- 1 - ! " # $!# $! ## %&' ( ! " Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $% &!'( ) * $ $ + #$ &( # $ , %" # %!'' - 3 - $- &!'( ) * $# . $# . $ (( / + # # *+ # $ # - (!(( # $ $- %0$ $- $ ' (' # - , # - $ 1 - 1 - # ! * 1 - #+ 234566758349387:;<=853>5?@49AB7?25?=7>7?@A9 =A>67?45@3A? 5C5B:7: 3? @7B>4 A9 DE:F>7?@ 5?: AB:7B :5@7:(!((3?$?A' ('65447:;<$::8 - 4 - 7?3AB 3G38 -E:F7 5?: 7>;7B %0$ $3D5<56EB5 *27B73?59@7BB797BB7:@A54H@B3;E?58I9AB;B7G3@<+ 5@7 A9 5==3:7?@ :75@2 A9 2B3J5?@ 5:5B 3?GA8G7>7?@A9G723=875?:835;383@<5B7?A@3?:346E@7 ?8< :346E@7 3? @234 566758 34 3? B7467=@ A9 KE5?@E> A9 =A>67?45@3A? 75B: B3 5?F5?5FAE:5 $ 3B5:5B 875B?7: =AE?478 9AB 5667885?@4 5?: >@ B77@3 5@38 78JE?:3 875B?7:=AE?4789ABB746A?:7?@A%?4EB5?=7A>65?< 5?: B3 E:25B425? 875B?7: =AE?478 9AB B746A?:7?@ A%3?4EB5?=7=A>65?< B35?F5?5FAE:53B5:5B875B?7:=AE?4789AB 5667885?@4 254 @5J7? @234 AEB@ @2BAEF2 DE:F>7?@ 5?: 5C5B: 65447: ;< @B3;E?58 5?: CAE8: 4E;>3@ @25@ A? @27 :5@7 A9 5==3:7?@ 37 A? (("(' @27 :7=7547: 2B3J5?@ 5:5B C54 5F7: ! <75B4 75B?3?F 4(((( % 6> 9BA> 5FB3=E8@EB7 A@3A?58 3?=A>7 9AB <75B (' 54 67B =25B@ 6B765B7: ;< 34 4!( % 5?: @B3;E?58 - 5 - 254 @5J7? 45>7 E@ @B3;E?58 254 ?A@ 5::7: 9E@EB7 6BA467=@4 3? @7B>4 A9 :7=343A? A9 A?I;87 67L AEB@ 3? =547 A9 ) B76AB@7: 3? 7 9EB@27B 4E;>3@4 @25@ @27 5C5B: E?:7B =A?G7?@3A?58 275:4 34 584A A? 8AC7B 43:7 =A?43:7B3?F ?E>;7B A9 :797?:5?@4 ;73?F 47G7? 3? ?E>;7B ==AB:3?F8<274AEF2@9AB588AC3?F5667585?:7?25?=3?F =A>67?45@3A? ! 7B =A?@B5 >@B77@3 5@38 78JE:?3 54 C788 54 B3E:25B425> 875B?7: =AE?478 4E;>3@@7: @25@ 3? 5;47?=7 A9 3?=A>7 6BAA9 @B3;E?58 254 6BA67B8< @5J7? 3?=A>7 A9 :7=7547: 5@ 4!( % B3;E?58 254 584A 5C5B:7: 566BA6B35@7 =A>67?45@3A? E?:7B A@27B 275:4 ?4A95B 54 8A44 A9 =A?4AB@3E> @A 5667885?@ ?A 34 =A?=7B?7:@B3;E?582545C5B:7: 4!(((( %5?:@AC5B:4 8A44A99383588AG75?:5997=@3A?3?B7467=@A9A@27B=853>5?@4 @B3;E?58 254 5C5B:7: 4!((( % B3;E?58 5C5B:7: 4(((( %@AC5B:49E?7B587L67?4745?:A;47KE3745?: - 6 - 4(((( %@AC5B:48A44A974@5@744E=2@275C5B:34 DE4@ 5?: 6BA67B 5?: :A74 ?A@ =588 9AB 5?< 3?@7B97B7?=7 ==AB:3?F8<4AEF2@@A:34>344566758 5G3?F 275B: =AE?478 5?: 59@7B 67BE43?F 7?@3B7 566758 6567B4 KE74@3A?4 C23=2 5B3474 9AB =A?43:7B5@3A? 5B7 M3+ 27@27B @27 =A>67?45@3A? 5C5B:7: ;< @B3;E?58 ;793@4 C3@23? @27 7L6B7443A? DE4@ =A>67?45@3A?N 33+93@34?A@4AC27@27B3?@7B97B7?=7;<@234 AEB@34=5887:9AB7?25?=7>7?@NO EB5?4C7B@A5;AG76A3?@49AB=A?43:7B5@3A?343? 65B@8<5993B>5@3G79AB9A88AC3?FB754A?4 ' :>3@@7:8< 5==3:7?@ A==EBB7: 3? @27 <75B (' ?=A>7 93L7: ;< 9AB <75B (' 34 4!( % ? G37CA985C853::AC?;<A?I;87E6B7>7AEB@3?=547A9 *E6B5+ @5J3?F 3?@A =A?43:7B5@3A? 5F7 A9 :7=7547: 54 ! <75B4 !P AEF2@ @A 25G7 ;77? 5::7: @AC5B:4 9E@EB7 6BA467=@4 A?43:7B3?F ?E>;7B A9 - 7 - :797?:5?@4 3? @7B>4 A9 85C 853: :AC? ;< A?I;87 67L AEB@ 3? =547 A9 ! " # $%& % B76AB@7: 3? ' 5 4E> A9 4(((( % 254 @A ;7 5::7: @AC5B:4 938358 =A?4AB@3E> @A 75=2 A9 @27 :797?:5?@4 37 4'(((( % AC5B:4 9E?7B58 7L67?474 5?:8A44A974@5@7 4!((( %@A75=2275:345C5B:7: ?G37CA9DE:F>7?@A9A?I;87E6B7>7AEB@3?=547A9 *4E6B5+(P254@A;75::7:5474=585@3A? A? @27 =A>67?45@3A? 5C5B:7: E?:7B =A?G7?@3A?58 275:4 9AB 75=2 @2B77 <75B4 9BA> ( ? =547 A? 25?: @27B7 5B7 @CA @7B>4 A9 @2B77 <75B4 ==AB:3?F8< 5 4E> A9 4((( %34B7KE3B7:@A;75C5B:7:E?:7B@27275:A9 (P74=585@3A?9AB@CA@7B>437(P==AB:3?F8<A?B7% :7@7B>3?5@3A?A9=A>67?45@3A?45>7CAE8:;7549A88AC4 *+,-./0*1-+231 /412 A44A99E@EB7:767?:7?=< *Q!(R!PSLL % !+ 4"((( % 1 (2018) 18 SCC 130 - 8 - A44A9=A?4AB@3E> *((((L+ 4'(((( % A44A974@5@7 4!((( % #E?7B587L67?474 4!((( % (P74=585@3A? 4((( % 2+5 - " 6"7 " #AB59AB7453:B754A?49A88AC3?FAB:7B 3+ 6675834( 33+ -E:F>7?@ 5?: AB:7B :5@7: (!(( 3? $?A' ('65447:;<$::87?3AB 3G38 -E:F7 5?: %0$ $3D5<56EB5 34 >A:3937: 667885?@4 5B7 7?@3@87: 9AB =A>67?45@3A? A9 4((( % 54 5F53?4@ 4(( % 5C5B:7: ;< @B3;E?58 5==AB:3?F8< @27 7?25?=7>7?@ CAE8: ;7 5@ 4'(( % 45>7 42588 =5BB< 3?@7B74@ 5@ P659BA>:5@7A967@3@3A?@388B7583T5@3A? 333+ A@2 3?4EB5?=7 =A>65?374 42588 :76A43@ 7?25?=7: =A>67?45@3A? C3@23? 5 67B3A: A9 - 9 - 43L C77J4 9BA> :5@7 A9 B7=736@ A9 =A6< A9 @234AB:7B;79AB7=A?=7B?7:@B3;E?58 3G+ 66AB@3A?>7?@ 5?: :34;EB47>7?@ A9 7?25?=7:=A>67?45@3A?5467BAB:7B65447: ;<@B3;E?58 G+ ?G37CA945>7?AAB:7B54@A=A4@ ,7 %#' ! ,7 %' ! - 34@A8A