- 1 - !"! #! $ %&!#!! $ %&!% ## ' ( ! ! "# $ " " " $" ! ! ! " " %$& ' " " %$$ Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & " (" (%'$ ( #" (%'$" " ! ) ) " *+! "*" ) (" %'$ , - ) " *&&! "*" ) (" %'$ ! !" $&. " . " ,# ) & "!# +$ ! -" ,)$,. # ! / " !"- * * 0 - 0 - - 3 - &% *0 - # 1234 561 277188295/: ;<=9:18 294 28:< 561 ;<=9:18 277123>9?@<356131:7<94195: 61731:195A3>5277128>:@>814732B>9?56>:;<=35 5< :15 2:>41 561 <3413 42514 +$ 72::14 CB 561 8123914 >9?81 -=4?1 >9 <,)$, <3 >::=1 29B <56134>31;5><9:2:56>:;<=35411D:@>5 ' 6131:7<94195<:294,62E12773<2;614561 A3>5 <=35 :11F>9? 561 318>1@ 5625 <3413 42514 $'$$ 72::14CB56131:7<94195<294561;<9:1G=195D=525><9 <3413 42514 $& 72::14 CB 561 31:7<94195 <& CB A6>;6 561 31E19=1 31;<34: A131 5329:@13314 5< 31:7<94195 <:294,6131>9>92;;<3429;1A>5682A>931:71;5<@8294 B<$, :>5=2514 25 288=3?> E>882?1 @H287=3 28=F 61B 62E1 28:< :<=?65 2 A3>5 >9 561 925=31 <@ D2942D=: 5< 31:7<94195<&5<19513561>392D1:>956131E19=131;<34: 31825>9? 5< 561 8294 B<$," D12:=3>9? 2;31: $ - 4 - ?=952: <@ 288=3?> E>882?1" @H287=3 528=F2 CB 41815>9? 561 92D1<@31:7<94195< & 5 >: ;<9519414 5625 >9 561 A3>5 73<;114>9?:" 715>5><913 <$ 294 561 @25613 <@ 715>5><913 < A2: ;=85>E25>9? 561 8294 2: 2 519295 @513 6>: 41256" 561 715>5><913: ;<95>9=14 5< ;=85>E251 561 :2>4 8294 2: 519295: 61@25613<@561 715>5><913<624@>814292778>;25><9>9 <3D<$=9413561239252F21352>992D:C<8>5><9;5" $+,, C1@<31 561 294 3>C=928" @H287=3 28=F" ;82>D>9? <;;=729;B 3>?65: >9 31:71;5 <@ 561 2@<31:2>4 8294 61 31:7<94195 < 294 >:53>;5 2F@ <DD>5511" 282C=3?2>" A131 2332B14 2: 31:7<94195: >9 561 73<;114>9?: C1@<31 561 294 3>C=928 294 561 3>C=928 2@513 ;<94=;5>9? 29 19G=>3B 72::14561<341342514$,,;<9@133>9?561<;;=729;B 3>?65:>9@2E<=3<@561715>5><913:61262:>842372::1429 <3413 >9 <3D < 2;F9<A814?>9? 561 31;1>75 <@ 731D>=D 2D<=95<@:'"$'$)294561312@513">::=142;135>@>;2515< 5625 1@@1;5 61 :2>4 <3413 <@ 561 294 3>C=928 A2: ;628819?14 CB 561 31:7<94195 < 2: A188 2: >:53>;5 2F@ <234 C1@<31 56>: <=35 >9 <$','')," A6>;6 A2: - 5 - 4>:D>::14 CB 56>: <=35 <3413 42514 ,+, 61312@513" 31:7<94195 < 294 >:53>;5 2F@ <234 62E1 @>814A3>5277128>9<$$,)%C1@<3156>:<=3561 >E>:><9 19;6 <@ 56>: ;<=35 28:< 4>:D>::14 561 277128 9 :7>51<@5625"5612771882956131>9C1>9?=9:=;;1::@=8"D241 29 2551D75 5< 19513 561>3 92D1:" 1951314 31E19=1 31;<34: 7=3:=295 5< <%,)$$$ <<9 561312@513" 31:7<94195 < >9>5>2514 73<;114>9?: =9413 1;5><9 & <@ 5612F@;5"$++29472::14561<341342514$'$$ 513D>9? 561 715>5><913: 2: I19;3<2;613:J <9 561 :=CK1;5 D25513 <@ 561 8294" 4>31;514 561715>5><913: >1"31:7<94195 <: 294 , 6131>9 5< C1 1E>;514 @3<D 561 73<7135B >9 G=1:5><961312@513"25561C161:5<@56131:7<94195<" D=525><973<;114>9?:A13128:<>9>5>2514294561:2D1A2: 52F19 9<51 CB 561 8123914 >9?81 -=4?1 294 28:< D241 29 <C:13E25><9562573<7135BA2:9<8<9?1322F@3<7135B294 56173<E>:><9:<@5612F@;5"$++A1319<52778>;2C815< 5618294 2E>9? ;<9:>41314 56>: D2513>28 <9 31;<34" 561 A3>5<=35>97232<:,294%>94152>84>:;=::14561:2D1 - 6 - 29429<C:13E25><9>:D2415625>5>:9<4<=C55625 1;5><9 %' # <@ 561 2F@ ;5" $++ 73<E>41: 29 277128 31D14B <A1E13">9;2:1:A613131:7<94195<62:2::=D149<9 1L>:5195 K=3>:4>;5><9" 561 <=35: =9413 35>;81 <@ 561 <9:5>5=5><9 <@ 94>2 231 9<5 4>:2C814 @3<D 72::>9? 2773<73>251<3413:"62E>9?;<9:>4131456>:D2513>28<931;<34 294 28:< ;<D>9? 5< 561 ;<9;8=:><9 5625 31:7<94195 < A>56<=5K=3>:4>;5><9>9E<F14 1;5><9&<@5612F@;5"$+ 288<A14 561 A3>5 715>5><9 294 G=2:614 561 ;<9:1G=195 D=525><9 <3413 294 1953>1: 1>9? 2??3>1E14 CB 561 :2D1" 561731:195A3>5277128>:@>814CB5612F@ <234 61 ;<=9:18 277123>9? @<3 561 277188295 A<=84 ;<951945625561<341372::14CB5618123914 >9?81-=4?1>: 133<91<=: 294 561 :2>4 <3413 2D<=95: 5< D>:;233>2?1 <@ K=:5>;161;<=9:18A<=8428:<E161D1958B;<951945625561 E13B2773<2;6<@5618123914 >9?81-=4?15625561277188295 A2: =9:=;;1::@=8 >9 561 1238>13 73<;114>9?: 294 277188295 A>56<=529BK=3>:4>;5><9>9E<F14 1;5><9&<@5612F@;5" $+" 2: 561 :2D1 >: 133<91<=: 294 :2D1 31G=>31: >9513@1319;1 61 ;<=9:18 @<3 561 277188295 A<=84 - 7 - E161D1958B ;<95194 5625 561 8123914 >9?81 -=4?1 A6>81 288<A>9? 561 A3>5 715>5><9 @2>814 5< ;<9:>413 5625 2H1551 <5>@>;25><9>::=14CB561239252F2 5251 <234<@2F@>: 9<5 9=88>@>14 CB 29B ;<D715195 <=35 294 619;1 >5 31G=>31: >9513@1319;1 , "8123914;<=9:18@<331:7<94195<: 294 , A<=84 E161D1958B ;<95194 5625 561 8123914 >9?81 -=4?1 ;<9:>41314 561 D2513>28 <9 31;<34 7235>;=8238B 52F>9? 9<51 <@ 561 277188295 2: =9:=;;1::@=8 >9 561 1238>13 A3>5 715>5><92:A1882:>9561A3>527712829428:<62E>9?52F19 9<51 <@ 1L13;>:>9? 561 K=3>:4>;5><9 294 513D>9? 561 31:7<94195<:294,2:19;3<2;613:";<DD>551429133<3 294619;1>54<1:9<531G=>31>9513@1319;1<@56>:;<=35 % 61 ;<=9:18 277123>9? @<3 561 5251 28:< :=CD>5 56255618123914 >9?81-=4?162:9<5;<DD>551429B133<3>9 72::>9?:=;6<341329424152>814<341362:C11972::14 + 2E>9? 61234 561 277188295/: ;<=9:18 294 28:< ;<=9:18 @<3 561 31:7<94195: 294 <9 713=:28 <@ 561 195>31 D2513>28 <9 31;<34" >5 >: 9<5 >9 4>:7=51 5625 56>: 277188295 - 8 - 1238>136242773<2;614561A3>5<=35CB@>8>9?A3>5715>5><9>9 <$',''),294561:2D1A2:4>:D>::14"28:<2A3>5 277128A2:@>814>9<$$,)%294561:2D1A2:28:< 4>:D>::14E195618123914 >9?81-=4?162:52F199<51<@ 72::>9? <@ <3413 CB 561 3>C=928 294 1E19 561 31:7<94195: 62E1 72>4 561 731D>=D <@ :'"$'$)" 5< 5625 1@@1;5 28:< >::=14;135>@>;25129427235@3<D5625>97232<'<@561A3>5 <3413 4>:;=::14 A>56 31?234 5< 6<A 561 277188295 624 1L13;>:14 561 7<A13: >9E<F>9? 1;5><9 & <@ 561 2F@ ;5"$+29428:<52F199<51>97232<&562556173<7135B A2: 9< 8<9?13 2 A2F@ 73<7135B =9413 561 73<E>:><9: <@ 561 2F@;5294A1319<52778>;2C815<5618294 =35613"D241 29<C:13E25><95625A>56<=529BK=3>:4>;5><9>9E<F14 1;5><9 &<@5612F@;529452F>9?9<51<@288561:1D2513>28<9 31;<34"24152>814<3413A2:72::14D<317235>;=8238B>97232 <:,294%D24129<C:13E25><9294CB1L13;>:>9?561A3>5 K=3>:4>;5><9"288<A14561A3>5715>5><9"G=2:614561>D7=?914 ;<9:1G=195 D=525><9 <3413 >9 <+)$'$& 42514 $&" 561 :2D1 ;2D1 >95< 1L>:519;1 2@513 561 277188295 A2: =9:=;;1::@=8 C1@<31 561 8123914 >9?81-=4?1 - 9 - 2: A188 2: C1@<31 561 277188251 K=3>:4>;5><9 294 A619 :=;6 C1>9?561;2:1">5>:9<56>9?C=52;8123;=5;2:1<@2C=:1<@ 73<;1::<@82A $ 7235 @3<D 5625" >5 >: E13B ;8123 5625 A619 561 8294 A2: ?329514 >9 @2E<=3 <@ 31:7<94195 <: 294," 561 :2D1A2:;<9@>3D14CB56>:<=3529428:<>9561A3>5277128 294 561 73<7135B A2: 9<5 2 A2F@ 73<7135B 9413 561:1 ;>3;=D:529;1:"A619:=;6C1>9?561;2:1"5612F@;5>5:18@ A<=84 9<5 2778>;2C81 91E1356181:: 561 277188295 62: 1L13;>:14 294 1951352>914 561 73<E>:< 5< 1;5><9 & <@ 561 ;5 A6>;6 2D<=95: 5< ;8123 2C=:1 <@ 73<;1:: <@ 82A 294 A>56<=5 K=3>:4>;5><9 72::14 :=;6 29 <3413 19;1" >5 >: 2 @>5 ;2:15<>D7<:1612EB;<:5<95612771882952942;;<34>9?8B ;<:5 <@ :") >: >D7<:14 <9 561 277188295 294 561 :2D1:6288C172B2C815<56131:7<94195<:294,A>56>9 2713><4<@@<=3A11F:@3<D5<42B@561277188295@2>8:5< 417<:>5561;<:52:<3413142C<E1A>56>9:5>7=825145>D1"561 1?>:53B >: 4>31;514 5< 31;<E13 561 ;<:5 CB >::=>9? 2 ;135>@>;251 2: 233123: <@ 8294 31E19=1 294 62E>9? 31;<E1314 561:2D1>92;;<3429;1A>5682A@3<D561277188295"72B561 - 10 - 2D<=95 5< 31:7<94195 <: 294 , <9 561>3 73<713 >4195>@>;25><9 $$ ;;<34>9?8B" 561 A3>5 277128 >: !)* '#!!( & !)* '%( & >:5<*$ 8<*& *