=:1-:02::04 B18@=25 02- 2A2B747 1=274L@2:4 ;C<34=-2:1C= @=74B 255 0427-:1--:2:4789:04542B=47;C@=-456CB:04;521<2=: :02: :04 ;521<2=: 02- -@-:21=47 >B14DC@- :B2@<2:1; 8B21= 1=?@B92=70273C-:04271=?@B9=-@33CB:C6:04;2-4 ;521<2=:4M2<1=47:04C;:CB2-# A0C2--4--47!J 71-28151:9 :C :04 A0C54 8C79 8@: :04 B18@=25 02- :2I4= C=59& J:1-25-C;C=:4=747:02::04;521<2=:A2- 42B=1=> -!!!! 34B <C=:0 89 0C@-40C57 -@34BD1-1C= ACBI8@::04B18@=2502-:2I4=:041=;C<42--+&! - 4 - 34B<C=:02=7:0@-:04;C<34=-2:1C=2A2B7476CB5C--C6 6@:@B4 42B=1=> ;232;1:9 1- C= :04 5CA4B -174 04B46CB4 B4L@4-:47:C4=02=;4:04;C<34=-2:1C= : 1- -@8<1::47 89 :04 542B=47 ;C@=-45 6CB B4-3C=74=: C N =-@B2=;4 C<32=9 :02: :04 ;C<34=-2:1C=2A2B74789:04B18@=251-?@-:2=73BC34B 2=7=447-=C1=:4B64B4=;4 * 7<1::4759 1: 1- ;2-4 C6 :04 71-28151:9 -@664B47 89 :04 ;521<2=: # C;:CB 26:4B ;51=1;25 2=7 B271C5C>1;254M2<1=2:1C=C6:04;521<2=:02-1--@47M# N 1-28151:9 4B:161;2:4 2--4--1=> !J 71-28151:9 :C :04 A0C548C79 ) 42B=47 ;C@=-45 6CB :04 ;521<2=: ;C=:4=747 :02::04;521<2=:-@-:21=4704<CBB02>1;;C=:@-1C=1=N' OB4>1C=1=N32B14:25B4>1C=2=77166@-4-;4B48B25 474<22=7-04A2-:B42:47;C=-4BD2:1D4592=771-;02B>47 C= &&!! 1= -:2854 ;C=71:1C= A1:0 27D1;4 :C :2I4 2=:1-43:1; 7B@>- 6CB 5C=> :1<4 4 25-C ;C=:4=747 :02: - 5 - # 02- 2--4--47 !J 71-28151:9 :C :04 A0C54 8C79 8@: :04 B18@=25 02- :2I4= C=59 & B7 C6 !J & J A01;0 =447- :C 84 4=02=;47 :C &J = B4359 542B=47 ;C@=-45 6CB B4-3C=74=: C N =-@B2=;4 C<32=9 -@8<1:-:02::04C;:CB1-=C:24BC@B>4C=041-C=59 B:0C32471; @B>4C= :04B46CB4 01- 2--4--<4=: A1:0 B4>2B7 :C =4@BC5C>1;25 ;C=71:1C= ;2==C: 84 B45147 @3C= C=-174B1=> :04 =2:@B4 C6 1=?@B14- 2=7 :04 4D174=;4 C6 # :01- C@B: 61=7- =C B42-C= :C 1=:4B64B4 A1:0 :04 71-28151:92--4--4789:04C;:CB2=7:2I4=89:04B18@=25 2:& J 0C@>0 :04 ;521<2=: -:2:4- :02: -04 A2- 42B=1=>-!!!! 34B<C=:0-0402-=C:3BC7@;472=9 7C;@<4=: :C 3BCD4 :04 -2<4 - :04 2;;174=: 1- C6 :04 942B &)&!! 2- 34B :04 >@17451=4- 1--@47 89 :04 2B=2:2I2 :2:4 4>25 4BD1;4- @:0CB1:9 :01- C@B: 744<- 1: 233BC3B12:4 :C B42--4-- :04 1=;C<4 C6 :04 ;521<2=: 2: -& )! 34B <C=:0 ;;CB71=>59 :04 ;521<2=:1-4=:1:5476CB5C--C66@:@B442B=1=>2-@=74B. - 6 - -& )! M&M&M& JP- !)+ + 04;521<2=:A2-27<1::471=:040C-31:256CB 729-C=-174B1=>:0434B1C7C60C-31:251K2:1C==2:@B4C6 1=?@B14- 2=7 C:04B B454D2=: 62;:CB- :01- C@B: 61=7- 1: B42-C=2854 :C 2A2B7 2= 2<C@=: C6 -)!!! 6CB 321= 2=7 -@664B1=> -!!! 6CB 5C-- C6 2<4=1:14- 2=7 - !!!! 6CB :B2=-3CB:2:1C= 4M:B2 =C@B1-0<4=: 2=7 2::4=72=: ;02B>4- '@B:04B 7@4 :C 1=?@B14- :04 ;521<2=: <1>0:=C:02D42::4=7472=9ACBI2:542-:6CB234B1C7C6 <C=:0- 04=;4 :01- C@B: 61=7- 1: B42-C=2854 :C 2A2B7 -!!! 6CB 5C-- C6 1=;C<4 7@B1=> 5217 @3 34B1C7 CA4D4B :04 ;C<34=-2:1C= C6 -+) 2A2B747 89 :04B18@=256CB<471;254M34=-4-=447-=C1=:4B64B4=;4 &! 04 ;C<34=-2:1C= 2A2B747 89 :04 B18@=25 1- <C7161472-@=74B. 5 C 427- A2B789:04 B18@=25 A2B789:01- C@B: & #21= 2=7 -@664B1=> -&!!!! -)!!! - 7 - 471;25 M34=-4- -+) -+) C-- C6 6@:@B4 42B=1=>;232;1:9 -!* - !)+ B2=-3CB:2:1C= 4M:B2 =C@B1-0<4=: 2=7 2::4=72=: ;02B>4- -&!!! - !!!! C-- C6 2<4=1:14- -!!! -!!! * C-- C6 1=;C<4 7@B1=> 5217 @3 34B1C7 -!!! -!!! C:25 - )* -&+) 04B4A155844=02=;4<4=:C6-*)& && =:04B4-@5::046C55CA1=>CB74B1-32--47. $1% 334251- $11% 04 ;521<2=: 1- 4=:1:547 6CB :04 4=02=;47 ;C<34=-2:1C= C6 -*)& A1:0 1=:4B4-: 2: *J 34B 2==@< 6BC< :04 72:4 C6 34:1:1C=:155:0472:4C6B4251K2:1C= - 8 - $111% 4-3C=74=: C N =-@B2=;4 C<32=9 1- 71B4;:47 :C 743C-1: :04 4=:1B4 ;C<34=-2:1C=2<C@=:25C=>A1:01=:4B4-:A1:01= C=4<C=:06BC<:0472:4C6:01-?@7><4=: $1D% = -@;0 743C-1: :04 ;521<2=: 1- 34B<1::47:CA1:07B2A:044=:1B42<C@=:25C=> A1:01=:4B4-:2;;B@47C=1: +,- ('!! ) & 1-:C.&5C.) .