Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66745 (KAR)
SATTEWWA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/200264/2025 · 2025-11-19
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66745 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66745 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$#%##
&'#( '
)*
&'#(
+*
&'#(
,
&'#(
*
&'#(
'
! ""
"
! ! #
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! $
%
! %
! ! %"
&
! %#
! &"
! ! &&
- 3 -
$
! $
! """
"
! "%%
#
! #!#
%
! #! ! #!%
! %""
- 4 -
&
! %
! %&
! '
! &
"$ '
! &
(
) *
+
+
+
$$$
"
++
+
- 5 -
$
#
$
%
++
++
++
+
+
$
+,
++
! (
) +%-
+*
' +
""
""& +
+
./01
*
'
+
+
+
'
+
+
$"$""$"
+ &$"$" %
, ' '
"*
'
+
%
- 6 -
+
+
+
'
'
)*'
'''
2
" '''
2
#
'
2
%
2
2
'
2
&
'
'
2
'
2
- 7 -
! 2
$
2
'
2
"
2
#
'
2
%
,
2
2
'
2
& '
2
- 8 -
'
2
! '''
2
"$
'''
2
"
'''
2
""
2
"# '
2
"%
,
'
2
"
'
2
" ,
'
2
"&
'
2
- 9 -
" '
2
"! ''
2
#$ '' ' '
2
# , '
2
#"
'
2
##
2
#%
'
2
#
2
# , '
2
- 10 -
#&
,
'
2
# '''
2
#! 2
%$ ,
2
% ''
2
%" '''
2
%#
2
%%
'
2
%
'
2
- 11 -
%
2
%& '' '
2
%
2
%! 2
$
2
'
2
"
2
#
2
%
- 12 -
2
2
2
&
2
2
! 2
$
2
2
"
2
- 13 -
#
'
2
%
'+
2
+
2
2
&
'
2
2
! '
2
&$
2
- 14 -
&
'
'
2
&"
'
2
&#
2
&%
2
&
2
&
2
&&
2
&
2
- 15 -
&! 2
$
2
2
"
2
# , '
2
%
2
'
2
'' '
2
- 16 -
&
2
2
!
2
!$
2
! 2
!"
'
2
!#
2
!%
2
- 17 -
! 2
! 2
!&
2
! 2
!! '
2
$$
2
$
2
$"
2
- 18 -
$#
2
$%
2
$ '
2
$ '
2
$& ,
2
$
3
2
$! 2
$
2
- 19 -
2
"
2
#
2
%
'
2
, '
2
2
&
2
2
- 20 -
! '
2
"$
2
"
2
""
2
"#
2
"%
'
2
"
2
" , '
2
- 21 -
"&
2
"
2
"! 2
#$
'
2
# '
2
#"
2
##
2
#%
2
- 22 -
#
'
2
#
2
#&
'
2
#
2
#! '
2
%$ '
2
%
2
%" , '
2
- 23 -
%#
2
%% '
2
% '''
2
%
'
2
%&
2
%
2
%! 2
$ '''
2
''4
'
2
" '
2
- 24 -
# '
2
% '''
2
2
2
&
2
2
! 2
$
2
2
"
2
- 25 -
#
2
% ,
'
2
'
2
2
& '
2
'
2
! 2
&$
'
2
&
2
- 26 -
&"
2
&#
2
&%
2
&
'
2
&
2
&&
2
&
2
&! '
2
$ +3 '
2
2
- 27 -
" 3
2
# '
2
%
' '
2
2
2
& +
2
'
2
! 2
!$
2
- 28 -
! 2
!" '
2
!#
2
!%
2
! '
2
! '
2
!&
2
! '
2
!! 2
"$$
2
- 29 -
"$
2
"$"
2
"$#
2
"$% '
2
"$ '
2
"$
'
2
"$& '
2
"$ '
2
"$!
2
"$ '
2
- 30 -
"
2
""
2
"# +
2
"%
'
2
"
'
2
"
'
2
"& +
'
2
"
' '
2
"! '
2
- 31 -
""$
2
""
2
"""
+'
2
(
)
*
+
+
$
" +
$$"
#
+
!$$$
%
+
55
"&
+
$
- 32 -
++
++
6 $
&
+,
++
$
(
) +# - + +%-
+&*
' +
""
""& +
+
* '
+
+
#""$"%
&
+
,
*
'
'
+
& +
+
'
#+
"$"
+
,
)*
7 +
+
+
- 33 -
+*'
! %#
"
$
#
#
#
%
'
%&
%
"$$
'
%
$
&
%&
&"$
$
"
! '
- 34 -
""&
$
#&&
%#
%
"
,
%&
#
' #
""
% '
%%
'
%
&#
%!&
&
%%
$
$%
- 35 -
! "
% ! "$
$
"
"%
(
) *
+
+
$$$
" +
$
#
+
"$! %
++
+
$
- 36 -
$
+,
++
(
) #- %-
+*
' +
"" +
+
*
"$)"*)809* +
!! " +
$#"$# 3
$"$#
' +
"%#
"%# 3+
+
, * '
+
,
3
+
* '
+
'
+
+ "$"%"$"! '
+
'
+ +
"$)"* )809* * '
+
%
+
+
*
+
+
- 37 -
,'
! %"%
"
! % %
#
! %
%
! %
'
! #"
'
! #"
- 38 -
&
! %
! #$
! ! "$! $ +
! ""#"
! ""
"
! #
! %
- 39 -
%
! ! %
! &
! ! ! ! "
"$
! - 40 -
"
! ""
""
! #
"#
! #
"%
! "&
"
! "! "
! #$
"&
- 41 -
! "#! "
! "%$
"! !
"%&
#$
! "%! #
! "! #"
'
! #$$
##
! #
#%
- 42 -
! #
#
! #%
#
! ##
#&
! # %
#
! $
#! ! %$ ,
! !"
- 43 -
%
! %"
! %# '
! $
%%
! %
! "$$
%
! " $
%&
! "
- 44 -
%
! "
%! ! #%
$
! &%
! "! "
! #$! #
! #$
%
! %&
- 45 -
! %
! !%
&
,
! !#$
! $#
! ! $%
$
! ""
! "#$
- 46 -
"
! "! #
! #!$
%
! #! ! %
! %"
&
! %! ! $#
- 47 -
! ! $%
&$ ,
! ! &
! "
&"
! %
&#
! #
&%
'
! %%
&
4
! !$
- 48 -
&
! ! &&
! "%
&
! %
&! '
! %
$
! &$
! &! "
! !$! - 49 -
#
! !$"
%
! !$
! "$$"
! "$%
&
! "$&#
! "%! ! ! "%&
- 50 -
!$
! "%&
! ! "% ! !"
! "%%
!#
! "%#
!%
! "%#&
! ! "! ! ! "#
- 51 -
!&
! "#
! ,
! ""&
!! ,
! ""&
$$
! ""! $
! ""
$"
! "##
$#
3
! "! - 52 -
$%
! $"! $ 4
! $"
$
! &! $&
! " #
$
! &""
$! ! &
$
! - 53 -
&#
! &"
"
! #%
#
! %$
(
) *
+
+
+
$$$
"
++
+
$
#
- 54 -
$
%
++
++
++
+
+
$
+,
++
!
(
) +%
+*
' +
""
""& +
+
* '
+
+
+ '
+
+
$"$""$"
+ &"$" %
, ' '
"*
'
+
%
+
+ +
'
'
- 55 -
*'
! #&
"
! %
#
! %
%
! $&
! $
! - 56 -
&
,
! "
! "&
! ! #
$
! ""#"
! ""
"
! #
! #
- 57 -
%
! %
! "
! %
&
! ! ""#
! ! ""&
"$
! "#$
- 58 -
"
! "#
""
! "%#
"#
! "
"%
! "
"
! "
"
! #%
"&
! #%"
- 59 -
"
! ##
"! ! #%
#$
! %!%
#
! %&
#"
! %"
##
! % ! #%
! "$
- 60 -
#
)*
! &#
#
! &#&
#&
! ! #
! ! #! ! !! %$
! "%
%
! "#&
- 61 -
%"
! #! %#
! %% ) *
! "! % '
! "! %
! "##
%&
! ""! %
! ""%
- 62 -
%! ! "#""
$
! "#""
! "#%
"
! "#! #
! "#!! %
! "%$
! "%$"
- 63 -
! "%$#
&
! "%%&
! "% $
! ! "%&"
$
! "%$
! "$"
"
! "$
- 64 -
#
! ""
%
! """
! ""
! "%%
&
! #
! $#
! ! "
- 65 -
&$
! #
&
! &%
&"
! ! &#
! !&
&% ,
! "$#
&
! #"! &
! "&&
- 66 -
&&
! &
&
! !"
&! ! "%
$
! #$
, ) *
! #%&
"
! "
#
! "$#$
- 67 -
%
! ""#
! !$#
!
&
&
! %
(
) *
+
+
+
$$$
"
++
+
$
- 68 -
#
$
%
++
++
++
+
+
$
+,
++
! (
) +%-
+*
' +
""
""& +
+
* '
+
+
+ '
+
+
$"$""$"
+ &"$" %
, ' '
"*
'
+
%
+
+ +
'
'
- 69 -
+ '
5
) 5
*
:.0.0;<:=1 8=: >:?;=: ./01 ;@=. 0< ./:1: A=0. B:.0.0;<1 CD80E0<F .; >: ./: B=0E8=G E:E>:=1 ;? ./:
090H;HH:1/8 =8./8E0I =8E::< =@1/0 8/8I8=0 8<F/
0G8E0.8<<@1::I0<F?;DD;A0<F=:D0:?1
'
*
11@: 8 A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1 H0=:C.0<F ./: =:1B;<H:<.1 .; 0<CD@H: ./:
<8E:1 ;? ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 0< ./: ?0<8D :D0F0>D:
<;<>;==;A:=1 9;.:= D01. 8<H .; B:=E0. ./: B:.0.0;<:=1.;C81../:9;.:0<./::D:C.0;<.;
./: C;EE0..:: ;? E8<8F:E:<. ;? ./: ./ =:1B;<H:<. 1;C0:.G 1C/:H@D: .; >: /:DH ;< $"$""$" 81 B:= ./: C8D:<H8= ;? :9:<.1 H8.:H &$"$" B@>D01/:H >G ./: %./ =:1B;<H:<. 90H: 8<<:J@=:8 >G 8DD;A0<F ./01 A=0.B:.0.0;<
"* ; 011@: A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1 H0=:C.0<F ./: %./ =:1B;<H:<. .; H:CD8=: ./:
:D:C.0;< =:1@D.1 ;? ./: ./ =:1B;<H:<.1;C0:.G 8?.:= C;EBD:.0;< ;? ./: :D:C.0;< B=;C:11 0< 8CC;=H8<C:A0./D8A
- 70 -
)*'
*
11@: 8 A=0. ;= ;=H:= 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? C:=.0;=8=0 K@81/0<F ./: ?0<8D 0<:D0F0>D: 9;.:=1 D01.1H8.:H#""$"%B811:H>G=:1B;<H:<. ;1 8<H & 0<
0<1;?8= 81 ./:
B:.0.0;<:=1 8=: C;<C:=<:H 90H: <<:J@=: 8<H
"*
11@: 8 A=0. ;= ;=H:= A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1H0=:C.0<F./:=:1B;<H:<. ;&.; =:H;./:?0<8D:D0F0>D:9;.:=1D01.B:=.80<0<F.; H:?8@D.:=10<C;EBD08<C:A0./@D:#H;?./: E:<H:H@D:1"$">G0<CD@H0<F./:<8E:1 ;? ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 8. <<:J@=: 8<H H =:1B:C.09:DG
+*'
* :CD8=: ./8. :C.0;< "$)"*)809* ;? ./: 8=<8.8I8C;;B:=8.09:1;C0:.0:18C.!!81 0<1:=.:H >G 1:C.0;< " ;? 8=<8.8I8 C.
;$#"$# B@>D01/:H 0< ./: F8L:..: ;< $"$#01@D.=890=:18<HD8CI1D:F01D8.09: C;EB:.:<CG0<90:A;?=.0CD:"%#8<H"%#3 ;?./:;<1.0.@.0;<;? <H0890H:<<:J@=:
"*
11@: 8 A=0. ;=H:= ;= H0=:C.0;< 0< <8.@=: ;? C:=.0;=8=0 K@81/0<F <<:J@=: 90L ./:
0<:D0F0>D: 9;.:=1 D01.1 E:E>:= H8.:H <0D B@>D01/:H >G ./: =:1B;<H:<.1 ; 0< 1; ?8= 81./:B:.0.0;<:=/:=:0<8=:C;<C:=<:H
#*
11@: 8 A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1 ;= 8<G ;./:= 8BB=;B=08.: A=0. ;= ;=H:= ;?
H0=:C.0;< H0=:C.0<F ./: =:1B;<H:<.1 .;
C;<H@C../::D:C.0;<1.;./:=:1B;<H:<. ;
- 71 -
;C0:.G ?;= ./: .:=E
"$"%"$"! 0< 8CC;=H8<C: A0./ ./: D01. ;? E:E>:= 1;C0:.0:1 A0./;@. 0<101.0<F ?;= C;EBD08<C: ;? :C.0;<
"$)"* )809* ./: 8=<8.8I8 ;;B:=8.09:
;C0:.0:1C. %*
11@: 8 A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1 H0=:C.0<F ./: =:1B;<H:<.1 ;% 8<H .;
0<CD@H: ./: <8E:1 ;? ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 0< ./:
:D0F0>D: 9;.:=1 D01. ;? =:1B;<H:<. ; 1;C0:.G
,'
* 11@: 8 A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1 H0=:C.0<F ./: =:1B;<H:<.1 .; 0<CD@H: ./:
<8E:1 ;? ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 0< ./: ?0<8D :D0F0>D:
>;==;A:=1 9;.:= D01. 8<H .; B:=E0. ./: B:.0.0;<:=1.;C81../:9;.:0<./::D:C.0;<.;
./: C;EE0..:: ;? E8<8F:E:<. ;? ./: ./ =:1B;<H:<. 1;C0:.G 1C/:H@D: .; >: /:DH ;< $"$""$" 81 B:= ./: C8D:<H8= ;? :9:<.1 H8.:H &"$" B@>D01/:H >G ./: %./ =:1B;<H:<.90H: <<:J@=: >G 8DD;A0<F ./01 A=0.B:.0.0;<
"* ; 011@: A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1 H0=:C.0<F ./: %./ =:1B;<H:<. .; H:CD8=: ./: :D:C.0;<=:1@D.1;?./:./=:1B;<H:<.1;C0:.G 8?.:= C;EBD:.0;< ;? ./: :D:C.0;< B=;C:11 0< 8CC;=H8<C:A0./D8A
*'
*
11@: 8 A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1 H0=:C.0<F ./: =:1B;<H:<.1 .; 0<CD@H: ./:
<8E:1 ;? ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 0< ./: ?0<8D :D0F0>D:
>;==;A:=1 9;.:= D01. 8<H .; B:=E0. ./: B:.0.0;<:=1.;C81../:9;.:0<./::D:C.0;<.;
- 72 -
./: C;EE0..:: ;? E8<8F:E:<. ;? ./: ./ =:1B;<H:<. 1;C0:.G 1C/:H@D: .; >: /:DH ;< $"$""$" 81 B:= ./: C8D:<H8= ;? :9:<.1 H8.:H &"$" B@>D01/:H >G ./: %./ =:1B;<H:<.90H: <<:J@=: >G 8DD;A0<F ./01 A=0.B:.0.0;<
"* ; 011@: A=0. 0< ./: <8.@=: ;? E8<H8E@1 H0=:C.0<F ./: %./ =:1B;<H:<. .; H:CD8=: ./: :D:C.0;<=:1@D.1;?./:./=:1B;<H:<.1;C0:.G 8?.:= C;EBD:.0;< ;? ./: :D:C.0;< B=;C:11 0< 8CC;=H8<C:A0./D8A
" 81: ;? ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 01 ./8. ./: :D:C.0;< .; ./:180H1;C0:.GA811C/:H@D:H.;>:/:DH;<$"$""$" 8<H C8D:<H8= ;? :9:<.1 0< ./:1: =:F8=H1 A:=: 011@:H ;< &$"$" /8../:=: A:=:.A; C8.:F;=0:1 ;?:E>:=1 <8E:DG >;==;A:=1 8<H <;<>;==;A:=1 /: B:.0.0;<:=1 A:=: 0< ./: C8.:F;=G ;? <;<>;==;A:=1 8<H ./:G 8=: ./:
8C.09: E:E>:=1 ;? ./: =:1B;<H:<.1;C0:.G /;@F/ ./:
B:.0.0;<:=1 A:=: :D0F0>D: 9;.:=1 8<H A:=: 8D1; :D0F0>D: .; C;<.:1../::D:C.0;<./:0=<8E:1A:=:H:D:.:H81./:G/8H <;. 8..:<H:H ./: 8<<@8D F:<:=8D E::.0<F1 /8. A0./;@.
011@0<F <;.0C: .; ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 81 =:K@0=:H @<H:= @D: #)"*)0* 8<H )00* ;? ./: 8=<8.8I8 ;;B:=8.09:
- 73 -
;C0:.0:1 @D:1 ! $ M/:=:0<8?.:= =:?:==:H .; 81 N./:
@D:1 ! $7 ?;= >=:90.GO 8<H A0./;@. /:8=0<F ./:
B:.0.0;<:=1./:0=<8E:1/89:>::<H:D:.:H?=;E./:D01.;? :D0F0>D: 9;.:=1 :0<F 8FF=0:9:H ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 8BB=;8C/:H./01;@=.1::I0<F./:8>;9:=:D0:?1 # < #$"$" ./01 ;@=. /8H B811:H ./: ?;DD;A0<F;=H:=
! ! !! ! " ! ! #$
%
! &''('" &''('
)('(' %
*
&+,-.$
/
*
"01(
%
"
%
"
2
. ('(''('3%"! - 74 -
! -
! ! .*
" %
" %" 4 %
5
% G ;=H:= H8.:H $""$" ./01 ;@=. /8H .8I:< <;.: ;? ./: 1@>E0110;< E8H:
./8. ./;@F/ =:1B;<H:<. ;"A81 =:1.=80<:H ?=;E C;@<.0<F ./: 9;.:1 /:/8HC;@<.:H./:9;.:18<HH:CD8=:H./:=:1@D.18I0<F <;.: ;? ./: 18E: ./01 ;@=. /8H 1.8G:H ./: :D:C.0;<1 ;? ./:H/G8I1/88<H B8H/G8I1/8A/0C/A811C/:H@D:H.;
>: /:DH ;< #$""$"
. 01 1@>E0..:H ./8. ./;@F/ ./: 9;.:1C81.:H0<./::D:C.0;<81B:=./:D01.8<<;@<C:H/89: >::<C;@<.:H./:9;.:1;?./:B:.0.0;<:=1/89:<;.>::< C;@<.:H 8<H 0< 90:A ;? ./: 0<.:=0E ;=H:= F=8<.:H >G ./01 C;@=.:D:C.0;<.;./:B;1.;?H/G8I1/88<H B8H/G8I1/8 018D1;<;.C;<H@C.:H
:8=H:=@1:H./:=:C;=H1
- 75 -
:.0.0;<:=1 /89: :11:<.08DDG =801:H ./: 011@: A0./ =:F8=H .; B=;B=0:.G ;= ;./:=A01: ;? ./: B=;C:11 ;? B=:B8=8.0;< ;? :D:C.;=8D =;DD1 +@=./:= 10<C: <; ;./:= F=;@<H1 ;= =:D0:?1 8=: B=:11:H >:?;=: 8H9:=.0<F .; ./:
=098D 1@>E0110;<1 ;< ./: 011@: ;? B=:B8=8.0;< ;? :D:C.;=8D =;DD1 8<H 1::I0<F 0<H@DF:<C: 0< ./: B=;C:11 ;? :D:C.0;< <:C:118=G .; =:?:= .; ./: 1:..D:H B;10.0;< ;? D8A 0< ./: E8..:=;?:<.:=.80<0<FB:.0.0;<1=8010<F011@:1B:=.80<0<F.; :D:C.0;<B=;C:11 & B:J ;@=. 0< ./: C81: ;? !" #$%&# $"$' 91 #( )%"$"!#$)1@B=8*=:?:==0<F.;0.198=0;@1:8=D0:= P@HFE:<.18.B8=8F=8B/#"/811@EE:H@B81@<H:= * 6
- % % % ! ! ! % %. 7
! ! ! %
%
% ! ! 8$
+,
" - .# $ /& 0!' $1$! " %! " 1 "! $ 1$!& &
$ # !"
"
#!"
!"$" $%, / "! 2% "! 0## 2%& "' #"3 #
$$%1&- /$%& $1$$"& #1$!&
"'"$-#3(&
4%!"$!'#"
- 76 -
/ 11! "
$ # 1& 1$!& , '!%&#"!$!$!0
"% "& 2% " %/$3 # 1$&$
#
"!
"" # 1
# '#& ! 0"$! 1& $
%$#$"
#
1$!&
" / !$/! " 2%&# &9/ 4 " -
!: . 4
% %
$
% 4
%
! ! %
! ! %
% , #% $$%1&- /$%& $ !"'& # 1$&$
# 1$!&- 4%!"$3"3""/
""
# %$ #" / %&#
$ $' $$ $ ##1$&$
#1$!&- $3 # /" #$- $ 1$$3 " 3"1
3! #"0%!/$ !$'!$$!$!$$$3"//'## $% "$ !"$! "! "&
$ 3(& #4%$! #%$
9. ! %
%
! ! &'0; 9
! ! "
"
. -
! %
! ! ! ! %
%
! %
!! 5 ;
9
- 77 -
< ./: C81: ;? %1$ %$ 5"$
" "! #$ 3 5))"%#( )1@B=8* 8. B8=8F=8B/ $/81/:DH81@<H:=
6" ! < ! "" 4
"
" / 0' . ! %
! %
! %! 4 ==5
! +@=./:= ./01 ;@=. 0< ./: C81: ;?6#""! 5"$'
"! #$ 3
"
)"$""(" 0< ' ;"!"&"$"# 8<H C;<<:C.:H E8..:=1 H8.:H
"""$"# A/:=:0< =:?:==0<F .; P@HFE:<.1 ;? ./: B:J ;@=. 0< ./: C81: ;? #$ " "!&%$% 7""$!" 0".6&$6"#"$"4,"#"("$%&!#"81"!"(
"#" "! "#$ 3 "
6"#"$"#$" "! #$ & ( + 0. /81 >::< /:DH ./8. ./:
H01B@.:1 A0./ =:F8=H .; B=:B8=8.0;< ;? 9;.:=17 D01. A/0C/ ?;=E1 0<.:F=8D B8=. ;? :D:C.0;< B=;C:11 ./: =:E:HG 8980D8>D:01@<H:=:C.0;<&$)"*;?./:C.!! - 78 -
$ < ./: D0F/. ;? ./: 8?;=:180H B=0<C0BD:1 ;? D8A 8<H./:;=H:=;?./01;@=.10<C:./:011@:0<9;D9:H0<./01 C81: 01 A0./ =:F8=H .; 98D0H0.G ;= ;./:=A01: ;? ./: B=:B8=8.0;<;?./::D:C.;=8DD01.A/0C/?8DD11K@8=:DGA0./0< ./: B=;9010;<1 ;? :C.0;< &$ ;? ./: C. !! ./:
B:.0.0;<01!1! A0././:?;DD;A0<FH0=:C.0;<1 0* /:B:.0.0;<:=18=:8.D0>:=.G.;1::I=:H=:118D;? ./:0= F=0:98<C: >G =8010<F 8 H01B@.: @<H:= :C.0;< &$ ;? ./: 8=<8.8I8 ;;B:=8.09:
;C0:.0:1C.!! 00* /:G1/8DD=801:1@C/H01B@.:A0./0<H8G1?=;E ./: H8.: ;? =:C:0B. ;? ./: C:=.0?0:H C;BG ;? ./01 ;=H:=0?1;8H901:H 000* B;<?0D0<F;?1@C/H01B@.:./::F01.=8=;?;
;B:=8.09: ;C0:.G 1/8DD :J8E0<: ./: E8..:= 8<H 8?.:= /;DH0<F :<K@0=G >G B=;90H0<F 1@??0C0:<. ;BB;=.@<0.0:1 .; ./: B8=.0:1 B811 8BB=;B=08.: ;=H:=./:=:;< 09* @>P:C. .; ;@.C;E: ;?
./: H01B@.: ./: 9;.:1 C81.:H >G ./: B:.0.0;<:=1 1/8DD >: .8I:< 0<.; C;<10H:=8.0;<
- 79 -
9* /: :F01.=8= 1/8DD @<H:=.8I: ./: :J:=C01: 8<H C;<CD@H: ./: B=;C::H0<F1 A0./0< 8 B:=0;H ;? $ H8G1?=;E./:H8.:;?1@>E0110;<;?./:H01B@.: 81H0=:C.:H8>;9:
90* /::D:C.0;<1.;./:=:10H:<.8<H0C:=:10H:<. 1/8DD >: C;<H@C.:H 8?.:= H01B;18D ;? ./: H01B@.: 81H0=:C.:H/:=:0<8>;9:
900*
.01E8H:CD:8=./8.0?./:B:.0.0;<:=1?80D.;=801:
./: H01B@.: A0./0< ./: B:=0;H ;? H8G1 81 8>;9:./::D:C.0;<.;./:B;1.;?=:10H:<.8<H 0C:
=:10H:<. 1/8DD >: C;EE:<C:H 8<H B=;C::H:H0<8CC;=H8<C:A0./D8A
:<H0<F 0<.:=D;C@.;=G 8BBD0C8.0;<1 0? 8<G H; <;. 1@=909: ?;=C;<10H:=8.0;<CC;=H0<FDG./:G8=:H01E011:H
-' &##( %
01. ;D ;#