- 1 - !" #$ %% # $ & !" #$%" & '!& #&! (!& " & # " ()&( '!#& (*&# '!#& + ( ,'%&*(& "(- & & &#&" #*" (" ".(&" '#" '!#&/ ( &&& #" !&(&&&! (" &&& &" " Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (!% ."#( &" !(" '!#& +( ,'%&*!#!(&"(0 (&(&&&( - ( & & & ! (& $,- ( ( & ( %&# ( &% ( *!#( '% ( && & && *!# (" '!#& & ( '% &# ( (& % "&( &((*!(&)!&(% %%# $ & ( &&& #" !&(&&&! (" &&& &" " (!% ."#( &" !(" '!#& + ( ,'%&*!#!(&"(- & !" #%" & '!& #&! (!& " & # " ()&( '!#& (*&# '!#&/ & &#&" #*" - 3 - (" ".(&" '#" '!#&/ +( ,'%&*(& "(0 (&(&&&( - ( & & & ! (& $,- ( ( & (%&#((&( *!#( ( & '% ( && &(& & && *!#(" '!#&"!&#( )!(! (&( ( " &# &&" ( & %" *!#( &( &! 1' *!(& & 23 2456 78 9:5 ;4<2=<>9 355?2>@ 5>:<>;5=5>9 9:5 ;=A5>3<92> 23 2456 78 9:5 &>3BC<>;5 =A<>8 ;:<445>@2>@ 9:5 DB<>9B= ;=A5>3<92> <E<C656 (:5 2=AB@>56 <E<C6 2> 79: 9:5 <AA5<43 23 6<956 A<33562> 789:5&&66292><45>2C2F24 *B6@5"<4<7BC<@2,C3:C9G9:59C27B><4H- - 4 - 5<C6 9:5 45<C>56 ;B>354 C 9:5 ;4<2=<>9 <>6 9:545<C>56;B>354C9:5&>3BC<>;5=A<>82>79:9:5 <AA5<43 $ 5<C>56;B>354C9:5<AA544<>9;4<2=<>9EB46 ;>95>69:<9"9:5 <AA544<>9;4<2=<>9E<3CB>>2>@<=562;<4 3:A <>6 <43 E<3 62>@ <@C2;B49BC<4 EC? <>6 ;>3265C2>@ 9:53<=5"9:52>;=59<?5>789:59C27B><423>4E5C3265 5BC9:5C3B7=2939:<9"9:5623<72429839<956789:5;9C/ 23$I<>69:59C27B><4:<39<?5>9:5623<724298<9 I <>6 9:5 3<=5 23 >9 ACA5C <>6 ;CC5;9 (:5 ;4<2=<>9:<33B39<2>56C<;9BC54E5C5>6C2@:9C<62B3 <>6:5E<3<6=299562>:3A29<4C9:C556<83<>69:5C523< 3BC@5C8 E:5C52>" <> 2=A4<>9 23 2J56 <>6 29 C5DB2C53 9 75 C5=F56>3265C2>@9:53<=5"9:5;=A5>3<92><E<C656 CA<2><>63B5C2>@"4332>;=56BC2>@4<26BAA5C26" 433 <=5>29253 <>6 <995>6<>9 ;:<C@53 <C5 > 4E5C 3265 39:5;4<2=<>9C5DB2C533BC@5C8CC5=F<42=A4<>9":5 23 5>92945 C B9BC5 =562;<4 5JA5>353 (:5 9C27B><4 :<3 >9 <E<C656 B9BC5 =562;<4 5JA5>353 29: 9:23" :5 AC<83 C 5>:<>;5=5>9;=A5>3<92> - 5 - 5<C>56 ;B>354 C 9:5 &>3BC<>;5 =A<>8 3B7=293 9:<9" 9:5 2>KBC8 25 C<;9BC5 :<3 >9 <5;956 9:5 2>;=5 9:5 ;4<2=<>9 <3 :5 23 CB>>2>@ =562;<4 3:A <>6 AC<83 C C56B;2>@ 9:5 ;=A5>3<92> <E<C656 78 9:5 9C27B><4 <F2>@:5<C69:545<C>56;B>3543"9:23BC9:<3 A5CB3569:52=AB@>56*B6@=5>9<>69:59C2<4BC9C5;C63 (:5<;;265>9:<39<?5>A4<;52>9:585<C 3 A5C 9:5 ;:<C9 AC5A<C56 C 359945=5>9 623AB953 2> ? 6<4<9:" 9:5 >92><4 2>;=5 C 9:5 85<C 23 3$" A5C=>9:(:5C5C5"9:52>;=59<?5>789:5 9C27B><423>4E5C3265(:5;4<2=<>9E<3CB>>2>@<=562;<4 3:A <>6 E<3 <43 62>@ <@C2;B49BC<4 EC? (:5C5C5" 9:5 2>;=5:<39759<?5><93$" <3A5C9:5;:<C9 (:5;4<2=<>9:<33B39<2>56C<;9BC54E5C5>6 C2@:9C<62B3<>6:5B>65CE5>93BC@5C8<>6<>2=A4<>9:<3 755> 2J56 23 9:5 ;9CE:<3353356 9:5 623<724298 <>6 233B56 623<724298 ;5C922;<95 <3 A5C J" E:5C52> 9:5 623<724298 23 39<956 <3 $I (:5 9C27B><4 :<3 9<?5> - 6 - 623<724298 <9 I (:5 ;4<2=<>9 E<3 >9 >48 62>@ 7B32>533 =562;<4 3:A" 7B9 E<3 <43 62>@ <@C2;B49BC<4 EC? (:5C5C5" 9:5 623<724298 :<3 <5;956 :23 2>;=5 (:5C5C5" 9:5 ;>95>92> 9:5 45<C>56 ;B>354 C 9:5 &>3BC<>;5 =A<>8 ;<>>9 75 <;;5A956 (:5 <@5 9:5 ;4<2=<>9 <3 > 9:5 6<95 9:5 <;;265>9 23 85<C3 <>6 ;>3265C2>@ 9:5 3<=5" 9:5 =B492A425C GH 9<?5> 78 9:5 9C27B><423ACA5C<>6;CC5;9>3265C2>@9:53<=5"433 B9BC52>;=5EB4675<3B>65C 3$" ...IL3"" (:5 ;4<2=<>9 :<3 3B39<2>56 >5 C<;9BC5 <>6 B>65CE5>9<3BC@5C8<>6<>2=A4<>9232J56>3265C2>@9:5 3<=5" 9:5 ;=A5>3<92> <E<C656 78 9:5 9C27B><4 C A<2> <>63B5C2>@2><3B=3" 23>4E5C3265(:5 ;4<2=<>9235>92945C ;=A5>3<92> 3$" 9E<C63 A<2><>63B5C2>@3 (:5 ;4<2=<>9 :<3 755> <6=29956 2> 9:5 3A29<4 C9:C556<83<>6:5B>65CE5>93BC@5C8<>6;>3265C2>@9:5 3<=5" :5 23 5>92945 C 433 2>;=5 6BC2>@ 4<26 BA A5C26 - 7 - C 9:C55 6<83 2> < 3B= 3$" . $ 6<83 L 3$ " >3265C2>@9:5C<;9BC53B39<2>56<>6<@59:5 ;4<2=<>9" 433 <=5>29253 <3 <E<C656 78 9:5 9C27B><4 2> < 3B=3" 23>4E5C3265(:5;4<2=<>9235>92945 C433<=5>292532><3B=3" (:5 ;4<2=<>9 :<3 755> <6=29956 2> 3A29<4 C 9:C556<83<>69:5C5C5":5235>92945C<995>6<>9;:<C@53" 6 <>6 ;>F58<>;5 ;:<C@53 2> < 3B= 3" A5C 6<8"253" .$6<83L3$" (:5;9CE: 5J<=2>56 9:5 ;4<2=<>9 <>6 233B56 J / 623<724298 ;5C922;<9525:<339<9562>:23;5C922;<95<>6<432> :23 5F265>;5 9:<9" 9:5C5 23 < >556 C C5=F<4 2=A4<>9 2J56 <>6 5JA5>353 C 9:5 3<=5 23 3" 9 3" 2> AC2F<95 :3A29<43 >3265C2>@ 9:5 <;9 9:<9" 9:5;4<2=<>9C5DB2C533BC@5C8CC5=F<49:52=A4<>9":5 23 5>92945 C B9BC5 =562;<4 5JA5>353 3$" (:5 =562;<4 5JA5>353 <E<C656 78 9:5 9C27B><4 2> < 3B= 3" 23ACA5C<>6;CC5;9 - 8 - >3265C2>@ 9:5 <7F5 <3A5;9" 9:5 ;4<2=<>9 23 5>92945C9:544E2>@;=A5>3<92> ' ( )*+,(-.(/0)1,*23(1 (/0)1,*23(1 *4*5+)+ 67 283,(952 B9BC54332>;=5 3"" <2><>63B5C2>@3 3$" $ <26BAA5C26,3$".$- 3$ " 995>6<>9;:<C@53 3$" 33<=5>29253 3" 562;<45JA5>353 3" B9BC5=562;<45JA5>353 3$" (2*' ,:;<# $ 5>;5" 9:5 ;4<2=<>9 23 5>92945 C 99<4 ;=A5>3<92> 3" " " <3 <@<2>39 3"" <E<C656789:59C27B><4 &>F25E9:5<7F5"9:544E2>@ ,2- 2456 78 9:5 &>3BC<>;5=A<>823623=233560 ,22- 2456 78 9:5 ;4<2=<>923<44E562> A<C90 ,222- (:5 ;4<2=<>9 23 5>92945 C 99<4 ;=A5>3<92> 3" " <3 <@<2>39 3"" <E<C656789:59C27B><40 - 9 - ,2F- (:5 C<95 2>95C539 > 9:5 ;=A5>3<92> <>6 C65C 65A329 A<3356 78 9:5 9C27B><4C5=<2>3B><495C560 ,F- (:5 &>3BC<>;5 =A<>8 3:<44 65A329 9:5 ;=A5>3<92> <=B>9 E29: 2>95C539 E29:2> < A5C2632JE55?3C=9:236<8"<242>@E:2;:2923 42<7459A<82>95C539<99:5C<95 IA5C<>>B=" 9244A<8=5>90 ,F2- (:5<=B>965A32956789:5&>3BC<>;5 =A<>8 23 C65C56 9 75 9C<>3=29956 9 9:5 9C27B><4 +# ! " 2394