Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66760 (KAR)

AMBARISH @ AMRESH S/O TIPPANNA HAWALDAR v. TIPPANNA S/O NAGAPPA AND ANR

MFA/202422/2022 · 2025-10-09

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' () $$ * %&' ( ) !! " # !$ % & !'() ')((* !'() '+,)% ',-% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! !',,%*% # &. %,**- % & & %/(% & & %/*%* (-*%+ ' * ( ) " ! ! && "& ! ! !',,%*% # % - 3 - ',-%(+ & !'() ')((* !'() '+,)% ',-%(+ # !$&%. *+%**, & & %/(% & %+ %/*%* (-*%+ ' " & & 0 # 0 12341516788679:7;69<:56=>2;7=?<::<2@A<51516 B2@:6@52>967;@6=B23@:69>2;51687;5<6:516C7;657D6@ 38>2;><@79=<:82:79 - 4 - 67;=5167;43?6@5:2>E251:<=6: ( 16:6788679:7;6><96=747<@:5516F3=4?6@57@= 7A7;= =756= %/*%* 87::6= EC 516 252; BB<=6@5: 97<?: ;<E3@79'7=74<;<<@2(-2>*%+ - 16>7B5:2>516B7:67;651752@*,%*%516 B97<?7@5A6@5521<:123:6>2;=;<@D<@4A756;7@=A1<9616 A7: ;653;@<@4 52 516 97@= EC A79D 7 ;7B52; E67;<@4 ;64<:5;75<2@ 2!'() ')((* 7@= ;7<96; 2!'() ' +,)% B7?6 <@ ;7:1 7@= @649<46@5 ?7@@6; 7@= =7:16= 52 516B97<?7@5=3652A1<B116:3:57<@6=4;<6G23:<@F3;<6: , 16 <@F3;6= B97<?7@5 746= , C67;: ><96= 7 B97<? 865<5<2@ E6>2;6 516 ;<E3@79 B97<?<@4 B2?86@:75<2@ 2> :,****' 16 ;<E3@79 B2@:<=6;<@4 516 6@5<;6 6G<=6@B6 2@ ;6B2;= 4;7@56= B2?86@:75<2@ 2> :(,-(' A<51 <@56;6:5 75 )H 87 >;2? 516 =756 2> 865<5<2@ 5<99 ;679<:75<2@ 7@= =<;6B56= ;6:82@=6@5 2' @:3;7@B62?87@C52=682:<5516:7?6 - 5 - ) 44;<6G6=EC516:7<=F3=4?6@52>516 ;<E3@79 516 <@F3;6= B97<?7@5 17: 8;6>6;;6= 7@ 788679 <@ & 2*-* 7@= 516 @:3;7@B6 2?87@C 17: 8;6>6;;6= 7@2516; 788679 <@ & 2*%)(* 7@= <@ E251 516 788679: I37@53? 2> B2?86@:75<2@ 7A7;=6= EC 516 ;<E3@79<:=<:8356= / 16 B97<?7@5 <@ 1<: 788679 B2@56@=6= 5175 16 17: :3:57<@6= >;7B53;6 <@F3;<6: E35 516 ;<E3@79 17: 4;7@56= <@7=6I3756 B2?86@:75<2@ 6 A7: 67;@<@4 :%,***' 86; ?2@51 EC =2<@4 74;<B3953;79 A2;D 35 516 ;<E3@79 17: 57D6@ 2@9C :%****' 86; ?2@51 6 6J7?<@6=5162B52;7:A127::6::6=516=<:7E<9<5C 75 -*H 52 516 92A6; 9<?E 7: 86; J+ E35 516 ;<E3@79 17: 6;;2@623:9C 57D6@ <5 7: (*H 12341 16 ;6I3<;6: 7@2516; :3;46;C @2 7?23@5 <: 4;7@56= 3@=6; 516 167= K>353;6 ?6=<B79 6J86@:6:L 13: 16 ;6I36:56= >2; 6@17@B6?6@5 16@:3;7@B62?87@C<@<5:788679B2@56@=6= 5175516<@:3;6=G61<B96A7:@25<@G29G6=<@5167BB<=6@5 - 6 - 7@=<5A7:>79:69C<?89<B756=516=;<G6;2>516G61<B96A7: @2517G<@4G79<==;<G<@49<B6@B67@=516;6<:G<2975<2@2>516 829<BC B2@=<5<2@: 2 6C6A<5@6:: A7: 6J7?<@6= 16 ;<E3@79 17: >7<96= 52 788;6B<756 5175 516 2A@6; 7@= <@:3;6; 2> 516 5;7<96; 7;6 79:2 6I3799C 9<7E96 52 87C 516 B2?86@:75<2@7@=516B2?86@:75<2@4;7@56=<:6JB6::<G6 7@= 513: ;6I36:56= >2; ?2=<><B75<2@ 5 <: >3;516; :5756= 5175516=697C<@><9<@4516788679EC516B97<?7@5<:52E6 B2@:<=6;6= + 67;@6= B23@:69 >2; B97<?7@5 B2@56@=6= 5175 7::6::6= 516 =<:7E<9<5C 75 -*H E35 516 ;<E3@79 6;;6=<@57D<@4516=<:7E<9<5C7:(*H16;67:516967;@6= B23@:69 >2; 516 @:3;7@B6 2?87@C B2@56@=6= 5175 516 ;<E3@7917:;<4159CB2@:<=6;6=516=<:7E<9<5C7@=<5@66=: @2<@56;>6;6@B6 16B97<?7@517::3:57<@6=7E;7:<2@96>5 69E2AF2<@5>;7B53;62>;<415>6?3;869G<B=<7516:<:7@=16 ><96= A23@= B6;5<><B756 3@=6; J) 7@= =<:B17;46 :3??7;<6:3@=6; J:/7@=66J7?<@6=5162B52; 7: 7@= 79:2 ><96= =<:7E<9<5C B6;5<><B756 3@=6; J+ - 7 - : 86; J+ M =<:7E<9<5C B6;5<><B756 516 B97<?7@5 17: :3:57<@6= *H 92A6; 9<?E =<:7E<9<5C 7@= *H 5;3@D =<:7E<9<5C 35 516 >;7B53;6: 7;6 3@<56= 2@:<=6;<@4 516 :7<= >7B5 516 ;<E3@79 17: ;<4159C 57D6@ 516 =<:7E<9<5C 7: (*H 7@=51<:23;5 ><@=:@2 ;67:2@ 52 <@56;>6;6 A<51 516 =<:7E<9<5C7::6::6=EC516 ;<E3@79 %* 16 B97<?7@5 A7: 746= , C67;: =2<@4 74;<B3953;79A2;D7@=4655<@4:%***'86;?2@51E35 @2<@B2?68;22><:8;2=3B6=:16?65A<517@7BB<=6@5 2@ *,%*% 7: 86; 516 43<=69<@6: :5<839756= EC 516 !7;@757D7575664796;G<B6:3512;<5C1<:<@B2?6<:52 E6 57D6@ 75 :%%/,*' 86; ?2@51 16 ?395<89<6; 2> % 7=2856=EC516 ;<E3@79<:F3:57@=8;286;7@=<5@66=:@2 <@56;>6;6@B6 16;6>2;651692::2>>353;6<@B2?6B2?6:52 :%%/,*J%J%J(*HN/)%-**' %% 16;6<:@2=<:8356;647;=<@4?6=<B796J86@:6: 4;7@56=EC516 ;<E3@7975:%(/-('A1<B1@66=:@2 <@56;>6;6@B6EC51<:23;5 - 8 - % : 86; 516 =2B3?6@5: 516 B97<?7@5 17: :3>>6;6= >;7B53;6 2> ;<415 >6?3; 7@= 869G<B =<7516:<: 7@= 16A7:12:8<579<O6=>2;%%=7C:2@:<=6;<@4516@753;62> 516 <@F3;<6: 7@= 516 86;<2= 2> 12:8<579<O75<2@ 51<: 23;5 ><@=: <5 788;28;<756 52 4;7@5 7@ 7?23@5 :,****' >2; 87<@ 7@= :3>>6;<@4. 7@ 7?23@5 2> :****' >2; 92:: 2> 7?6@<5<6: 7@= 7@ 7?23@5 2> :(****' >2; 5;7@:82;575<2@6J5;7@23;<:1?6@57@=7556@=7@5B17;46: %( &3;516; 516 B97<?7@5 ?<415 @25 17G6 7556@=6= 1<:A2;D75967:5>2;786;<2=2>51;66?2@51:=3652516 <@F3;<6: :3:57<@6= <@ 516 7BB<=6@5 16;6>2;6 51<: 23;5 ><@=: <5 ;67:2@7E96 52 4;7@5 7@ 7?23@5 2> :(,,*' :%%/,*'J(>2;92::2><@B2?6=3;<@497<=3886;<2= %- 13: 516 B97<?7@5 <: 6@5<596= >2; 516 B2?86@:75<2@7:3@=6; 9 2 67=: A7;=EC516 ;<E3@79 A7;=EC51<: 23;5 % 7<@ 7@= :3>>6;<@4: :****' :,****' 6=<B79 6J86@:6: :%(/-(' :%(/-(' - 9 - ( 2:: 2> >353;6 67;@<@4B787B<5C :)-***' :/)%-**' - 556@=7@5 B2@G6C7@B6 B17;46: >22= 7@=@23;<:1?6@5 :%****' :(****' , 2:: 2> 7?6@<5<6: 7@= >353;6 3@1788<@6:: '' :****' ) 2:: 2> <@B2?6 =3;<@4 97<= 38 86;<2= :**** :(,,*' +,- ./!!/( .*!! ( 0.. 1,2345+6027489,- ./!!/( +,-096,9:0;09+ .*! /!( %, 16 @:3;7@B6 2?87@C B2@56@=6= E6>2;6 516 ;<E3@79 5175 516 =;<G6; 2> 5162>>6@=<@4G61<B96 A7: @25 17G<@4 G79<= =;<G<@4 9<B6@:6 35 B2@:<=6;<@4 516 B28C 2> 516 =;<G<@4 9<B6@:6 ><96= E6>2;6 516 ;<E3@79 <5 A7: B967; 5175516=;<G6;A7:17G<@4G79<==;<G<@49<B6@:6755165<?6 2> 7BB<=6@5 7@= 7BB2;=<@49C 516 @:3;7@B6 2?87@C <: 9<7E965287C516B2?86@:75<2@ %) 16C79:2;7<:6=2EF6B5<2@:51755162A@6;7@= <@:3;6; 2> 516 5;7<96; A6;6 @25 <?8967=6= E6>2;6 516 ;<E3@79 16C234155217G657D6@:7<=2EF6B5<2@E6>2;6 - 10 - 516 ;<E3@797551667;9<6;82<@52>5<?6E35516C>7<96=52 =2 516 :7?6 6@B6 516 :7<= 7;43?6@5 B7@@25 E6 7BB6856= @2A 16 7?23@5 7A7;=6= EC 516 ;<E3@79 <: =682:<56=EC516@:3;7@B62?87@CE6>2;6516 ;<E3@79 16;6>2;6 ;6:82@=6@5 2 B7@@25 E6 6J2@6;756= >;2? 5169<7E<9<5C %/ @ 516 ;6:395 516 788679 ><96= EC 516 B97<?7@5 =6:6;G6:52E687;59C7992A6=7@=516788679><96=EC516 @:3;7@B6 2?87@C <: 52 E6 =<:?<::6= 7@= 16@B6 516 >2992A<@4 < & 2*-* ><96= EC 516 B97<?7@5<:7992A6=<@87;5 << & 2*%)(* ><96= EC 516 @:3;7@B62?87@C<:16;6EC=<:?<::6= <<< 16 <?834@6= F3=4?6@5 7@= 7A7;= 87::6=EC516 ;<E3@79<:16;6EC?2=<><6= <G 16 B97<?7@5 <: 6@5<596= >2; 516 6@17@B6= B2?86@:75<2@ 2> :%+),*' A<51 - 11 - <@56;6:575516;7562>)H86;7@@3?>;2?516 =7562>865<5<2@5<99;679<O75<2@ G 16 @:3;7@B6 2?87@C <: =<;6B56= 52 =682:<5 516 6@17@B6= B2?86@:75<2@ 792@4 A<51<@56;6:5A<51<@786;<2=2>2@6?2@51>;2? 516=7562>51<:F3=4?6@5 G< @ :3B1 =682:<5 516 B97<?7@5 <: 75 9<E6;5C 52 A<51=;7A 516 6@5<;6 6@17@B6= B2?86@:75<2@7?23@55246516;A<51<@56;6:5 3( %$' # <:52%92,