Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66774 (KAR)
JAYAPPA @ JAYANANDA v. BHIMAPPA AND ANR
MFA/200359/2025 · 2025-11-20
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66774 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66774 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$ $$
%!& '
! " # ! $!$
%
! & $$ '( )&
& (! (! & & ) ! ! $
*& *
)) $+'! " # !&
&
$!)(, $ !!!((
*
%
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&) ) ! #%)
&
$ * &
&
& &)
&
*
!(!((' $ &
$ $&$!+ (((! & ) & &
* $
& -&
#
./01. 2.3 455346 78 678239 :/; 49<7887/= >72. 2.3 ?/=83=2 /: 634;=39 ?/0=836 :/; 2.3 54;2738 72 78 24@3= 05 :/;:7=469785/846! (! .78 455346 78 :7639 4147=82 2.3 A091<3=2 4=9 4>4;9 94239 !(!((' 548839 BC 2.3 ;7=?7546 3=7/;
7D76 0913 4=9 &
$ $7A4C450;4 7= &$ /!+ /: (((! ! .3 ?647<4=2 <32 >72. 4= 4??793=2 /= +!+!((4=9808247=391;73D/087=A0;38! .3;3:/;3.3 :7639 4 ?647< 532727/= B3:/;3 2.3
;7B0=46 ?647<7=1 ?/<53=8427/=/:8! ! .3
;7B0=46?/=8793;7=1 2.3 3=27;3 3D793=?3 /= ;3?/;9 1;4=239 ?/<53=8427/= /:
- 3 -
8!(( >72. 7=23;382 42 +E 5!4! :;/< 2.3 9423 /:
532727/= 2766 ;34678427/= 4=9 97;3?239 ;385/=93=2 /! >=3;2/935/8722.384<3! '! 11;73D39BC2.38479A091<3=24=94>4;92.3 7=A0;39 ?647<4=2 .48 5;3:3;;39 2.78 455346 7= >.7?. 72 78 ?/=23=9392.422.3
;7B0=467842.7;954;2C4=9482.3;3 >48=/9;7D7=167?3=?32.3
;7B0=46/01.22/.4D3/;93;39 :/;54C4=9;3?/D3;C!&341;34</0=284;31;4=2390=93; /2.3; .3498! =23;382 78 2/ B3 4>4;939 42 E 5!4! .3;3:/;3;3F038239:/;3=.4=?3<3=2/:?/<53=8427/=! ! 34;92.34;10<3=28/:B/2.87938! +! 34;=39?/0=836:/;;385/=93=2/!(=80;4=?3 /<54=C ?/=23=939 2.42 2.3
;7B0=46 .48 4>4;939 8! 2/>4;98 53;<4=3=2 5.C87?46 9784B7672C 4=9 6/88/:4<3=72738 4853;2.393?787/=/:2.3/=GB6353H /0;2 7= 2.3 ?483 /:
- 4 -
4=9 468/ 4>4;939 493F0423 ?/<53=8427/= 0=93;/2.3;.34984=972=3398=/7=23;:3;3=?3! ! 34;=39 ?/0=836 :/; 2.3 4553664=2 ;36739 05/= 2.3 A091<3=2 /: 2.3 /=GB63 53H /0;2 7= ! " # $!! ! %! & #(4=980B<722392.422.37=?/<3/:2.34553664=2782/ B3 24@3= B487=1 /= 2.3 <7=7<0< >4138 /: 2.3 8@76639 >/;@3;7=2.3?/=?3;=39564?3! .34;=424@4 24233146 3;D7?38 02./;72C .48 5;354;39 ?.4;2 B487=1 /= 2.3 <7=7<0<>413853;247=7=12/2.3?/=?3;=39C34;8!3=?3 482.34553664=2<32>72.4=4??793=27=2.3C34;((.78 =/27/=467=?/<3782/B324@3=428!'( 53;</=2.! 3 >48 4139 C34;8 4=9 2.3 455;/5;7423 <06275673; 78 IG! ! 8 53; H!&397?/63146 3;27:7?423 2.3 4553664=2.48808247=392.3:/66/>7=17=A0;738 ! );4?20;3/:63:2:3<0;
1 AIR 2014 SC 736 2 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 871
- 5 -
(! );4?20;3/:63:227B74 ! 0264?3;4239>/0=9/D3;6423;467<54?2/:63:2 2.71.4=963:2631! '! 02 64?3;4239 >/0=9 /D3; 6423;46 4853?2 /: 63:2 3C3B;/>! ! B;487/=/D3;63:21;3422/3! 853;H!'>/0=9?3;27:7?423.3.48808247=392.3 :/66/>7=17=A0;738 ! 47=4=923=93;=388/D3;2.363:22.71.! (! 47=4=923=93;=388/D3;2.363:2631! .39/?2/;488388392.39784B7672C42E2/2.363:2 6/>3;67<B4=9 ;9/:72?/<382/+E! .082.36/88/: :020;334;=7=18>/069B3 8!'(H(HH+EJ8!'+ ! ! .3
;7B0=46 .48 4>4;939 4= 4</0=2 /: 8!+ 2/>4;98<397?463H53=8384853;H8! 4=94=972=3398=/7=23;:3;3=?3! - 6 -
! .3 4553664=2 >48 49<72239 7= 2.3 ./857246 :/;
( 94C8! /=8793;7=12.3=420;3 /:7=A0;7384=953;7/9/:
./85724678427/= 2.78 /0;2 :7=98 72 ;348/=4B63 2/ 1;4=2 4= 4</0=2/:8! :/;547=4=980::3;7=18!(
:/; 6/88 /: 4<3=72738 4=9 8!
:/; 2;4=85/;2427/= 3H2;4=/0;78.<3=24=94223=94=2?.4;138! ! .3 4553664=2 <71.2 =/2 .4D3 4223=939 4=C >/;@ 42 63482 :/; 4 53;7/9 /: :/0; </=2.8 903 2/ 2.3 7=A0;738808247=39! .3;3:/;32.78/0;2:7=9872;348/=4B63 2/1;4=24=4</0=2/:8! #8!'(H'%:/;6/88 /:7=?/<390;7=164790553;7/9! (! 3=?32.34553664=2783=272639:/;2.3</97:739 ?/<53=8427/=0=93;97::3;3=2.349848B36/> 47=4=980::3;7=1 8! &397?463H53=838 8!+
/88/::020;334;=7=18 8!'+
/88/:7=?/<390;7=164790553;7/9 8! ;4=85/;2427/= 3H2;4 =/0;78.<3=2 4=94223=94=2?.4;138 8! /88/:4<3=72738 8!(
()* +,,-
- 7 -
.082.34553664=2783=272639:/;2/246?/<53=8427/= /:8!' ' >72.7=23;38242+E53;4==0<:;/<2.3 9423/:532727/=2766;34678427/=! ! .3
;7B0=46 .369 2.42 2.42 2.3;3 >48 =/ 9;7D7=1 67?3=?3 4=9 48 80?. 2.3 />=3; 46/=3 78 674B63 2/ 54C 2.3 ?/<53=8427/= 4=9 3H/=3;4239 2.3 =80;4=?3 ?/<54=C! />3D3; 48 72 78 4 ?483 /: =/ 9;7D7=1 67?3=?3 2.78/0;2:7=9872;348/=4B632/;36C05/=2.3A091<3=2/:
2.3/=GB6353H/0;27="
'#( ) ! * 4=9 /;93; :/; 54C 4=9 ;3?/D3;C 2/ 2.3 =80;4=?3 /<54=C! .3;3:/;3 ;385/=93=2 /!( =80;4=?3 /<54=C 78 97;3?239 2/ 935/872 2.3 2/246 ?/<53=8427/= /: 8!' ' >72. 7=23;38242+E5!4!>72.67B3;2C2/;3?/D3;2.384<3:;/< ;385/=93=2/!/>=3;/:2.3D3.7?63! '! =2.3;380622.3:/66/>7=1/;93;78548839 #7% 5534678466/>397=54;2! 3 (2018) 3 SCC 208
- 8 -
#77% .3 4553664=2 ?647<4=2 78 3=272639 :/; 2/246 ?/<53=8427/= /: 8!' ' >72. 7=23;382 42 +E 53;
4==0<:;/<2.39423/:532727/=27662.39423/:;34678427/=! />3D3;4853;/;93;94239!!((2.34553664=278 =/23=272639:/;7=23;382:/;2.39364C3953;7/9/:++94C8 7=:767=12.3455346! #777% 385/=93=2 /!(=80;4=?3 /<54=C 78 97;3?239 2/ 935/872 2.3 4:/;38479 ?/<53=8427/= 4</0=2 >72.7=/=3</=2.:;/<2.39423/:2.78A091<3=24=92.3C 4;3 67B3;2C 2/ ;3?/D3; 2.3 84<3 :;/< ;385/=93=2 /! K />=3;BC9035;/?388/:64>! #7D% = 80?. 935/872 2.3 4553664=2 78 53;<72239 2/ >72.9;4> 2.3 3=27;3 4</0=2 46/=1 >72. 7=23;382 4??;039 /=72! +.- %$& #
782/! 6/!'