- 1 - !"! #"$$ %% &$' ( ! " #$ % &'($) % *'"$ %+ " Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %% ")("% % % ! ,$,$# "$$$$$ * "-) $ . % ! % ! % %,/-/%! % % ! 0! " 1233456756 89:6;45< 25: 2=2>: :2<4: ,$,$# ?2@@4: AB >3 457C> 7D73 !9:64 25: 2< 232A9>267 75 @1C><E<>7A9523.75 5C"-) $<17@2??4237@F734: ;<>7:4D7 ! 9??2: 342>54: GC95@43 @9A;7<<4: 2??423 =2@ AB G327;25< FC> 45125G4;45< CF GC;?45@2<7C5 < =2@ @9A;7<<4: C5 $$($ =145 G327;25< =2@ =23H756 <C=2>:@17@325:C5175G1C37*17<<2?9>>C2::>7D4>CF>2G<C> 5C*( *"(":>CD4 7< 75 >2@1 25:54637645< ;2554> 25: :2@14: 26275@< G327;25< G29@756 2GG7:45< 5 @27: 2GG7:45< G327;25< @9@<2754: 6>74DC9@ 7589>74@ 25: =2@ 2:;7<<4: <C 1C@?7<234@?7<4<2H756<>42<;45<14:7:5C<>4GCD4>F933B25: @9@<2754: ?4>;2545< ?1B@7G23 :7@2A737<B 3C@@ CF 42>5756 - 3 - G2?2G7<B14>4FC>414F734:G327;?4<7<7C595:4>4G<7C5",,CF G<26275@<C=54>25:75@9>4> ( 5 @4>D7G4 C=54> CF CFF45:756 >2G<C> :7: 5C< 2??42> 25: =2@ ?32G4: 4I*?2><4 53B 75@9>4> F734: CA84G<7C5@ :45B756264CGG9?2<7C575GC;425:3C@@CF42>5756G2?2G7<BCF G327;25< < =2@ 23@C @9A;7<<4: <12< :>7D4> CF 75@9>4: D417G34 =2@ 5C< 1C3:756 D237: 25: 4FF4G<7D4 :>7D756 37G45@4 25: <14>4 =2@ D7C32<7C5 CF <4>;@ 25: GC5:7<7C5@ CF 75@9>25G4 2@ =433 2@ G327; =2@ 4IG4@@7D4 2@4: C5 @2;4 <>7A9523 F>2;4: 7@@94@ 25: >4GC>:4: 4D7:45G4 327;25< 4I2;754: 17;@43F 25: >>2:44? 9;2> 2<7H2> 2@ @*" 25: 25: 6C< ;2>H4: I@*"<C"5@9>4>:7:5C<342:25B4D7:45G4 # 5 GC5@7:4>2<7C5 <>7A9523 143: <12< 2GG7:45< CGG9>>4::94<C>2@125:54637645<:>7D756CF75@9>4:D417G34AB 7<@ :>7D4> 25: G327;25< 12: @9@<2754: ?4>;2545< ?1B@7G23 :7@2A737<B 3C@@ CF 42>5756 G2?2G7<B 25: 2=2>:4: GC;?45@2<7C5 2@95:4> ) *+,+-.+/01 23+-1/.*- 24-. " 27525:9FF4>756 @$$$$ * - 4 - <<45:25<FCC:25: GC5D4B25G4G12>64@ @$$$$ * ( C@@CFF9<9>475GC;4 @-)($$ * # 4:7G234I?45@4@ @$$$ * C@@CF75GC;4:9>756 <>42<;45< @#$$$ * , C@@CF2;457<74@25:59<>7<7C5 FCC: @$$$$ * ./) 1 556 5. 7@@2<7@F74:?>4@45<2??423=2@F734: 6. < =2@ @9A;7<<4: G327;25< 12: @9@<2754: 2;?9<2<7C5 CF >761< 346 2ACD4 H544 >7A9523 2=2>:4: @$$$$ *<C=2>:@?27525:@9FF4>756=17G1=2@752:4J92<4 < =2@ @9A;7<<4: * 12: 2@@4@@4: ?4>;2545< ?1B@7G23 :7@2A737<B 2< '$/ C=4D4> <>7A9523 2@@4@@4: F95G<7C523 :7@2A737<B2<C53B$/=17G1=2@752:4J92<4<23@C4>>4:75 5C<2::756F9<9>4?>C@?4G<@2@?4>:4G7@7C5CFC5.A349?>4;4 C9><75G2@4CF " < =2@ @9A;7<<4: <>7A9523 =2@ 5C< 89@<7F74: GC5@7:4>756 32B CFF ?4>7C: 2@ C53B ( ;C5<1@ < =2@ F9><14> @9A;7<<4: 2=2>: CF @$$$$ * <C=2>:@ 3C@@ CF 1 $($))# - 5 - 2;457<74@=2@GC5<>2>B<C:4G7@7C5CFC5.A349?>4;4C9><75 G2@4 CF ! < =2@ 23@C @9A;7<<4: <12< <>7A9523 12@ 5C< 2=2>:4: 25B GC;?45@2<7C5 <C=2>:@ F9<9>4 ;4:7G23 4I?45@4@ 5 2ACD4 6>C95:@ @C961< FC>45125G4;45< 7. 5 C<14> 125: >7 9A2@1 2332?9> 342>54: GC95@43FC>75@9>4>C??C@4:2??423<=2@@9A;7<<4:;4:7G23 A733@ 7@@94: AB 2;2>4::B 1C@?7<23 FC> @(($$$ * =4>4 ?>C:9G4: @ CA@4>D4: AB <>7A9523 G327;25< 12: 2D2734: :7@GC95< CF @,#$$ * 23@C 5:4> @9G1 G7>G9;@<25G4@ <>7A9523 =2@ 5C< 89@<7F74: 75 2=2>:756 @$$$ * <C=2>:@ ;4:7G23 4I?45@4@ < =2@ @9A;7<<4: @75G4 <14>4 =2@ 4IG4@@ 2=2>: 95:4> @27: 142: <14>4 =C93: A4 5C @GC?4 FC> 45125G4;45< 25: C5 2ACD4 6>C95:@ @C961< FC> :7@;7@@23 CF 2??423 8. 5>4?3B7<=2@@9A;7<<4:2?2><F>C;1C@?7<23A733@ FC>@(($$$ *4D45A733@CF?9>G12@4CF;4:7G754=4>423@C ?>C:9G4: 14>4FC>4 2=2>: <C=2>:@ ;4:7G23 4I?45@4@ =2@ 89@<7F74: $"""(#( - 6 - 9. 42>:GC95@43?4>9@4:89:6;45<25:2=2>: 10. %>C; 2ACD4 C53B ?C75< <12< =C93: 2>7@4 FC> GC5@7:4>2<7C57@ K14<14> G327;25< 7@ 45<7<34: FC> 45125G4;45< CF GC;?45@2<7C52@@C961<FC>LM 11. 2;47@25@=4>4:?2><3B752FF7>;2<7D4FC>FC33C=756 >42@C5@ 12. GG9>>45G4 CF 2GG7:45< :94 <C >2@1 25: 54637645< :>7D756 CF :>7D4> CF 75@9>4: >2G<C> G327;25< @9@<275756 6>74DC9@7589>74@342:756<C?4>;2545<?1B@7G23:7@2A737<B 3C@@ CF42>5756G2?2G7<B75@9>4>.@372A737<B<C?2BGC;?45@2<7C52>4 5C<75:7@?9<4327;25<@9@<2754:>2:4*GC;?C95:F>2G<9>4 CF >761< <7A72 @12F< ;7::34 25: 9??4> <7A72 4<G 342:756 <C 2;?9<2<7C5 CF 17@ >761< 346 2ACD4H544 34D43 C5.A34 9?>;4 C9><75G2@4CF" #$ %& & ' ()>4?C><4:75!*+!,!-2=2>:4:@"$$$$ *<C=2>:@ ?275 25: @9FF4>756 75 G2@4 CF 2;?9<2<7C5 45G4 @2;4 7@ 2=2>:4: - 7 - 13. %C> 75?2<745< CF # :2B@ <>7A9523 2=2>:4: @$$$$ * <C=2>:@ FCC: 2<<45:25< 25: GC5D4B25G4 2;4 2??42>@89@<25:?>C?4>25::C4@5C<G233FC>75<4>F4>45G4@ ?4> I*"( :7@2A737<B G4><7F7G2<4 25: :4?C@7<7C5 CF * G327;25<12:@9@<2754:?4>;2545<?1B@7G23:7@2A737<B<C4I<45< CF'$/327;25<=2@(B42>@264:GCC37425:2;?9<2<7C5CF >761< 346 =C93: 4FF4G< 17@ 42>5756 G2?2G7<B 5 G2@4 CF 9@4 CF 2><7F7G72337;A:7@2A737<B=C93:>4:9G4<CG4><2754I<45<4@7:4@ ?C@@7A737<B CF 42>5756 75GC;4 AB 23<4>52<7D4 2DCG2<7C5 7@ 23@C >4J97>4: <C A4 GC5@7:4>4: 5:4> 2ACD4 G7>G9;@<25G4@ 2@@4@@;45<CFF95G<7C523:7@2A737<B2<$/AB<>7A95232??42>@ <C A4 89@< 25: ?>C?4> 9< 2@ ?4> :4G7@7C5 75 G2@4 CF 70 /8++, &143,/' G327;25< =C93: A4 45<7<34: FC> 2::7<7C5 CF F9<9>4 ?>C@?4G<@ <C 17@ ;C5<13B 75GC;4 75G4 G327;25< =2@ @27: <C A4 264: ( B42>@ @43F 4;?3CB4: 25: 42>5756 @"#)$ *?;"$/12@<CA42::4:<C17@;C5<13B75GC;4 25: ;93<7?374> 2??37G2A34 =C93: A4 E"". 45G4 GC;?45@2<7C5 <C=2>:@F9<9>43C@@CF42>57567@>4*2@@4@@4:2<@"$)$'$ * N"#)$ *O"$/PI""I"I$/ 14. >7A9523 2=2>:4: @$$$ * <C=2>:@ ;4:7G23 4I?45@4@1C961GC95@43FC>75@9>4>@C961<<C:7@?9<4@2;4 - 8 - 7<7@>4J97>4:<CA4>484G<4:FC>FC33C=756>42@C5@%7>@<3B@75G4 <17@7@G327;25<.@2??423FC>45125G4;45<25:75@9>4>12@5C< G12334564: 2=2>: 4GC5:3B <C<23 ;4:7G23 A733@ @9A;7<<4: 5C< C53B 75G39:4: 1C@?7<23 A733@ FC> <>42<;45< A9< 23@C FC> ?9>G12@756 CF ;4:7G754@ =17G1 =2@ 5C< 75G39:4: 75 1C@?7<23 A733@ 14>4FC>4 2=2>: CF @$$$ * <C=2>:@ ;4:7G23 4I?45@4@7@89@<25:?>C?4> 15. C>;233B75G2@4CF2;?9<2<7C5CF37;A@7I;C5<1@ ?4>7C:7@GC5@7:4>4:2@32BCFF?4>7C:45G4G327;25<=C93:A4 45<7<34:FC>@''$$ *<C=2>:@@2;4@?4>:4G7@7C575G2@4 CF /9 42/, &143,/' 2=2>: CF @$$$$ * <C=2>:@ 3C@@ CF 2;457<74@ =C93: A4 6>C@@3B 752:4J92<4 25: 7@ 45125G4: <C @"$$$$ * :;7<<4:3B G327;25< 12@ @9@<2754: 2;?9<2<7C5 CF>761<3462ACD4H5441C961<14>47@5C@?4G7F7G4D7:45G4 2AC9< GC@< CF 2><7F7G723 37;A <2H756 5C<4 CF 544: FC> ?4>7C:7G ;275<4525G4 2@ =433 2@ >4?32G4;45< 75 2A@45G4 CF @?4G7F7G ;2<4>7237<7@FC95:2??>C?>72<4<C2=2>:@"$$$$$ *7539;* @9;<C=2>:@F9<9>4;4:7G234I?45@4@<C=2>:@37;A19@<C<23 GC;?45@2<7C57@2@95:4> - 9 - ) *+,+-.+/01 23+-1/.*- 24-. " 27525:9FF4>756 @"$$$$ * <<45:25<FCC:25: GC5D4B25G4G12>64@ @$$$$ * ( C@@CFF9<9>475GC;4 @"$)$'$ * # 4:7G234I?45@4@ @$$$ * C@@CF75GC;4:9>756 <>42<;45< @''$$ * , C@@CF2;457<74@25:59<>7<7C5 FCC: @"$$$$ * ) %9<9>44:7G234I?45@4@ @"$$$$$ * ./) 1 6 16. C5@4J945<3BFC33C=756 7 ??4237@233C=4:75?2>< 77 !9:6;45< 25: 2=2>: :2<4: ,$,$# ?2@@4:AB>3457C>7D73!9:6425:2< 232A9>26775 5C"-) $7@;C:7F74: 327;25<7@143:45<7<34:FC>GC;?45@2<7C5CF @"(#($ * F>C; 75@9>4> =7<1 75<4>4@< 2< ,/ ?2 F>C; :2<4 CF G327; ?4<7<7C5 <733 :4?C@7< - 10 - 777 5@9>4> 7@ :7>4G<4: <C :4?C@7< 45125G4: GC;?45@2<7C5=7<1752?4>7C:CF@7I=44H@ 7D 5:4?C@7<<>7A9523<C:4?C@7<$/CF@2;4 75 F7I4: :4?C@7< FC> 2 ?4>7C: CF B42>@ 25: >4342@4>4;275756$/75F2DC9>CFG327;25< 06 &$$' " ! 7@<C"3C#(