Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66743 (KAR)

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA v. MALLIKARJUN S/O NARSAPPA

CRL.A/200067/2017 · 2025-11-10

H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#$ %! & $'!%! & $'!"'# " $ %% ()(%*+,(!!* - ! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "#$ % &&&$ $#&$' '(#)*&'"&+ &&&$ $#&$' '(#) *&'"&+ $$&&* , - . / / - 3 - #'$ / 0123 433510607 89 :;0 <=73>02: 74:07 &&&$ 503457123:;0?5705?@4AB=1::4C12?$#&$'?@:;0 771:1?24C 1D:51A: 427 0DD1?2 =730 1745 1::123 4: 4D464E4C942@?5D;?5:,514C?=5:-F;05012:;04AA=D07 ;4D 8002 4AB=1::07 @?5 :;0 ?@@02A0 G=21D;48C0 =2705 0A:1?2D *&' '(#) 427 "&+ ?@ 2714 024C ?70 @?5 D;?5: ,- :;0 A?>GC41242:):4:0 ;4D 4GG5?4A;07 :;1D ?=5:F1:;:;0G50D02:4GG04C ;0A4D0?@:;0G5?D0A=:1?21D:;4::;04AA=D07 F4D :;0 ;=D8427 ?@ :;0 70A04D07 4347061 5?> :;015 F07C?AE ?20 >4C0 A;1C7 F4D 8?52 ;0 70A04D07 F4D F?5E1234D4.?>42?C1A0?2D:48C04::;0=>424847 ?C1A0 :4:1?2 427 D;0 F4D 50D17123 12 :;0 42A;494: B=45:05D F;1A; F050 D1:=4:07 AC?D0 :? :;0 G?C1A0 D:4:1?2 @:05 :;0 >4551430 :;0 4AA=D07 =D07 :? D=DG0A: :;0 A;4D:1:9 ?@ ;1D F1@0 427 12A?220A:1?2 F1:; :;0 D4>0 ;0 - 4 - =D07 :? :04D0 427 48=D0 :;0 70A04D07 =D123 @1C:;9 C423=430 ;4: 80123 D? ?2 $$&'&$" 4: 48?=: && G> 4@:05 A?>GC0:123 ;05 7=:9 F;02 :;0 70A04D07 50:=5207 ;?>0 :;0 4AA=D07 G1AE07 =G B=4550C F1:; ;05 4CC03123 :;4: ;0 ;47 ;05 C?60 C0::05D 50A01607 @5?> ;05 C?605 G51?5 :? :;0 >4551430 427 :;4: 0602 4@:05 :;0 >4551430 D;0 F4D ;46123 C?60 4@@415D F1:; ;05 >4C0 A?CC043=0D4::;0G?C1A0D:4:1?242748=D07;0589A4CC123 ;054HD:500:G5?D:1:=:0I;0A5=0C427D=DG1A1?=D4::1:=70 ?@:;04AA=D07A4=D07>02:4C427G;9D1A4C:?5:=50:?:;0 70A04D07427=C:1>4:0C9480::07;05:?D0:;05D0C@?2@150 427A?>>1:D=1A170 " >>0714:0C9 4@:05 :;0 12A1702: :;0 12<=507 A?>GC41242:F4D:4E02:?:;0;?DG1:4CF;050D;034604 A?>GC412: :? :;0 G?C1A0 89 F49 ?@ D:4:0>02: 43412D: :;0 4AA=D07F;1A;C07:?:;05031D:54:1?2?@A4D043412D:;1> @?5:;0?@@02A0DG=21D;48C0=27050A:1?2D'(#)427*&' ?@ =8D0B=02:C9 F;1C0 =27053?123 :504:>02: :;0 70A04D07 D=AA=>807 :? :;0 8=52 12<=510D ?2D0B=02:C9 - 5 - 4@:05 A?>GC0:1?2 ?@ :;0 1260D:134:1?2 :;0 A?>GC41242: G?C1A0 @1C07 A;4530 D;00: 43412D: :;0 4AA=D07 @?5 :;0 4@?50D417 ?@@02A0D 427 4CD? @?5 :;0 ?@@02A0 G=21D;48C0 =27050A:1?2"&+?@ ' ;04AA=D07F4D?2841C7=5123:;0G02702A9?@ :;0 A4D0 80@?50 :;0 C045207 431D:54:0 ;0 C045207 431D:54:0 :??E A?321J42A0 ?@ :;0 ?@@02A0D G=21D;48C0 =27050A:1?2D'(#)*&'427"&+?@4275031D:0507 :;0A4D043412D::;04AA=D07@?5:;0D417?@@02A0DD:;0 A4D0F4D0KAC=D160C9:5148C089:;00DD1?2D?=5:1:F4D A?>>1::07 :? :;0 :514C ?=5: @?5 @=5:;05 G5?A007123D AA?57123C9:;0A4D0F4D:4E02=G89:;0:514C?=5: * 2 :;0 84D1D ?@ :;0 >4:0514CD 4641C48C0 12 :;0 G5?D0A=:1?2 G4G05D ?2 50A?57 :;0 :514C ?=5: @54>07 A;4530 43412D: :;0 4AA=D07 @?5 :;0 ?@@02A0D G=21D;48C0 =2705 0A:1?2D '(#) 427 "&+ ?@ ;0 4AA=D07 GC047072?:3=1C:9?@:;0A;4530D427AC41>07:?80:5107 - 6 - + 2 D=GG?5: ?@ :;0 A4D0 ?@ :;0 G5?D0A=:1?2 # F1:20DD0D F050 0K4>1207 4D .$ :? .# 427 :;0 7?A=>02:D4:K$:?(427:;0>4:0514C?8<0A:D4:$ :?'F050G5?7=A07@:05AC?D123?@:;0061702A0?@:;0 G5?D0A=:1?2:;04AA=D07F4D0K4>120789:;0:514C?=5: =2705 0A:1?2 "$" ?@ 5 F;05012 :;0 4AA=D07 702107 :;0061702A0?@ G5?D0A=:1?2?@F1:20DD0D 4D @4CD08=: ;0 7172?:A;??D0:?477=A042970@02A0061702A0?F0605 :;0 4AA=D07 G5?7=A07 " 7?A=>02:D 4: KD$ :? " 12 D=GG?5:?@;1D70@02A0 @:05;045123:;0453=>02:D?@8?:;:;0G45:10D 427 ?2 A?2D1705123 :;0 >4:0514CD @?5:;A?>123 ?2 50A?57 :;0 :514C ?=5: A?>123 :? :;0 A?2AC=D1?2 :;4: :;0 G5?D0A=:1?2 ;4D @41C07 :? G5?60 809?27 504D?248C0 7?=8: :;4::;04AA=D07A?>>1::07:;0?@@02A0DA;4530743412D: ;1> 4AB=1::07 :;0 4AA=D07 =2705 1>G=3207 <=73>02: F;1A;50D=C:0712:;0G50D02:4GG04C - 7 - # 0457 :;0 C045207 A?=2D0C 4GG045123 @?5 :;0 :4:0 A?>GC41242: 427 4CD? :;0 C045207 A?=2D0C @?5 :;0 4AA=D07 ( .0 ;460 G05=D07 :;0 ?54C 427 7?A=>02:459 061702A0?250A?574DF0CC4D:;050C0642:>4:0514CD427 :;0G512A1GC0D?@C4F4GGC1A48C0:?:;0A4D0?2;427 $& ?F:;0G?12::;4:451D0D@?5?=5A?2D17054:1?2 1D:;4: .;0:;05 :;0 :514C ?=5: ;4D A?>>1::07 429 055?5 12 4AB=1::123 :;04AA=D07@?5:;0?@@02A0DA;45307 =27051>G=3207<=73>02:L $$ :1D=271DG=:07@4A::;4::;070A04D071DF1@0?@ :;04AA=D07;0A?2:02:1?2?@:;0G5?D0A=:1?21D:;4::;0 4AA=D07 D=8<0A:07 :;0 70A04D07 :? >02:4C 427 G;9D1A4C A5=0C:9 4CC03123 :;4: D;0 F4D ;46123 4@@415 F1:; ;05 A?CC043=0D427:;4:D;0;47C?605045C105:?;05>4551430 427 D;0 A?2:12=07 :;4: 50C4:1?2D;1G 0602 4@:05 :;0 >4551430 427 :;05089 A4=D07 >02:4C A5=0C:9 :? :;0 - 8 - 70A04D07?F06054D513;:C9G?12:07?=:89:;0C045207 A?=2D0C @?5 :;0 4AA=D07 :;050 1D 48D?C=:0C9 2? >4:0514C @?5:;A?>123 @5?> :;0 G5?D0A=:1?2 :? D;?F :;4: :;0 70A04D07 ;47 0605 C?7307 429 A?>GC412: 43412D: :;0 4AA=D07G51?5:?:;04CC030712A1702::1DG05:1202::?2?:0 :;4: :;0 70A04D07 F4D F?5E123 4D 4 .?>42 ?C1A0 ?2D:48C0;050@?501@:;050;4712@4A:8002429>02:4C A5=0C:9?5;454DD>02:89:;04AA=D07:;070A04D0780123 4G?C1A0?@@1A14C F?=C7504D?248C9;46080020KG0A:07:? C?7304A?>GC412:43412D:;1> $ ::;0:1>0?@453=>02:D:;0C04520777C ;4D D:5?23C9 50C107 =G?2 :;0 A?>GC412: C?7307 89 :;0 70A04D07 1>>0714:0C9 4@:05 :;0 4CC0307 12A1702: ;0 A?2:02:1?2 ?@ :;0 C045207 5?D0A=:?5 1D :;4: :;0 D417 A?>GC412:4>?=2:D:?7912370AC454:1?2427:;050@?50:;0 :514C?=5:;4DA?>>1::07055?5122?:GC4A12350C142A0?21: F;1C0A?2D1705123:;0G5??@?@:;04CC030712A1702:427:;0 ?@@02A0DA;4530743412D::;04AA=D07 - 9 - $" : 1D 50C0642: :? 50@05 :? :;0 G?5:1?2 12 :;0 A?>GC412:503457123:;04CC030712A1702:F;1A;5047D:;=D !" #$ % #& '( )*+, +! -+!' % .' /0! !" #$ % ! 1+!' 2 ,345 +346 7 -89' 0! :+! ;" <!=" >5 ? @ *896 0? ,A :);%6 0! B +A C5/ . B(D>5A@*!@E!8F +,345?G : +,34 8F 'F< H 'I * '; ' 3 J % K5!D @!<*!.$L8+,>8MN+,B;% C5 , >8 -:*'46 '4 B *OP % @ >8 MN+FQ -,0!'4+!!-!) B' !A '7 R .34+, + > '? ,0 :! B' ST +: '? @ >8 MN+S'4F6 - ,>8-:*1+' %!;I U?+,M8'V:': - 10 - -W'X ' !: S'46 '? , '? Y!; !< D =P +,34 8F 'F< @!< *! .$L 8+, >8 MN+,X4@OP'46 $' D D=8>1::07 89 :;0 C045207 A?=2D0C @?5 :;0 4AA=D07 :;0 50C0642: G?5:1?2 ?@ :;0 A?>GC412: 1271A4:0D :;4: 4: :;0 121:14C D:430 :;0 4AA=D07 4::0>G:07 :? 0K:123=1D; @150 8=: :;0 70A04D07 ?2A0 43412 D0: ;05D0C@ 48C4J0 427 :;05089 D=D:41207 8=52 12<=510D ;0 ?2C9 4CC034:1?212:;0A?>GC412:1D:;4::;04AA=D077?=8:07;05 @170C1:9 427 A;4D:1:9M ;?F0605 :;0 4605>02:D 12 :;0 A?>GC412:F?=C7D;?F:;4:06021@:;04AA=D07;4748=D07 ;054D4CC0307:;0D4>0F?=C72?:A?2D:1:=:0480:>02::? A?>>1:D=1A170 $* ?F 1: 1D 50C0642: :? A?2D1705 :;0 061702A0 ?@ G5?D0A=:1?2@?5:;A?>123?250A?57;0.$;4C0>>41D >?:;05?@:;070A04D07;070G?D07:;4:48?=:+9045D 43? :;0 >4551430 ?@ :;0 4AA=D07 427 :;0 70A04D07 F4D G05@?5>074274::;0:1>0?@>4551430:;070A04D07F4D - 11 - F?5E123 4D A?2D:48C0 4: 427;1 =2< ?C1A0 :4:1?2 12 17454274@:05:;0>4551430:;070A04D07F4D:542D@05507 :? =>424847 2 :;0 D417 F07C?AE 4 @0>4C0 A;1C7 F4D 8?52 ;0 70A04D07 F4D 12@?5>123 ;05 :;5?=3; G;?20 48?=: A5=0C A?27=A: ?@ :;0 4AA=D07 6059 ?@:02 427 F;02 D;0 >0: :;0 70A04D07 427 :;0 4AA=D07 D;0 4761D07 :;0 4AA=D07 :? A?550A: ;1D A?27=A: 8=: :;0 4AA=D07 717 2?: A?550A:;1DA?27=A: $+ : 1D 4CD? :;0 061702A0 ?@ .$ :;4: 4@:05 E2?F123 :;0 @4A: :;4: :;0 70A04D07 F4D 47>1::07 :? ;?DG1:4C7=0:?8=5212<=510D?2:;020K:749D;0F02::? :;0;?DG1:4C 4: 97054847 427 4::;4: :1>0:;0 70A04D07 F4D=2705C1::C081:A?2DA1?=D427F;02D;002B=1507:;0 70A04D07:;070A04D07:?C7;05:;4:;05;=D842710:;0 4AA=D07 F4D 6059 ?@:02 7?=8:123 ;05 A;4D:1:9 F;02 D;0 F4D3?123:?7=:94271:;4780A?>0A5=0C:9:?;054274D D=A;D;0:5107:?A?>>1:D=1A17089D0::123@150:?;05D0C@ ;1D1D:;0061702A0?@.$503457123:;04CC030712A1702: 427:;04CC0307A5=0C:9:?:;04AA=D07:?:;070A04D07 - 12 - $ ?F06054DG?12:07?=:89:;0C045207A?=2D0C @?5 :;0 4AA=D07 12 :;0 061702A0 12 A5?DD)0K4>124:1?2 .$;4D47>1::07:;4::;070A04D07F4D2?:124G?D1:1?2 :? DG04E AC045C9 : 1D 4CD? :;0 061702A0 ?@ .$ 12 A5?DD)0K4>124:1?2:;4::;04AA=D07F4DG50D02:12427;1 ?DG1:4C=:1:1D:;0061702A0?@.$:;4:4@:05A?>123:? ;?=D0?@:;04AA=D077?=8:123:;024:=50?@:;070A04D07 427B=4550CC123F1:;:;070A04D07:;097172?:4GG5?4A; @4>1C9 0C705D 4D F0CC 4D G?C1A0 ?@@1A05D @?5 50D?C6123 :;0 71DG=:0=5:;051:1D47>1::0789.$:;4::;070A04D07 ;47D;?F2;054D2?>120012G?C1A9;1D061702A0?@ .$ F?=C7 AC045C9 D;?F :;4: :;050 1D 2? 061702A0 @5?> .$ :;4: :;0 4AA=D07 D=8<0A:07 :;0 70A04D07 :? A5=0C:9 F;1A; 50D=C:07 12 480::123 ?@ :;0 70A04D07 :? A?>>1: D=1A170 $# .")>8474D 1D ?20 ?@ :;0 4::0D:05D :? :;0 DG?: G42A;424>4 4: K" 0 ;4D 2?: D=GG?5:07 :;0 A4D0?@:;0G5?D0A=:1?2427;02A0;01D:504:07;?D:1C0 - 13 - $( ;0 C045207 5?D0A=:?5 4D 50@05507 :? :;0 061702A0 ?@ .') >: 46051 427 .*)42:?D; F;? F050A?CC043=0D?@:;070A04D0712:;0G?C1A0D:4:1?2;0 061702A0 ?@ .' 12 A;10@)0K4>124:1?2 1D :;4: ?20 9045 G51?5:?:;012A1702::;070A04D07F4D0KG50DD123;053510@ 427 4CD? 80@?50 :;0 A?CC043=0D 48?=: 7?=8:123 24:=50 ?@ :;0 4AA=D07 :04D123 ;05 :;4: D;0 7060C?G07 D?>0 0K:54 >451:4C 4@@415D F1:; >4C0 A?CC043=0D 12 :;0 G?C1A0 D:4:1?2 ;0 061702A0 ?@ .* 42:?D; 1D 4CD? :;0 D4>0 12 ;1D 061702A012A;10@)0K4>124:1?2?F06054DG?12:07?=:89 :;0 C045207 A?=2D0C @?5 :;0 4AA=D07 8?:; .' 427 .* D:4:07 12 :;015 061702A0 12 A5?DD)0K4>124:1?2 :;4: :;0 70A04D077172?:A?>GC41243412D:;05;=D84274AA=D07?@ 316123 :?5:=50 @?5 ?:;05 >4::05D 0KA0G: 503457123 ;05 A;454A:05 & .+);164E=>45 1D 85?:;05 ?@ :;0 70A04D07 1D061702A01D503457123:;04CC03071CC):504:>02:89:;0 4AA=D07 :? :;0 70A04D07 ;0 061702A0 ?@ .+ 12 A;10@)0K4>124:1?2 1D :;4: ?2 $&'&$" 4: 48?=: &&& - 14 - 4>;050A0160712@?5>4:1?2?605G;?20@5?>=>424847 54@@1A?C1A0:4:1?2:;4:;1DD1D:05:;070A04D07D=D:41207 8=52 12<=510D 427 D;0 F4D 47>1::07 :? =>424847 ?6052>02: ?DG1:4C 427 :;0504@:05 :? 427;1 ?DG1:4C 97054847 @?5 ;13;05 :504:>02: 427 ;02A0 ;0 7150A:C9 F02: :? 427;1 ?DG1:4C 97054847 427 02B=1507 :;0 70A04D074274::;4::1>0:;070A04D07:?C7;1>:;4:7=0 :?A?2:12=?=D1CC):504:>02:3160289:;070A04D074AA=D07 7?=8:123 ;05 A;454A:05 D;0 F02: =2705 @5=D:54:1?2 427 4::0>G:07 :? A?>>1: D=1A170 ;0504@:05 ?2 &&'&$" :;070A04D07D=AA=>807:?8=5212<=510DD=D:4120789;05 2:;020K:74910?2$#&'&$":;0G?C1A0A4>0:?:;0 ;?DG1:4C427A?27=A:0712B=0D:G42A;424>44DG05K' ?F0605 :;0 061702A0 ?@ .+ 1D ?2C9 503457123 :;0 4CC0307 12A1702: ;050 1D 48D?C=:0C9 2? F;1DG05 89 .+ :;4::;070A04D07A?>GC41207;1>?@4291CC):504:>02:4: 429 :1>0 G51?5 :? :;0 4CC0307 12A1702: ;050@?50 4D D=8>1::0789:;0C045207A?=2D0C@?5:;04AA=D07060212 :;0 061702A0 ?@ .+ :;050 1D 48D?C=:0C9 2? >4:0514C - 15 - 43412D::;04AA=D07:?>4E0?=:?@@02A0G=21D;48C0=2705 0A:1?2'(#)?@ $ . 4EE4GG4 1D :;0 :;02 ?@ A?>GC41242: G?C1A0 D:4:1?2 D G05 ;1D 061702A0 4@:05 ;0 D=8>1::07 A;4530D;00:43412D::;04AA=D074@:05:4E1238?27D@5?> .$ :? .+ 427 .$ ;0 G5?G05:10D G5?7=A07 12 :;0 A4D0 F050 1702:1@107 89 ;1> 4: $ :? ' =5:;05 :;0 G;?:?A;45:1D3?:>45E074:K(12:;0061702A0?@. =: 12 :;0 061702A0 12 A5?DD)0K4>124:1?2 . 70G?D07 :;4: 7=5123 ;1D 1260D:134:1?2 ?@ :;0 A4D0 ;0 717 2?: 61D1: :;0 DG?: 427 50A?57 :;0 D:4:0>02: ?@ G05D?2D 50D17123 204589 :;0 DG?: ?@ :;0 12A1702: ;1D 061702A0 ?@ . F?=C7 D;?F :;4: 0KA0G: @1C123 ?@ :;0 A;4530 D;00: ?2 A?>GC0:1?2 ?@ 1260D:134:1?2 :;050 1D 2? G45: GC4907 89 . 12 :;0 1260D:134:1?2 ?@ :;0 A4D0 :? >4E0 ?=: 429 >4:0514C43412D::;04AA=D07@?5:;0?@@02A0DA;45307 .#) 54;4C47 1D :;0 :;02 ?@ A?>GC41242: G?C1A0 D:4:1?2 D G05 ;1D 061702A0 4: :;0 :1>0 ?@ :;0 - 16 - 4CC030712A1702:;0F4DF?5E1234D427?2$&'&$" ;0 F02: :? 97054847 427 3460 50B=1D1:1?2 :? .$" @?5 12B=0D: 2 $#&'&$" ;0 50A?5707 :;0 D:4:0>02:D ?@ .$427.$"427A?27=A:07:;012B=0D:G42A;424>4?@ :;0 70A04D07 427 :;0504@:05 ;0 ;42707 ?605 :;0 7047 8?79 :? .$.$ 427 4@:05 50:=52123 D02: F51::02 50B=1D1:1?2:?:;0?=5:@?512AC=D1?2?@0A:1?2"&+?@ :?:;0A4D0;050@?500KA0G:50A?57123?@D:4:0>02:D?@ .$ 427 .$" :;050 1D 2? >4:0514C 12 :;0 061702A0 ?@ .#503457123:;01260D:134:1?2?@:;0A4D0 " D?8D0560789:;0:514C?=5:12:;0<=73>02: :;0F;?A?27=A:07:;01260D:134:1?27107427;02A0;0 A?=C7 2?: 80 0K4>1207 89 :;0 G5?D0A=:1?2 ;050@?50 0KA0G: :;0 48?60 50@05507 061702A0 ?@ .$ 427 ." :? .#:;0501D48D?C=:0C92?>4:0514C@?5:;A?>123@5?>:;0 G5?D0A=:1?2 :? G5?60 :;4: :;050 F4D 429 12A1702: 1>>0714:0C9G51?5:?:;070A04D07A?>>1::123D=1A170:;4: :;04AA=D07480::07:;070A04D07:?A?>>1:D=1A170 - 17 - ' D 71DA=DD07 ;05012 48?60 :;0 C045207 5?D0A=:?5 ;4D 50C107 >=A; ?2 :;0 D:4:0>02: 4: K* F;1A; 1D 12 :;0 @?5> ?@ A?>GC412: D:4:123 :;4: :;0 :514C ?=5: ;4D A?>>1::07 055?5 12 2?: A?2D1705123 :;0 D417 7?A=>02: 4D 79123 70AC454:1?2 ?@ :;0 70A04D07 @ :;0 D:4:0>02: ?@ K* 1D A?2D170507 4D 79123 70AC454:1?2 0602 F1:;?=: :;0 A?55?8?54:160 061702A0 :;0 :514C ?=5: A?=C7 ;460 50A?5707 A?261A:1?2 ?@ :;0 4AA=D07 @?5 :;0 ?@@02A0DA;45307 * 05 A?2:54 D=8>1DD1?2 ?@ :;0 C045207 A?=2D0C @?5 :;0 4AA=D07 1D :;4: :;0 ;4D 2?: @?CC?F07 G5?G05 G5?A07=50 F;1C0 50A?57123 :;0 4CC0307 D:4:0>02: ?@ :;0 70A04D07 4: K* @?5 A?2D1705123 :;0 D4>0 4D 79123 70AC454:1?2?@:;070A04D07DG?12:07?=:89:;0C045207 A?=2D0C @?5 :;0 4AA=D07 1: 1D 50C0642: :? 50@05 :? :;0 061702A0 ?@ . F;? 1D :;0 7?A:?5 4CC0307C9 3460 :504:>02::?:;070A04D0712:;0;?DG1:4C;0D4177?A:?5 1D . 5 ;4274 2754<00: :;02 F?5E123 4D 071A4C - 18 - @@1A05 4: =>424847 ?6052>02: ?DG1:4C F;05012 :;0 12<=507:??E:504:>02:1>>0714:0C94@:05:;012A1702: + :1D:5=0:;4:12:;0D:4:0>02:1:K*:;0501D >02:1?2:;4:, 427=2705:;0D417 027?5D0>02: :;050 1D D1324:=50 427 D04C ?@ :;0 7?A:?5 ;0D1324:=50?@:;070A04D071D>45E074:K;181:*4 =:4DG?12:07?=:89:;0C045207A?=2D0C@?5:;04AA=D07 :;0 . 47>1::07 12 ;1D 061702A0 12 A5?DD)0K4>124:1?2 :;4: 12 ;1D C0::05 4: K$ ;0 >02:1?207 :;0 12<=510D 4D 4AA1702:4C8=5204CD?47>1::07:;4:12:;00K:54A: 4:K4CD?:;0;1D:?59?@12<=591DD;?F24D4AA1702:4C 8=52 =5:;05 :;0 061702A0 ?@ . 12 A5?DD)0K4>124:1?21D:;4:;07172?:3160429027?5D0>02: :? 503457123 :;0 G;9D1A4C 427 >02:4C @1:20DD ?@ :;0 12<=50770A04D07:?3160D:4:0>02:427F;02:;012<=507 F4D 85?=3;: :? :;0 ;?DG1:4C D;0 F4D =2705 D051?=D A?271:1?2?50?605:;0C045207A?=2D0C@?5:;04AA=D07 - 19 - ;4D754F2:;04::02:1?2?@:;1D?=5::?:;0G;?:?D?@:;0 70A04D07 4: K( F;1A; F?=C7 D;?F :;4: :;050 F4D 8427430 12 8?:; :;0 =GG05 C1>8D ?@ :;0 70A04D07 ;050@?50:;04CC0307@4A::;4::;070A04D07G=:D1324:=50 :?:;0D:4:0>02:4:K*A504:0D7?=8:12:;0>127?@:;0 ?=5: # :1D:5=0:;4:1@:;07912370AC454:1?21D?@D=A; 424:=50:;4:1@1:12DG150D@=CCA?2@1702A0?@:;0?=5:2? A?55?8?54:1?21D50B=1507:?80C10607912370AC454:1?2: :;1DD:4301:1D50C0642::?50@05:?:;050A02:70A1D1?2?@ :;0?2/8C0G0K?=5:50G?5:0712 F;05012 ?2/8C0 G0K ?=5: 50@055123 :? :;0 045C105 70A1D1?2 50G?5:0712 !" # ;4D?8D05607:;4::;0D41770A1D1?2;4DC4177?F2 A05:412@4A:?5D:?80:4E0212:?A?2D17054:1?2F;1C050D:123 :;0 A?261A:1?2 ?2 :;0 84D1D ?@ 79123 70AC454:1?2 : 1D 50C0642: :? 50@05 :? G454 ?@ :;0 48?60 50@0502A0 045C10570A1D1?2F;1A;5047D:;=D - 20 - ./010234356./078/9/:43413:/02 3.;36.06 1 9123 70AC454:1?2 A42 80 :;0 D?C0 84D1D ?@ A?261A:1?2 1@ 1: 12DG150D :;0 @=CC A?2@1702A0 ?@ :;0 ?=5: 11 ;0 ?=5: D;?=C7 80 D4:1D@107 :;4: :;0 70A04D07 F4D 12 4 @1: D:4:0 ?@ >127 4: :;0 :1>0 ?@ >4E123:;0D:4:0>02:427:;4:1:F4D2?::;050D=C: ?@:=:?5123G5?>G:123?51>43124:1?2 111 .;050 :;0 ?=5: 1D D4:1D@107 :;: :;0 70AC454:1?2 1D :5=0 427 6?C=2:459 1: A42 84D0 1:D A?261A:1?2F1:;?=:429@=5:;05A?55?8?54:1?2 16 :A422?:80C4177?F24D4248D?C=:05=C0 ?@ C4F :;4: :;0 79123 70AC454:1?2 A422?: @?5> :;0 D?C0 84D1D A?261A:1?2 =2C0DD 1: 1D A?55?8?54:07 ;0 5=C0 50B=15123 A?55?8?54:1?2 1D >050C9 4 5=C0 ?@ G5=702A0 6 .;050:;07912370AC454:1?21DD=DG1A1?=D1: D;?=C7 2?: 80 4A:07 =G?2 F1:;?=: A?55?8?54:160 061702A0 61 79123 70AC454:1?2 F;1A; D=@@05D @5?> 12@15>1:9D=A;4D:;070A04D07F4D=2A?2DA1?=D427 A?=C7 20605 >4E0 429 D:4:0>02: A422?: @?5> :;0 84D1D?@A?261A:1?2 611 050C9 80A4=D0 4 79123 70AC454:1?2 7?0D 2?:A?2:4124CC:;070:41CD4D:?:;0?AA=5502A01:1D 2?::?8050<0A:07 - 21 - 6111 6021@1:1D48510@D:4:0>02:1:1D2?::?80 71DA45707 1K .;02 :;0 090F1:20DD 4@@15>D :;4: :;0 70A04D07 F4D 2?: 12 4 @1: 427 A?2DA1?=D D:4:0 :? >4E0 :;0 79123 70AC454:1?2 >071A4C ?G121?2 A422?: G50641C K @ 4@:05 A450@=C DA5=:129 :;0 ?=5: 1D D4:1D@107 :;4: 1: 1D :5=0 427 @500 @5?> 429 0@@?5: :? 127=A0:;070A04D07:?>4E04@4CD0D:4:0>02:4271@ 1:1DA?;0502:427A?2D1D:02::;050D;4CC802?C034C 1>G071>02::?>4E01::;084D1D?@A?261A:1?20602 1@:;0501D2?A?55?8?54:1?2 ( ;0@4A:?5DC4177?F212:;0D41770A1D1?2F?=C7 AC045C9 D;?F :;4: 4@:05 A450@=C DA5=:129 1@ :;0 A?=5: 1D D4:1D@107:;4:1:1D:5=0427@500@5?>4290@@?5::?127=A0 :;0 70A04D07 :? >4E0 4 @4CD0 D:4:0>02: 427 1@ 1: 1D A?;0502: 427 12A?2D1D:02: :;050 D;4CC 80 2? C034C 1>G071>02: :? >4E0 1: :;0 84D1D ?@ A?261A:1?2 0602 1@ :;050 1D 2? A?55?8?54:1?2 =: 12 :;0 A4D0 ?2 ;427 4D D=8>1::0789:;0C045207A?=2D0C@?5:;04AA=D0706021@ :;0 D:4:0>02: 4: K* 1D A?2D170507 4D :;0 79123 70AC454:1?2 ?@ :;0 70A04D07 :;0 A?2:02:D :;05012 7? 2?: - 22 - >4E0?=:429A4D043412D::;04AA=D07:?G5?60:;4::;0 4AA=D07D=8<0A:07:;070A04D07:?429G;9D1A4C?5>02:4C A5=0C:9 "& ?50?605 :;0 D:4:0>02: 4: K* 7?0D 2?: G5?60 429 4A: ?@ :;0 70A04D07 F;1A; 12D:134:07 :;0 70A04D07:?A?>>1:D=1A170:1DF0CCD0::C07G512A1GC0?@ C4F:;4::;0G5?D0A=:1?2;4D:?G5?60809?27504D?248C0 7?=8:D :;0 20K=D 80:F002 :;0 1>>0714:0 4A: ?@ :;0 4AA=D07F1:;:;0A?>>1DD1?2?@D=1A17089:;070A04D07 D?8D0560789:;0:514C?=5:12:;01>G=3207<=73>02: :;0A?2:02:D?@:;0D:4:0>02:4:K*F?=C7AC045C9D;?F :;4: :;0 70A04D07 G?=507 E05?D020 ?2 ;05 8?79 427 D0: ;05D0C@ 12:? @150 ?2C9 :? :;504:02 :;0 70A04D07 @?5 :;0 4CC0307504D?2:;4::;04AA=D0748=D07;05:;4:D;0F4D ;4612350C4:1?2D;1GF1:;;05>4C0A?CC043=0D12:;0G?C1A0 D:4:1?2F;050D;0F4DF?5E123 "$ =5:;05 :;0 :514C ?=5: ;4D 50@05507 :? D?>0 70A1D1?2D ?@ ?=5 ?2/8C0 13; ?=5: ?@ 4524:4E4 427 - 23 - ?8D05607:;4:F;02;=D8427;4D47>1::07:;0F1@0:?:;0 ;?DG1:4C427F;02G5?D0A=:1?2@41C07:?477=A0:;050C148C0 061702A0:?12@0548?=::;0:?5:=503160289:;0;=D8427 :;02 :;0 ;=D8427 A422?: 80 G=21D;07 @?5 :;0 ?@@02A0D G=21D;48C0=27050A:1?2'(#)427"&'?@ " 2:;0A4D0?2;4271:1D=271DG=:07@4A::;4: 1>>0714:0C9 4@:05 :;0 12A1702: :;0 4AA=D07 ;1>D0C@ :??E :;070A04D07:?:;0;?DG1:4C@?5:504:>02:?50?6051:1D >02:1?207 12 :;0 D:4:0>02: 4: K* 1:D0C@ :;4: :;0 4AA=D07 :5107 :? 0K:123=1D; :;0 @150 =: :;0 70A04D07 43412 D0: ;05D0C@ 12:? @150 427 D=D:41207 8=52 12<=510D ;050@?50 4D D=8>1::07 89 :;0 C045207 A?=2D0C @?5 :;0 4AA=D07:;0501D2?055?5A?>>1::0789:;0:514C?=5::? A?>0:?:;0A?2AC=D1?2:;4::;0G5?D0A=:1?2;4D@41C07:? G5?60 809?27 4CC 504D?248C0 7?=8: :;4: :;0 4AA=D07 48=D07 :;0 70A04D07 12 429 @1C:;9 C423=430 1>>0714:0C9 045C105:?:;012A1702:?@:;070A04D07A?>>1::123D=1A170 427 ;0 D=8<0A:07 :;0 70A04D07 :? >02:4C 427 G;9D1A4C A5=0C:9F;1A;F?=C750D=C:0712:;070A04D07A?>>1::123 - 24 - D=1A170 ;0 >0:1A=C?=D A?2D17054:1?2 ?@ :;0 504D?2123 ?@ :;0:514C?=5:F?=C7AC045C9D;?F:;4::;0:514C?=5:;4D A?2D170507 ?54C 427 7?A=>02:459 061702A0 ?2 50A?57 12 G5?G05 G05DG0A:160 427 :;05089 A?>0 :? :;0 G5?G05 A?2AC=D1?2:;4::;0G5?D0A=:1?2;4D@41C07:?G5?60809?27 504D?248C07?=8::;0?@@02A0DA;453043412D::;04AA=D07 ;050@?50 :;0G5?D0A=:1?2 ;4D =::05C9 @41C07 :? >4E0 ?=: 429 35?=27 :? 12:05@050 F1:; :;0 1>G=3207 <=73>02: ?@ :;0 :514C ?=5: 503457123 :;0 ?5705 ?@ 4AB=1::4C G4DD07 12 @46?=5?@:;04AA=D0702A0:;0501D2?35?=27>470?=: 89 :;0 G5?D0A=:1?2 :? 12:05@050 F1:; :;0 1>G=3207 <=73>02: ?@ :;0 :514C ?=5: 4: :;0 ;427D ?@ :;1D ?=5: 12 :;0 G50D02: 4GG04C ?2D0B=02:C9 :;0 4GG04C 1D C148C0 :? 8071D>1DD07 "" 2:;050D=C:F0G5?A007:?G4DD:;0@?CC?F123 ;04GG04C1D;0508971D>1DD07 ?2D0B=02:C9 :;0 <=73>02: 427 ?5705 ?@ 4AB=1::4C 12 ?$#&$' G4DD07 89 :;0 771:1?24C 1D:51A: 427 0DD1?2 =730 - 25 - 1745 1::123 4: 4D464E4C942 1D A?2@15>07 427:;04AA=D07D;4CCD:4274AB=1::07 02784AE:;0:514C?=5:50A?57D4C?23 F1:;A?G9?@:;1D<=73>02::?:;0:514C?=5: @?5:;F1:; !9 (%!* ' !9 ("'# "* ' 1D:?$C?("