- 1 - !" #$% %% & '!( ) !" # $ % &! &!&' ' '( ) !" # $ ('* ""'"' % ( ( +$%( ( ""''"' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( +, '" ( - - . $ /01233425016054789:/4;520<2=:2>20=1::/4 ?@7><4=: 2=7 2A2B7 72:47 ""''"' 321147 89 :/4 4<84B 0?2923@B2 C6DB 1/DB: EB08@=25FG 0= D+, '"! 144H0=> 4=/2=;4<4=: D6 ;D<34=12:0D= ' /4 0=?@B47 ;520<2=: 2>47 ' 942B1 <4: A0:/ 2= 2;;074=: D= '"&'"! 2=7 1@1:20=47 >B04ID@1 0=?@B041 4=;4 /4 60547 2 ;520< 34:0:0D= 846DB4 :/4 B08@=25144H0=>;D<34=12:0D=D61"""""" 6BD<:/4 B413D=74=:1 /4 B08@=25 26:4B ;D=1074B0=> :/4 4=:0B4 4I074=;4 D= B4;DB7 2A2B747 :/4 ;D<34=12:0D= D6 1 , A0:/ 0=:4B41: 2: ,J 34B 2==@< 6BD< :/4 72:4 D6 34:0:0D= :055 B4250K2:0D= 2=7 70B4;:47 B413D=74=: =1@B2=;4D<32=9:D329:/4;D<34=12:0D=>>B04I47 - 3 - 89 :/4 1207 2A2B7 :/4 2334552=:;520<2=: /21 3B464BB47 :/01233425 42B7 2B>@<4=:1 D6 8D:/ :/4 32B:041 2=7 34B@147:/4<2:4B02512I2052854D=B4;DB7 & : 01 :/4 <20= ;D=:4=:0D= D6 :/4 2334552=: ;520<2=::/2:/4A21ADBH0=>0=/2B2:/(@B>4 D<32=9 2=7 >4::0=> 0=;D<4 D6 1""" 34B <D=:/ :;D=:4=74789:/4542B=47;D@=1456DB:/4;520<2=::/2: :/4 ;520<2=: 1@1:20=47 <@5:0354 6B2;:@B4 0=?@B041 8@: :/4 B08@=25 2A2B747 <42>B4 ;D<34=12:0D= @=74B 255 /4271 2=7=D2<D@=:A212A2B747@=74B:/4/4275D11D66@:@B4 42B=0=> ;232;0:9 6DB :/4 B421D= :/2: :/4 :B42:47 D;:DB A21=D:4L2<0=47846DB4:/4B08@=252=7:/@1B4M@41:47 6DB 4=/2=;0=> :/4 ;D<34=12:0D= A0:/ ,J 0=:4B41: 34B 2==@< : 01 1@8<0::47 89 542B=47 ;D@=145 6DB B413D=74=: D' N =1@B2=;4 D<32=9 :/2: 6B2;:@B4 01 @=0:472=7:/4AD@=712B4/425474;D=:4=747:/2:0= - 4 - 2B2 D&" D6 :/4 0<3@>=47 ?@7><4=: :/4 B08@=25 D814BI47 :/2: 21 34B :/4 4I074=;4 D6 D;:DB 6B2;:@B4 D6 B0>/::08022=774=:256B2;:@B42B4@=0:472=7211@;/:/4 B08@=25 /21 B0>/:59 =D: ;D=1074B47 :/4 70128050:9 A/0;/ =4471=D0=:4B64B4=;4 ! 1 34B L, D@=7 4B:060;2:4 ;520<2=: 1@1:20=47:/46D55DA0=>0=?@B041- % <255;B@1/47AD@=7DI4B5DA4B50<81* '% L;<AD@=7DI4B;/0=* % A4550=>DI4BB0>/:546:?@1:845DA:/4H=44 =1@33DB:D6/01;214;520<2=:4L2<0=47:ADD;:DB12=7 8D:/D6:/4<011@471432B2:40128050:94B:060;2:41& D;:DB0=/01 4I074=;4 /21 1:2:47:/2: :/4B401 /01:DB9D6 74=:D25I4D52B 6B2;:@B4 A0:/ 5D11 D6 @334B 6BD=: :44:/ 4 251D1:2:47:/2:0=:4B<2L0552B960L2:0D=D6A0B41A217D=4 :D ;DBB4;: :/4 6B2;:@B4 2=7 7@4 :D 6B2;:@B4 2=7 5D11 D6 @334B 6BD=: :44:/ 32:04=: 01 @=2854 :D 1342H 2=7 ;/4A 6DD7 3BD34B59 2=7 /2I0=> 320= 0= :/4 ?2A1 2: B0>/: 2=7 - 5 - @=2854:D;5D14:/450313BD34B59;;DB70=>59/421141147 "J 70128050:9 :D :/4 A/D54 8D79 N D;:DB 0= /01 4I074=;4 /21 1:2:47 :/2: ;520<2=: 1@1:20=47 0=?@B041 :D 5DA4B 503 0=?@B9 :D :/4 ;/0= 2=7 0=?@B9 :D B0>/: 54> A0:/ 6B2;:@B4 D6 3BDL0<25 :0802 2=7 ;D<<0=@:47 6B2;:@B4 3B414=: /4B4 01 70660;@5:9 0= 1M@2::0=> ;BD11 54> 10::0=> 2=7H=4450=>:4B<0=2559D=B0>/:5DA4B50<8A0:/J42;/ 70128050:9 3B414=: A0:/ ,J :D:25 251D 1:2:47 :/2: <DI4<4=:1 D6 B0>/: H=44 2B4 320=6@5 2=7 B41:B0;:47 2=7 D30=47 :/2: :/4 ;520<2=: /21 1@1:20=47 '" :D 'J 34B<2=4=: 70128050:9 B452:0=> :D B0>/: 5DA4B 50<8 D=1074B0=> :/4 <470;25 4I074=;4 :/01 D@B: 60=71 0: B421D=2854 :D :2H4 D6 J 70128050:9 'J 21 6@=;:0D=2570128050:9 + /D@>/ :/4 ;520<2=: 1:2:41 :/2: /4 A21 42B=0=>1""" 34B<D=://4/21=D:3BD7@;472=9 7D;@<4=: :D 3BDI4 :/4 12<4 1 :/4 2;;074=: 01 D6 :/4 942B'"!2134B:/4;/2B:011@4789:/42B=2:2H2 :2:4 4>25 4BI0;41 @:/DB0:9 :/01 D@B: 744<1 0: 233BD3B02:4 - 6 - :D 211411 :/4 0=;D<4 D6 :/4 ;520<2=: 2: 1 +" 34B <D=:/::/4:0<4D62;;074=::/4;520<2=:A212>47' 942B1 2=7 233BD3B02:4 <@5:03504B 23350;2854 :D /01 2>4 >BD@301E F;;DB70=>59:/4;520<2=:014=:0:5476DB5D11 D66@:@B442B=0=>21@=74B- 1 +" L'L L'JO1''! "" /4;520<2=:A2127<0::470=:/4/D130:256DB, 7291D=1074B0=>:/434B0D7D6/D130:250K2:0D==2:@B4D6 0=?@B041 2=7 D:/4B B454I2=: 62;:DB1 :/01 D@B: 60=71 0: B421D=2854 :D 2A2B7 2= 2<D@=: D6 1+""" 6DB 320= 2=7 1@664B0=> 2=7 1"""" 6DB :B2=13DB:2:0D= 4L:B2 =D@B01/<4=: 2=7 2::4=72=: ;/2B>41 (@B:/4B 7@4 :D 0=?@B041 :/4 ;520<2=: <0>/: =D: /2I4 2::4=747 2=9 ADBH 2:5421:6DB234B0D7D6&<D=:/1/4=;4:/01D@B:60=710: B421D=2854:D2A2B71""" 6DB5D11D60=;D<47@B0=> 5207 @3 34B0D7 DA4I4B :/4 ;D<34=12:0D= 2A2B747 89 :/4 B08@=25 6DB <470;25 4L34=141 2: 1+& 6DB 6@:@B4 <470;25 4L34=141 2: 1'""" 2=7 1'""" - 7 - 6DB5D11D62<4=0:04101?@1:2=73BD34B2=7A/0;/=4471 =D0=:4B64B4=;4 , /4 ;D<34=12:0D= 2A2B747 89 :/4 B08@=25 01 <D70604721@=74B- 5 D 4271 A2B789:/4 B08@=25 A2B789:/01 D@B: 20= 2=7 1@664B0=> 1""" 1+""" ' 470;25 L34=141 1+& 1+& D11 D6 6@:@B4 42B=0=>;232;0:9 1''! "" & B2=13DB:2:0D= 4L:B2 =D@B01/<4=: 2=7 2::4=72=: ;/2B>41 1'""" 1"""" D11 D6 2<4=0:041 1'""" 1'""" ! D11 D6 0=;D<4 7@B0=> 5207 @3 34B0D7 1 """ 1""" + (@:@B4 <470;25 4L34=141 1'""" 1'""" - 8 - D:25 1 , 1&,! /4B4A055844=/2=;4<4=:D61" "" " 413D=74=: D' N =1@B2=;4 D<32=9 /21 25B4279 743D10:47 :/4 ;D<34=12:0D= 2<D@=: 2A2B747 89 :/4B08@=25 =:/4B41@5::/46D55DA0=>DB74B01321147- $0% 3342501 $00% /4 ;520<2=: 01 4=:0:547 6DB :/4 4=/2=;47 ;D<34=12:0D= D6 1" "" A0:/ 0=:4B41: 2: !J 34B 2==@< 6BD< :/4 72:4 D6 34:0:0D=:055:/472:4D6B4250K2:0D= $000% 413D=74=: D' N =1@B2=;4 D<32=9 01 70B4;:47 :D 743D10: :/4 26DB41207 ;D<34=12:0D=2<D@=:25D=>A0:/0=:4B41:A0:/0= D=4<D=:/6BD<:/472:4D6:/01?@7><4=: - 9 - $0I% = 1@;/ 743D10: :/4 ;520<2=: 01 34B<0::47:DA0:/7B2A:/44=:0B42<D@=:25D=> A0:/0=:4B41:2;;B@47D=0: D@=145 6DB B413D=74=: D' 01 34B<0::47 :D 6054 2H252:A0:/0=:ADA44H1 *+& '%( $ 01:D- 5D- -