Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66785 (KAR)
GOPAMMA AND ORS v. SHIVARAJ AND ORS
MFA/201368/2021 · 2025-10-29
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66785 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66785 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #$% &'
&( ' '
( ' '
( ' ) '
)
( ' '
( ((" # %
&* & "
+"
,
# %
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( ' ' $ "($- ( * $")
( ' ! ' & $ "($- ( * +")
+"
,
#( (" . &/
%
- #% & & 0) ($ #1
&
%
&
2 3
&
'"! (-
& ' '
- 3 -
#' %
450 677869 :;<8= 8>?5@; - #% @A ?48 @?@= 845>980>?""#48=85;6A?8==8A8==8<?@60B?48>?CA@= 04@=?%460D88;A598<DE?48>965F6;?0D85;G6GG=58H8<DE ?48I:<GF8;?6;<6J6=<<6?8<"!76008<DE?48 <<98;5@=5H59:<G86;<
696D:=6G55; @(-
6>?0 G5H5;G =508 ?@ ?48 A595;G @A ?48 677869 D=58A9E0?6?8<6=8?46?@;"!6?6D@:?7F J48; ?48 <8>8608< >=@005;G ?48 =@6< DE J69K @; 5<6=$ :F76 =@6< ;86= 659@@= =@00 6? ?46? ?5F8 6 F@?@= >E>98 D86=5;G =8G50?=6?5@; @
$ "($- J45>4 J60 D85;G=5<<8;5;6=6046;<;8G95G8;?F6;;8=8;<6;G8=5;G ?@ 4:F6; 95A8 6;< <6048< 6G65;0? ?48 <8>8608< 0 6 =80:9? @A ?48 6A@=8065< 6>>5<8;? ?48 <8>8608< 0:0?65;8< G=58H@:05;I:=5806;<0:>>:FD8<?@?485;I:=580A?8=?48
- 4 -
6>>5<8;? ?48 <8>8608< J60 4@075?695L8< 6;< <:=5;G ?48 >@:=08@A?=86?F8;?48J60<58<
48>965F6;?0A598<678?5?5@;:;<8=8>?5@;!! @A ?48 >? 088K5;G >@F78;06?5@; A@= ?48 <86?4 @A ?48 <8>8608<69@;GJ5?45;?8=80? ) ; 7:=0:6;>8 @A 08=H5>8 @A ;@?5>8 ?48 =807@;<8;? @0 6;< 67786=8< ?4=@:G4 ?485= >@:;089 D:? 46H8 ;@? A598< 6;E @DI8>?5@; 6;< =807@;<8;? @ ;0:=6;>8@F76;E67786=8<?4=@:G45?0>@:;0896;<A598< @DI8>?5@; <8;E5;G ?48 6H8=F8;?0 F6<8 5; ?48 >965F 78?5?5@;
;?48D6050@A?487986<5;G0@A?4876=?580?48 965F0=5D:;69A=6F8<?48500:806;<?48=86A?8==8>@=<8< ?488H5<8;>848>965F6;?05;@=<8=?@7=@H8?48>608 >965F6;?@8M6F5;8<45F089A60&$6;<G@?8M45D5?8< <@>:F8;?0 ;6F89E M ?@ M ; D8469A @A =807@;<8;?0 ;85?48= 6<<:>8< 6;E 8H5<8;>8 ;@= G@? - 5 -
F6=K8< 6;E <@>:F8;?0 48 965F0 =5D:;69 DE ?48 5F7:G;8<I:<GF8;?489<?46??486>>5<8;??@@K 796>8 @; 6>>@:;? @A =604 6;< ;8G95G8;? =5<5;G @A ?48 @AA8;<5;G H845>98 DE 5?0 =5<8= 60 6 =80:9? @A J45>4 ?48 <8>8608<0:0?65;8<5;I:=5806;<0:>>:FD8<?@?485;I:=580 48=5D:;69A:=?48=489<?46??48>965F6;?06=88;?5?98<?@ 6>@F78;06?5@;@A0")-($69@;GJ5?45;?8=80?6??48 =6?8 @A !3 76 6;< <5=8>?8< ?48 ;0:=6;>8 @F76;E ?@ <87@05? ?48 >@F78;06?5@; 6F@:;? 69@;G J5?4 5;?8=80? 85;G6GG=58H8<DE?4806F8?450677869460D88;A598<
! =56;I88H 6?59 ?48 986=;8< >@:;089 A@= ?48 >965F6;?0460=6508<?48A@99@J5;G>@;?8;?5@;0' 6% 5=0?9E ?48 >965F6;?0 >965F ?46? ?48 <8>8608< J606G8<6D@:?)E86=06??48?5F8@A?486>>5<8;?6078= ?48=87@=?6;<48J6086=;5;G0($78=F@;?4 DE<@5;G?48D:05;8005;?48;6F8@A0?E98@A
:F6=:<5@ 6;<5<8@98>?=@;5>69806;<8=H5>88;?8=6?:FD65
- 6 -
:??48=5D:;694606008008<?48;@?5@;695;>@F8@A?48 <8>8608<6?0"($50@;9@J8=05<8 D% 8>@;<9E48460>@;?8;<8<?46?6078=?4896J 965< <@J; DE ?48 @;CD98 :7=8F8 @:=? 5; ?48 >608 @A
5; >608 ?48 <8>8608< J60 089A$8F79@E8< @= @; 6 A5M8< 0696=E 6; 6<<5?5@;@A3@A?4880?6D95048<5;>@F8?@J6=<0BA:?:=8 7=@078>?0C04@:9<D8?48J6==6;?J48=8?48<8>8608<J60 ?486G8@A)E86=04806F804699D8>@;05<8=8< >% 45=<9E6078=?4896J965<<@J;DE?48@;CD98 :7=8F8 @:=? 5; ?48 >608 @A #0:7=6% ?48>965F6;?06=88;?5?98<A@=0($?@J6=<0B9@00@A 80?6?8C6;<0($?@J6=<0BA:;8=698M78;080C <% @:=?49E 60 78= ?48 I:<GF8;? @A ?48 @;CD98 :7=8F8 @:=? 5; ?48 >608 @A
!
86>4 @A ?48 >965F6;?0 6=8 8;?5?98< A@=
- 7 -
>@F78;06?5@; @A 0)($ :;<8= ?48 486< @A B9@00 @A 9@H86;<6AA8>?5@;6;<>@;0@=?5:FC 8% 60?9E>@;05<8=5;G?486G86;<6H@>6?5@;@A?48 <8>8608< ?48 @H8=699 >@F78;06?5@; 6J6=<8< DE ?48 =5D:;6950@;?489@J8=05<88;>8487=6E0A@=699@J5;G ?48677869
- 8= >@;?=6 ?48 986=;8< >@:;089 A@= ?48 ;0:=6;>8 @F76;E 460 =6508< ?48 A@99@J5;G >@:;?8=$ >@;?8;?5@;0' 6% 5=0?9E8H8;?4@:G4?48>965F6;?046H8>965F8< ?46??48<8>8608<J6086=;5;G0"($78=F@;?4?48E 46H8 ;@? 80?6D95048< ?48 06F8 M>87? A@= 7=@<:>5;G ?48 0696=E >8=?5A5>6?8 6? M ?48 >965F6;?0 46H8 ;@? 8M6F5;8< ?48 6:?4@= @A ?48 065< <@>:F8;?0 48=8A@=8 ?48 =5D:;69 460 =5G4?9E 6008008< ?48 5;>@F8 @A ?48 <8>8608<;@?5@;699E
- 8 -
D% 8>@;<9E 05;>8 ?48 >965F6;?0 46H8 A6598< ?@ 80?6D9504?485;>@F8@A?48<8>8608<?48E6=8;@?8;?5?98< A@=>@F78;06?5@;?@J6=<0BA:?:=87=@078>?0C >% 45=<9E @; 677=8>56?5@; @A @=69 6;< <@>:F8;?6=E 8H5<8;>8 6;< >@;05<8=5;G ?48 6G8 6;< 6H@>6?5@; @A ?48 <8>8608< ?48 @H8=699 >@F78;06?5@; 6J6=<8<DE?48=5D:;6950I:0?6;<=860@;6D988;>848 7=6E0A@=<50F50069@A?48677869
" 86=< ?48 986=;8< >@:;089 A@= ?48 76=?580 6;< 78=:08<?48I:<GF8;?6;<6J6=<@A?48=5D:;69
?50;@?5;<507:?8?46?6;<K:F6=<58<5;?48 =@6< ?=6AA5> 6>>5<8;? @>>:==8< @; "! <:8 ?@=604 6;<;8G95G8;?=5<5;G@A?48F@?@=>E>98D86=5;G=8G50?=6?5@;
@
$ "($-DE5?0<=5H8=
H8; ?4@:G4 ?48 >965F6;?0 46H8 >965F8< ?46? <8>8608< J60 86=;5;G 0($ 78= F@;?4 8M>87? 7=@<:>5;G?480696=E>8=?5A5>6?86?MD:??48E6=8;@? - 9 -
8M6F5;8< ?48 6:?4@= @A ?48 <@>:F8;?0 0 78= ?48 G:5<895;80 500:8< DE ?48
6=;6?6K6 ?6?8 8G69 8=H5>80 :?4@=5?E A@= ?48 6>>5<8;? ?6K8; 796>8 5; ?48 E86= ! ?48 ;@?5@;69 5;>@F8 @A ?48 <8>8608< 460 ?@ D8 ?6K8; 6? 0"-($ 7F ? ?48 ?5F8 @A 6>>5<8;? <8>8608< J60 6G8<6D@:?)E86=03460?@D86<<8<@;6>>@:;?@A A:?:=8 7=@078>?0 48 <8>8608< J60 D6>489@= J8 6=8 @A ?48 @75;5@; ?46? 3 @A ?48 5;>@F8 460 ?@ D8 <8<:>?8< A@= 78=0@;69 8M78;080 6;< =8F65;5;G 6F@:;? 460 ?@ D8 ?6K8; 60 450 >@;?=5D:?5@; ?@ ?48 A6F59E 6;< F:9?57958= 67795>6D98?@4506G8G=@:750B)C4:0?48>965F6;?06=8 8;?5?98< ?@ >@F78;06?5@; @A 0"-($ #0"-($ M 3% #0 "($NN)N(?4% @; 6>>@:;? @A B9@00 @A <878;<8;>EC
; 6<<5?5@; ?48 >965F6;?0 6=8 8;?5?98< ?@ >@F78;06?5@;@A0($@;6>>@:;?@AB9@00@A80?6?8C 6;< >@F78;06?5@; @A 0($ @; 6>>@:;? @A BA:;8=69 8M78;080C
- 10 -
; H58J @A ?48 96J 965< <@J; DE ?48 :7=8F8 @:=? 5; ?48 >608 @A "
# #0:7=6%>965F6;?@06;<76=8;?0@A?48<8>8608<50 8;?5?98< A@= >@F78;06?5@; @A 0)($ 86>4 :;<8= ?48 486< @A B9@00 @A A59569 >@;0@=?5:F >965F6;?
@0 6;< ) D=@?48= 6;< 050?8= @A ?48 <8>8608< 6=8 8;?5?98< A@= >@F78;06?5@;@A0)($86>4:;<8=?48486<@AB9@00 @A>@;0@=?5:FC
48 >@F78;06?5@; @A ! "#$ 6J6=<8< DE?48=5D:;69:;<8=?48486<@ABF8<5>698M78;080C5060 78=?48F8<5>69D59907=@<:>8<DE?48>965F6;?04806F8 50I:0?6;<=860@;6D98
) 4:0?48>965F6;?06=88;?5?98<?@?48A@99@J5;G >@F78;06?5@;'
- 11 -
%&'(!)*+( ,(-'.-+'.'(* ')-! %,(*+( /!0 @00@A <878;<8;>E
"- :;8=698M78;080
@00@A80?6?8
@00@AA59569 >@;0@=?5:F
" @00@A>@;0@=?5:F
" 8<5>69M78;080 -)- *)1
#$
;?48=80:9??48A@99@J5;G@=<8=5076008<'
6% 4867786950)112'-+(&).* D% 48 I:<GF8;? @A ?48 965F0 =5D:;69 50 F@<5A58< >% 48 >965F6;?0 6=8 8;?5?98< ?@ 6 ?@?69 >@F78;06?5@; @A ! #$ 60 6G65;0? 0")-($6J6=<8<DE?48=5D:;69
- 12 -
<% 48 ;0:=6;>8 @F76;E 50 <5=8>?8< ?@ <87@05? ?48>@F78;06?5@;6F@:;?69@;GJ5?45;?8=80?6? !3 76 A=@F ?48 <6?8 @A A595;G @A ?48 >965F 78?5?5@; ?599 ?48 <6?8 @A =8695L6?5@; J5?45; 6 78=5@<@A05MJ88K0A=@F?48<6?8@A=8>857?@A >@7E@A?450I:<GF8;? 8% 48 677@=?5@;F8;? <87@05? 6;< =898608 @A 6F@:;?04699D8F6<85;?8=F0@A?486J6=<@A ?48=5D:;69
3-$ /430
3-$ /56750
50?@'9@')) '