- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) !" " # $ % &" ' % (" ) % ' ' * %+) % %(" ) ! # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * * % +,!# * " * &&- " " &%," "* * " ' ' . $ / 01234 56 0478294 56 /53294 74015/:4/30 :2: /53 3;7/;1</:3=4746574043 =20 <114<> 20 62>4: ?@ 3=4 2/0;7</94 95A1</@ <B<2/033=4C;:BA4/3</:<D<7::<34:&&-1<004: ?@ 3=4 4/257 282> ;:B4 </: ::2325/<> <0<8<E<>@</2/ 5&56, , /4;?=<:7<?<2$;??<AA<<B4:@4<70 A43 D23= </ <992:4/3 5/ </: 0=4 62>4: 9><2A 1432325/ 9><2A2/B 95A14/0<325/ 56 0% D23= 2/347403 =4 72?;/<> 95/02:474: 3=4 4/3274 482:4/94 5/ 74957:</:B7</34:0,+%D23=2/347403<33=47<34 56-F147<//;A675A:<34561432325/32>>74<>20<325/ - 3 - ) BB72484: ?@ 3=4 0<2: 57:47 3=4 <114>></3 /0;7</94 95A1</@ =<0 17464774: 3=20 <114<> A<2/>@ 95/34/:2/B 3=<3 3=474 20 2/85>84A4/3 56 /:29< 9<7 ?4<72/B 5% +) =4 95A1><2/3 20 3=<3 3=4 9><2A</3 64>> :5D/ 675A 3=4 3D5 D=44>47 D=2>4 37<84>>2/B 5/ 23 0 147 =47 5D/ 03<34A4/3 95A1><2/3 D<0 B284/ <6347 ) :<@0 </: 3=4 84=29>4 D<0 2A1>29<34: =4 A43 D23= </ <992:4/3 5/ </: B<84 95A1><2/3 5/ </: 1><//4: 35 2A1>29<34 3=4 84=29>4 35 B43 D75/B6;> 95A14/0<325/ / G=2?23 0=4 =<0 9>4<7>@ 03<34:3=<30=464>>:5D/675A3D5D=44>47</:0;03<2/4: =4<:2/C;7@=4<114>></3<>0574>24:;15/3=4C;:BA4/3 56 3=4 5/.?>4 ;174A4 5;73 2/ 3=4 9<04 56 7415734: 2/ 2/ D=29=23D<0=4>:<0;/:47' “It is now well known that a fraud vitiates all solemn acts. Thus, even if the date of birth of the petitioner had been recorded in the service returns on the basis of the certificate produced by the petitioner, the same is not sacrosanct nor the respondent company would be bound thereby." - 4 - 3 20 95/34/:4: ?@ 3=4 <114>></32/0;7</94 95A1</@ 3=<3 3=4 2/0;7</94 95A1</@ 20 14702034/3>@ 1;70;2/B 3=4 A<3347 <0 3=4@ <74 :4<>2/B D23= 1;?>29 A5/4@ =4 72?;/<> 74>24: ;15/ 3=4 C;:BA4/3 56 3=4 5/.?>4 ;174A4 5;73 2/ 3=4 9<04 56 7415734:2/ !! !" 2/D=29=23D<0=4>:3=<3:4><@2/>5:B2/B*9<//53?4< B75;/: 35 :5;?3 3=4 9><2A</3.0 9<04 D=29= 20 /53 <11>29<?>42/3=417404/3043569279;A03</940=4746574 74H;4034:35043<02:43=4<D<7: & 4<7: 3=4 <7B;A4/30 56 >4<7/4: 95;/04> 657 <114>></32/0;7</9495A1</@ + =474 20 /5 :201;34 74B<7:2/B 3=4 6<93 3=<3 3=4 1432325/479><2A</3A43D23=3=4<992:4/35/ 741573IG=2?239>4<7>@74<:0<065>>5D0 !"## $ %& '(") & *" ) + , - -&& + - + +& . - &/ - 5 - =4 1432325/479><2A</3 D=2>4 D<>E2/B 5/ - A43 D23= </ <992:4/3 :;4 35 3=4 7<0= </: /4B>2B4/94 56 3=4 :72847 56 3=4 /:29< 9<7 ?4<72/B 5% +) 5/ <347 =47 03<34A4/3 D<0 74957:4: 5/ 2/ D=29= 0=4 03<34: 3=<3 0=4 A43 D23= <992:4/3:;4353=4/4B>2B4/94563=4:7284756/:29< 9<7?4<72/B 5%+)=495A1><2/3D<0B284/ <6347):<@0245/53=4A<2/95/34/325/ 56 3=4 <114>></32/0;7</94 95A1</@ 20 3=<3 23 20 < 9>4<7 9<04562A1>29<325/563=484=29>4</:23<A5;/303567<;: 1><@4:;15/3=45;73</:23D<0/5395/02:474:?@3=4 372?;/<>/1<7<B7<1= 5)563=42A1;B/4:C;:BA4/323 D<05?04784:3=<33=474D<0:4><@2/>5:B2/B3=4*?;3 23 20 /53 2/34/325/<> 0 3=4 9=<7B4 0=443 20 62>4: <B<2/03 :72847 56 3=4 5664/:2/B 84=29>4 74015/:4/3 50 </: <74C52/3>@</:04847<>>@A<:4>2<?>4351<@95A14/0<325/ </: :274934: 74015/:4/3 52/0;7</94 95A1</@ 35 :4150233=4<A5;/3 -432325/479><2A</3D<0<:A2334:2/3=4=50123<> 5/</::209=<7B4:5/</:0=4=<0 - 6 - 4G1><2/4:74<05/657/53B282/B95A1><2/332>> /3=41432325/0=4=<003<34:3=<3D=2>40=4D<0B52/B?@ D<>E 5/ - 0=4 A43 D23= </ <992:4/3 :;4 35 3=4 /4B>2B4/94 56 3=4 :72847 56 3=4 <65740<2: 9<7 ;3 2/ 3=4 4<7>247 03<34A4/3 B284/ 5/ 2304>6 23 D<0 A4/325/4: 3=<3 0=4 64>> :5D/ 675A 3=4 3D5 D=44>47 </: 0;03<2/4:=4<:2/C;7@</:3=4/<:A2334:2/3=4=50123<> /232<>>@ 3=4 1432325/479><2A</3 17464774: </ <114<> 2/ * 5& 56 ) </: 23 D<0 74A</:4: 657 6740= 95/02:47<325/ 47;0<> 56 3=4 74957: 0=5D0 3=<3 * 5&56)D<062>4:<B<2/033=4<D<7:563=4 72?;/<> 2/ 5& 56 , :<34: ,, =4 72?;/<>2/3=40<2:C;:BA4/3=4>:3=<39><2A</36<2>4:35 175843=<30=40;03<2/4:2/C;7240599;774:5/ </: 3=;0 0=4 20 /53 4/323>4: 657 95A14/0<325/ </: :20A2004: 3=4 9><2A 1432325/ ;3 2/ * 5& 56 )23D<05?04784:3=<33=474D<0:4><@56):<@02/ 62>2/B3=495A1><2/3</:95/34/3056G=2?23D474<>05 :209;004: ?;3 =4>: 3=<3 3=4 72?;/<> D<0 /53 C;032624: 2/ :20A2002/B 3=4 9><2A 1432325/ 5/ 3=4 B75;/: 56 :4><@ <0 - 7 - D4>> <0 6<>04 2/85>84A4/3 56 3=4 84=29>4 D23=5;3 <:C;:29<32/B3=49<045/A47230</:3=;023D<074A</:4: ?<9E =4>4<7/4:95;/04>6573=4<114>></32/0;7</94 95A1</@03<34:3=<33=47420/5:209;0025/74B<7:2/B3=4 2A1>29<325/ 56 3=4 84=29>4 ?@ 3=4 72?;/<> <B<2/ =4 372?;/<> 03<34: 3=<3 <992:4/3 599;774: 5/ G=2?23*D<074B203474:5/</:3=47420 :4><@56&:<@000=4D<0;/:47374<3A4/3</:=4705/ D<04/B<B4:2/17582:2/BA4:29<>374<3A4/335=473=474 D<0 :4><@ 2/ >5:B2/B 3=4 * </: <9957:2/B>@ B7</34: 95A14/0<325/ =4 >4<7/4: 95;/04> 6;73=47 03<34: 3=<3 3=47420/5:209;0025/74B<7:2/B2/85>84A4/3563=4972A4 84=29>4 ;3 3=4 72?;/<> =<0 02A1>@ 5?04784: 3=<3 <0 9=<7B40=4432062>4:<63472/84032B<325/3=4<992:4/3=<0 599;774: 5/>@ :;4 35 3=4 /4B>2B4/94 56 3=4 :72847 56 3=4 5664/:2/B 84=29>4 / 3=4 D5;/: 94732629<34 23 D<0 03<34: 3=<3 23 20 < 75<: 37<6629 <992:4/3 84/ 2/ 3=4 :209=<7B4 0;AA<7@<>0523D<003<34:3=<30=40;03<2/4:2/C;7@2/< 75<:37<6629<992:4/3 - 8 - =4 1432325/479><2A</3 4G<A2/4: </ 4@4D23/400 5/ =47 ?4=<>6 5 :5;?3 0=4 A43 D23= </ <992:4/3 5/ ?;3 0=4 D<0 2/ 3=4 =50123<> 32>> </::209=<7B4:5/3=<3:<@=415>29403<34: 3=<33=5;B=3=4@7494284: 741573<00=4D<0/532/ 6;>> 95/0925;0/400 3=4@ 74957:4: =47 03<34A4/3 5/ </:2/3=40<2:03<34A4/30=4A4/325/4:3=4 /<A4 56 3=4 <65740<2: 9<7 </: 03<34: 3=<3 0=4 9<A4 35 E/5D<?5;33=4/;A?47563=49<73=75;B=3=44@4D23/400 </:?<04:5/3=40<2:03<34A4/3*D<074B203474:</: 9=<7B40=443D<0<>0562>4:<B<2/033=4:72847563=49<7 , =4 72?;/<> B7</34: 95A14/0<325/ 56 0,+%D23=2/347403<33=47<3456-F147<//;A 675A 3=4 :<34 56 1432325/ 32>> 74<>20<325/ </: :274934: 74015/:4/3 52/0;7</94 95A1</@ 35 1<@ 3=4 95A14/0<325/D23=2/3D5A5/3=053=462/:2/B74B<7:2/B 2/85>84A4/3 56 84=29>4 D<0 <>74<:@ :4<>3 D23= ?@ 3=4 72?;/<> </: 3=20 5;73 62/:0 /5 74<05/ 35 2/3476474 D23= 3=4 0<2: 62/:2/B 5D4847 3=4 <114>></32/0;7</94 95A1</@20:274934:35:4150233=495A14/0<325/<A5;/3 - 9 - 56 Rs.,+% D23= 2/347403 <3 3=4 7<34 56 &F 147 <//;A675A:<34561432325/32>>74<>20<325/ )/3=4740;>33=465>>5D2/B57:47201<004:' !2# 114<>20<>>5D4:2/1<73 !22# =4 ><2A</3 20 4/323>4: 657 3=4 353<> 95A14/0<325/56Rs.,+%D23=2/347403<3&14794/3 147 <//;A 675A 3=4 :<34 56 1432325/ 32>> 3=4 :<34 56 74<>2J<325/ !222# =4 <114>></3/0;7</94 95A1</@ 20 :274934: 35 :415023 3=4 <65740<2: 95A14/0<325/ D23=2/ 5/4 A5/3= 675A3=4:<3456951@563=2057:47 !28# /0;9=:4150233=49><2A</320147A2334:35 D23=:7<D 3=4 4/3274 <A5;/3 <>5/B D23= 3=4 2/347403 <997;4:5/23 *+, &% ( $ 203 5'> 5',&