- 1 - !" #$ % $$ $&& '( ')')) * !"##$ % & ' ( # ) ) ! #*$ ' '' * !"##$ % &' ) #+ ( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ') # &#( ) &( #!*"* , & ( # * & )' #-$ *$( $#- ) ' ) ) )) $# $$ $" * *" $ ) $&#(&.(&/($&(&01( ) & ) ( #-!- ' #!*"* ' ) ' ' 2'' ' %$ & 2'' '( 34 5.656/47 1889/47 6 :; <34 155=:81<:6; 6# * >:=479;74.48<:6;$#-6>6746>.:?:;1= .68479.4#-@$&>6./36.<A.,(:/1//1:=:;B<346.74. 71<47 #!*"* ://9:;B ;6<:84 6> <34 /1:7 155=:81<:6; 1;7 81==:;B 956; <34 1554==1;< 1889/47 6 <6 3104 3:/ /1C6;<34155=:81<:6; 41.7 .: 1B1=: 1:?631; 9.4/3 =41.;47 869;/4= >6. <34 1554==1;< 1;7 .: 1?171. 3131D977:; - 3 - =41.;47 :B3 69.< 604.;?4;< =4174. >6. .4/56;74;< 6# <1<4 4/56;74;< 6 :/ /4.047 1;7 9;.45.4/4;<474.9/47<34?1<4.:1=/101:=1D=46;.486.7 $ ; 0:4E 6> <34 .:01= 86;<4;<:6;/ 9.B47 DC <34 =41.;47869;/4=>6.D6<3<3451.<:4/<3456:;<<31<E69=7 1.:/4>6.?C86;/:74.1<:6;:/ 'C1;/E4.<6<341D60456:;<:/:;<34 >6. <34>6==6E:;B 34 1554==1;< 34.4:; E1/ 1..1C47 1/ 1889/47 6 :; <34 ) 1;7 E3:=4 >:=:;B <34 >:;1= .456.<3:/ ;1?4 E1/ 7.65547 34; <34 ?1<<4. E1/ 54;7:;B D4>6.4 <34 .:1= 69.< :; 5=1/4 & (6# * <34 5.6/489<:6; 15541./ <6 3104 >:=47 6# * 9;74. 48<:6;$#-6>.5.1C:;B<6:?5=417<341554==1;<1/ 1889/47 6 34 .:1= 69.< :;/<417 6> 86;/:74.:;B <34 - 4 - 155=:81<:6; :; <34 1D/4;84 6> <34 1554==1;< 34.4:; 5.6844747 <6 ://94 ;6<:84 <6 3:? 1;7 <34 /1:7 6.74. :/ 1//1:=47:;<3:/15541= 41.;47869;/4=>6.<341554==1;<5=184/.4=:1;84 6; <34 748:/:6; 6> <34 6;,D=4 54F 69.< :; <34 81/4 6> # <6 86;<4;7<31<48<:6;$#-6>.764/;6<86;<4?5=1<4 5.60:7:;B 1; 6556.<9;:<C 6> D4:;B 341.7 <6 <34 5.656/47 1889/47E3:=486;/:74.:;B<34155=:81<:6;1;7<34.4DC<34 .:1=69.<31/86??:<<471;4..6.:;://9:;B<34;6<:84<6 <341554==1;<346;,D=454F69.<:;<34/1:781/431/ 86;/:74.47<34/9D?://:6;/?1746;D431=>6><3451.<:4/ E:<3.4>4.4;84<6:</41.=:4.748:/:6;:;<3481/4 E34.4 <34 69.< 34=7 <31< /:;84 1 54./6; E36 :/ 17747 9;74.48<:6;$#-6>.:/;484//1.:=C341.7D4>6.434 E1/ /6 17747 1;7 6><4; B4</ 1 >9.<34. 341.:;B :> 34 1 *$$!@! 2 *# - # - 5 - 831==4;B4/ <34 /9??6;:;B 6.74. 34 81;;6< 101:= <34 .4?47C 6> 7:/831.B4 ><4. 86;/:74.:;B <34 .:01= 86;<4;<:6;/ .1:/47 D4>6.4 :< <34 6;,D=4 54F 69.< 86;8=9747:;51.1B.1536/$1;7$$1/9;74. ! " #$ %& ' " #$ ( ' ' ) *+ ' ' ' , ' ( ' " #$ % )- - ' , ' ' ' - 6 - . & & ' & & " #$ % / 0 " ' ( ' ' & & ( ' " #$ % ' & )& ' " #$% )' ' ' / ' ) !)- ' - 7 - ) ' *1 + " 34 51.1B.153/ 4F<.18<47 1D604 7:/8=6/4 <31< <34 54./6; /9??6;47 ?9/< 3104 D44; B:04; 1; 6556.<9;:<C 6> D4:;B 341.7 D4>6.4 34 D4:;B 17747 1/ 1; 1889/47 <6 >184 <.:1= E1/ 34=7 <6 D4 ;6< 86;<4?5=1<47 9;74.48<:6;$#-6>.34.4>6.4:<E1/34=7<31< <34/1?481;;6<D47:=9<47DC:?56.<:;BE:<3<34/86546> 48<:6;$#-6>.5.:;8:5=4/6>;1<9.1=G9/<:84E3:83:/ B6:;B <6 D4 >6==6E47 79.:;B <.:1= 34 /4<<=47 56/:<:6; 6> =1E :/ 1=/6 3:B3=:B3<47 <31< 5.:;8:5=4/ 6> ;1<9.1= G9/<:84 81;;6< D4 155=:47 :; /<.1:<G18H4< >6.?9=1 1;7 <34CE69=7 7454;7956;<34>18</6>418381/4 @ > <3:/ 5.:;8:5=4 6> =1E :/ 155=:47 :; <345.4/4;< 81/4 <34 86?5=1:;1;< 6. <34 5.6/489<:6; /369=7 3104 831==4;B47<346.74.:;I94/<:6;E34.4<34.:1=69.<31/ 836/4;<6://94;6<:84<6<341554==1;<<631043://1C6; 6# * <.1;B4=C 5.656/47 1889/47 6 31/ - 8 - 5.4>4..47<3:/15541=831==4;B:;B://91;846>;6<:84<63:? DC.1:/:;B/404.1=B.69;7/6<3:;B5.404;</<341554==1;< <6.1:/41==<36/4B.69;7/D4>6.4<34.:1=69.<E3:83:/ .4I9:.47 <6 86;/:74. 6# * >:=47 DC <34 5.6/489<:6; 34; <34 86?5=1:;1;< 1;7 <34 5.6/489<:6; 1.4 ;6< 310:;B 1;C B.:401;84 6; <34 :?59B;47 6.74. ://9:;B;6<:84<6<345.656/471889/47676;6<>:;7 1;C?4.:<:;<3415541=886.7:;B=C1;/E4.<341D604 56:;<:;<34 1;75.68447<651//<34>6==6E:;B 348.:?:;1=15541=:/ +( '$$) % :/<6#=6#