Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66718 (KAR)
SMT. GAYATRI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/200522/2025 · 2025-10-09
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66718 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66718 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$ # #
% &
! "#$
%
&
'
&
( &
")'
#
"*)'
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
! "*)'
*
" &
! "*)'
&
&
! "#$
$
! "#$
+ &
! "#$
%
'
$,
&
+
##$ ##+
! *'#)#*"#
##)'#)#
*
- "
&
- "' ! * $
(
- 3 -
(
./0/012.3045.613./704183/5.029:9930.;.<5=/7. 13<.3 <:/.< ##)'#)# >:44.< 5= 3.4>12<.2/ 1* ? 4404/:2/1@@044012.3A:2A.B029/7.3.40<.2/0:BA.3/060A:/. >31<8A.<:/22.C83."'
# :4. 16 /7. >./0/012.3 04 /7:/ 47.D:4 5132 12 '')+'EE':/ ://090:BB083:<"7.D:4@:330.</1
12. :30 12 #))$#)'* 6/.3 /7. @:330:9. 47. 4/:3/.< 3.40<029 D0/7 7.3 7845:2< :/ 857:472:9:3 :<:470;>./ :29:3.<<= 04/30A/ .B:29:2: /:/. 7. 7:4 91/ /D1 <:897/.347:/7.37845:2<:30 >:44.< :D:=12#*)#)#';.3402A./7.247.7:43./832.</1 7.3 >:3.2/:B 7184. :/ ://090 :BB0 :2< 7:4 5..2 3.40<029 D0/7 7.3 4@:BB A70B<3.2 .4>12<.2/ 1 7:< 0448.< 21/060A:/01202;0/029:>>B0A:/0124631@.B0905B.A:2<0<:/.4/1 60BB >14/4 16 29:2D:<0 13F.34 :2< .B>.3 02 0<:3 04/30A/ ./0/012.37:< :>>B0.< /1 /7.>14/16 29:2D:<0 13F.3 02 7157:9:BB0 29:2D:<0 .2/3. 83:<" D70A7
- 4 -
D:4 3.4.3;.< 82<.3 D0<1D G81/: ./0/012.3 7:< :B41 15/:02.<:3.40<.2/0:BA.3/060A:/.02/.3@41622.C83."' 0448.< 5= /7. .>8/= :7:40B<:3 83:<" 15B0 83:< :B8F0<:304/30A/A.3/06=029/7.>./0/012.37.3.02/15. /7. 3.40<.2/ 16 ://090 :BB0 83:<" 15B0 83:< :B8F :2< 0<:3 04/30A/ 7:/ 7.3 :>>B0A:/012D:4:AA.>/.< 5= /7. 3.4>12<.2/ ? :8/7130/0.4 >31;04012:B B04/ 02 /704 3.9:3<D:40448.<:4>.322.C83."02D70A7/7.2:@. 16/7.>./0/012.3D:43.6B.A/.<:/B1'
702944/11</784>30;:/.3.4>12<.2/1+7:< 60B.< 15H.A/0124 :BB.9029 /7:/ /7. >./0/012.3 7.3.02 7:< 48>>3.44.</7.6:A/4:2<15/:02.<:3.40<.2/0:BA.3/060A:/. 5:4.<12/7.6:B4.<1A8@.2/47:/47.04/7.>.3@:2.2/ 3.40<.2/16.B:29:2:4/:/.:448A747.D:421/.2/0/B.< 613 /7. 3.40<.2/0:B A.3/060A:/. A.3/06=029 7.3 /1 5. /7. 3.40<.2/16 ://090:BB0 8348:2//1D70A7:3.>13/D:4 A:BB.< 613 631@ /7. 1660A. 16 /7. :7:40B<:3 D71 5= 704 A1@@820A:/012 <:/.< '*)$#)# >31<8A.< :/ 22.C83." 485@0//.< 704 3.>13/ 1>02029 /7:/ /7. >./0/012.3 04
- 5 -
02<..</7.3.40<.2/16 ://090:BB083:<"3.40<029/7.3. 4854.G8.2//1<.@04.167.37845:2< /0412B=/7.3.:6/.3 :2 :>>102/@.2/ 13<.3 D:4 0448.< 02 6:;183 16 /7. >./0/012.3 :>>102/029 7.3 :4 /7. 29:2D:<0 D13F.3 16 7157:9:BB029:2D:<0.2/3..66.A/0;.631@')'#)#
* .029 :9930.;.< /7. >30;:/. 3.4>12<.2/ 1+ >3.6.33.< :2 :>>.:B 5.613. 3.4>12<.2/ 1* ? 4404/:2/ 1@@044012.3
.4>12<.2/ 1* ? 4404/:2/ 1@@044012.3 5= 13<.3 <:/.< ##)'#)# 0@>892.< 02 /704D30/>./0/012>31<8A.<:/22.C83.":BB1D.</7.4:0< :>>.:BA:2A.B029/7.3.40<.2/0:BA.3/060A:/.0448.<026:;183 16/7.>./0/012.3124.G8.2//7.3.8>123.4>12<.2/1 0448.< 471D"A:84. 21/0A. <:/.< 'E)##)# :4 >.3 22.C83." 9930.;.< 5= D70A7 /7. >./0/012.3 7:4 :>>31:A7.</704183/
.:32.< A1824.B 613 /7. >./0/012.3 /:F029 /704 183/ /731897 /7. 3.A13<4 485@0/4 /7:/ /7. 4404/:2/ 1@@044012.37:4>:44.</7.0@>892.<13<.3D70A73824
- 6 -
A12/3:3=/1/7.;.3=1;.32@.2/
3<.3<:/.<#)E#)'+ >31;0<029@:22.3@./71<:2<@.A7:204@613:>>102/029 /7. 29:2D:<0 D13F.34 . 485@0/4 /7:/ :<@0//.<B= /7. >./0/012.35.029:D0<1D04.2/0/B.</15.90;.2>3.6.3.2A. 1;.3 1/7.3 A:2<0<:/.4 .A12<B= 7. 485@0/4 /7:/ /7. 4404/:2/ 1@@044012.3 A18B< 21/ 7:;. A:2A.BB.< /7. 3.40<.2/0:BA.3/060A:/.5:4.<12/7.:BB.9:/0121647.7:;029 5..2 @:330.< /1 12.
:30 16 :<:470;>./ :29:3.<<= <04/30A/ .B:29:2: D0/718/ /:F029 02/1 A1240<.3:/012 /7:/ 4:0< :30 7:4 >:44.< :D:= 12 #*)#)#' :2< .;.3 402A./7.2/7.>./0/012.37:45..23.40<029:/ ://090:BB0 D0/77.3A70B<3.2027.3>:3.2/:B7184..485@0/4/7:/ /7. >./0/012.3 7:;029 5..2 5132 :/ ://090 :BB0 :2< 21D 3.40<029 :4 : D0<1D 4:/0460.4 :BB /7. 3.G803.@.2/416 /7. 1;.32@.2/
3<.3 >31;0<029 613 :2 :>>102/@.2/ 16 29:2D:<0 D13F.3 704 6:A/8:B :2< B.9:B :4>.A/ 16 /7. @://.3 7:4 5..2 1;.3B11F.< 5= /7. 4404/:2/ 1@@044012.3D:33:2/02902/.36.3.2A.://7.7:2<416/704 183/
- 7 -
$ .:32.< A1824.B :>>.:3029 613 >30;:/. 3.4>12<.2/1+://7.18/4./485@0/4/7://7.>./0/012.3 D71AB:0@4/15./7.3.40<.2/16 ://090:BB07:441897/ :>>102/@.2/ 02 3.4>.A/ 16 29:2D:<0 .2/3. D70A7 04 40/8:/.< :/ 7157:9:BB0 . 485@0/4 /7:/ >30;:/. 3.4>12<.2/ 1+ 04 /7. 3.40<.2/ 16 7157:9:BB0 :4 48A7 >./0/012.3.;.2067.B</15./7.3.40<.2/16 ://090:BB004 21/ .2/0/B.< /1 5. :>>102/.< :4 29:2D:<0 D13F.3 16 29:2D:<0.2/3.:/7157:9:BB01D.;.3/1:G8.3=5= /704 183/ :4 /1 D7./7.3 /7. 7157:9:BB0 29:2D:<0 .2/3. 02AB8<.4 ://090 :BB0 :3.: B.:32.< A1824.B 613 3.4>12<.2/1+>B.:<409213:2A./1/7.4:@. + .:32.< <<0/012:B 1;.32@.2/ <;1A:/. :>>.:30296133.4>12<.2/14'/1$485@0/4/7:/7.D18B< 4..F024/38A/012402/704@://.3
. /7:/ :4 0/ 04 7:;029 7.:3< B.:32.< A1824.B 613/7.>:3/0.4/7.>102//7:/:304.4613A1240<.3:/01204
- 8 -
!"!#$ %%&
'
(
)*
E
7. 1;.32@.2/ 3<.3 <:/.< #)E#)'+ >31;0<.4 980B/02.44 613 :>>102/@.2/ 16 29:2D:<0 13F.37.B>.3 B:84. # 16 /7. 4:0< 13<.3 3.G803.4 >31<8A/012 16 <1@0A0B.3.40<.2/0:B A.3/060A:/. 3.B.;:2/ >13/01216D70A73.:<4:482<.3
!"#$ % &'( )*+,- * - . - /0 1-2$ 3 -!+45
6 789 - :+
6 789 - +;- $ -<= > +
?@ ;A % 2 * &'
-8 B
') .384:B 16 /7. .2/03. 1;.32@.2/
3<.3 <:/.< #)E#)'+ <1 21/ 02<0A:/. /7. @020@8@ =.:34 16 3.40<.2A. 3.G803.< 613 0448:2A. 16 <1@0A0B. A.3/060A:/. 12./7.B.44 /7.3. 04 21 <04>8/. 16 /7. 6:A/ /7:/ /7. >./0/012.3045132:2<531897/8>:/ ://090:BB07.D:4
- 9 -
@:330.<02/7.=.:3#)'*:2<3.40<.<D0/77.37845:2<:/ .B:29:2: 8> /1 #)#' :2< :6/.3 <.@04. 16 7.3 7845:2< 47.4/:3/.<3.40<0295:AF:/ ://090:BB0D0/77.3>:3.2/4 704 6:A/ 04 21/ 5..2 <04>8/.< 83/7.3 485">:3: 16 :3:
/7.1;.32@.2/
3<.3<:/.<#)E#)'+>31;0<.4 :482<.3 IJ
K -"
0
CD-! E
F D-! G +?H
I&' DG-J $ -<= >@ &',
HJ $@ $ - +9>K
-8 L B
'' 784 >.384:B 16 /7. 1;.32@.2/
3<.3 @13. >:3/0A8B:3B= /7. 3.B.;:2/ >13/012 .C/3:A/.< 7.3.02:51;.
02<0A:/.4/7://7.>./0/012.3:>:3/631@5.029/7.3.40<.2/ 16 ://090 :BB0 :B41 4:/0460.4 /7. 3.G803.@.2/ 613 A1240<.3:/012 16 7.3 A:4. 82<.3 G81/: 613 D0<1D 7.4. - 10 -
/D1:4>.A/416/7.@://.37:;.21/5..2/:F.221/.165= /7. 4404/:2/ 1@@044012.3 02 /7. 0@>892.< 13<.3 7. 4404/:2/ 1@@044012.3 02 /7. 0@>892.< 7:4 1>02.< /7:/ :>>B0A:2/ 4..F029 <1@0A0B.3.40<.2/0:B A.3/060A:/. 47:BB .0/7.3/7.>.3@:2.2/3.40<.2/13@84/7:;.5..23.40<029 613 : @020@8@ >.301< 16 40C =.:34 02A. /7.7845:2<16 >./0/012.37:<>:44.<:D:=02/7.#)#':2<47.7:45..2 3.40<029://7.:<<3.4490;.202/7.:>>B0A:/012/7.3.:6/.3
47. 7:< 21/ A1@>B./.< /7. 4:0< @020@8@ >.301< 16 40C =.:34 1/7029 04 3.6.33.< /1 02 /7. 0@>892.< 13<.3 >3.4A305.< @020@8@ 3.G803.@.2/ 16 40C =.:34 AA13<029B=/7.61BB1D029
: 7.30/ ./0/01204 5 7. 0@>892.< 13<.3 <:/.< ##)'#)# :/ 22.C83."044./:40<.://.3043.@:2<.< 5:AF/1/7.4404/:2/1@@044012.361363.47 A1240<.3:/012 /:F029 02/1 A1240<.3:/012 /7. :613.4:0< 1;.32@.2/ 3<.3 <:/.<
- 11 -
#)E#)'+ 02 0/4 .2/03./= @13. >:3/0A8B:3B= /7.>13/0124D70A7:3..C/3:A/.<7.3.02:51;. A 7. 4404/:2/ 1@@044012.3 47:BB >:44 :>>31>30:/. 13<.3 :6/.3 :6613<029 48660A0.2/ 1>>13/820/=D0/702:218/.3B0@0/1640CD..F4 631@ /7. <:/. 16 3.A.0>/ 16 A.3/060.< A1>= 16 /70413<.3 < 02A.3.4>12<.2/1+7:43:04.<:20448.16 29:2D:<0 .2/3. 16 7157:9:BB0 21/ 02AB8<029 ://090:BB0:3.:3.4>12<.2/1#" .>8/=1@@044012.347:BBB11F02/1D7./7.3 ://090 :BB0 :3.: 6:BB4 D0/702 7157:9:BB0 29:2D:<0.2/3.:2<>:44:>>31>30:/.13<.3 02/7043.9:3<
'( %# #& $
04/1'B1'*