- 1 - ! "# $% "" &'( )* % + &'( ) * ! " # $%& ' &( ) * &( + Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * &, # ' %& - &* %& . & %, )&) &)*+ ! " ,'/ ,, # , , +* "# , $ % '&+ $ $ +) * $%& ' & ( * & ( ) - 3 - ' %& -' &* % 0 ! $ " # & * %, )&) &)*+ " # ! " ,/ %# , , ' , % $ % '&+ $ $ , ,, , $% 1 $ - 4 - % 234 345677896:;4 ,3<4= >>687 89? 5<:44:@A65=3:9 8<346 :;= :B =26 A;?CD69= 89? 8E8<? ?8=6? >8446? @F =26 693:< 3G37 $;?C6 89? :=:< 553?69= 783D4<3@;987 8?C3<339 :'&+ <36BB85=4C3G39C<346=:B3739C:B=2348>>68789? 5<:44:@A65=3:9 8<6 =28= :9 ''- =26 ?656846? ;DD8<3 6??8 8C8998 E84 ><:566?39C :9 234 D:=:<5F576 @68<39C <6C34=<8=3:9 : -&'+* 68< ;DDF :=67 39 =26 73D3=4 :B 28? 8C8< =26 ?<3G6< :B 7:<<F@68<39C<6C34=<8=3:9:)&)28?>8<H6?234 G623576 39 =26 D3??76 :B =26 <:8? E3=2:;= B:77:E39C =26 =<8BB35 <;764 ;DD8<3 6??8 8C8998 394>3=6 :B ?;6 ?373C69565:;7?9:=8G:3?=268553?69=89?58D6395:9=85= E3=2 =26 483? 7:<<F ;6 =: E2352 26 4;4=8396? C<36G:;4 39A;<364 89? 4;55;D@6? =: =26 39A;<364 26 >6=3=3:96<4 @639C =26 76C87 <6><6469=8=3G64 :B =26 ?656846?;DD8<3 6??8 8C8998 B376? 5783D >6=3=3:9 ;9?6< 65=3:9 -- :B - 5 - =265=466H39C5:D>6948=3:9:9855:;9=:B=26?68=2 :B;DD8<36??88C899839=26<:8?=<8BB358553?69= * 26 <3@;987 344;6? 9:=356 =:=26:E96< :B =26 :BB69?39C7:<<F64>3=646<G356:B9:=356=26:E96<:B=26 :BB69?39C 7:<<F <6D8396? ;9<6><6469=6? 89? E84 >7856? 6I>8<=6 ' 26 94;<8956 :D>89F B376? 4=8=6D69= :B :@A65=3:94 ?69F39C =26 8G6<D69=4 D8?6 39 =26 5783D >6=3=3:9 89? 5:9=69?6? =28= =26 ?656846? 23D467B 28? 5:9=<3@;=6?=:=2658;46:B=268553?69=69563=><8F6? =: ?34D344 =26 5783D >6=3=3:9 8C8394= =26 94;<8956 :D>89F 26 <3@;987 :9 =26 @8434 :B >768?39C4 :B =26 >8<=364B<8D6?=26<676G89=344;64 - 26 >6=3=3:96<4 =: 4;@4=89=38=6 =263< 5846 6I8D396? >6=3=3:96< : 84 % 89? C:= D8<H6? - ?:5;D69=4 84 I4 =: - 9 <6@;==87 =26 - 6 - ?D3934=<8=3G6 BB356< :B =26 94;<8956 :D>89F E84 6I8D396? 84 % 89? C:= D8<H6? ' ?:5;D69=4 84 I4=:' + 26 <3@;987 8B=6< <65:<?39C =26 6G3?6956 268<39C @:=2 43?64 89? :9 844644D69= :B G6<@87 89? ?:5;D69=8<F 6G3?6956 877:E6? =26 5783D >6=3=3:9 39 >8<= 89?8E8<?6?5:D>6948=3:9:B4*&E3=239=6<64= 8==26<8=6:B-J>6<899;DB<:D=26?8=6:B>6=3=3:9=377 <6873K8=3:9 26 <3@;987 267? =28= =26 :E96< 89? =26 94;<8956 :D>89F8<6A:39=7F89?46G6<877F738@76=:>8F =26 5:D>6948=3:9 8D:;9= 89? ?3<65=6? =26 94;<8956 :D>89F=:?6>:43==265:D>6948=3:98D:;9= 26 94;<8956 :D>89F 8CC<36G6? @F =26 A;?CD69= 89? 8E8<? >8446? @F =26 <3@;987 39 B84=6939C 738@373=F><6B6<<6?898>>68739,:+-'&)89? =26 >6=3=3:96<4 B376? 5<:44:@A65=3:9 39 , :*'& @639C ?3448=34B36? E3=2 =26 L;89=;D:B5:D>6948=3:98E8<?6?@F=26<3@;987 - 7 - ) 68<? =26 768<96? 5:;9467 B:< =26 94;<8956 :D>89F89?768<96?5:;9467B:<=26>6=3=3:96<4 26768<96?5:;9467B:<=2694;<8956 :D>89F 4;@D3=4=28==26<3?6<:B=26D:=:<5F5765:9=<3@;=6?=:=26 58;46:B=268553?69=89?=26<6345:9=<3@;=:<F96C73C6956 :9=26>8<=:B=26<3?6<:B=26D:=:<5F57664;@D3=4=28= =26<3@;9872845:DD3==6?896<<:<39B84=6939C=2669=3<6 738@373=F :9 =26 94;<8956 :D>89F 6 874: 4;@D3=4 =28= =26 <3@;987 284 9: A;<34?35=3:9 =: 69=6<=839 =26 5783D >6=3=3:984=26>6=3=3:96<48<6=26<643?69=4:B6789C898 =8=6 89? =26 8553?69= :55;<<6? 39 =26 6789C898 =8=6 9 =2646 C<:;9?4 26 ><8F4 =: 877:E =26 8>>687 B376? @F =2694;<8956 :D>89F89?=:?34D344=265<:44:@A65=3:9 B376?@F=26>6=3=3:96<4 768<96? 5:;9467 B:< =26 >6=3=3:96<4 4;@D3=4 =28= =26 528<C6 4266= 284 @669 B376? 8C8394= =26 ?<3G6< :B =26 :BB69?39C G623576 89? 9: 528<C6 4266= E84 - 8 - B376? 8C8394= =26 <3?6< :B =26 D:=:<5F576 6 B;<=26< 4;@D3=4 =28= =26 94;<8956 :D>89F 284 9:= 6I8D396? 89F 6F6E3=964464 =: 64=8@7342 =28= =26 <3?6< :B =26 D:=:<5F576 5:9=<3@;=6? =: =26 58;46 :B =26 8553?69= 6 4;@D3=4 =28= =26 >6=3=3:96<4 28G6 ><:?;56? <643?69=387 56<=3B358=64 =: ?6D:94=<8=6 =28= =26F 8<6 <643?69=4 :B 8<98=8H8 89? =26 <643?69=387 56<=3B358=6 34 D8<H6? 84 I- 6 5:9=69?4 =28= =26 <3@;987 E84 A;4=3B36? 39 69=6<=83939C=265783D>6=3=3:989?=28==265:D>6948=3:9 8E8<?6? @F =26 <3@;987 34 :9 =26 7:E6< 43?6 6956 :9 =2646C<:;9?426><8F4=:?34D344:B=268>>687B376?@F =26 94;<8956 :D>89F 89? B:< 877:E39C =26 5<:44 :@A65=3:9B376?@F=26>6=3=3:96<4 6<;46? =26 <65:<?4 89? 5:943?6<6? =26 4;@D3443:94:B=26768<96?5:;9467B:<=26>8<=364 * 26 >:39=4 =28= 8<346 B:< 5:943?6<8=3:9 @6B:<6 =234 :;<=8<6E3=2<6C8<?=:=26L;89=;D:B738@373=F89? =26L;89=;D:B5:D>6948=3:9 - 9 - ' 26<6349:?34>;=6<6C8<?39C=26:55;<<6956:B =26 8553?69= 89? =26 ?68=2 :B =26 ?656846? 39 =26 <:8? =<8BB35 8553?69= =28= :55;<<6? :9 ''- 26 >6=3=3:96<4 28G6 ><:?;56? =26 528<C6 4266= D8<H6? 84 I' E2352 ?3457:464 =28= =26 8553?69= :55;<<6? ?;6 =: =26 <842 89? 96C73C69= ?<3G39C :B =26 ?<3G6< :B =26 :BB69?39C G623576 26<6B:<6 =26 <3@;987 E84 A;4=3B36? 39 894E6<39C 344;6 :39 =268BB3<D8=3G66956 B39? 9: 6<<:<39=26B39?39C<65:<?6?@F=26<3@;987:9344;6: 94:B8< 84 738@373=F 34 5:956<96? =26 768<96? 5:;9467 B:< =26 94;<8956 :D>89F 4;@D3=4 =28= =26 :BB69?39CG623576E84>8<H6?39=26D3??76:B=26<:8?89? =268553?69=:55;<<6??;6=:=26<84289?96C73C69=<3?39C :B =26 <3?6< :B =26 D:=:<5F576 84 E677 84 =26 <842 89? 96C73C69=?<3G39C:B=26:BB69?39CG623576@F3=4?<3G6<=34 5:9=69?6? =28= =26<6 E84 5:D>:43=6 96C73C6956 :9 =26 >8<=:B@:=2=26<3?6<:B=26D:=:<5F57689?=26?<3G6<:B =26 :BB69?39C G623576 :E6G6< =: 4;@4=89=38=6 =234 - 10 - 5:9=69=3:9=2694;<8956 :D>89F2849:=6I8D396?89F 6F6E3=9644 =: 64=8@7342 =28= =26 <3?6< :B =26 D:=:<5F576 5:9=<3@;=6? =: =26 58;46 :B =26 8553?69= 89? 9: 528<C6 4266= 34 B376? 8C8394= =26 ?656846?<3?6< ?D3==6?7F =26 528<C6 4266= E84 B376? :97F 8C8394= =26 ?<3G6< :B =26 :BB69?39C G623576 26 <3@;987 5:943?6<39C I' 284 <3C2=7F<65:<?6?3=4B39?39C=28==268553?69=28?:55;<<6? ?;6 =: <842 89? 96C73C69= ?<3G39C :B =26 ?<3G6< :B =26 :BB69?39C G623576 89? <3C2=7F 48??76? =26 738@373=F :9 =26 :E96<89?=26394;<6<:B=26:BB69?39CG623576A:39=7F89? 46G6<877F 26<6B:<6 ?: 9:= B39? 89F 6<<:< 39 48??739C =26 738@373=F :9 =26 :E96< 89? 94;<8956 :D>89F A:39=7F 89?46G6<877F - 9G36E:B=268@:G6?345;443:94894E6<=26 >:39=E3=2<6C8<?=:738@373=F855:<?39C7F + 94:B8< 84 L;89=;D :B 5:D>6948=3:9 34 5:956<96? 3= 34 5:9=69?6? @F =26 >6=3=3:96<4 =28= =26 ?656846?;DD8<3 6??8 8C8998 E84 8C6? 8@:;= ' - 11 - F68<484:B=26?8=6:B=268553?69=89?26E84E:<H39C84 84:9 89? 68<939C 4& >6< D:9=2 : 4;@4=89=38=6=2648D6=26>6=3=3:96<428G69:=><:?;56? 89F395:D6><::B9=268@46956:B><::B:B395:D6=26 9:=3:987 395:D6 284 =: @6 =8H69 84 >6< =26 4526?;76 9:=3B36?@F 3956=268553?69=34:B=26F68<- =269:=3:987395:D634=8H698=4+&>6<D:9=2: =268B:<6483?8D:;9=84=26?656846?E848C6?'F68<4 J :B =26 483? 8D:;9= 284 =: @6 8??6? :9 855:;9= :B B;=;<6 ><:4>65=4 39 G36E :B =26 78E 783? ?:E9 @F =26 :94=3=;=3:9 6952 :B =26 :9M@76 ;><6D6 :;<= 39 =26 5846 :B ! "# $ %! &' # ' <6>:<=6? 39 ( & ))( 2;4 =26 D:9=27F 395:D6 5:D64=:4)*+& ;=:BE23525:943?6<39C=28==26<68<6B:;<?6>69?69=4 ?66D 3= 8>><:><38=6 =: ?6?;5= &'=2 :B =26 483? 395:D6 =:E8<?4>6<4:9876I>69464:B=26?656846?89?=26<6B:<6 =26D:9=27F395:D6:B=26?656846?5:D64=:4*& 8H39C39=:855:;9==268C6:B=26?656846?E2352E84' - 12 - F68<4 8= =26 =3D6 :B 8553?69= D;7=3>736< :B 284 =: @6 8?:>=6? 84 >6< =26 A;?CD69= :B =26 :91@76 ;><6D6 :;<= 39 =26 5846 :B & * $ +' , <6>:<=6?39-./0&26<6B:<6 =26 >6=3=3:96<4 8<6 69=3=76? =: 8 4;D :B 4'+-'& "4*&II#:9855:;9=:B7:44:B?6>69?695F ,;<=26< 39 G36E :B =26 78E 783? ?:E9 @F =26 :9M@76 ;><6D6 :;<= 39 =26 5846 :B 1 2 ! "# $ '' 3 '<6>:<=6?39-4/4& 6852>6=3=3:96<3469=3=76?=:84;D:B4'&=:E8<?4 7:44 :B 5:94:<=3;D 26 >6=3=3:96<4 8<6 B:;< 39 9;D@6< 26956=265:D>6948=3:9=:E8<?47:44:B5:94:<=3;DE:;7? @64)&"'I'#98??3=3:9=26>6=3=3:96<4 8<6 69=3=76? 8 4;D :B 4& =:E8<?4 B;96<87 6I>6946489?:=26<56<6D:936489?84;D:B4& =:E8<?47:44:B64=8=6 - 13 - ) 2;4 39 877 =26 >6=3=3:96<4 8<6 69=3=76? =: 8 =:=87 5:D>6948=3:9 :B 4+''& 84 8C8394= 4*&8E8<?6?@F=26<3@;98726>6=3=3:96<4 69=3=76?B:<896928956?5:D>6948=3:9:B4+''& 9 G36E :B =26 8@:G6 ?345;443:9 ><:566? =: >844=26B:77:E39C 3 26 8>>687 B376? @F =26 94;<8956 :D>89F 39 , :+-'&) 34 33 265<:44:@A65=3:9B376?@F=26>6=3=3:96<4 39 , :*'& 34 333 263D>;C96?A;?CD69=89?8E8<??8=6? >8446? @F =26 693:< 3G37 $;?C6 89? 8?C3<3 39 :'&+34D:?3B36? 3G 26 >6=3=3:96<4 8<6 69=3=76? =: 6928956? 5:D>6948=3:9:B4+''&398??3=3:9 =: =26 5:D>6948=3:9 8E8<?6? @F =26 - 14 - <3@;98787:9CE3=239=6<64=8==26<8=6:B -J >6< 899;D B<:D =26 ?8=6 :B 5783D >6=3=3:9=377=26?8=6:B<6873K8=3:9 G 26 94;<8956 :D>89F 34 ?3<65=6? =: ?6>:43= =26 5:D>6948=3:9 8D:;9= E3=2 855<;6? 39=6<64= E3=239 8 >6<3:? :B 63C2= E66H4 B<:D =26 ?8=6 :B <6563>= :B 5:>F :B =234A;?CD69= G3 26 8D:;9= 39 ?6>:43= 34 :<?6<6? =: @6 =<894D3==6?=:=26<3@;987 G33 26 6C34=<F 34 ?3<65=6? =: 469? @85H =26 <387 :;<=<65:<?4=:=26<3@;987 ,) & ( % 34=: 7:) =