- 1 - ! "#$## #%% & '( ')%*& '** + ! " " # $% "!& " Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $'( " " " )!)! !!)! " $'% " *! %" " " # + $# + ,- .//01-2 34 56 .1- 7 8 9!')! 94 :,-;36-9;:,-6-.<4-2223:394.6 -11394102=-" > 7 8 3?.@.50<. ,-<-34.;:-< <-;-<<-2 :9 .1 A<3.6 90<:B ;9< :,- 1.C- 9; /94D-43-4/- 31 3E50=434= :,- ?02=E-4: 9; /94D3/:394 2.:-2 )!)! .42 9<2-< 9; 1-4:-4/-2.:-2!!)!/94D3/:34=,3E;9<:,-9;;-4/- 50431,.F6- 042-< -/:394 $'% 9; 423.4 -4.6 92- ;9< 1,9<:AB .42 -/:394*! 9;:,-<9:-/:3949;,362<-4 ;<9E -G0.6 ;;-4/-1 /: ;9< 1,9<: A B .42 1-4:-4/34= ,3E :9 042-<=9 <3=9<901 3E5<3194E-4: ;9< . - 3 - 5-<3929;)@-.<1.42:95.@.;34-9;1*))))>;9<:,- 9;;-4/-042-< -/:394$'%9;.42042-< -/:394%9; ,-/.1-9;:,-5<91-/0:39434F<3-;31:,.:#! :,- E9:,-< 9; :,- D3/:3E 692=-2 :,- ;3<1: 34;9<E.:394 .1 5-<G!.66-=34=:,.:,-<2.0=,:-<31.=-2!!@-.<1.42 :,- .//01-2 3420/34= ,-< F@ 5.@34= E94-@ /9EE3::-2 .==<.D.:-2 5-4-:<.:3D- 1-G0.6 .11.06: 20<34= "-F<0.<@ )! 34:,- 6.42F-694=34= :9 94-044.50<..6.:-.42 :,-<-F@/9EE3::-2:,-9;;-4/-1.11:.:-2.F9D- $ 4:,-F.1319;:,-;3<1:34;9<E.:394692=-2F@ #! " .1 5-< G! H.1 <-=31:-<-2 .=.341: :,- .//01-2 //01-2 H.1 .55<-,-42-2 3/:3E .42 :,- .//01-2 H-<- 10F?-/:-2 :9 E-23/.6 -G.E34.:394 ;:-< /9E56-:34= :,- 34D-1:3=.:394 /,.<=->1,--: /.E- :9 F- ;36-2,-<3.690<::99C/9=43I.4/-;9<:,-.F9D-1.32 9;;-4/-1 .42 10EE94-2 :,- .//01-2 //01-2 ,.1 - 4 - .55-.<-2F-;9<-:,-<3.690<:.4256-.2-249:=036:@;9< :,-/,.<=-16-D-66-2.=.341:,3E.42/6.3E-2:9F-:<3-2 ( ,- 5<91-/0:394 34 9<2-< :9 5<9D- :,- =036: 9; :,- .//01-2 -G.E34-2 #1! :9 ! =9: E.<C-2 29/0E-4:1 .: G1! :9 ( 34 10559<: 9; 3:1 /94:-4:394 .42 32-4:3;3-2 ! .42 ,- .//01-2 ,.1 2-43-2 .66 :,- 34/<3E34.:34= E.:-<3.61 .D.36.F6- 94 <-/9<2 .42 -G.E34-2:,<--H3:4-11-1.1#!:9#$34,312-;-4/- * ;:-<:.C34=34:9/94132-<.:394.66:,-E.:-<3.61 94<-/9<2:,-<3.690<:/.E-:9:,-/94/601394:,.::,- 5<91-/0:394 31 10//-11;06 34 5<9D34= :,- =036: 9; :,- .//01-2F-@942<-.194.F6-290F:.42.//9<234=6@5.11-2 :,- 3E50=4-2 ?02=E-4: 9; /94D3/:394 .42 9<2-< 9; 1-4:-4/- -34= .==<3-D-2 F@ :,- 1.E- .//01-2 31 34 .55-.6F-;9<-:,3190<: % -.<2 <3 .E.2.50<6-.<4-2/9041-6;9< :,-.55-66.4: <3 .42--5.:366-.<4-2/9041-6;9<:,- 1-/942<-15942-4:.42 <3.E.2.< ,.,.F022346-.<4-2 - 5 - /9041-6 ;9< :,- ;3<1: <-15942-4:> :.:- -<01-2 :,- E.:-<3.6134/60234=:,-<3.690<:<-/9<21 ' 4 D3-H 9; :,- <3D.6 /94:-4:3941 0<=-2 F@ 6-.<4-2/9041-6;9<F9:,:,-5.<:3-1:,-5934::,.:H9062 .<31-;9<E@/94132-<.:39431 J @.41H-<:9:,-.F9D-5934:31A ;9<:,-;9669H34= : 31 :,- /94:-4:394 9; :,- 5<91-/0:394 :,.: D3/:3E H.1 .=-2 !$ @-.<1 .42 :,- .//01-2 H.1 .=-2 ' @-.<1 ,- .//01-2 ,.2 60<-2 .42 :99C ,-< :9 :,- 4-3=,F9<34= 6.42 /9EE3::-2 .==<.D.:-2 5-4-:<.:3D- - 6 - 1-G0.6 .11.06: <-5-.:-26@ 20<34= :,- ;3<1: H--C 9; "-F<0.<@)! !) : 31 .619 1:.:-2 :,.: 94 )$)! :,- .//01-2H.1.=.34;90424-.<:,-,901-9;:,-D3/:3E- H.1 1--4 F@ # > :,- ;.:,-< 9; :,- D3/:3E =3<6 .42 :,-<-F@ 34/32-4: ,.1 /.E- 34:9 63=,: H,3/, <-106:-2 34 ;3634=9;:,-;3<1:34;9<E.:394F@#!.15-<G!.=.341: :,-.//01-2 !! 4 G! :,- E9:,-< 9; :,- D3/:3E =3<6 ,.1 1:.:-2:,.:H,-41,-H.134;9<E-2F@,-<1941:,.::,- D3/:3E =3<6 H.1 :.C-4 F@ :,- .//01-2 :9 :,- 4-.<F@6.42 ,-K0-1:394-2:,-D3/:3E,-D3/:3E 34;9<E-2,-<:,.: :,-.//01-2,.1/9EE3::-2<.5-94,-< 34/-.//01-231 /691-6@<-6.:-2:9:,-;.E36@1,-,.24-D-<<-D-.6-2:,31 ;./: :9 ,-< ,01F.42 .42 1,- C-5: K03:- F@ .2D3134= :,- D3/:3E =3<6 49: =9 H3:, :,- .//01-2 9H-D-< .=.34 94 )$)! :,- ;.:,-< 9; :,- D3/:3E =3<6 49:3/-2 :,- .//01-2 4-.< :,- ,901- 20<34= 43=,: ,90<1 .42 1/962-2 ,3E:H.1:,-<-.;:-<#!34;9<E-2.F90::,-34/32-4: - 7 - 34 K0-1:394 :9 :,- ;.:,-< 9; :,- D3/:3E =3<6 #,-4 -4K03<-2 :,- D3/:3E 4.<<.:-2 :,- 9;;-4/- /9EE3::-2 F@ :,-.//01-2:,.:1,-H.1:.C-4:9:,-4-.<F@6.42F@:,- .//01-2 .42 /9EE3::-2 <.5- .42 5.32 1!))> -./, 94 :H9 9//.13941 ,-<-.;:-< :,- ;3<1: 34;9<E.:394 /.E- :9 F-692=-2 ! 4 <-/-35: 9; :,- ;3<1: 34;9<E.:394 :,- D3/:3E =3<6 .42 :,- .//01-2 H-<- 10F?-/:-2 :9 E-23/.6 -G.E34.:394F@:,-#!!L9/:9<,-9/:9<,.13110-2 G1! .42 !$ .//9<234= :9 H,3/, :,- ,@E-4 9; :,- D3/:3E=3<6 H.1 <05:0<-2 9H-D-< 1,- 1:.:-1 3:E.@ F- 20-:9/@/634=,9<1-<3234=.42,-.D@-G-</31--:/ ,- .619 1:.:-1 :,.: 1,- 29-1 49: ;342 .4@ 13=4 H,3/, 31 10==-1:3D-9;5-4-:<.:394.111:.:-2F@:,-D3/:3EH3:,:,- ,31:9<@9;<.5-/9EE3::-294,-<F@:,-.//01-2 !$ #! F-34= :,- ;3<1: 34;9<E.4: :,- E9:,-< 9; :,-D3/:3E=3<6;066@10559<:-2:,-/.1-9;:,-5<91-/0:394 - 8 - !( #31:,-D3/:3E=3<6.=-2.F90:!!@-.<11,- .619 ;066@ 10559<:-2 :,- /.1- 9; :,- 5<91-/0:394 .42 H3:,1:992:,-6-4=:,@.421-.</,34=/<911>-G.E34.:394F@ :,-6-.<4-2/9041-6;9<:,-.//01-2 !* #1$ :9 * .<- :,- E.,.I.< H3:4-11-1 :9 :,- 159:E.,.I.<.:G(#%31:,-;9<E.6H3:4-11H,931 :,-4-3=,F90<:9:,-#!#'31:,--.2 .1:-<9;:,- /,996 H,-<- :,- D3/:3E H.1 1:02@34= .42 ,.2 3110-2 -<:3;3/.:-1.15-<G1J.42.//9<234=:9H,3/,:,- 2.:-9;F3<:,9;:,-D3/:3E=3<631!!))J.::,-:3E-9; 34/32-4:,-<-;9<-.194:,-2.:-9;34/32-4:.194 "-F<0.<@)!1,-H.1.=-2946@!!@-.<1 !% #J#!:9#!%.42#!J.<-:,-;9<E.6 9;;3/3.6H3:4-11-1#31:,-;.:,-<9;:,-D3/:3E=3<6H,9 2-591-2 .F90: 49:3/34= :,- .//01-2 4-.< ,31 ,901- .42 ;3634= 9; :,- ;3<1: 34;9<E.:394 .1 5-< G! #!' 31 :,- H,9 <-=31:-<-2 :,- " .42 /9420/:-2 343:3.6 34D-1:3=.:394 #! 31 :,- 34D-1:3=.:34= 9;;3/-< H,9 /9420/:-2:,-34D-1:3=.:394.42;36-2:,-;34.6<-59<: - 9 - !' ,--D32-4/-9;#!##.42#!!.<- D-<@E.:-<3.6:9;34290:.1:9H,-:,-<:,-5<91-/0:39431 10//-11;06345<9D34=:,-=036:9;:,-.//01-29<49:# -D-4:,90=,E349<.=-2!!@-.<1,.1;066@10559<:-2:,- /.1-9;:,-5<91-/0:394-<-D32-4/-/9<<9F9<.:-2F@:,- -D32-4/-9;#!>:,-E9:,-<9;:,-D3/:3E=3<6 !J #!! L 9/:9< 1:.:-1 :,.: ,@E-4 H.1 <05:0<-2 F0: 3: E.@ F- 20- :9 <.5- /9EE3::-2 F@ :,- .//01-29<E.@F-20-:9/@/634=9<,9<1-<3234=:H.1 4-D-< :,- /94:-4:394 9; :,- .//01-2 :,.: :,- D3/:3E =3<6 H.101-2:9/@/634=9<,9<1-<3234=#!!,.1=3D-4,-< 9534394 042-< G!$ :,.: :,-<- H.1 49 13=4 9; 5-4-:<.:394:315-<:34-4::949:-:,.::,-34/32-4:,.2 :.C-456./-20<34=:,-;3<1:H--C9;"-F<0.<@)!,- D3/:3EH.110F?-/:-2:9-G.E34.:394946@94()$)! 42-<10/,/3</0E1:.4/-1H-/.449:-G5-/:.4@13=419; 5-4-:<.:394;904294:,-F92@9;:,-D3/:3E=3<6 - 10 - ! : 31 :,- /94:-4:394 9; :,- 6-.<4-2 /9041-6 ;9< :,-.55-66.4:.//01-2:,.::,-<-H.1366>H366F-:H--4#! .42:,-.//01-2:9;36-.;.61-/9E56.34:.1:,-D3/:3E.42 .//01-2 H-<- /901341 ,-<- H.1 23150:- F-:H--4 #! .42 :,- ;.:,-< 9; :,- .//01-2 ,- E9:3D- 9< 366>H366 31 .6H.@1 . 290F6- -2=-2 H-.594 4 D3-H 9; :,- 1.32 E9:3D- .//01-2 E3=,: ,.D- /9EE3::-2 :,- 9;;-4/- 9<-9D-< 29 49: ;342 .4@ <-.194 :9 231F-63-D- :,- D-<1394 9; #! # .42 # ,-<-;9<- .E 9; :,- 9534394:,.::,-.//01-2,.1/9EE3::-25-4-:<.:3D-1-G0.6 .11.06: 94 :,- E349< =3<6 .1 2-;34-2 042-< -/:394 $ 50431,.F6-042-< -/:394(9;:,- /: ) ,- 9;;-4/- 34 K0-1:394 H.1 /9EE3::-2 20<34= ;3<1: H--C 9; "-F<0.<@ )! ,-<-;9<- :,- .//01-2 31 63.F6-;9</94D3/:394;9<E343E0E5-<3929;1-D-4@-.<19; 3E5<3194E-4:,-.E-42E-4::9 -/:394(9;:,- /: H.1 !%)J)! 50431,.F6- H3:, E343E0E 3E5<3194E-4: ;9< . 5-<392 9; !) @-.<1 H,3/, 31 49: - 11 - .5563/.F6-:9:,-;./:19;/.1-34,.422949:;342.4@ <-.194:93E591-E.G3E0E1-4:-4/-94:,-.//01-2 ! ,.D-=94-:,<90=,:,-3E50=4-2?02=E-4:9; /94D3/:394 .42 9<2-< 94 1-4:-4/- 5.11-2 F@ :,- <3.6 90<: ,- <3.6 90<: ,.1 .55<-/3.:-2 :,- E.:-<3.61 94 <-/9<2 .42 /.E- :9 :,- /94/601394 :,.: :,- .//01-2 ,.1 /9EE3::-2 :,- 9;;-4/- <-5-.:-26@ 94 :,- D3/:3E =3<6 .42 /9EE3::-2 :,- 9;;-4/- 50431,.F6- 042-< -/:394 *6 50431,.F6- 042-< -/:394 % 9; :,- /: .42 .//9<234=6@ 1-4:-4/-2 ,3E :9 042-<=9 <3=9<901 3E5<3194E-4:;9<.5-<3929;)@-.<1 34/-:,-34/32-4: ,.2 :.C-4 56./- 5<39< :9 .E-42E-4: .42 134/- 3: 31 :,- 15-/3;3//94:-4:3949;:,-5<91-/0:394:,.::,-.//01-2,.2 /9EE3::-25-4-:<.:3D-1-G0.6.11.06:946@94/-20<34=:,- ;3<1: H--C 9; "-F<0.<@ )! :,- 3E50=4-2 ?02=E-4: 9; /94D3/:394.42 9<2-< 9; 1-4:-4/-/.661 ;9< 34:-<;-<-4/- F@ :,3190<://9<234=6@.41H-<:,-.F9D-5934: .425<9/--2:95.11:,-;9669H34= - 12 - 3 ,-.55-.631 33 ,- 3E50=4-2 ?02=E-4: 9; /94D3/:394 2.:-2 )!)!.429<2-<9;1-4:-4/-2.:-2!!)! 5.11-2 34 5-/3.6 .1- 9!')! F@ :,- 223:394.6 -113941 02=-" > 3?.@.50<31E923;3-2.1042-< . ,- .55-66.4:.//01-2 31 /94D3/:-2 ;9< :,- 9;;-4/- 042-< -/:394 $ 50431,.F6- 042-< -/:394 ( 9; :,- /: .42 ,- 31 1-4:-4/-2 :9 042-<=9 <3=9<901 3E5<3194E-4:;9<.5-<3929;'@-.<1.42:9 5.@;3429;1*))))>42-;.06::95.@ ;34-,-1,.66042-<=913E56-3E5<3194E-4: ;9<.5-<3929;%E94:,1 F ,-.55-66.4:.//01-231-4:3:6-2;9<1-:9;; - 13 - / ,- 9:,-< 59<:394 9; :,- 9<2-< 5.11-2 F@ :,-<3.690<:1,.66,962=992 2 -=31:<@ :9 1-42 F./C :,- <3.6 90<: <-/9<21 .694= H3:, /95@ 9; :,31 ?02=E-4: ;9<34;9<E.:394.42;9<4--2;06./:394 ,& '##* $ 31:9! 69*