- 1 - !! ""# "$%! ! &! #'#(##" # #(( )%* # #(( )%* ! !"#$$ % & ' " !"#$$ % & ' $(&$' )$*$! $# $ *$" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! % & ' " *) !"#$$ % & ' $(&$' $# $ *$" *( $ *$" )$*$! + '" $ ,- ./012034 05-6 *# 7-089 2-4 :14, 0..16-34 ;3 $( ! *$!0369<==-8-6581->;<913?<81-9 -=1/-6./012@-4141;3 - 3 - 13 ; )$*$!A-=;8-4,-66141;30/-31;81>1/<65- 036 04 1?070@<80 &=;8 9,;84 B4,- 481A<30/C' 9--D135 .;2@-39041;3;=9 $ 0/;35:14,134-8-94 * ,-481A<30/0=4-8.;3916-81354,--3418-->16-3.-;3 8-.;860:086-609<2;=9 *!"( 0/;35:14,134-8-94044,- 804- ;= )E @-8 033<2 -135 05581->-6 A7 4,- 9016 <652-34 0360:086 ; *##**$)19=1/-6A74,-083040D0404- ;06 8039@;84 ;8@;8041;3 &=;8 9,;84 B4,- .;8@;8041;3C' ;3 4,- 58;<36 ;= /10A1/147 036 ; **$*!*$) 19 =1/-6 A7 4,- ./0120349--D135-3,03.-2-34;=4,-.;2@-39041;30:086-6A7 4,-481A<30/ -083-6 .;<39-/ =;8 4,- ./012034 9<A2149 4,04 4,- ./012034 :09 -083135 0 9<2 ;= 9 $ @-8 2;34, 036 ,- 9@-34 0 9<2 ;= 9 * 4;:0869 2-61.0/ -F@-39-9 - -F0213-64,-;.4;809 *036,-099-99-64,-6190A1/14704 E4;4,-815,4/;:-8/12A036$!E6190A1/1474;4,-/-=4<@@-8 /12A A<4 4,- 481A<30/ ,09 40D-3 ;3/7 $E ,- 2</41@/1-8 19 40D-3 04 B$(C <84,-8 ,- 9<A2149 4,04 4,- 02;<349 58034-6 <36-8 4,- ;4,-8 ,-069 08- 0/9; ;3 2-05-8 916- 036 3--69 -3,03.-2-34;=4,-.;2@-39041;3 - 4 - G -083-6.;<39-/=;84,-39<803.-.;2@0379<A2149 4,043;3 48-04-6;.4;8,09099-99-64,-6190A1/147099<.,4,- 481A<30/,09815,4/740D-3$E6190A1/1473--693;134-8=-8-3.- -=<84,-89<A2144-64,044,-.,085- 9,--419=1/-60501394A;4, 4,->-,1./-91 - 816-8;=4,-2;4;8.7./-0364,-681>-8;=4,-A<9 ! -0864,-085<2-349=8;2A;4,916-9 # 3 @-8<90/ ;= 4,- 8-.;869 14 9,;:9 4,04 :,1/- 4,- ./012034 :09 816135 4,- 2;4;8.7./- A-08135 8-51948041;3 ; *" (!G 4,- 681>-8 ;= 4,- A<9 A-08135 8-51948041;3 ; )G .02- =8;2 ;@@;914- 618-.41;3 13 0 ,15, 9@--6 809, 0363-5/15-342033-8;3:8;35916-609,-64;4,-2;4;8.7./- 419619.<99-6134,-<652-344,044,-816-8;=4,-2;4;8.7./- :09 40/D135 ;3 4,- 2;A1/- :,1/- 816135 4,- 2;4;8.7./- ,19 ./-08/7 9,;:9 4,04 4,-8- 19 0/9; 3-5/15-3.- ;3 4,- @084 ;= 4,- 2;4;8.7./194 ,085- 9,--419=1/-60501394A;4,4,->-,1./-9A<4 4,-481A<30/-88-613=1F1354,-/10A1/147;3/7;34,-A<9 -3.- 4,19 ;<84 =1369 14 8-09;30A/- 4; =1F 4,- .;3481A<4;87 3-5/15-3.- ;3 A;4, >-,1./-9 13 4,- 8041; ;= *E ;3 4,- 816-8 ;= 4,- 2;4;8.7./-036"E;34,-681>-8;=4,-A<9 - 5 - ( ,;<5,4,-./012034,099404-64,04,-:09-083135 0 9<2 ;= 9 $ @-8 2;34, ,- ,09 3;4 @8;6<.-6 037 13.;2-@8;;= -2-4:14,0..16-34134,-7-08*$! 9@-84,- 5<16-/13-9 199<-6 A7 4,- 083040D0 404- -50/ -8>1.-9 <4,;8147 4,- 13.;2- ;= 4,- ./012034 19 4; A- 40D-3 04 9 " @-8 2;34, ,- ./012034 -F0213-6 4,- ;.4;8 ,- ./0120349<94013-613?<81-90369:-//135;>-84,-815,4-7-:14, A/<19, .;/;8 @013 036 61==1.</47 4; ;@-3 4,- 02;<34H 0A8091;3 ;>-8815,4@0/-3-08I75;208-6619,036;39.039,;:94,04 =80.4<8-;=20361A/-04815,4@0802-61088-51;3036.8031; =0.10/ ,-13?<81-92-341;3-6134,-:;</6.-841=1.04-04/ ; $036* 08-581->;<913304<8-03613?<87; 19912@/- ;3916-81354,- 0A;>-13?<81-94,-;.4;8099-99-64,-6190A1/147;=4,-./012034 04$E4;4,-:,;/-A;67 ,-481A<30/,09815,4/740D-3$E 6190A1/1474;4,-:,;/-A;67036143--693;134-8=-8-3.- -3.- 4,-/;99;==<4<8--083135.0@0.1471909<36-8 9 " J$*J$(J$EK9 $#* " ,- 481A<30/ ,09 0:086-6 0 9<2 ;= 9 ##( 4;:0869 2-61.0/ -F@-39-9 ,- 902- 19 .;88-.4 036 3--69 3; 134-8=-8-3.- ,- ./012034 :09 13@041-34 =;8 -15,4 6079 - 6 - ;3916-81354,-304<8-;=13?<81-9@-81;6;=,;9@140/1I041;34,19 ;<84 =1369 14 8-09;30A/- 4; 58034 03 02;<34 ;= 9 ! 4;:0869 @013 036 9<==-8135 9 *! 4;:0869 /;99 ;= 02-3141-9 9 4;:0869 48039@;84041;3 -F480 3;<819,2-34 036 044-36034 .,085-9 ,- ./012034 215,4 ,0>- 3;4044-36-6037;4,-8:;8D=;804/-094G2;34,9 -3.-09<2 ;=9 * &9 " JG2;34,9'4;:0869/;99;=13.;2- 6<8135/016<@@-81;6 -3.-4,-4;40/.;2@-39041;31909<36-8 #+ ,-./012,3/-453 1634 $ ;99;=-083135.0@0.147 9 $#* * -61.0/-F@-39-9 9 ##( 0130369<==-8135 9 ! G ;99;=02-3141-9 9 *! ! 8039@;84041;3 -F480 3;<819,2-34 036 044-36034 .,085-9 9 ! ;99 ;= 13.;2- 6<8135 /016 <@ @-81;6 9 * 4-+ /7 ) ..;86135/74,-=;//;:135;86-8 " &1' ;4,0@@-0/908-0//;:-613@084H &11' ,- ./012034 19 -3414/-6 4; 4;40/ .;2@-39041;3;=9 ##) 0/;35:14,134-8-9404 4,-804-;=#E@-8033<2=8;24,-604-;=@-4141;3 - 7 - 41// 4,- 604- ;= 8-0/1I041;3 09 0501394 9 *!"( 0:086-6A74,-481A<30/H &111' ,- .;3481A<4;87 3-5/15-3.- 19 =1F-6 ;3 A;4, 4,- >-,1./-9 1 - *E ;3 4,- 816-8 ;= 4,- 2;4;8.7./- A-08135 8-51948041;3 ; *" (!G 036"E;34,-681>-8;=4,-A<9A-081358-51948041;3 ; )GH &1>' ,- 8-9@;36-34 ; * 19 618-.4-6 4; 6-@;914"E;=4,-.;2@-39041;302;<340/;35:14, 134-8-94 :14,13 ;3- 2;34, =8;2 4,- 604- ;= 4,19 ;86-8H &>' ,- 02;<34 6-@;914-6 A7 4,- 39<803.- .;2@037 A-=;8- 4,19 ;<84 9,0// A- 480392144-6 4; 4,-481A<30/=;84,:14,H &>1' 3 9<., 6-@;914 4,- ./012034 19 @-82144-64;:14,680:4,--3418-02;<340/;35:14, 134-8-940..8<-6;314 /. )(##"* '" 194; $/; (