- 1 - ! " !#!! ! $ %&'%()*+%)) , ! "#!#$# % & % Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & '()*+ & (+( ++'+ & & , & & ++)+$ (+( & && #+* '#' '' & & & & - - ./0/1232456/727245/038/259:;;<3/=43:5=25 4++)+$457./>2?/4>7./?/:05/===? 212? <=9/ :5= & :?:8<0:92 ./0/25:>7/0 0/>/00/= 74 :3 @ 02:? 4<07, :0/ 2A6<95259 7./ B<=9A/57 4> ;4512;7245 :5=40=/04>3/57/5;/=:7/=(+(;4512;72597./A >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;72453 #+* '#' :5= '' 4> 7./ 5=2:5 /5:? 4=/ >40 3.407 @, :5= 3/57/5;259 74 <5=/094 32A6?/ 2A602345A/57 >40 45/ C/:0 - 3 - :5= 74 6:C >25/ 4> 3'+++" /:;. >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 #+* 4> D 3/57/5;259 74 <5=/09432A6?/2A602345A/57>4045/C/:0:5=6:C>25/4> 3#+++"/:;.>407./4>>/5;/6<523.:8?/<5=/0/;7245 '#' 4> D 3/57/5;259 74 <5=/094 32A6?/ 2A602345A/57 >40 45/ C/:0 :5= 6:C >25/ 4> 3#+++" /:;. >40 7./ 4>>/5;/6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245'' 4> E27. =/>:<?7 3/57/5;/3D E.2;. E:3 ;45>20A/= 25 02A25:? 66/:? 4(+(457./>2?/4>7./?/:05/===27245:?23702;7 :5=/332453<=9/:?:8<0:92./0/25:>7/00/>/00/=74:3 @&203766/??:7/4<07,12=/B<=9A/57=:7/=++'+ &:;73 4> 7./ ;:3/ 25 802/> :0/ 7.:7 "7./ 25B<0/= /C/"E275/33 >2?/= 7./ >2037 25>40A:7245 E27. 3.4F :9:04?2;/7:7245:9:2537:;;<3/=43:5=:??/9259 ;4AA2332454>7./:>40/3:2=4>>/5;/3>7/00/9237/02597./ & 251/3729:7245 E:3 <5=/07:F/5 :5= 7./ >25:? 0/6407 ;:A/748/>2?/= ./?/:05/=:92370:7/744F;4952G:5;/ 4> 7./ 4>>/5;/3 :5= 0/9237/0/= 7./ ;:3/ 25 4++)+$ ./:;;<3/=:66/:0/=8/>40/7./ 02:? - 4 - 4<07 :5= 6?/:=/= 547 9<2?7C >40 7./ ;.:09/3 ?/1/?/= :9:25377./A ./ 6043/;<7245 /H:A25/= 3 74!947 A:0F/= H3 74 $ :5= 2=/572>2/= 3 74 ' ./ :;;<3/= .:1/ =/52/= :?? 7./ 25;02A25:7259 A:7/02:?3 :1:2?:8?/ 45 0/;40= 25 3<66407 4> 7./20 =/>/5;/ ./ 02:? 4<07:>7/07:F2592574;4532=/0:7245:??7./3/A:7/02:?345 0/;40= ;:A/ 74 7./ ;45;?<3245 7.:7 7./ 6043/;<7245 23 3<;;/33><? 25 6041259 7./ 9<2?7 4> 7./ :;;<3/= 8/C45= 0/:345:8?/=4<87;;40=259?C7./2A6<95/=B<=9A/574> ;4512;7245 :5= 40=/0 4> 3/57/5;/ ;:A/ 74 8/ 6:33/= /259:9902/1/=8C7./3:A/7./:;;<3/=.:1/60/>/00/= 7./ :66/:? 25 02A25:? 66/:? 4(+( ./ &2037 66/??:7/ 4<07 45 0/":660/;2:7245 4> 7./ A:7/02:?3 45 0/;40=>4<5=7.:77./6043/;<7245233<;;/33><?256041259 7./ 9<2?7 4> 7./ :;;<3/= 8/C45= 0/:345:8?/ =4<87 :5= :;;40=259?C =23A233/= 7./ :66/:? 8C ;45>20A259 7./ B<=9A/57 4> ;4512;7245 :5= 40=/0 4> 3/57/5;/ 6:33/= 8C 7./ 02:?4<07/259:9902/1/=8C7./3:A/7./:;;<3/= :0/8/>40/7.234<07 - 5 - ' /:0= 02 :.:57/3. /3:2 ?/:05/= ;4<53/? >407./0/1232456/727245/03:5=0246:?023.5::=:1 ?/:05/= 29. 4<07 41/05A/57 ?/:=/0 >40 7./ 0/3645=/57/0<3/=7./A:7/02:?3450/;40= * 5 12/E 4> 7./ 021:? ;457/572453 <09/= 8C 7./ ?/:05/=;4<53/?>40847.7./6:072/37./642577.:7E4<?= :023/>40AC;4532=/0:724523 # C:53E/0747./:841/6425723- >407./>4??4E259 $ 7 23 7./ ;457/57245 4> 7./ 6043/;<7245 7.:7 "7./ 25B<0/= /C/E275/33 E:3 E40F259 :3 : ;45=<;740 25 8<3 8/:0259 0/92370:7245 4"'&"')* - 6 - E.2?/ E:3 7./ =021/0 5 +)+!+# :7 ('+ :A 7./C E/0/ 45 =<7C 604;//=259 >04A :0<0 12??:9/ 74 <6/0:0F/7 ./:;;<3/=4E.4E:370:1/?259257./ 8<3 :3F/= 74 3746 5/:0 <F7.: ./:7/0 0/><3/=7437467./8<337:72597.:77./0/2354=/3295:7/= 3746 / 9:1/ 3295:? 74 3746 7./ 8<3 5/:0 /E:092 ;0433 ;;<3/= 4 :8<3/= 8/259 7./ ;45=<;740 8/2597./=021/0E27.>2?7.C?:59<:9/E27.:5257/5724574 60414F/7./A74;4AA2780/:;.4>6/:;/ /A:5.:5=?/= 8C6<??259.23<52>40AE27.:5257/5724574=/7/0.2A >04A=23;.:09259.234>>2;2:?=<7C:5=;:<3/=.<07 /.:3 :?34 ;02A25:??C 2572A2=:7/= 74 7:F/ :E:C 7./ ?2>/ 4> :5= 7./0/8C ;4AA277/= 7./ :>40/3:2= 4>>/5;/3 ./ 25;2=/573:2=74.:1/4;;<00/=45+)+!+#:7('+:A ./ >2037 25>40A:7245 ;:A/ 74 8/ >2?/= 45 7./ 1/0C 3:A/ =:C ) "23 7./ 25B<0/= /C/"E275/33 E.4 .:3 ><??C 3<66407/= 7./ ;:3/ 4> 7./ 6043/;<7245 8/259 7./ =021/0 4> 7./ 8<3 23 7./ /C/"E275/33 ./ .:3 :?34 ><??C - 7 - 3<66407/=7./;:3/4>7./6043/;<7245'"237./=4;740 E.4 /H:A25/= 7./ 25B<0/= :5= 233</= 7./ E4<5= ;/072>2;:7/ :3 6/0 H :;;40=259 74 E.2;. .:= 3<37:25/= >4<0 32A6?/ 25B<02/3 * 23 7./ A:.:G:0 E275/33 74 7./ 3647 A:.:G:0 H3' :5= * # 23 7./ /647:5:9/0E.4233</=7./;/072>2;:7/:36/0H#74 7.//>>/;77.:77./25B<0/=:5=E/0/45=<7C:77./ 72A/ 4> 7./ 25;2=/57 3$ :5= ) :0/ 7./ 51/3729:7259 >>2;/03 ! 23 7./ /C/"E275/33 74 7./ 25;2=/57 E.4 36/:F3:84<77./25;2=/578<7>:2?3742=/572>C7./:;;<3/= ! &04A7./:841/A:7/02:?3450/;40=2723;?/:0 7.:7 7./ 25B<0/= /C/"E275/33 :5= 7./ /C/"E275/33 .:1/ ><??C 3<66407/= 7./ ;:3/ 4> 7./ 6043/;<7245 1/57.4<9.7./CE/0/;0433"/H:A25/=:7?/597.547.259 .:3 8//5 /?2;27/= 74 =238/?2/1/ 7./20 1/03245 ./ E4<5= ;/072>2;:7/233</=8C':36/0H:?343<6640737./ ;:3/ 4> 7./ 6043/;<7245 5=/0 3<;. ;20;<A37:5;/3 :A 4>7./46252457.:77./6043/;<7245233<;;/33><?256041259 - 8 - 7./9<2?74>7./:;;<3/=8/C45=0/:345:8?/=4<87:5=7./ :;;<3/=:0/?2:8?/>40;4512;7245 ( 77.2337:9/?/:05/=;4<53/?>407./6/727245/03 ;457/5=/= 7.:7 7./ 02:? 4<07 ;4AA277/= :5 /0040 25 3/57/5;259 7./ :;;<3/= >40 847. 7./ 4>>/5;/3 <5=/0 /;72453 '#' :5= '' 4> E.2;. :0/ .:1259 ;4AA45 2590/=2/573 :5= 7./0/>40/ 60:C3 >40 3/57/5;259 7./ :;;<3/= >40 :5C 45/ 4> 7./ 4>>/5;/ :5= :?34 74 3.4E ?/52/5;C25>:14<04>7./:;;<3/=8C2A64325945?C>25/:3 7./C:0/547.:827<:?4>>/5=/03 + .:1/945/7.04<9.7./2A6<95/=B<=9A/574> ;4512;7245:5=40=/04>3/57/5;/6:33/=8C7./ 02:?4<07 ./ 02:? 4<07 604;//=/= 74 ;4532=/0 7./ A:7/02:?3 45 0/;40=:5=029.7?C>40A/=:546252457.:77./6043/;<7245 233<;;/33><?2560412599<2?74>7./:;;<3/=>407./4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;72453 #+* '#' :5= '' 4> /;7245 '#' 4> 0/>/03 74 :33:<?7 40 ;02A25:? >40;/ 74 =/7/07./6<8?2;3/01:57>04A=23;.:09259.23=<72/3E.2;. 236<523.:8?/E27.A:H2A<A2A602345A/574>7E4C/:0340 - 9 - E27.>25/40E27.847.E.2?//;7245''4>0/>/0374 14?<57:02?C ;:<3259 .<07 74 =/7/0 6<8?2; 3/01:57 >04A .23 =<7CE.2;.236<523.:8?/E27.7./A:H2A<A6<523.A/574> 7.0//C/:0340E27.>25/40E27.847. ./0/>40/2723;?/:0 7.:7 /;7245 '' 4> 23 7./ A:B40 4>>/5;/ ./5847. /;72453'':5='#'4>:0/2514F/=/;7245'#'4> 8/259 7./ A2540 4>>/5;/ A/09/3 E27. /;7245 '' 4> 5=/0 3<;. ;20;<A37:5;/3 7./ 02:? 4<07 ;4<?= 547 .:1/ 604;//=/= 74 3/57/5;/ 7./ :;;<3/= >40 847. 7./ 4>>/5;/340/41/07./4>>/5;/3>40E.2;.7./:;;<3/=:0/ ;4512;7/=:0/6<523.:8?//27./0E27.2A602345A/5740E27. >25/40E27.847.:5=54A252A<A3/57/5;/2360/3;028/= >40:5C4>7./3/4>>/5;/3 ./ A:7/02:?3 45 0/;40= =23;?43/3 7.:7 7./ 25;2=/57.:=4;;<00/=25:36<04>A4A/57E./57./8<325 E.2;. :;;<3/= E:3 70:1/?259 E:3 547 37466/= :7 .23 0/I</37 ./0/>40/:A4>7./46252457.:77./C.:=547 ;4AA277/= 7./ 4>>/5;/ E27. :5C 60/6:0:7245 /5;/ 7./ - 10 - 257/0/374>B<372;/E2??8/A/72>7./C:0/3/57/5;/=746:C >25/E27.4<72A643259:5C3<837:5721/3/57/5;/ 512/E4>7./:841/:53E/07./:841/64257 @ :5= 604;//= 74 6:33 7./ >4??4E259 : 02A25:?0/1232456/72724523 8 ./B<=9A/574>;4512;7245=:7/=(+( 6:33/=254++)+$457./>2?/4>7./ ?/:05/= ==? 212? <=9/ :5= & :?:8<0:9223./0/8C;45>20A/= ; ./ 40=/0 4> 3/57/5;/ 6:33/= 8C 7./ 02:? 4<0723A4=2>2/=:3<5=/0 2 ./ 6/727245/03:;;<3/= :0/ 3/57/5;/= 746:C>25/4>3#+++">407./4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/<5=/0/;7245#+*4>5 =/>:<?7 74 6:C >25/ 74 <5=/094 32A6?/ 2A602345A/57>40#=:C3 - 11 - 22 ./6/727245/03:;;<3/=:0/3/57/5;/= 74 6:C >25/ 4> 3++++" >40 7./ 4>>/5;/6<523.:8?/<5=/0/;7245''4> 5 =/>:<?7 74 6:C >25/ 74 <5=/094 32A6?/2A602345A/57>4045/A457. 222 4 3/6:0:7/ 3/57/5;/ 23 2A643/= >40 7./4>>/5;/<5=/0/;7245'#'4>:3 7./ 3:A/ A/09/3 E27. /;7245 '' 4> 21 &25/:A4<572>:5C=/64327/=8C7./ 6/727245/03:;;<3/= >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ <5=/0 /;7245 '#' 4> 23 40=/0/= 74 8/ 0/><5=/= 74 7./A 45 =</ 2=/572>2;:7245 /92370C23=20/;7/=743/5=8:;F7./ 02:?4<07 0/;40=3 :5= &2037 66/??:7/ 4<07 0/;40=3 :?459 7./ ;46C4>7./B<=9A/57>4025>40A:7245:5=>405//=><? :;7245 -* %!!) # 2374?4'*