Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66742 (KAR)
SOMANING @ SOMA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201242/2025 · 2025-08-29
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66742 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66742 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "# $ ##
#
%
%&'(
)% '' *
!""
#!! " $%&%'()
! )* ! &) ! &'() ! !! ) )' )( %( %(+ ) ! ! '(
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! #
#
,- .-/0/012-3 4-025 67789-: 1' 02 30;- 1&'() 1< 0=6>6.83 836? 1?07- /6/012 .-2:025 02 1'( 12 /,- <0?- 1< /,- ::? 09/307/ 62: -99012962:.-706?8:5-0=6>6.833-509/-3-:<13/,- 1<<-27- .8209,64?- 82:-3 -7/0129 ) )' )( %( %(+3@)094-<13-/,09183/9--A0255362/1<460? 82:-3-7/012&)1<,636/0>665630A836A9,662,0/6 () <13 9,13/ B ()C 12 /,- 46909 1< /,- <039/ 02<13;6/012?1:5-:4>/,-02<13;62/$>1/046
!67/9 1< /,- 769- 02 430-< 63- /,6/ /,- 02<13;62/$<6/,-3 1< /,- :-7-69-: ?1:5-: /,- <039/ 02<13;6/012 656029/ 67789-: 19' 62: @0/, 0=6>6.83 836? 1?07- /6/012 6??-5025 71;;099012 1< 1<<-27- .8209,64?-82:-3-7/0129))')(%(%(+3@)
- 3 -
,- .-/0/012-3 62: 1/,-3 67789-: @-3- 6..3-,-2:-:
:83025 02D-9/056/012 / 09 9/6/-: /,6/ /,- .-/0/012-3 @69 633-9/-: 12 '+()() 027- /,-2 ,- 09 02 =8:0706? 789/1:> -/0/012-3 ,6: 6..3167,-: /,09 183/ 4> <0?025 90;0?63 460? .-/0/0129 127- :83025 730;- 9/65- 62: /,- 9-712:12-6</-3<0?0251<7,635-9,--/
1@-D-341/,/,- .-/0/0129 76;- /1 4- :09;099-: 12 ;-30/9 1@ /,- .-/0/012-3 ,69 6..3167,-: /,09 183/ <13 /,- /,03: /0;- 9--A0255362/1<460? ) -63: 30 ,636264696D-9,@63 6;6:6.83 ?-632-: 71829-? <13 /,- .-/0/012-3 62: 30 6;6:63 ,6,648::02?-632-:
05,183/ 1D-32;-2/?-6:-3<13 /,-3-9.12:-2/$/6/--389-:/,-;6/-306?9123-713:
2 D0-@ 1< /,- 30D6? 712/-2/0129 835-: 4> /,- ?-632-:71829-?<1341/,/,-.63/0-9/,-.102//,6/@18?: 6309-<13;>71290:-36/01209
- 4 -
% > 629@-3 /1 /,- 641D- .102/ 09 02 /,- + <13/,-<1??1@025
+ /09 /,- 712/-2/012 1< /,-.319-78/012 /,6/69 .-3/,-7,635-9,--/67789-:1',6:0??070/3-?6/0129,0. @0/,/,-@0<-1</,-:-7-69-:,-:-7-69-:7685,//,-; 3-:,62:-:62:E8-9/012-:987,67/9,-3-<13-67789-: 19' 62: 7129.03-: /15-/,-3 /1 7689- /,- :-6/, 1< :-7-69-:69968?/-:,0;@0/,626F-031231:62:46;411 7?84,-2/,-:-7-69-:3609-:,8-62:73>9'62:G 76;-/1/,-9.1/,-67789-:730;026??>02/0;0:6/-:/,-;
21/ /1 3-D-6? /,-9- <67/9 /1 62>41:> -?9- 62: 6489-: /,-; 02 <0?/,> ?625865- ,- 02=83-: 989/602-: <6/6? 02=830-962:?6/-3:0-:7713:025?>/,-<026?3-.13/76;- /14-<0?-: G 9 .-3 .19/ ;13/-; 3-.13/ /,- :-7-69-: ,6:
989/602-: 69 ;62> 69 90F 02=830-9 @,07, 63- -0/,-3 ?67-36/012913712/890129,-:-6/,1</,-:-7-69-:@69 :8-/1,-;133,65079,17A6963-98?/1<;8?/0.?-02=830-9
- 5 -
989/602-: 1D-3 ,-6: 62: <67- ,- 6??-56/0129 ;6:- 656029/ /,- .3-9-2/ .-/0/012-3 4-025 /,- ;602 67789-: 09 D-3> 9-30189 6A025 02/1 71290:-36/012 /,- 26/83- 62: 9-301892-99 1< /,- 1<<-27- /,- -63?0-3 460? .-/0/0129 @-3- :09;099-: & 1@ 0/ 09 9/6/-: /,6/ 9' 62: * @-3- -F6;02-: 4-<13- /,- 306?
183/ 9' /1 ) 63- /,- @0/2-99-9 <13 /,- ;6,6H63 9 62: % 63- /,- ->-$ @0/2-99-9 09 /,- @0<- 1< 67789-: 1' 8/ 41/, /,-9-@0/2-99-963-960:/1,6D-/832-:,19/0?-62:,6D- 21/ 98..13/-: /,- 769- 1< /,- .319-78/012 + 9.-6A9 6418//,-;1/0D-<13/,-67789-:/17689-/,-:-6/,1</,- :-7-69-:G09/,-97304-1</,-<039/02<13;6/012& 09 /,- :17/13 @,1 /3-6/-: 62: * 09 /,- .627,6 @0/2-99D-2/,185,/,-.319-78/01270/-:69;62>69'* @0/2-99-9 /,- 1/,-3 @0/2-99-9 /1 4- -F6;02-: 4> /,- .319-78/012 63- -0/,-3 <13;6? 13 1<<0706? @0/2-99-9 / 09 .-3/02-2/ /1 21/- /,6/ 12 /,- 46909 1< /,- 9/6/-;-2/9 1< /,-9-->-$@0/2-99-9/,--63?0-3460?.-/0/0129<0?-:4>/,-
- 6 -
.-/0/012-376;-/14-:09;099-:,-2/,-->-$@0/2-99-9 /1 /,- 0270:-2/ ,6D- 21/ 98..13/-: /,- 769- 1< /,- .319-78/012 6; 1< /,- 1.02012 /,6/ :-/-2/012 1< /,- .-/0/012-3 02 789/1:> ;6> 6;182/ /1 02<3025-;-2/ 1< ,09 305,//1?0<-62:?04-3/> * 1290:-3025 6?? /,-9- <67/9 62: 70378;9/627-9 6; 1< /,- 1.02012 /,6/ /,- .-/0/012-3 09 -2/0/?-: /1 4- -2?635-:12460?984=-7//1712:0/0129@,07,@0??/6A-763- 1</,-02/-3-9/1</,-.319-78/012@0/2-99-92D0-@1</,- 641D- 629@-3 /,- 641D- .102/ 02 /,- 6<<03;6/0D- 62: .317--:/1.699/,-<1??1@025
,-.-/0/01209 ,- .-/0/012-3 09 13:-3-: /1 4- -2?635-: 12 460? 02 30;- 1&'() 1< 0=6>6.83 836? 1?07- /6/012 12 14/602025/,-412:02698;1<9((((($8.--9@1 6A,9 12?> @0/, /@1 983-/0-9 <13 /,- ?0A-98; /1 /,-
- 7 -
96/09<67/012 1< /,- =8309:07/0126? 183/ 984=-7/ /1 /,- <1??1@025712:0/0129 6 ,- .-/0/012-3 9,6?? 21/ 71;;0/ 90;0?63 1<<-27-9 4 ,- .-/0/012-3 9,6?? 21/ /,3-6/-2 13 /6;.-3@0/,/,-.319-78/012@0/2-99-9 7 ,- .-/0/012-3 9,6?? 6..-63 4-<13- /,- 183/6962:@,-23-E803-: :
< 02 769- /,- .-/0/012-3 D01?6/-9 62> 1< /,- 712:0/0129 69 9/6/-: 641D- /,- .319-78/012@0??4-6/?04-3/>/1;1D-/,- 306?183/9--A0257627-??6/0121<460? 2 <83209,025 /,- 983-/0-9 4> /,- .-/0/012-3/,-306?183/096/?04-3/>/1:03-7/ /,- 2D-9/056/025 <<07-3 /1 D-30<> /,- 7133-7/2-99 1< /,- 6::3-99 62: 68/,-2/070/> 1< /,- :178;-2/9 <83209,-: 4> /,- .-/0/012-3 62: /,- 983-/0-9 62: 6 3-.13/ ;6> 4- 76??-: <13 02
- 8 -
/,6/ 3-563: @,07, 09 /1 4- 984;0//-: 4> /,- 2D-9/056/025 <<07-3 @0/,02 % :6>9 ,- 306? 183/ 12 96/09<67/012 ;6> .317--: /1 677-./ /,- 983-/0-9 <13 /,- .83.19- 1< 3-?-69025 /,- .-/0/012-312460? ,( %##' $
09/1'?1')
"