- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) ! " " # $" ! % " && " " ' &&()*' & " " ! " && " "+ # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $"" & , " & '% & & *-$% & ( ! & & ! ' ' '+" ! " -'" & '- & ! ." ! $ /01233425013647466482920:1;;/4!<89=4:;2:8 2>26882;48' ' '+3211480: ? -'321148 @A;/4880;0?:254:0?60B05!<8942:8 252@<6290 $7?6 1/?6; C;/4 ;60@<:25D% 144E0:9 4:/2:F4=4:; ?7 ;/4 F?=34:12;0?: ' /4 F520=2:; =4; >0;/ 2FF084:; ?: ' 2:8 1<774648 9604B?<1 0:G<6041 4 ;??E ;642;=4:; 0: ;/4 ?130;25 4 70548 F520= 34;0;0?: 144E0:9 F?=34:12;0?: ?7 1 25?:9 >0;/ 0:;4641; @47?64 ;/4 ;60@<:25 /4 ;60@<:2527;46F?:108460:9;/44:;0644B084:F4?:64F?68/21 - 3 - 2>26848 2 1<= ?7 1 '- 25?:9 >0;/ 0:;4641; 2; ;/4 62;4?7)H3462::<=76?=;/482;4?734;0;0?:;055;/482;4 ?7 64250I2;0?: 99604B48 @A ;/4 1208 2>268 ;/4 F520=2:; 364746648 ;/4 36414:; 233425 144E0:9 4:/2:F4=4:; ?7 ;/4 F?=34:12;0?: - : ;/4 36414:; 233425 0; 01 F?:;4:848 ;/2; =42946 2=?<:;1 >464 962:;48 <:846 ;/4 /428 ?7 320: 2:8 1<77460:9 /4F520=2:;1<1;20:48=25<:0;48762F;<64?7609/; ;/ =4;2;26125 @?:4 2:8 =25<:0;48 762F;<64 ?7 547; 52;4625 =2554?5<1 2:8 641;60F;48 =?B4=4:; ?7 547; 2:E54 /4 F520=2:;>212860B46 <4;?;/42FF084:;/41<1;20:485?11 ?7 0:F?=4 /4 ;60@<:25 /21 2>26848 =42946 2=?<:;1 0 4 =480F25 4J34:141 2:8 251? 5?11 ?7 2=4:0;041 2:8 5?11 ?7 7<;<64 0:F?=4 8<60:9 ;642;=4:; 3460?8 2:8 2;;4:82:; F/26941 /4647?64/464K<41;17?64:/2:F4=4:; 426:48 F?<:145 7?6 ;/4 2334552:; =20:5A F?:;4:848 ;/2; /4 >21 >?6E0:9 21 2 860B46 J ) 01 ;/4 >?<:8F46;070F2;4 J *01;/48012@050;AF46;070F2;4011<48@A ' 4 >21 /?130;250I48 7?6 2 3460?8 ?7 ) 82A1 /4 - 4 - ?F;?6 21141148 ;/4 8012@050;A 21 - --H 2:8 ;/4 ;60@<:25 /21;2E4:H0 4 -68?7- --H2:8;/48012@050;A01;?@4 4:/2:F48 426:48 F?<:145 7?6 ;/4 6413?:84:; ?33?148 ;/4 12=4?:;/496?<:8;/2;;/4;60@<:25/21609/;5A;2E4:-68 ?7;/48012@050;A21141148@A ' ?:108460:9;/4:2;<64?7 ;/40:G<6A2:8;/4?30:0?:?7;/4?F;?6;/01?<6;70:81:? 6421?:;?0:;467464>0;/;/48012@050;A21141148@A;/4?F;?6 /4 F520=2:; /21 :? 70548 2:A 0:F?=4 36??7 4 =4; >0;/ 2FF084:; ?: ' 1 346 ;/4 9<08450:41 ?7 ;/4 26:2;2E2;2;4492546B0F41<;/?60;A/010:F?=401;?@4 ;2E4: 2; 1 * 7?6 ;/4 A426 ' 4:F4 ;/4 5?11 ?7 7<;<640:F?=401 1 *('((L1 *) /4 ;60@<:25 2>26848 2 1<= ?7 1 -' ;?>2681 =480F25 4J34:141 2:8 0; :4481 :? 0:;467464:F4 ?:108460:9;/4:2;<64?7;/40:G<60412:8;/4?FF<32;0?:?7 ;/4 F520=2:; 2:8 ?;/46 6454B2:; 72F;?61 ;/01 ?<6; 70:81 0; 6421?:2@54 ;? 4:/2:F4 ;/4 2=?<:; 962:;48 <:846 ;/4/428 320:2:81<77460:9;?21<=?71 5?11?72=4:0;041 - 5 - 1 ' ;62:13?6;2;0?: 4J;62 :?<601/=4:; 2:8 2;;4:82:; F/26941 ;? 1 - 4 =09/; /2B4 :?; 2;;4:848 2:A >?6E 7?6 2; 5421; 7?<6 =?:;/1 8<4 ;? ;/4 0:G<6041 1<1;20:48 @A /0= 4:F4 /4 01 4:;0;54 ;? 2 1<= ?7 1 - $1 * ( =?:;/1% 4:F4 ;/4 ;?;25 F?=34:12;0?:>?<58@421<:846 * +,-./01+2.,342 0523 20:2:81<77460:9 1 ' ?11?77<;<640:F?=4 1 *) - 480F254J34:141 1 -' ?11?72=4:0;041 1 ' 62:13?6;2;0?: 4J;62 :?<601/=4:; 2:8 2;;4:82:; F/26941 1 - ) ?11 ?7 0:F?=4 8<60:9 5208 <3 3460?8 $1 * ( =?:;/1% 1 - 3,* .! 6 ) /4F520=2:; 014:;0;548 ;? ;?;25 F?=34:12;0?: ?7 1 -') 25?:9 >0;/ 0:;4641; 2; ;/4 62;4 ?7 )H 346 2::<=76?=;/482;4?734;0;0?:;055;/482;4?764250I2;0?:21 2920:1;1 '-2>26848@A;/4;60@<:25 * 426:48 F?<:145 7?6 ;/4 :1<62:F4 F?=32:A 1<@=0;;48 ;/2; ;/4 F?=34:12;0?: 2=?<:; 2>26848 @A ;/4 ;60@<:2501843?10;48 - 6 - + FF?680:95A;/47?55?>0:9?6846 $0% /423342501255?>480:326;, $00% /4 F?=34:12;0?: 2>26848 @A ;/4 ;60@<:250:21<=?71 '-014:/2:F48;? 1 -')25?:9>0;/0:;4641;2;;/462;4?7)H 3462::<=76?=;/482;4?734;0;0?:;055;/482;4?7 64250I2;0?:, $000% :1<62:F4 F?=32:A 01 8064F;48 ;? 843?10; ;/4 4:/2:F48 F?=34:12;0?: ?7 1 -25?:9>0;/0:;4641;>0;/0:23460?8?7 ?:4=?:;/76?=;/482;4?7;/01?6846, $0B% : 1<F/ 843?10; ;/4 F520=2:; 01 346=0;;48 ;? >0;/862> ;/4 4:;064 2=?<:; 25?:9 >0;/0:;4641;2FF6<48;/464?: .-6 &% ( $ 01;? 5? -+