- 1 - ! "!# $%!!&!& !!## '&( ) ! " # $% $ & & '! # $ &' ($ $ )* ) # $ $ # $ ($& $ )* + Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )! ,%! -,#), . &%)- -,#), . / ( & $ $ 0 ' % 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 2=3>?4=@6 @AB54=; @14776=C2=C <16 D>9CB6=< 4=9 4E4?9 94<69 %)- 5433692= A-,#),:;<166=2A?2F27>9C64=9 . >996:2147 ) 635A=96=< A 23 @742B4=< 4=9 ?635A=96=< A) 23 AE=6? A8 <16 F612@76 E12@1 E43 2=3>?69 E2<1 4556774=<2=3>?4=@6@AB54=; - 3 - % 1684@<376492=C<A8272=CA8@742B56<2<2A=34?6 43>=96?$. 14< A= ))) ?635A=96=< A) 47A=C E2<1 ?635A=96=< A .6F6=9?4554 2?494? 1416:CA>94 1A>94?2 4=9 A<16?3 E6?6 <?4F672=C 2= ?>236? 665 :64?2=C2<36C A'.)%. .-%-:67A=C2=C<A?635A=96=< A) <A F232< 123 C?4=9.BA<16? 4< '4?2:4F2 F2774C6 8?AB 434=>?<4:A><4BE16=<16;E6?6A=472GA<2 474C4=>? ?A49 =64? <16 74=9 A8 ?2 4=@14<6 ?635A=96=< A):62=C<169?2F6?A8<163429F612@769?AF6 <1634B62=4?4314=9=6C72C6=<B4==6?7A3<@A=<?A7AF6? <16F612@769>6<AE12@12<<>?=694=9<>?<769A=<16?A49 3 4 ?63>7< A8 <16 4@@296=< 1416:CA>94 1A>94?2 3>3<42=69 C?26FA>3 2=D>?263 4=9 9269 635A=96=< A . 6F6=9?4554 2?494? 4=9 A<16?3 3>3<42=69 2=D>?263 635A=96=< A 143 82769 <16 @742B 56<2<2A= 366G2=C @AB56=34<2A= - 4 - * 16 4556774=< 2=3>?4=@6 @AB54=; @A=<63<69 <163429@742B56<2<2A=164556774=<2=3>?4=@6@AB54=; 149 <4G6= >5 <16 @A=<6=<2A= <14< <16 @A=92<2A=3 A8 <16 2=3>?4=@65A72@;14F6:66=F2A74<694=9<16?68A?62<23=A< 724:76<A54;4=;@AB56=34<2A= 16?2:>=471438?4B69233>6 A%E12@1?6493 <1>3$. 16 ?2:>=47 48<6? ?6@A?92=C <16 6F296=@6 4=9 574@2=C ?6724=@6 A= <16 96@232A= A8 <16 2F232A= 6=@1 A8 <123 A>?< 4=3E6?69 <16 3429 233>6 2= <16 =6C4<2F6 4=9 1679 <14< <16 ?635A=96=< A) 2=3>?4=@6 @AB54=; 23 724:76<A54;<16@AB56=34<2A=<A<16@742B4=<3 - 5 - , CC?26F69 :; <16 3429 D>9CB6=< 4=9 4E4?9 543369 :; <16 ?2:>=47 <16 4556774=< =3>?4=@6 AB54=;23:68A?6<123A>?< 164556472382769A=<168A77AE2=CC?A>=9$. < 23 3>:B2<<69 <14< <16 96@64369 4=9 A<16?3 E6?6 >=4><1A?2H69 54336=C6? @4??269 2= <16 2=3>?69 5?2F4<6 F612@762=F2A74<2A=A8<165A72@;<6?B34=9E2<1A><4F4729 56?B2< 16 5?AF232A=3 A8 6@<2A= *, A8 @< 9A =A< ?6I>2?6 <16 ?23G <A :6 @AF6?69 >=96? <16 5A72@; =A? <16 5A72@;@AF6?69<16?23G16?247A>?<842769<A455?6@24<6 <1684@<4=9543369<164E4?9 - 16 @A=<6=<2A= A8 <16 4556774=< 2=3>?4=@6 @AB54=;<14<<16?635A=96=< A.6F6=9?45542?494? E43542954336=C6?2=45?2F4<6F612@764=9<16?68A?6<16 2=3>?4=@6@AB54=;23=A<724:76<A54;<16@AB56=34<2A= 43<16@A=92<2A=3A8<165A72@;14F6:66=F2A74<69 - 6 - 16 ?2:>=47 E1276 @A=3296?2=C <16 3429 233>6 143 C2F6= 2<3 ?643A=3 2= 4?4 A3* 4=9 *) E12@1 ?649 <1>3$. ! " # $% " &''# ()$ '(*+$,-.*/'# ( ) . 0 1 023 ++4)+, 056)7)+48 ' 91 9 9 9 91 99 " 1 :"1 ; < =>" # $3(33 ' ? @1 9 # 8 19 A.B 9 " 9 9 # C ' 1 9 ;0 5 3 D = 1 % 9 - 7 - " " " # C "% 1 " "'919 19 " 1 "E * 9">" 1 " 1 9 " % 9 " 9 " " "' " >" # 3 ' 03 3<F5 C3 <&*3 /C3'(? @1< = # 9 " 3 1 1 % 1 " 1 1 ' 1 % .1 $3. '=3' 3 < G F*. ? @1 # 1 D 3 19 9 % ) # 3 03 3<F5C3 <&*3 /C3'(? @ $3. '=3' 3 < G F*. ? @ 3 "1 " - 8 - ) " " ' 1 % -))+H 3 " ) %" 1 )-)+H" +)-)+4 *: : D " 1 9 " % 9 " 9 " " " 1 I 9 "" 1' 93 "1' , 05# H74 H76 +6 9 "E 162F232A=6=@1A8<123A>?<2=<16@436A8 ?65A?<69 2= ! " E12@1 143 :66= ?67269 >5A= :; <16 ?2:>=47 2< 23 1679 <14< 28 <16 F612@76 23 4 5?2F4<6F612@7657269A=12?6<16AE=6?B4;:6724:768A? 56=47 4=9 823@47 @A=36I>6=@63 >=96? <16 A<A? 612@763 @< 8A? 54;B6=< A8 56=47<; 4=9 <4J63 45572@4:76 <A <16 - 9 - @ABB6?@247 F612@763 >< 8?AB <16 3<4=95A2=< A8 <16 2=3>?6?B4G63=A92886?6=@6E16<16?<162=B4<62345429 54336=C6?A?C?4<>2<A>354336=C6?&16=<165A72@;233>69 234AB5?616=32F6A72@;@AF6?2=C<16?23GA8<162=B4<63 A8 4 5?2F4<6 F612@76 <16 2=3>?6? @4==A< 4FA29 724:272<; A= <16C?A>=9<14<<162=B4<6234542954336=C6? ) 162F232A=6=@1A8<123A>?<2=<16@436A8 # $ % & # ?65A?<69 2= ' ! ((" @A=3296?2=C <16 32B274? 5A2=< E16?62= 2< 143 A:36?F692=4?4 A3*4=9E12@1?649<1>3$. " " I" (# ' 91 ' " ' # 9" # * 3 . G1 / *1 > ' * . 1 # 1 " 9 I $ "# G 1'(*++$3*,7- - 10 - ' # ( 3I%2 0 5 31 7-- ; % " """9 9' >" " H198 H'9 "9D # "# $1 0 0 C 1 ' 9 3 ; % " " " "9 9E H' 2 = $ " # 3I% " 1 , I"19 98 '" 9 D " . 6 0 5 31 7--1 # . 6 9 9 9 27773#>77 - 11 - " . 7H1 . 6C 9 # 9 I ! ! . " 1D" I " D " 9 9 " 1 % ! ! # 9 % " 9 9 # ! ! # 9 % " 99 " " 3H 77 9 " # 3 9 . # 099G '# (17773#>.#1 9 " - 12 - 9 " ' 9 19; 9 " # '* # =."17-- 3#> + .#1 9 ,H " " 9 " . 7H 1 "" ; . 7H 9 ' 9 9 " . 7H9 " 1 9 ! ! 9 I . # 1 ' 9 . 7H" " 1 9 " - 13 - . 7H 1 9 " " 3 9 9 D " . 7H 1317--1" # % " 939 9%0C "# G ' # ( * *1 777 3#> H0C ' 9 3 . 6 9 > 9 9 9 ,1 1"99 %3 %!1" " 3 . 6 0 5317--E &". 4"99D # *. 2 = $ " # 3I $ . 21 "# 0 - 14 - 9'3# (5I% 3 G3 " # 0 C G'# (**B4 %9E % A=3296?2=C <16 4:AF6 96@232A=3 4=9 <16 96@232A=3?67269 >5A=:;<16 ?2:>=47 <16?6 23 =AC?A>=9 8A?2=<6?86?2=CE2<1<16D>9CB6=<4=94E4?9543369:;<16 ?2:>=47=<16?63>7<<1645564723 6C23<?;2392?6@<69<A<?4=3B2<<164BA>=<2=965A32< <A?2:>=47 !*+ '!&!&( % 23< A$7 A$*% 3++,3#>H, 47773#>H